In this article we suggest a mechanism for norm regulation that does not rely on explicit information exchange or costly reinforcement, but rather on the sensitivity of group members to social cues in their environment. We examine whether brief conversational silences can (a) signal a threat to one’s inclusionary status in the group and (b) motivate people to shift their attitudes to be in line with group norms. In two experiments—using videotaped and actual conversations, respectively—we manipulated the presence of a brief silence after group members expressed a certain attitude. As predicted, attitudes changed relative to the norm after such a brief silence. Those highly motivated to belong changed their attitude to become more normative, whereas those less motivated to belong shifted away from the group norm. The results suggest that social regulation may occur through very subtle means.
AschSolomon E.1956. “Studies of Independence and Conformity: I. A Minority of One against a Unanimous Majority.” Psychological Monographs70(9):1–70.
2.
AxelrodRobert. 1986. “An Evolutionary Approach to Norms.” American Political Science Review80:1095–1111.
3.
BanduraAlbert. 1977. Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
4.
BaumeisterRoy F.1991. Meanings of Life. New York: Guilford Press.
5.
BaumeisterRoy F.LearyMark R.1995. “The Need to Belong: Desire for Interpersonal Attachments as a Fundamental Human Motivation.” Psychological Bulletin117:497–529.
6.
BernsteinMichael J.YoungSteven G.BrownChristina M.SaccoDonald F.ClaypoolHeather M.2008. “Adaptive Responses to Social Exclusion: Social Rejection Improves Detection of Real and Fake Smiles.” Psychological Science19:981–83.
7.
BlantonHartChristieCharlene2003. “Deviance Regulation: A Theory of Identity and Action.” Review of General Psychology7:115–49.
8.
BrewerMarilynn B.1991. “The Social Self: On Being the Same and Different at the Same Time.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin17:475–82.
9.
BrownPenelopeLevinsonStephen C.1978. “Universals of Language Usage: Politeness Phenomena.” Pp. 56–324 in Questions and Politeness, edited by GoodyE. N.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
10.
ChekrounPeggyBrauerMarkus. 2002. “The Bystander Effect and Social Control Behavior: The Effect of the Presence of Others on People’s Reactions to Norm Violations.” European Journal of Social Psychology32: 853–67.
11.
CialdiniRobert B.2001. Influence: Science and Practice. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
12.
CialdiniRobert B.GoldsteinNoah J.2004. “Social Influence: Compliance and Conformity.” Annual Review of Psychology55:591–621.
13.
ColemanJames. 1990. Foundations of Social Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
14.
DovidioJohn F.EllysonSteve L.1982. “Decoding Visual Dominance: Attributions of Power Based on Relative Percentages of Looking While Speaking and Looking While Listening.” Social Psychology Quarterly45:106–13.
15.
EaglyAlice H.ChaikenShelly C.1993. The Psychology of Attitudes. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
16.
FehrErnstGächterSimon. 2000. “Fairness and Retaliation: The Economics of Reciprocity.” Journal of Economic Perspectives14:159–81.
17.
FeldmanDaniel C.1984. “The Development and Enforcement of Group Norms.” The Academy of Management Review9:47–53.
18.
FestingerLeon. 1950. “Informal Social Communication.” Psychological Review57:271–82.
19.
FestingerLeon. 1954. “A Theory of Social Comparison Processes.” Human Relations7:117–40.
20.
FestingerLeonThibautJohn. 1951. “Interpersonal Communication in Small Groups.” Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology46:92–9.
21.
FlacheAndreasMacyMichael. 1996. “The Weakness of Strong Ties: Collective Action Failure in a Highly Cohesive Group.” Journal of Mathematical Sociology21:3–28.
22.
GardnerWendy L.PickettCynthia L.BrewerMarilynn B.2000. “Social Exclusion and Selective Memory: How the Need to Belong Influences Memory for Social Events.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin26:486–96.
23.
GibsonDavid R.2003. “Participation Shifts: Order and Differentiation in Group Conversation.” Social Forces81:1335–80.
24.
GibsonDavid R.2005. “Taking Turns and Talking Ties: Networks and Conversational Interaction.” American Journal of Sociology110:1561–97.
25.
GoethalsGeorge R.1987. “Theories of Group Behavior: Commentary.” Pp. 209–29 in Theories of Group Behavior, edited by MullenB.GoethalsG. R.New York: Springer.
26.
GoffmanErving. 1981. Forms of Talk. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
27.
HasegawaTomohiroGudykunstWilliam B.1998. “Silence in Japan and the United States.” Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology29:668–84.
28.
HechterMichael. 1987. Principles of Group Solidarity. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
HechterMichaelKanazawaSatoshi. 1993. “Group Solidarity and Social Order in Japan.” Journal of Theoretical Politics5:455–93.
30.
HomansGeorge C.1961. Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
31.
HorneChristine. 2001a. “The Enforcement of Norms: Group Cohesion and Meta-Norms.” Social Psychology Quarterly64:253–66.
32.
HorneChristine. 2001b. “Sociological Perspectives on the Emergence of Norms.” Pp. 3–34 in Social Norms, edited by HechterM.OppK. D.New York: Russell Sage.
33.
HornseyMatthew J.JettenJolanda. 2004. “The Individual within the Group: Balancing the Need to Belong with the Need to be Different.” Personality and Social Psychology Review8:248–64.
34.
HowellJennifer L.KoudenburgNamkjeLoschelderDavidWestonDaleFransenKatriende DominicisStefanoGallagherStephenHaslamS. Alexander. 2013. “The Ironic Health Effects of Pursuing Social Ties: Evidence From an Emerging Network.” Unpublished manuscript.
35.
JaworskiAdam. 1993. The Power of Silence: Social and Pragmatic Perspectives. London: Sage Publications.
36.
JettenJolandaBranscombeNyla R.SpearsRussellMcKimmieBlake M.2003. “Predicting the Paths of Peripherals: The Interaction of Identification and Future Possibilities.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin29:130–40.
37.
JettenJolandaHaslamCatherineHaslamS. Alexander, 2011. The Social Cure. Hove, UK: Psychology Press.
38.
JohannesenRichard L.1974. “The Functions of Silence: A Plea for Communication Research.” Western Speech38:25–45.
39.
KerrNorbert L.LevineJohn M.2008. “The Detection of Social Exclusion: Evolution and Beyond.” Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice12:39–52.
40.
KittsJames A.2003. “Egocentric Bias or Information Management? Selective Disclosure and the Social Roots of Norm Misperception.” Social Psychology Quarterly66: 222–37.
41.
KoudenburgNamkjePostmesTomGordijnErnestine H.2011. “Disrupting the Flow: How Brief Silences in Group Conversations Affect Social Needs.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology47:512–15.
42.
KoudenburgNamkjePostmesTomGordijnErnestine H.2013. “Conversational Flow Promotes Social Unity.” Unpublished manuscript.
43.
KoudenburgNamkjePostmesTomGordijnErnestine H.Forthcoming. “Conversational Flow and Entitativity: The Role of Status.” British Journal of Social Psychology.
44.
LakinJessica L.ChartrandTanya L.ArkinRobert M.2008. “I Am Too Just Like You: Nonconscious Mimicry as an Automatic Behavioral Response to Social Exclusion.” Psychological Science19:816–22.
45.
LearyMark R.BaumeisterRoy F.2000. “The Nature and Function of Self-Esteem: Sociometer Theory.” Pp. 1–62 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. Vol. 32, edited by ZannaM. P.San Diego: Academic Press.
46.
LearyMark R.TamborEllen S.TerdalSonja K.DownsDeborah L.1995. “Self-Esteem as an Interpersonal Monitor: The Sociometer Hypothesis.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology68:518–30.
47.
LefflerAnnGillespieDair L.ConatyJoseph C.1982. “The Effects of Status Differentiation on Nonverbal Behavior.” Social Psychology Quarterly45:153–61.
48.
MacyMichael W.KittsJames A.FlacheAndreas. 1997. “The Weakness of Strong Ties II: Collective Action Failure in a Self-Organizing Social Network.” Presented to the Mathematical Sociology Section at the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, August 11, Toronto.
49.
MacyMichael W.KittsJames A.FlacheAndreasBenardSteve. 2003. “Polarization in Dynamic Networks: A Hopfield Model of Emergent Structure.” Dynamic Social Network Modeling and Analysis: Workshop Summary and Papers, The National Academics Press, Washington, DC, 162–73.
50.
MannLeon. 1969. “Queue Culture: The Waiting Line as a Social System.” American Journal of Sociology75:340–54.
51.
MarquesJosé M.PaezDario. 1994. “The ‘Black Sheep Effect’: Social Categorization, Rejection of Ingroup Deviates, and Perception of Group Variability.” European Review of Social Psychology5:37–68.
52.
MilgramStanleyLibertyHilary J.ToledoRaymondWackenhutJoyce1986. “Response to Intrusion into Waiting Lines.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51:683–89.
53.
MoldenDaniel C.LucasGale M.GardnerWendi L.DeanKristyKnowlesMegan L.2009. “Motivations for Prevention or Promotion Following Social Exclusion. Being Rejected versus Being Ignored.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology96:415–31.
54.
MorelandRichard L.LevineJohn M.1989. “Newcomers and Oldtimers in Small Groups.” Pp. 143–86 in Psychology of Group Influence, edited by PaulusP. B.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
55.
MorrisRichard T.1956. “A Typology of Norms.” American Sociological Review21: 610–13.
56.
MoscoviciSerge. 1991. Psychologie des Minorités Actives. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
57.
PettitPhilip. 1993. The Common Mind: An Essay on Psychology, Society and Politics. New York: Oxford University Press.
58.
PickettCynthia L.GardnerWendi L.KnowlesMegan L.2004. “Getting a Cue: The Need to Belong and Enhanced Sensitivity to Social Cues.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin30:1095–1107.
59.
PomerantzAnita1984. “Agreeing and Disagreeing with Assessments: Some Features of Preferred/Dispreferred Turn Shapes.” Pp. 57–101 in Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis, edited by AtkinsonJ. M.HeritageJ.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
60.
PostmesTomSpearsRussellLeaMartin. 2000. “The Formation of Group Norms in Computer-Mediated Communication.” Human Communication Research26:341–71.
61.
PostmesTomSpearsRussellLeeAntonia T.NovakRosemary J.2005. “Individuality and Social Influence in Groups: Inductive and Deductive Routes to Group Identity.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology89:747–63.
62.
PostmesTomSpearsRussellSakhelKhaledde GrootDaphne. 2001. “Social Influence in Computer-Mediated Communication: The Effects of Anonymity on Group Behavior.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin27:1242–54.
63.
RidgewayCecilia L.BergerJosephSmithLeRoy. 1985. “Nonverbal Cues and Status: An Expectation States Approach.” American Journal of Sociology90:955–78.
64.
RobinsonDawn T.BalkwellJames W.1995. “Density, Transitivity, and Diffuse Status in Task-Oriented Groups.” Social Psychology Quarterly58:241–54.
65.
SacksHarveySchegloffEmanuel A.JeffersonGail. 1974. “A Simplest Systematics for the Organization of Turn-Taking for Conversation.” Language50:696–735.
66.
SmithLaura G. E.PostmesTom. 2011. “The Power of Talk: Developing Discriminatory Group Norms through Discussion.” British Journal of Social Psychology50:193–215.
67.
Smith-LovinLynnRobinsonDawn T.1992. “Gender and Conversational Dynamics.” Pp. 122–56 in Gender, Interaction, and Inequality, edited by RidgewayC. L.New York: Springer.
68.
StansfeldStephen A.BosmaHansHemingwayHarryMarmotMichael G.1998. “Psychosocial Work Characteristics and Social Support as Predictors of SF-36 Health Functioning.” Psychosomatic Medicine60:247–55.
69.
TannenDeborah. 1993. “The Relativity of Linguistic Strategies: Rethinking Power and Solidarity in Gender and Dominance.” Pp. 165–88 in Gender and Conversational Interaction, edited by TannenD.New York: Oxford University Press.
70.
TurnerJohn C.1991. Social Influence. Milton Keynes, UK: Open University Press.
71.
WesselmannEric D.NairneJames S.WilliamsKipling D.2012. “An Evolutionary Social Psychological Approach to Studying the Effects of Ostracism.” Journal of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology6:308–27.
72.
WilliamsKipling D.2001. Ostracism: The Power of Silence. New York: Guilford Publications.
73.
WilliamsKipling D.2009. “Ostracism: Effects of Being Excluded and Ignored.” Pp. 275–314 in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, edited by ZannaM.New York: Academic Press.
