Does hearing about or witnessing someone else experience discrimination harm individuals’ mental health? Using data from the Nashville Stress and Health Study, we answer this question by examining how vicarious discrimination impacts depressive symptoms, anxiety symptoms, and anger among black Americans. We also test whether mastery and self-esteem moderate the association between vicarious discrimination and each mental health outcome. Findings indicate experiencing vicarious discrimination via a family member has a similar impact on mental health to personally experiencing discrimination. While experiencing vicarious discrimination via a close friend also increased mental health problems, it appeared to be less harmful than personally experiencing discrimination. Moreover, self-esteem moderated the association between vicarious discrimination via a family member and via a close friend and mental health, while mastery did not. This study provides new insights into ways vicarious discrimination impacts health as well as the role that psychosocial resources play in shaping this relationship.
AneshenselCarol S.2002. “Answers and Questions in the Sociology of Mental Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior43(2):236.
2.
AneshenselCarol S.2005. “Research in Mental Health: Social Etiology versus Social Consequences.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(3):221–28.
3.
AneshenselCarol S.RutterCarolyn M.LachenbruchPeter A.1991. “Social Structure, Stress, and Mental Health: Competing Conceptual and Analytic Models.” American Sociological Review56(2):166.
4.
AgnewRobert. 2002. “Experienced, Vicarious, and Anticipated Strain: An Exploratory Study on Physical Victimization and Delinquency.” Justice Quarterly19(4):603–32.
5.
ArveyRichard D.CavanaughMarcie A.1995. “Using Surveys to Assess the Prevalence of Sexual Harassment: Some Methodological Problems.” Journal of Social Issues51(1):39–52.
6.
BadawyPhilipSchiemanScott. 2020. “Control and the Health Effects of Work–Family Conflict: A Longitudinal Test of Generalized versus Specific Stress Buffering.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior61(3):324–41.
7.
BanksKira HudsonKohn-WoodLaura P.SpencerMichael. 2006. “An Examination of the African American Experience of Everyday Discrimination and Symptoms of Psychological Distress.” Community Mental Health Journal42(6):555–70.
8.
BarnesDavid M.BatesLisa M.2017. “Do Racial Patterns in Psychological Distress Shed Light on the Black–White Depression Paradox? A Systematic Review.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology52(8):913–28.
9.
BorJacobVenkataramaniAtheendar S.WilliamsDavid R.TsaiAlexander C.2018. “Police Killings and Their Spillover Effects on the Mental Health of Black Americans: A Population-Based, Quasi-experimental Study.” The Lancet392(10144):302–10.
10.
BriggsGabriel A.2015. The New Negro in the Old South. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
11.
BrownDouglas J.Zeigler-hillVirgil. 2018. “Self-Esteem.” Pp. 40–71 in The Self at Work: Fundamental Theory and Research, edited by FerrisD.JohnsonR. E.SedikidesC.New York: Routledge/Taylor & Francis Group.
12.
BrownTony N.WilliamsDavid R.JacksonJames S.NeighborsHarold W.TorresMyriamSellersSherrill L.BrownKendrick T.2000. “‘Being Black and Feeling Blue’: The Mental Health Consequences of Racial Discrimination.” Race and Society2(2):117–31.
13.
CastAlicia D.BurkePeter J.2002. “A Theory of Self-Esteem.” Social Forces80(3):1041–68.
14.
ChaeDavid H.YipTiffanyMartzConnor D.ChungKaraRichesonJennifer A.HajatAnjumCurtisDavid S.RogersLeoandra OnnieLaVeistThomas A.2021. “Vicarious Racism and Vigilance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Mental Health Implications among Asian and Black Americans.” Public Health Reports136(4):508–17.
15.
ChristakisNicholas A.FowlerJames H.2007. “The Spread of Obesity in a Large Social Network over 32 Years.” New England Journal of Medicine357(4):370–79.
16.
ColenCynthia G.LiQiReczekCorinneWilliamsDavid R.2019. “The Intergenerational Transmission of Discrimination: Children’s Experiences of Unfair Treatment and Their Mothers’ Health at Midlife.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior60(4):474–92.
17.
ConstantineMadonne G.BlackmonSha’Kema M.2002. “Black Adolescents’ Racial Socialization Experiences: Their Relations to Home, School, and Author.” Journal of Black Studies32(3):322–35.
18.
Dow DawnMarie. 2016. “The Deadly Challenges of Raising African American Boys: Navigating the Controlling Image of the ‘Thug.’”Gender and Society30(2):161–88.
19.
ElderGlen H.1994. “Time, Human Agency, and Social Change: Perspectives on the Life Course.” Social Psychology Quarterly57(1):4–15.
20.
EnglishDevinLambertSharon F.TynesBrendesha M.BowlegLisaZeaMaria CeciliaHowardLionel C.2020. “Daily Multidimensional Racial Discrimination among Black U.S. American Adolescents.” Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology66(December 2019):101068.
21.
GaymanMathew D.CisloAndrew M.GoidelAlexa R.UenoKoji. 2014. “SES and Race-Ethnic Differences in the Stress-Buffering Effects of Coping Resources among Young Adults.” Ethnicity and Health19(2):198–216.
22.
GeeGilbert C.WalsemannKatrina M.BrondoloElizabeth. 2012. “A Life Course Perspective on How Racism May Be Related to Health Inequities.” American Journal of Public Health102(5):967–74.
23.
GiesenAnnaEchterhoffGerald. 2018. “Do I Really Feel Your Pain? Comparing the Effects of Observed and Personal Ostracism.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin44(4):550–61.
24.
GraceMatthew K.2020. “Status Variation in Anticipatory Stressors and Their Associations with Depressive Symptoms.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior61(2):170–89.
25.
HarrellShelly P.2000. “A Multidimensional Conceptualization of Racism-Related Stress: Implications for the Well-Being of People of Color.” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry70(1):42–57.
26.
Heard-GarrisN. J.CaleM.CamajL.HamatiM. C.DominguezT. P.2018. “Transmitting Trauma: A Systematic Review of Vicarious Racism and Child Health.” Social Science and Medicine199:230–40.
27.
HollowayKathleenVarnerFatima. 2021. “Forms and Frequency of Vicarious Racial Discrimination and African American Parents’ Health.” Social Science and Medicine (July):114266.
28.
HudsonDarrell L.NeighborsHarold W.GeronimusArline T.JacksonJames S.2016. “Racial Discrimination, John Henryism, and Depression among African Americans.” Journal of Black Psychology42(3):221–43.
29.
HughesMichaelDemoDavid H.1989. “Self-Perceptions of Black Americans: Self-Esteem and Personal Efficacy.” American Journal of Sociology95(1):132–59.
30.
IsaacLarry W.JacobsAnna W.KucinskasJaimeMcGrathAllison R.2020. “Social Movement Schools: Sites for Consciousness Transformation, Training, and Prefigurative Social Development.” Social Movement Studies19(2):160–82.
31.
JacksonDylan B.TurneyKristin. 2021. “Sleep Problems among Mothers of Youth Stopped by the Police.” Journal of Urban Health 98:163–71.
32.
JacksonJames S.BrownTony N.WilliamsDavid R.TorresMyriamSellersSherrill L.BrownKendrick. 1996. “Racism and the Physical and Mental Health Status of African Americans: A Thirteen Year National Panel Study.” Ethnicity and Disease6(1–2):132–47.
33.
JacksonPamela BraboyWilliamsDavid R.SteinDan J.HermanAllenWilliamsStacey L.RedmondDeidre L.2010. “Race and Psychological Distress: The South African Stress and Health Study.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(4):458–77.
34.
JochmanJoseph C.CheadleJacob E.GoosbyBridget J.TomasoCaraKozikowskiChelseaNelsonTimothy. 2019. “Mental Health Outcomes of Discrimination among College Students on a Predominately White Campus: A Prospective Study.” Socius: Sociological Research for a Dynamic World5:237802311984272.
35.
KesslerRonaldMickelsonKristinWilliamsDavid. 1999. “The Prevalence, Distribution, and Mental Health Correlates of Perceived Discrimination in the United States.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior40(3):208–30.
36.
KimuraMasanoriDaiboIkuoYogoMasao. 2008. “The Study of Emotional Contagion from the Perspective of Interpersonal Relationships.” Social Behavior and Personality36(1):27–42.
37.
KoltaiJonathanBiermanAlexSchiemanScott. 2018. “Financial Circumstances, Mastery, and Mental Health: Taking Unobserved Time-Stable Influences into Account.” Social Science and Medicine202(February):108–16.
38.
LincolnKaren D.ChaeDavid H.2012. “Emotional Support, Negative Interaction and Major Depressive Disorder among African Americans and Caribbean Blacks: Findings from the National Survey of American Life.” Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology47(3):361–72.
39.
LincolnKaren D.Joseph TaylorRobertChattersLinda M.2013. “Correlates of Emotional Support and Negative Interaction among African Americans and Caribbean Blacks.” Journal of Family Issues34(9):1262–90.
40.
LouiePatriciaUpenieksLauraErvingChristy L.Thomas TobinCourtney S.2021. “Do Racial Differences in Coping Resources Explain the Black–White Paradox in Mental Health? A Test of Multiple Mechanisms.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior63(1):55–70.
41.
LouiePatriciaWheatonBlair. 2019. “The Black-White Paradox Revisited: Understanding the Role of Counterbalancing Mechanisms During Adolescence.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior60(2):169–87.
42.
MabryJ. BethKiecoltK. Jill. 2005. “Anger in Black and White: Race, Alienation, and Anger.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(1):85–101.
43.
MageeW.LouieP.2016. “Did the Difference between Black and White Americans in Anger-Out Decrease During the First Decade of the Twenty-First Century?”Race and Social Problems8(3):256–70.
44.
MastenCarrie L.MorelliSylvia A.EisenbergerNaomi I.2011. “An FMRI Investigation of Empathy for ‘Social Pain’ and Subsequent Prosocial Behavior.” NeuroImage55(1):381–88.
45.
McFarlandMichael J.TaylorJohnMcFarlandCheryl A. S.2018. “Weighed Down by Discriminatory Policing: Perceived Unfair Treatment and Black-White Disparities in Waist Circumference.” SSM-Population Health5(July):210–17.
46.
MilkieMelissa A.WarnerCatharine H.2011. “Classroom Learning Environments and the Mental Health of First Grade Children.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior52(1):4–22.
47.
MirowskyJohnRossCatherine E.2003. Social Causes of Psychological Distress. Hawthorne, NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
48.
MoradiBonnieSubichLinda Mezydlo. 2004. “Examining the Moderating Role of Self-Esteem in the Link between Experiences of Perceived Sexist Events and Psychological Distress.” Journal of Counseling Psychology51(1):50–56.
49.
MouzonDawne M.2013. “Can Family Relationships Explain the Race Paradox in Mental Health?”Journal of Marriage and Family75(2):470–85.
50.
NguyenAnn W.ChattersLinda M.TaylorRobert JosephMouzonDawne M.2016. “Social Support from Family and Friends and Subjective Well-Being of Older African Americans.” Journal of Happiness Studies17(3):959–79.
51.
NguyenDat TanWrightE. PamelaDeddingChristinePhamTam ThiBundersJoske. 2019. “Low Self-Esteem and Its Association with Anxiety, Depression, and Suicidal Ideation in Vietnamese Secondary School Students: A Cross-Sectional Study.” Frontiers in Psychiatry10(SEP):1–7.
52.
OrthUlrichRobinsRichard W.RobertsBrent W.2008. “Low Self-Esteem Prospectively Predicts Depression in Adolescence and Young Adulthood.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology95(3):695–708.
53.
OrthUlrichRobinsRichard W.WidamanKeith F.2012. “Life-Span Development of Self-Esteem and Its Effects on Important Life Outcomes.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology102(6):1271–88.
54.
ParadiesYinBenJehonathanDensonNidaEliasAmanuelPriestNaomiPieterseAlexGuptaArpanaKelaherMargaretGeeGilbert. 2015. “Racism as a Determinant of Health: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” PLoS ONE10(9):1–48.
55.
PearlinLeonard I.1989. “The Sociological Study of Stress.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior30(3):241.
56.
PearlinLeonard I.1999. “The Stress Process Revisited.” Pp. 395–415 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC.S.PhelanJ.C.Boston, MA: Springer.
57.
PearlinLeonard I.AneshenselCarol S.LeblancAllen J.1997. “The Forms and Mechanisms of Stress Proliferation: The Case of AIDS Caregivers.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(3):223.
58.
PearlinLeonard I.BiermanAlex. 2013. “Current Issues and Future Directions in Research into the Stress Process.” Pp. 325–40 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC.S.PhelanJ.C.BiermanA.Dordrecht: Springer.
59.
PearlinLeonard I.MenaghanElizabeth G.LiebermanMorton A.MullanJoseph T.1981. “The Stress Process.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior22(4):337.
60.
PearlinLeonard I.SchoolerCarmi. 1978. “The Structure of Coping.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior19(1):2–21.
61.
PearlinLeonard I.SchiemanScottFazioElena M.MeersmanStephen C.2005. “Stress, Health, and the Life Course: Some Conceptual Perspectives.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46(2):205–19.
62.
PearlinLeonard I.TurnerHeather A.1987. “The family as a context of the stress process.” Pp. 143–65 in Stress and Health: Issues in Research Methodology, edited by KaslS. V.CooperC.L.New York: Wiley.
63.
PittmanChavella T.2011. “Getting Mad but Ending Up Sad.” Journal of Black Studies42(7):1106–24.
64.
PriestNaomiPerryRyanFerdinandAngelineKelaherMargaretParadiesYin. 2017. “Effects over Time of Self-Reported Direct and Vicarious Racial Discrimination on Depressive Symptoms and Loneliness among Australian School Students.” BMC Psychiatry17(1):1–11.
65.
PudrovskaTetyanaSchiemanScottPearlinLeonard I.NguyenKim. 2005. “The Sense of Mastery as a Mediator and Moderator in the Association between Economic Hardship and Health in Late Life.” Journal of Aging and Health17(5):634–60.
66.
RadloffLenore Sawyer. 1977. “The CES-D Scale.” Applied Psychological Measurement1(3):385–401.
67.
RosenbergMorris. 1986. Conceiving the Self. New York: Basic Books.
68.
RosenbergMorrisSimmonsRoberta G.1972. Black and White Self-Esteem: The Urban School Child. Vol. 52. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association.
69.
RossCatherine E.MirowskyJohn. 2013. “The Sense of Personal Control: Social Structural Causes and Emotional Consequences.” Pp. 379–402 in Handbook of the Sociology of Mental Health, edited by AneshenselC. S.PhelanJ. C.BiermanA.Boston, MA: Springer.
70.
SchiemanScottPlickertGabriele. 2008. “How Knowledge Is Power: Education and the Sense of Control.” Social Forces87(1):153–84.
71.
SchiemanScottTurnerHeather A.2001. “‘When Feeling Other People’s Pain Hurts’: The Influence of Psychosocial Resources on the Association between Self-Reported Empathy and Depressive Symptoms.” Social Psychology Quarterly64(4):376.
72.
SchulzAmy J.GravleeClarence C.WilliamsDavid R.IsraelBarbara A.MentzGracielaRoweZachary. 2006. “Discrimination, Symptoms of Depression, and Self-Rated Health among African American Women in Detroit: Results from a Longitudinal Analysis.” American Journal of Public Health96(7):1265–70.
73.
SeatonEleanor K.YipTiffanySellersRobert M.2009. “A Longitudinal Examination of Racial Identity and Racial Discrimination among African American Adolescents.” Child Development80(2):406–17.
74.
SellersRobert M.SheltonJ. Nicole. 2003. “The Role of Racial Identity in Perceived Racial Discrimination.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology84(5):1079–92.
75.
SewellAbigail A.JeffersonKevin A.LeeHedwig. 2016. “Living under Surveillance: Gender, Psychological Distress, and Stop-Question-and-Frisk Policing in New York City.” Social Science and Medicine159:1–13.
76.
SewellAlyasah AliFeldmanJustin M.RayRashawnGilbertKeon L.JeffersonA.LeeHedwigAliAlyasahFeldmanJustin M.RayRashawnGilbertKeon L.2020. “Illness Spillovers of Lethal Police Violence: The Significance of Gendered Marginalization.” Ethnic and Racial Studies44(7):1089–1114.
77.
SiroisCatherine. 2020. “The Strain of Sons’ Incarceration on Mothers’ Health.” Social Science and Medicine264:113264.
78.
SonderlundAnders LarrabeeSchoenthalerAntoinetteThilsingTrine. 2021. “The Association between Maternal Experiences of Interpersonal Discrimination and Adverse Birth Outcomes: A Systematic Review of the Evidence.” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health18(4):1–31.
79.
SteffenPatrick R.McNeillyMayaAndersonNormanSherwoodAndrew. 2003. “Effects of Perceived Racism and Anger Inhibition on Ambulatory Blood Pressure in African Americans.” Psychosomatic Medicine65(5):746–50.
80.
TaylorDonald M.WrightStephen C.MoghaddamFathali M.LalondeRichard N.1990. “The Personal/Group Discrimination Discrepancy.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin16(2):254–62.
81.
TaylorJohnTurnerR. Jay. 2002. “Perceived Discrimination, Social Stress, and Depression in the Transition to Adulthood: Racial Contrasts.” Social Psychology Quarterly65(3):213.
82.
TaylorRobert JosephChattersLinda M.CrossChristina J.2021. “Taking Diversity Seriously: Within-Group Heterogeneity in African American Extended Family Support Networks.” Journal of Marriage and Family83(5):1349–72.
83.
TaylorRobert JosephChattersLinda M.WoodwardAmanda TolerBrownEdna. 2013. “Racial and Ethnic Differences in Extended Family, Friendship, Fictive Kin, and Congregational Informal Support Networks.” Family Relations62(4):609–24.
84.
ThoitsPeggy A.2010. “Stress and Health: Major Findings and Policy Implications.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior51(1 Suppl):S41–53.
85.
Thomas TobinCourtney S.ErvingChristy L.BarveApurva. 2021. “Race and SES Differences in Psychosocial Resources: Implications for Social Stress Theory.” Social Psychology Quarterly84(1):1–25.
86.
TrailThomas E.GoffPhillip AtibaBradburyThomas N.KarneyBenjamin R.2012. “The Costs of Racism for Marriage: How Racial Discrimination Hurts, and Ethnic Identity Protects, Newlywed Marriages among Latinos.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin38(4):454–65.
87.
TurnerR. Jay. 2013. “Understanding Health Disparities: The Relevance of the Stress Process Model.” Society and Mental Health3(3):170–86.
88.
TurnerR. JayTaylorJohnVan GundyKaren. 2004. “Personal Resources and Depression in the Transition to Adulthood: Ethnic Comparisons.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior45(1):34–52.
89.
TurneyKristin. 2022. “The Mental Health Consequences of Vicarious Adolescent Police Exposure.” Social Forces100(3):1142–69.
90.
TynesBrendesha M.Umaña-TaylorAdriana J.RoseChad A.LinJohnnyAndersonCarolyn J.2012. “Online Racial Discrimination and the Protective Function of Ethnic Identity and Self-Esteem for African American Adolescents.” Developmental Psychology48(2):343–55.
91.
UmbersonDebraCrosnoeRobertReczekCorinne. 2010. “Social Relationships and Health Behavior across the Life Course.” Annual Review of Sociology36:139–57.
92.
WethingtonElaine. 2000. “Contagion of Stress.” Pp. 229–53 in Advances in Group Processes, edited by ThyeS.R.LawlerE.J.MacyM.W.WalkerH.A.Vol. 17. New York: Emerald Group.
93.
WildemanChristopherSchnittkerJasonTurneyKristin. 2012. “Despair by Association? The Mental Health of Mothers with Children by Recently Incarcerated Fathers.” American Sociological Review77(2):216–43.
94.
WilliamsD. R.YuY.JacksonJ. S.AndersonN. B.1997. “Racial Differences in Physical and Mental Health. Socio-economic Status, Stress and Discrimination.” Journal of Health Psychology2(3):335–51.
95.
WilliamsDavid R.LawrenceJourdyn A.DavisBrigette A.VuCecilia2019. “Understanding How Discrimination Can Affect Health.” Health Services Research54(S2):1374–88.
96.
WilliamsDavid R.MohammedSelina A.2009. “Discrimination and Racial Disparities in Health: Evidence and Needed Research.” Journal of Behavioral Medicine32(1):20–47.
97.
WoffordNylaDefeverAndrew M.ChopikWilliam J.2019. “The Vicarious Effects of Discrimination: How Partner Experiences of Discrimination Affect Individual Health.” Social Psychological and Personality Science10(1):121–30.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
