Despite the widespread inclusion of diversity-related curricula in U.S. medical training, racial disparities in the quality of care and physician bias in medical treatment persist. The present study examined the effects of both formal and informal experiences on non-African American medical students’ (N = 2,922) attitudes toward African Americans in a longitudinal study of 49 randomly selected U.S. medical schools. We assessed the effects of experiences related to medical training, accounting for prior experiences and attitudes. Contact with African Americans predicted positive attitudes toward African Americans relative to white people, even beyond the effects of prior attitudes. Furthermore, students who reported having witnessed instructors make negative racial comments or jokes were significantly more willing to express racial bias themselves, even after accounting for the effects of contact. Examining the effects of informal experiences on racial attitudes may help develop a more effective medical training environment and reduce racial disparities in healthcare.
AllportGordon W.1954. The Nature of Prejudice. New York, NY: Perseus Books.
2.
AlwinDuane F.1997. “Feeling Thermometers Versus 7-Point Scales: Which Are Better?”Sociological Methods & Research25(3):318–40.
3.
ApfelbaumEvan P.PhillipsKatherine W.RichesonJennifer A.2014. “Rethinking the Baseline in Diversity Research: Should We Be Explaining the Effects of Homogeneity?”Perspectives on Psychological Science9(3):235–44.
Association of American Medical Colleges and Association of Schools of Public Health, Expert Panel on Cultural Competence Education for Students in Medicine and Public Health. 2012. Cultural Competence Education for Students in Medicine and Public Health: Report of an Expert Panel. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges and Association of Schools of Public Health. Retrieved July6, 2015 (https://members.aamc.org/eweb/upload/Cultural%20Competence%20Education_revisedl.pdf).
6.
BlanchardFletcher A.CrandallChristian S.BrighamJohn C.VaughnLeigh Ann. 1994. “Condemning and Condoning Racism: A Social Context Approach to Interracial Settings.”Journal of Applied Psychology79(6):993–97.
7.
BogartLaura M.CatzSheryl L.KellyJeffrey A.BenotschEric G.2001. “Factors Influencing Physicians’ Judgments of Adherence and Treatment Decisions for Patients with HIV Disease.”Medical Decision Making21(1):28–36.
8.
BurkeSara E.DovidioJohn F.PrzedworskiJulia M.HardemanRachel R.PerrySylvia P.PhelanSean M.NelsonDavid B.BurgessDiana J.YeazelMark W.van RynMichelle. 2015. “Do Contact and Empathy Mitigate Bias against Gay and Lesbian People among Heterosexual First-Year Medical Students? A Report from the Medical Student CHANGE Study.”Academic Medicine90(5):645–51.
9.
CalabreseSarah K.EarnshawValerie A.UnderhillKristenHansenNathan B.DovidioJohn F.2014. “The Impact of Patient Race on Clinical Decisions Related to Prescribing HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP): Assumptions about Sexual Risk Compensation and Implications for Access.”AIDS and Behavior18(2):226–40.
10.
ChiocchioFrançoisEssiembreHélène. 2009. “Cohesion and Performance: A Meta-analytic Review of Disparities between Project Teams, Production Teams, and Service Teams.”Small Group Research40(4):382–420.
11.
ChristOliverSchmidKatharinaLolliotSimonSwartHermannStolleDietlindTauschNicoleRamiahAnanthi AlWagnerUlrichVertovecStevenHewstoneMiles. 2014. “Contextual Effect of Positive Intergroup Contact on Outgroup Prejudice.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences111(11):3996–4000.
12.
CrandallChristian S.StangorCharles. 2005. “Conformity and Prejudice.” Pp. 295–309 in On the Nature of Prejudice: Fifty Years after Allport, edited by DovidioJ. F.GlickP.RudmanL. A.Malden, MA: Blackwell.
13.
CrispRichard J.TurnerRhiannon N.2011. “Cognitive Adaptation to the Experience of Social and Cultural Diversity.”Psychological Bulletin137(2):242–66.
14.
DerousEvaRyanAnn MarieSerlieAlec W.2015. “Double Jeopardy upon Resumé Screening: When Achmed Is Less Employable than Aïsha.”Personnel Psychology68(3):659–96.
15.
DevinePatricia G.ForscherPatrick S.AustinAnthony J.CoxWilliam T. L.2012. “Long-Term Reduction in Implicit Race Bias: A Prejudice Habit-Breaking Intervention.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology48(6):1267–78.
16.
DixonJeffrey C.2006. “The Ties That Bind and Those That Don’t: Toward Reconciling Group Threat and Contact Theories of Prejudice.”Social Forces84(4):2179–204.
17.
DovidioJohn F.EllerAnjaHewstoneMiles. 2011. “Improving Intergroup Relations through Direct, Extended and Other Forms of Indirect Contact.”Group Processes & Intergroup Relations14(2):147–60.
18.
DovidioJohn F.GaertnerSamuel L.KawakamiKerry. 2003. “Intergroup Contact: The Past, Present, and the Future.”Group Processes & Intergroup Relations6(1):5–21.
19.
EmersonMichael O.KimbroRachel TolbertYanceyGeorge. 2002. “Contact Theory Extended: The Effects of Prior Racial Contact on Current Social Ties.”Social Science Quarterly83(3):745–61.
20.
FordThomas E.FergusonMark A.2004. “Social Consequences of Disparagement Humor: A Prejudiced Norm Theory.”Personality and Social Psychology Review8(1):79–94.
21.
GawronskiBertramBodenhausenGalen V.2006. “Associative and Propositional Processes in Evaluation: An Integrative Review of Implicit and Explicit Attitude Change.”Psychological Bulletin132(5):692–731.
22.
GómezAngelTroppLinda R.FernándezSaulo. 2011. “When Extended Contact Opens the Door to Future Contact: Testing the Effects of Extended Contact on Attitudes and Intergroup Expectancies in Majority and Minority Groups.”Group Processes & Intergroup Relations14(2):161–73.
23.
GreenwaldAnthony G.McGheeDebbie E.SchwartzJordan L. K.1998. “Measuring Individual Differences in Implicit Cognition: The Implicit Association Test.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology74(6):1464–80.
24.
GreenwaldAnthony G.PettigrewThomas F.2014. “With Malice toward None and Charity for Some: Ingroup Favoritism Enables Discrimination.”American Psychologist69(7):669–84.
25.
GreenwaldAnthony G.PoehlmanT. AndrewUhlmannEric LuisBanajiMahzarin R.2009. “Understanding and Using the Implicit Association Test: III. Meta-analysis of Predictive Validity.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology97(1):17–41.
HallErika V.PhillipsKatherine W.TownsendSarah S. M.2015. “A Rose by Any Other Name? The Consequences of Subtyping ‘African Americans’ from ‘Blacks.’”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology56:183–90.
28.
HobermanJohn. 2012. Black and Blue: The Origins and Consequences of Medical Racism. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
29.
HoffmanKelly M.TrawalterSophieAxtJordan R.OliverM. Norman. 2016. “Racial Bias in Pain Assessment and Treatment Recommendations, and False Beliefs about Biological Differences between Blacks and Whites.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113(16):4296–301.
30.
HomanAstrid C.BuengelerClaudiaEckhoffRobert A.van GinkelWendy P.VoelpelSven C.2015. “The Interplay of Diversity Training and Diversity Beliefs on Team Creativity in Nationality Diverse Teams.”Journal of Applied Psychology100(5):1456–67.
31.
JackmanMary R.1994. The Velvet Glove: Paternalism and Conflict in Gender, Class, and Race Relations. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
32.
JackmanMary R.CraneMarie. 1986. “‘Some of My Best Friends Are Black . . .’: Interracial Friendship and Whites’ Racial Attitudes.”Public Opinion Quarterly50(4):459–86.
33.
JackmanMary R.MuhaMichael J.1984. “Education and Intergroup Attitudes: Moral Enlightenment, Superficial Democratic Commitment, or Ideological Refinement?”American Sociological Review49(6):751–69.
34.
KalevAlexandraDobbinFrankKellyErin. 2006. “Best Practices or Best Guesses? Assessing the Efficacy of Corporate Affirmative Action and Diversity Policies.”American Sociological Review71(4):589–617.
KirklandShari L.GreenbergJeffPyszczynskiTom. 1987. “Further Evidence of the Deleterious Effects of Overheard Derogatory Ethnic Labels: Derogation beyond the Target.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin13(2):216–27.
37.
KripalaniSunilBussey-JonesJadaKatzMarra G.GenaoInginia. 2006. “A Prescription for Cultural Competence in Medical Education.”Journal of General Internal Medicine21(10):1116–20.
38.
Lillie-BlantonMarshaBrodieMollyannRowlandDianeAltmanDrewMcIntoshMary. 2000. “Race, Ethnicity, and the Health Care System: Public Perceptions and Experiences.”Medical Care Research and Review57(4 suppl):218–35.
39.
MallettRobyn K.WilsonTimothy D.GilbertDaniel T.2008. “Expect the Unexpected: Failure to Anticipate Similarities Leads to an Intergroup Forecasting Error.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology94(2):265–77.
40.
MonteithMargo J.Ashburn-NardoLeslieVoilsCorrine I.CzoppAlexander M.2002. “Putting the Brakes on Prejudice: On the Development and Operation of Cues for Control.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology83(5):1029–50.
NiuNina N.SyedZeba A.KrupatEdwardShieldsHelen M.2012. “The Impact of Cross-cultural Interactions on Medical Students Preparedness to Care for Diverse Patients.”Academic Medicine87(11):1530–34.
43.
OswaldFrederick L.MitchellGregoryBlantonHartJaccardJamesTetlockPhilip E.2013. “Predicting Ethnic and Racial Discrimination: A Meta-Analysis of IAT Criterion Studies.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology105(2):171–92.
44.
PennerLouis A.GaertnerSamuelDividioJohn F.AlbrechtTerrance L.2013. “A Social Psychological Approach to Improving the Outcomes of Racially Discordant Medical Interactions.”Journal of General Internal Medicine28(9):1143–49.
45.
PerrySylvia P.MurphyMary C.DovidioJohn F.2015. “Modern Prejudice: Subtle, but Unconscious? The Role of Bias Awareness in Whites’ Perceptions of Personal and Others’ Biases.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology61:64–78.
46.
PettigrewThomas F.TroppLinda R.2006. “A Meta-analytic Test of Intergroup Contact Theory.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology90(5):751–83.
47.
PettigrewThomas F.TroppLinda R.2011. When Groups Meet: The Dynamics of Intergroup Contact. New York, NY: Psychology Press.
48.
PhelanSean M.PuhlRebecca M.BurkeSara E.HardemanRachelDovidioJohn F.NelsonDavid B.PrzedworskiJuliaBurgessDiana J.PerrySylviaYeazelMark W.RynMichelle van. 2015. “The Mixed Impact of Medical School on Medical Students’ Implicit and Explicit Weight Bias.”Medical Education49(10):983–92.
49.
PutnamRobert D.2007. “E Pluribus Unum: Diversity and Community in the Twenty-First Century; The 2006 Johan Skytte Prize Lecture.”Scandinavian Political Studies30(2):137–74.
50.
RughJacob S.MasseyDouglas S.2014. “Segregation in Post–Civil Rights America: Stalled Integration or End of the Segregated Century?”Du Bois Review11(2):205–32.
51.
RydellRobert J.McConnellAllen R.MackieDiane M.StrainLaura M.2006. “Of Two Minds: Forming and Changing Valence-Inconsistent Implicit and Explicit Attitudes.”Psychological Science17(11):954–58.
52.
SabinJanice A.NosekBrian A.GreenwaldAnthony G.RivaraFrederick P.2009. “Physicians’ Implicit and Explicit Attitudes about Race by MD Race, Ethnicity, and Gender.”Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved20(3):896–913.
53.
SarndalCarl-ErikSwenssonBengtWretmanJan. 1992. Model Assisted Survey Sampling. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.
54.
SchlueterElmarScheepersPeer. 2010. “The Relationship between Outgroup Size and Anti-Outgroup Attitudes: A Theoretical Synthesis and Empirical Test of Group Threat- and Intergroup Contact Theory.”Social Science Research39(2):285–95.
55.
SewellAbigail A.RayRashawn. 2015. “A Place to Trust: Black Protestant Affiliation and Trust in Personal Physicians.” Pp. 229–49 in Education, Social Factors, and Health Beliefs in Health and Health Care Services, Vol. 33, Research in the Sociology of Health Care, edited by KronenfeldJ. J.Bingley, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
56.
ShaversVickie L.FaganPebblesJonesDionneKleinWilliam M. P.BoyingtonJosephineMotenCarmenRorieEdward. 2012. “The State of Research on Racial/Ethnic Discrimination in the Receipt of Health Care.”American Journal of Public Health102(5):953–66.
57.
SheltonJ. NicoleRichesonJennifer A.2005. “Intergroup Contact and Pluralistic Ignorance.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology88(1):91–107.
58.
SmedleyBrian D.StithAdrienne Y.NelsonAlan R.2003. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Washington, DC: National Academies Press. Retrieved June26, 2015 (http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10260.html).
59.
SmithEliot R.DeCosterJamie. 2000. “Dual-Process Models in Social and Cognitive Psychology: Conceptual Integration and Links to Underlying Memory Systems.”Personality and Social Psychology Review4(2):108–31.
60.
SommersSamuel R.2006. “On Racial Diversity and Group Decision Making: Identifying Multiple Effects of Racial Composition on Jury Deliberations.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology90(4):597–612.
61.
StephanWalter G.StephanCookie White. 2005. “Intergroup Relations Program Evaluation.” Pp. 431–46 in On the Nature of Prejudice: Fifty Years after Allport, edited by DovidioJ. F.GlickP.RudmanL. A.Malden, MA: Blackwell.
62.
TroppLinda R.2007. “Perceived Discrimination and Interracial Contact: Predicting Interracial Closeness among Black and White Americans.”Social Psychology Quarterly70(1):70–81.
63.
TurnerRhiannon N.HewstoneMilesVociAlberto. 2007. “Reducing Explicit and Implicit Outgroup Prejudice via Direct and Extended Contact: The Mediating Role of Self-Disclosure and Intergroup Anxiety.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology93(3):369–88.
64.
van RynMichelleBurgessDiana J.DovidioJohn F.PhelanSean M.SahaSomnathMalatJenniferGriffinJoan M.FuSteven S.PerrySylvia. 2011. “The Impact of Racism on Clinician Cognition, Behavior, and Clinical Decision Making.”Du Bois Review8(1):199–218.
65.
van RynMichelleBurgessDianaMalatJenniferGriffinJoan. 2006. “Physicians’ Perceptions of Patients’ Social and Behavioral Characteristics and Race Disparities in Treatment Recommendations for Men with Coronary Artery Disease.”American Journal of Public Health96(2):351–57.
66.
van RynMichelleHardemanRachel R.PhelanSean M.BurkeSara E.PrzedworskiJuliaAllenMichele L.BurgessDiana J.RidgewayJenniferWhiteRichard O.DovidioJohn F.2014. “Psychosocial Predictors of Attitudes toward Physician Empathy in Clinical Encounters among 4732 1st Year Medical Students: A Report from the CHANGES Study.”Patient Education and Counseling96(3):367–75.
67.
van RynMichelleHardemanRachelPhelanSean M.DovidioJohn F.HerrinJ.BurkeSara E.NelsonDavid B.PerrySylviaYeazelMarkPrzedworskiJulia M.2015. “Medical School Experiences Associated with Change in Implicit Racial Bias among 3547 Students: A Medical Student CHANGES Study Report.”Journal of General Internal Medicine30(12):1748–56.
68.
WagnerUlrichChristOliverPettigrewThomas F.StellmacherJostWolfCarina. 2006. “Prejudice and Minority Proportion: Contact instead of Threat Effects.”Social Psychology Quarterly69(4):380–90.
69.
WearDelese. 1998. “On White Coats and Professional Development: The Formal and the Hidden Curricula.”Annals of Internal Medicine129(9):734–37.
70.
WilcoxClydeSigelmanLeeCookElizabeth. 1989. “Some like It Hot: Individual Differences in Responses to Group Feeling Thermometers.”Public Opinion Quarterly53(2):246–57.
71.
WrightStephen C.AronArthurMcLaughlin-VolpeTracyRoppStacy A.1997. “The Extended Contact Effect: Knowledge of Cross-Group Friendships and Prejudice.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology73(1):73–90.
72.
YeagerDavid S.WaltonGregory M.2011. “Social-Psychological Interventions in Education: They’re Not Magic.”Review of Educational Research81(2):267–301.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
