I-Challenges: Influencing Others’ Perspectives by Mentioning Personal Experiences in Therapeutic Community Group Meetings

Abstract

In this article, I examine the communicative practice of mentioning a personal experience as a vehicle for challenging a peer’s perspective. I study this in the context of therapeutic community (TC) group meetings for clients recovering from drug misuse. Using conversation analysis, I demonstrate that TC clients use this practice, which I call an I-challenge, to influence how their peers make sense of their own experiences and to do so without commenting on those peers’ experiences and perspectives. This study highlights the power of talking in the first person as a means of influencing others—a notion previously made popular by Thomas Gordon’s work on “I-messages.” Additionally, this study illustrates a novel way of studying social influence. Whereas previous research in social psychology has focused on the cognitive constraints behind phenomena of social influence and persuasion, here I contribute to understandings of the interactional norms underlying the organization of influence as a structured and coordinated domain of social action.

Keywords

conversation analysis addiction experience group social influence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allport

Gordon W.

1985. “The Historical Background of Social Psychology.” Pp. 1–46 in Handbook of Social Psychology. Vol. 1, 3rd ed., edited by Lindzey

Aronson

New York: Random House.

Arminen

Ilkka

. 2004. “Second Stories: The Salience of Interpersonal Communication for Mutual Help in Alcoholics Anonymous.” Journal of Pragmatics 36:319–47.

Bolden

Galina

Mandelbaum

Jenny

. 2017. “The Use of Conversational Co-Remembering to Corroborate Contentious Claims.” Discourse Studies 19:3–29.

Campling

Penelope

. 2001. “Therapeutic Communities.” Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 75:365–72.

Drew

Paul

. 1992. “Contested Evidence in Courtroom Cross-Examination: The Case of a Trial for Rape.” Pp. 470–520 in Talk at Work, edited by Drew

Heritage

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Drew

Paul

. 1998. “Complaints about Transgressions and Misconduct.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 31:295–325.

Drew

Paul

Walker

Traci

. 2009. “Going too Far: Complaining, Escalating and Disaffiliation.” Journal of Pragmatics 41:2400–14.

Gill

Virginia T.

Maynard

Douglas W.

1995. “On ‘Labelling’ in Actual Interaction: Delivering and Receiving Diagnoses of Developmental Disabilities.” Social Problems 42:11–37.

Gordon

Thomas

. 1970. P.E.T., Parent Effectiveness Training: The Tested New Way to Raise Responsible Children. New York: Peter H. Wyden.

10.

Gordon

Thomas.

[1974] 2003. Teacher Effectiveness Training. New York: Three Rivers Press.

11.

Heritage

John

. 2011. “Territories of Knowledge, Territories of Experience: Empathic Moments in Interaction.” Pp. 159–83 in The Morality of Knowledge in Conversation, edited by Stivers

Mondada

Steensig

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Heritage

John

. 2012. “The Epistemic Engine: Sequence Organization and Territories of Knowledge.” Research on Language & Social Interaction 45:30–52.

13.

Heritage

John

. 2015. “Well-Prefaced Turns in English Conversation: A Conversation Analytic Perspective.” Journal of Pragmatics 88:88–104.

14.

Heritage

Forthcoming. “Epistemics, Conversation Analysis, and ‘Post-Analytic’ Ethnomethodology: A Rebuttal.” Discourse Studies.

15.

Heritage

John

Lindström

Anna

. 1998. “Motherhood, Medicine, and Morality: Scenes from a Medical Encounter.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 31:397–438.

16.

Jefferson

Gail

. 1988. “On the Sequential Organization of Troubles-Talk in Ordinary Conversation.” Social Problems 4:418–41.

17.

Kendrick

Kobin.

2013. “The Role of Reciprocity in the Organization of Action-Sequencing.” Presented at the 7th Conversation Analysis Day, Loughborough University, UK.

18.

Kendrick

Kobin

Drew

Paul

. 2016. “Recruitment: Offers, Requests, and the Organization of Assistance in Interaction.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 49:1–19.

19.

Leudar

Ivan

Antaki

Charles

Barnes

Rebecca

. 2006. “When Psychotherapists Disclose Personal Information about Themselves to Clients.” Communication and Medicine 3:27–41.

20.

Oryan

Schlomit

Gastil

John

. 2013. “Democratic parenting: paradoxical messages in democratic parent education theories.” International Review of Education 59:113–129.

21.

Peräkylä

Anssi

Silverman

David

. 1991. “Owning Experience: Describing the Experience of Other Persons.” Text 11:441–80.

22.

Petty

Richard E.

Briñol

Pablo

. 2008. “Psychological Processes Underlying Persuasion. A Social Psychological Approach.” Diogenes 217:52–67.

23.

Pino

Marco

. 2016a. “Delivering Criticism through Anecdotes in Interaction.” Discourse Studies 18:695–715.

24.

Pino

Marco

. 2016b. “Knowledge Displays: Soliciting Clients to Fill Knowledge Gaps and to Reconcile Knowledge Discrepancies in Therapeutic Interaction.” Patient Education and Counseling 99:897–904.

25.

Pino

Marco

. 2016c. “When Assistance Is Not Given: Disaffiliative Responses to Therapeutic Community Clients’ Implicit Requests.” Pp. 674–93 in The Palgrave Handbook of Adult Mental Health, edited by O’Reilly

Parker

Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

26.

Pomerantz

Anita

. 1984. “Giving a Source or Basis: The Practice in Conversation of Telling ‘How I Know.’” Journal of Pragmatics 8:607–25.

27.

Rapoport

Robert N.

1959. Community as Doctor: New Perspectives on a Therapeutic Community. London: Tavistock Publications.

28.

Raymond

Geoffrey

Heritage

John

. 2006. “The Epistemics of Social Relations: Owning Grandchildren.” Language in Society 35:677–705.

29.

Ruusuvuori

Johanna

. 2005. “‘Empathy’ and ‘Sympathy’ in Action: Attending to Patients’ Troubles in Finnish Homeopathic and General Practice Consultations.” Social Psychology Quarterly 68:204–22.

30.

Sacks

Harvey

. 1984. “On Doing ‘Being Ordinary.’” Pp. 413–29 in Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis, edited by Atkinson

J. M.

Heritage

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

31.

Sacks

Harvey

. 1992. Lectures on Conversation. 2 vols. Oxford: Blackwell.

32.

Schegloff

Emanuel A.

1988. “Goffman and the Analysis of Conversation.” Pp. 89–135 in Erving Goffman: Exploring the Interaction Order, edited by Drew

Wootton

A. J.

Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.

33.

Schegloff

Emanuel A.

1990. “On the Organization of Sequences as a Source of ‘Coherence’ in Talk-in-Interaction.” Pp. 51–77 in Conversational Organization and Its Development, edited by Dorval

Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.

34.

Schegloff

Emanuel A.

1996. “Turn Organization: One Intersection of Grammar and Interaction.” Pp. 52–133 in Interaction and Grammar, edited by Ochs

Schegloff

E. A.

Thompson

S. A.

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

35.

Schegloff

Emanuel A.

1997. “Practices and Actions: Boundary Cases of Other-Initiated Repair.” Discourse Processes 23:499–545.

36.

Shah

Deepa

Paget

Sarah

. 2006. Service Standards for Addiction Therapeutic Communities. London: Royal College of Psychiatrists.

37.

Sidnell

Jack

. 2007. “‘Look’-Prefaced Turns in First and Second Position: Launching, Interceding and Redirecting Action.” Discourse Studies 9:387–408.

38.

Sidnell

Jack

Stivers

Tanya

. 2013. Handbook of Conversation Analysis. Boston: Wiley-Blackwell.

39.

Thaler

Richard H.

Sunstein

Cass R.

2009. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness. New York: Penguin Books.

40.

Wood

Wendy

. 2000. “Attitude Change: Persuasion and Social Influence.” Annual Review of Psychology 51:539–70.

41.

Wootton

A. J.

1977. “Sharing: Some Notes on the Organization of Talk in a Therapeutic Community.” Sociology 11:333–50.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.32 MB