Identity theory assumes that individuals seek identity verification in the form of consistency between the meanings implied by perceived feedback from others (reflected appraisals) and their own self-meanings (identity standards) during social interaction. When there is a lack of identity verification (discrepancy), individuals experience negative outcomes such as psychological distress. Most adults hold multiple identities, and discrepancies in certain identities may cause more distress than others. Moreover, reflected appraisals come from various sources, and discrepancies with certain sources may be more influential than others. Yet most research on identity verification has not included multiple identities or multiple sources of reflected appraisals. We use structural equation modeling to simultaneously investigate associations between identity discrepancies with four sources of reflected appraisals (spouse, family, friends, and others in general) and distress (depressive symptoms) in a sample of 735 respondents who occupy three identities (spouse/partner, parent, and religious). We find that discrepancies in more obligatory identities and those involving reflected appraisals from more proximal sources of feedback are most consistently associated with depressive symptoms. Implications of these findings for advancing identity theory and research are discussed.
American Association for Public Opinion Research. 2009. Standard Definitions: Final Dispositions of Case Codes and Outcome Rates for Surveys. 6th ed.Alexandria, VA: AAPOR.
3.
AsencioEmily K.2011. “Familiarity, Legitimation, and Frequency: The Influence of Others on the Criminal Self-View.” Sociological Inquiry81(1):34–52.
4.
BoucheyHeather A.HarterSusan. 2005. “Reflected Appraisals, Academic Self-Perceptions, and Math/Science Performance during Early Adolescence.” Journal of Educational Psychology97(4):673–86.
5.
BraunsbergerKarinWybengaHansGatesRoger. 2007. “A Comparison of Reliability between Telephone and Web-Based Surveys.” Journal of Business Research60(7):758–64.
6.
BurkePeter J.1991. “Identity Processes and Social Stress,”American Sociological Review56(6):836–49.
7.
BurkePeter J.1996. “Social Identities and Psychological Stress.” Pp. 141–74 in Psychosocial Stress: Perspectives on Structure, Theory, Life Course, and Methods, edited by KaplanH. B.Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
8.
BurkePeter J.2003. “Relationships among Multiple Identities.” Pp. 195–214 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by BurkeP. J.OwensT. J.SerpeR. T.ThoitsP. A.New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
9.
BurkePeter J.2006. “Identity Change.” Social Psychology Quarterly69(1):81–96.
10.
BurkePeter J.CervenChristine. 2019. “Identity Accumulation, Verification, and Well-Being.” Pp. 17–33 in Identities in Everyday Life, edited by StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
11.
BurkePeter J.HarrodMichael M.2005. “Too Much of a Good Thing?”Social Psychology Quarterly68(4):359–74.
12.
BurkePeter J.StetsJan E.2009. Identity Theory. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
13.
BurkePeter J.TullyJudy C.1977. “The Measurement of Role Identity.” Social Forces55(4):881–97.
14.
CarterMichael J.AsencioEmily K.2019. “Identity Processes in Face-to-Face and Digitally-Mediated Environments.” Sociological Perspectives62(2):220–39.
15.
CastAlicia D.2004. “Well-Being and the Transition to Parenthood: An Identity Theory Approach.” Sociological Perspectives47(1):55–78.
16.
CastAlicia D.BurkePeter J.2002. “A Theory of Self-Esteem.” Social Forces80(3):1041–68.
17.
ChattersLinda M.TaylorRobert JosephBullardKai McKeeverJacksonJames S.2009. “Race and Ethnic Differences in Religious Involvement: African Americans, Caribbean Blacks and Non-Hispanic Whites.” Ethnic and Racial Studies32(7):1143–63.
18.
ChouChih-PingBentlerPeter M.SatorraAlbert. 1991. “Scaled Test Statistics and Robust Standard Errors for Non-normal Data in Covariance Structure Analysis: A Monte Carlo Study.” British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology44(2):347–57.
19.
CollettJessica L.VercelKelciePierceKayla D. R.2019. “The Role of Significant Others in Shaping Fathers’ Identities and Behavior.” Pp. 359–80 in Identities in Everyday Life, edited by StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
20.
CooleyCharles H.1902. Human Nature and the Social Order. New York, NY: Scribner.
21.
DerogatisLeonard R.1993. BSI Brief Symptom Inventory: Administration, Scoring, and Procedures Manual. 4th ed.Minneapolis, MN: National Computer Systems.
22.
DerogatisLeonard R.MelisaratosNick. 1983. “The Brief Symptom Inventory: An Introductory Report.” Psychological Medicine13(3):595–605.
23.
EndersCraig K.BandalosDeborah L.2001. “The Relative Performance of Full Information Maximum Likelihood Estimation for Missing Data in Structural Equation Models.” Structural Equation Modeling8(3):430–57.
24.
FelsonRichard B.1989. “Parents and the Reflected Appraisal Process: A Longitudinal Analysis.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology56(6):965–71.
25.
FreyFrances E.TroppLinda R.2006. “Being Seen as Individuals Versus as Group Members: Extending Research on Metaperception to Intergroup Contexts.” Personality and Social Psychology Review10(3):265–80.
26.
GallagherMary. 2016. “Distinguishing Obligatory and Voluntary Identities.” Pp. 309–42 in New Directions in Identity Theory and Research, edited by StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
27.
GallagherMary. 2017. “Obligatory and Voluntary Identity Discrepancies, Self-Evaluation, and Psychological Distress.” Society and Mental Health7(2):51–68.
28.
GallagherMary. 2021. “General and Specific Sources of Reflected Appraisals.” Pp. 223–41 in Identities in Action: New Developments in Identity Theory, edited by BrennerP. S.StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.New York, NY: Springer.
29.
HitlinStevenElderGlen H.2007. “Time, Self, and the Curiously Abstract Concept of Agency.” Sociological Theory25(2):170–91.
30.
HuLi-tzeBentlerPeter M.1999. “Cutoff Criteria for Fit Indexes in Covariance Structure Analysis: Conventional Criteria Versus New Alternatives.” Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal6(1):1–55.
31.
KalkhoffWillMarcussenKristenSerpeRichard T.2016. “To Thine Own Self Be True? Clarifying the Effects of Identity Discrepancies on Psychological Distress and Emotions.” Social Science Research58:14–33.
32.
KaplanSeth A.SantuzziAlecia M.RuscherJanet B.2009. “Elaborative Metaperceptions in Outcome-Dependent Situations: The Diluted Relationship between Default Self-Perceptions and Metaperceptions.” Social Cognition27(4):601–14.
33.
KlineRex B.2005. Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling. 2nd ed.New York, NY: Guilford Press.
34.
KuhnManford H.1964. “The Reference Group Reconsidered.” The Sociological Quarterly5(1):5–21.
35.
MarcussenKristenAsencioEmily K.2016. “Stigma Resistance and the Mental Illness Self-View.” Pp. 473–508 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by StetsJ. E.SerpeR. T.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
36.
MarcussenKristenGallagherMary. 2017. “The Role of Aspirations and Obligations in Explaining the Relationship between Identity Discrepancies and Psychological Distress.” Sociological Perspectives60(6):1019–38.
37.
MarcussenKristenGaryKatharine M.SerpeRichard T.2021. “Meaning Matters: Measuring the Mental Illness Identity.” Social Science Research100:102617. doi:10.1016/j.ssresearch.2021.102617.
38.
MarcussenKristenLargeMichael D.2003. “Using Identity Discrepancy Theory to Predict Psychological Distress.” Pp. 151–66 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by BurkeP. J.OwensT. J.SerpeR. T.ThoitsP. A.New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
39.
MarkowitzFred E.AngellBethGreenbergJan S.2011. “Stigma, Reflected Appraisals, and Recovery Outcomes in Mental Illness.” Social Psychology Quarterly74(2):144–65.
40.
MatthewsT. J.HamiltonBrady E.2016. “Mean Age of Mothers Is on the Rise: United States, 2000-2014.” NCHS Data Brief 232. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db232.htm.
41.
McCallGeorge J.SimmonsJerry L.1978. Identities and Interactions. New York, NY: The Free Press.
42.
MeadG. H.1934. Mind, Self and Society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
43.
OatesGary L.GoodeJennifer. 2013. “Racial Differences in Effects of Religiosity and Mastery on Psychological Distress: Evidence from National Longitudinal Data.” Society and Mental Health3(1):40–58.
44.
O’BrienRobert M.2007. “A Caution Regarding Rules of Thumb for Variance Inflation Factors.” Quality and Quantity41(5):673–90.
45.
PavalkoEliza K.WoodburyShari. 2000. “Social Roles as Process: Caregiving Careers and Women’s Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior41(1):91–105.
46.
PayneKrista K.2019. “Median Age at First Marriage, 2017.” Family Profiles FP-19-09. Bowling Green, OH: National Center for Family and Marriage Research. doi:10.25035/ncfmr/fp-19-06.
47.
ReitzesDonald C.MutranElizabeth J.2002. “Self-Concept as the Organization of Roles: Importance, Centrality, and Balance.” The Sociological Quarterly43(4):647–67.
48.
ReitzesDonald C.MutranElizabeth J.2004. “Grandparent Identity, Intergenerational Family Identity, and Well-Being.” The Journals of Gerontology: Series B59(4):213–19.
49.
RidgewayCecilia L.CorrellShelley J.2006. “Consensus and the Creation of Status Beliefs.” Social Forces85(1):431–53.
50.
RobinsonDawn T.Smith-LovinLynnWisecupAllison K.2006. “Affect Control Theory.” Pp. 179–202 in Handbook of the Sociology of Emotions, edited by StetsJ. E.TurnerJ. H.New York, NY: Springer.
SavaleiVictoriaBentlerPeter M.2006. “Structural Equation Modeling.” Pp. 330–64 in The Handbook of Marketing Research: Uses, Misuses, and Future Advances, edited by GroverR.VriensM.Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
53.
SchreiberJames B.NoraAmauryStageFrances K.BarlowElizabeth A.KingJamie. 2006. “Reporting Structural Equation Modeling and Confirmatory Factor Analysis Results: A Review.” The Journal of Educational Research99(6):323–38.
54.
SerpeRichard T.StrykerSheldon. 2011. “The Symbolic Interactionist Perspective and Identity Theory.” Pp. 225–48 in Handbook of Identity Theory and Research, edited by SchwartzS.LuyckxK.VignolesV.London: Springer.
55.
ShibutaniTamotsu. 1955. “Reference Groups as Perspectives.” American Journal of Sociology60(6):562–69.
56.
SimmonsAlicia D.BoboLawrence D.2015. “Can Non-full-probability Internet Surveys Yield Useful Data? A Comparison with Full-Probability Face-to-Face Surveys in the Domain of Race and Social Inequality Attitudes.” Sociological Methodology45(1):357–87.
57.
SimonRobin W.1997. “The Meanings Individuals Attach to Role Identities and Their Implications for Mental Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(3):256–74.
58.
Smith-LovinLynn. 2003. “Self, Identity, and Interaction in an Ecology of Identities.” Pp. 167–78 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by BurkeP. J.OwensT. J.SerpeR. T.ThoitsP. A.New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
59.
Smith-LovinLynn. 2007. “The Strength of Weak Identities: Social Structural Sources of Self, Situation and Emotional Experience.” Social Psychology Quarterly70(2):106–24.
60.
StataCorp. 2017. Stata Statistical Software: Release 15. College Station, TX: StataCorp LLC.
61.
StetsJan E.2003. “Justice, Emotion, and Identity Theory.” Pp. 105–22 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by BurkeP. J.OwensT. J.SerpeR. T.ThoitsP. A.New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
62.
StetsJan E.2005. “Examining Emotions in Identity Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly68(1):39–58.
63.
StetsJan E.2021. “Micro, Meso, and Macro Processes in Identity Change: The 2020 Cooley-Mead Award Address”Social Psychology Quarterly84(4):286–308. doi:10.1177/01902725211046563.
64.
StetsJan E.BrennerPhillip S.BurkePeter J.SerpeRichard T.2017. “The Science Student Identity.” Social Science Research64(4):1–14.
65.
StetsJan E.BurkePeter J.2014. “Emotions and Identity Nonverification.” Social Psychology Quarterly77(4):387–410.
66.
StetsJan E.HarrodMichael M.2004. “Verification across Multiple Identities: The Role of Status.” Social Psychology Quarterly67(2):155–71.
67.
StetsJan E.SavageScott V.BurkePeter J.FaresPhoenicia. 2020. “Cognitive and Behavioral Responses to the Identity Verification Process.” Pp. 65–88 in Identity and Symbolic Interaction, edited by SerpeR. T.StrykerR.PowellB.New York, NY: Springer.
68.
StetsJan E.SerpeRichard T.2013. “Identity Theory.” Pp. 31–60 in Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by DeLamaterJ.WardA.New York, NY: Springer.
69.
StetsJan E.TrettevikRyan. 2014. “Emotions in Identity Theory.” Pp. 33–49 in Handbook of the Sociology of Emotions. Vol. II, edited by StetsJ. E.TurnerJ. H.New York, NY: Springer.
70.
StetsJan E.TrettevikRyan. 2016. “Happiness and Identities.” Social Science Research58:1–13.
71.
StrykerSheldonBurkePeter J.2000. “The Past, Present, and Future of an Identity Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly63(4):284–97.
72.
SullivanHarry Stack. 1953. The Interpersonal Theory of Psychiatry, edited by PerryH. S.GladwellM. L.New York, NY: Norton.
73.
TaylorRobert JosephChattersLinda M.JacksonJames S.2009. “Correlates of Spirituality among African Americans and Caribbean Blacks in the United States: Findings from the National Survey of American Life.” Journal of Black Psychology35(3):317–42.
74.
ThoitsPeggy A.1992. “Identity Structures and Psychological Well-Being: Gender and Marital Status Comparisons.” Social Psychology Quarterly55(3):236–56.
75.
ThoitsPeggy A.2003. “Personal Agency in the Accumulation of Multiple Role-Identities.” Pp. 179–94 in Advances in Identity Theory and Research, edited by BurkeP. J.OwensT. J.SerpeR. T.ThoitsP. A.New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum.
76.
TurnerRalph H.1956. “Role-Taking, Role Standpoint, and Reference-Group Behavior.” American Journal of Sociology61(4):316–28.
77.
WimberleyDale W.1989. “Religion and Role Identity: A Structural Symbolic Interactionist Conceptualization of Religiosity.” The Sociological Quarterly30(1):125–42.
78.
YeagerDavid S.KrosnickJon A.ChangLinChiatJavitzHarold S.LevenduskyMatthew S.SimpserAlbertoWangRui. 2011. “Comparing the Accuracy of RDD Telephone Surveys and Internet Surveys Conducted with Probability and Non-probability Samples.” Public Opinion Quarterly75(4):709–47.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
