Inertia,Density and the Structure of Organizational Populations: Entries in European Automobile Industries,1886-1981

Abstract

Existing theories of density dependence in organizational evolution treat the key processes as timeless functions of density. This paper revises the theory by specifying that the effects of density on legitimation and competition change systematically as organizational populations age. It argues that these changes in effects reflect population-level inertia due to institutionalization and the development of various forms of population structure. The proposed model of these processes implies a set of complex interactions between density and population age in effecting vital rates in organizational populations. These hypotheses are tested with data on entries of firms into the automobile indus tries of Belgium, Britain, France, Germany, and Italy during 1886-1981. These tests generally support the revised model. The pattern continues to hold when entry rates in each country are allowed to depend upon density in the whole set of countries, following Hannan et al. (1995).

Keywords

Descriptors: organizational ecology organizational evolution density dependence organizational inertia

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Amburgey, Terry L. , Tina Dacin , and Dawn Kelly 1994 'Disruptive selection and population segmentation: Interpopulation competition as a selection process' in Evolutionary dynamics of organizations. Joel A. C. Baum and Jitendra V. Singh (eds.), 240-254. New York: Oxford University Press.

Anderson, Philip 1995 'Microcomputer manufacturers' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 37-58. New York: Oxford University Press.

Baldwin, Nick , G.N. Georgano , Michael Sedgwick , and Brian Laban 1987 The world guide to automobile manufacturers New York: Facts on File Publications.

Barnett, William P. 1993

'Strategic Deterrence Among Multipoint Competitors'

Industrial and Corporate Change 2: 249-276.

Barnett, William P. 1994 'The liability of collective action: Growth and change among early telephone companies' in Evolutionary dynamics of organizations. Joel A. C. Baum and Jitendra V. Singh (eds.), 337-354. New York: Oxford University Press.

Barnett, William P. 1995 'Telephone industries' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 277-289. New York: Oxford University Press.

Barnett, William P. 1997

'The dynamics of competitive intensity'

Administrative Science Quarterly, forthcoming.

Barnett, William P. , and Glenn R. Carroll 1993

'How institutional constraints affected the organization of early U.S. telephony'.

Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 9: 98-126.

Barron, David N. 1992 'The analysis of count data: Over-dispersion and autocorrelation' in Sociological methodology 1992. Peter V. Marsden (ed.), 179-220. Oxford: Basil Blackwell .

10.

Barron, David N. 1995 'Credit unions' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 137-161. New York: Oxford University Press.

11.

Barron, David N. , Elizabeth West , and Michael T. Hannan 1994

'A time to grow and a time to die: Growth and mortality of credit unions in New York, 1914-1990'

American Journal of Sociology 100: 381-421.

12.

Baum, Joel A. C. , and Stephen J. Mezias 1992

'Localized competition and organizational failure in the Manhattan hotel industry, 1898-1990'

Administrative Science Quarterly 37: 580-604.

13.

Baum, Joel A. C. , and Walter W. Powell 1995

'Cultivating an institutional ecology of organizations: Comment on Hannan, Carroll, Dundon, and Torres'

American Sociological Review 60: 529-538.

14.

Baum, Joel A. C. , and Jitendra V. Singh 1994 'Organizational niches and the dynamics of organizational mortality'. American Journal of Sociology 100: 346-380.

15.

Blau, Judith R. 1995 'Art museums' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll, and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 87-120. New York: Oxford University Press.

16.

Boone, Christophe , and Arjen van Witteloostuijn 1995 'Industrial organization and organizational ecology: Potentials for cross-fertilization'. Organization Studies 16/2: 265-298.

17.

Burt, Ronald 1993 Structural holes: the social structure of competition Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

18.

Carroll, Glenn R. 1985

'Concentration and specialization : Dynamics of niche width in populations of organizations'

American Journal of Sociology 90: 1262-1283.

19.

Carroll, Glenn R. 1997

'Longterm evolutionary change in organizational populations: Theory, models, and findings in industrial demography'

Industrial and Corporate, forthcoming.

20.

Carroll, Glenn R. , and Michael T. Hannan 1989

'Density delay in the evolution of organizational populations: A model and five empirical tests'

Administrative Science Quarterly 34: 411-430.

21.

Carroll, Glenn R., and Michael T. Hannan, editors 1995a Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. New York; Oxford University Press.

22.

Carroll, Glenn R. , and Michael T. Hannan 1995 b'Automobile manufacturers' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 195-214. New York: Oxford University Press.

23.

Carroll, Glenn R. , and J. Richard Harrison 1994 'The historical efficiency of competition between organizational populations'. American Journal of Sociology 100: 720-749.

24.

Carroll, Glenn R. , Heather A. Haveman , and Anand Swaminathan 1990

'Karrieren in Organizationen: Eine ökologische Perspektive'

Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie 31: 146-178.

25.

Carroll, Glenn R. , Peter Preisendorfer , Anand Swaminathan , and Gabriele Wiedenmayer 1993

'Brewery and brauerei: The organizational ecology of brewing'

Organization Studies 14/2: 155-188.

26.

Carroll, Glenn R. , and Anand Swaminathan 1992 'The organizational ecology of strategic groups in the American brewing industry from 1975 to 1990' . Industrial and Corporate Change 1: 65-97.

27.

DiMaggio, Paul J. , and Walter W. Powell 1983

'The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields'

American Sociological Review 48: 147-160.

28.

Dobbin, Frank 1995 'Railroads' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 59-86. New York: Oxford University Press.

29.

Freeman, John , Glenn R. Carroll , and Michael T. Hannan 1983 'The liability of newness: Age dependence in organizational death rates'. American Sociological Review 48: 692-710.

30.

Freeman, John , and Alessandro Lomi 1994 'Resource partitioning and founding of banking cooperatives in Italy' in Evolutionary dynamics of organizations. Joel A. C. Baum and Jitendra V. Singh (eds.), 269-293. New York: Oxford University Press.

31.

Georgano, G. N., editor 1982 The new encyclopedia of motorcars : 1885 to the present, 3rd ed. New York: Dutton.

32.

Haberman, Shelby J. 1977 'Log-linear models and frequency tables with small expected cell counts'. Annals of Statistics 5: 1148-1165.

33.

Hannan, Michael T. 1989 'Competitive and institutional processes in organizational ecology' in Sociological theories in progress: new formulations. J. Berger, M. Zelditch, Jr., and B. Andersen (eds.), 388-402. Newbury Park CA: Sage.

34.

Hannan, Michael T. 1991 'Theoretical and methodological issues in analysis of density-dependent legitimation in organizational evolution' in Sociological methodology , 1991. Peter V. Marsden (ed.), 1-42. Oxford : Basil Blackwell.

35.

Hannan, Michael T. , and Glenn R. Carroll 1992 Dynamics of organizational populations: density, legitimation and competition New York: Oxford University Press.

36.

Hannan, Michael T. , and Glenn R. Carroll 1995

'Theory building and cheap talk about legitimation: Reply to Baum and Powell'

American Sociological Review 60: 539-544.

37.

Hannan, Michael T. , Glenn R. Carroll , Elizabeth A. Dundon , and John C. Torres 1995

'Organizational evolution in multinational context: Entries of automobile manufacturers in Belgium, Britain, France, Germany, and Italy'

American Sociological Review 60: 509-528.

38.

Hannan, Michael T. , and John Freeman 1977

'The population ecology of organizations'

American Journal of Sociology 82: 929-964.

39.

Hannan, Michael T. , and John Freeman 1989 Organizational ecology Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

40.

Hannan, Michael T. , James Ranger-Moore , and Jane Banaszak-Holl 1990 'Competition and the evolution of organizational size distributions' in Organizational evolution: new directions. Jitendra V. Singh (ed.), 246-268. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

41.

Hannan, Michael T. , Elizabeth West , and David N. Barron 1994 Dynamics of credit unions in New York Madison WI: Filene Center and Center for Credit Union Research.

42.

Haveman, Heather A. 1995 'The demographic metabolism of organizations: Industry dynamics, turnover, and tenure distributions'. Administrative Science Quarterly 40: 586-618.

43.

Haveman, Heather A. , and Lisa E. Cohen 1994

'The ecological dynamics of careers: The impact of organization founding, dissolution, and merger on job mobility'

American Journal of Sociology 100: 104-152.

44.

Jepperson, Ronald L. 1991 'Institutions, institutional effects, and institutionalism' in The new institutionalism in organizational analysis. Walter W. Powell and Paul J. DiMaggio (eds.), 143-163. Chicago : University of Chicago Press.

45.

Land, Kenneth C. , Walter R. Davis , and Judith R. Blau 1994 'Organizing the boys of summer: The evolution of U.S. minor league baseball, 1883-1990'. American Journal of Sociology 100: 781-813.

46.

Leslie, P.H. 1959

'The properties of a certain lag type of population growth and the influence of an external random factor on the number of such populations'

Physiological Zoology 3: 151-159.

47.

Lomi, Alessandro 1995 a'The population and community ecology of organizational founding: Italian Cooperative Banks, 1936-1989'. European Sociological Review 11: 75-98.

48.

Lomi, Alessandro 1995 b'The population ecology of organizational founding: Location dependence and unobserved heterogeneity' Administrative Science Quarterly 40: 111-145.

49.

McCullagh, P. 1983 'Quasi-likelihood functions'. The Annals of Statistics 11: 59-67.

50.

Maddison, Angus 1991 Dynamic forces in capitalist development New York: Oxford University Press.

51.

Meyer, John W. 1992 'Institutionalization and the rationality of formal organizational structure' in Organizational environments: ritual and rationality. John W. Meyer and W. Richard Scott (eds.), 261-282. Updated ed. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

52.

Meyer, John W. , and Brian Rowan 1977

'Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony'

American Journal of Sociology 83: 340-363.

53.

Minkoff, Debra 1993 'The organization of survival: Women's and racial ethnic voluntarist and activist organizations, 1955-1985'. Social Forces 71: 887-908.

54.

Olzak, Susan 1989 'Analysis of events in studies of collective action' . Annual Review of Sociology 15: 119-141.

55.

Olzak, Susan , and Elizabeth West 1991

'Ethnic conflicts and the rise and fall of ethnic newspapers'

American Sociological Review 56: 458-474.

56.

Péli, Gábor 1993 'A logical formalization of population dynamics: The density dependence model of organizational ecology'. CCSMOM Report 93-100 Centre for Computer Science in Organization and Management, University of Amsterdam.

57.

Podolny, Joel M. 1993 'A status-based model of market competition'. American Journal of Sociology 98: 829-872.

58.

Podolny, Joel M. 1995 'Investment Banks' in Organizations in industry: strategy, structure, and selection. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 290-307. New York: Oxford University Press.

59.

Podolny, Joel M. , Toby E. Stuart , and Michael T. Hannan 1996 'Networks, knowledge, and niches: Competition in the worldwide semiconductor industry, 1984-1991' . American Journal of Sociology, 102: 659-689.

60.

Singh, Jitendra V. , and Charles J. Lumsden 1990 'Theory and research in organizational ecology'. Annual Review of Sociology 16: 161-195.

61.

Sørensen, Jesper B. 1996 'The structural dynamics of inter-organizational competition and managerial mobility: a study of the television industry' . Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Stanford University.

62.

Stinchcombe, Arthur L. 1965 'Social structure and organizations' in Handbook of organizations. James G. March (ed.), 142-193. Chicago : Rand McNally.

63.

Swaminathan, Anand , and Carroll, Glenn R. 1995 'Beer brewers' in Organizations in industry. Glenn R. Carroll and Michael T. Hannan (eds.), 223-243. New York: Oxford University Press.

64.

Torres, John C. 1995 'The dynamics of the U.K. motor industry, 1894-1990' . Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. Stanford University.

65.

West, Elizabeth 1995

'Organization building in the wake of ethnic conflict: A comparison of three populations'

Social Forces 73: 1333-1364.

66.

White, Harrison C. 1981

'Where do markets come from?'

American Journal of Sociology 87: 517-547.

67.

Wholey, Douglas R. , Jon B. Christian-son , and Susan M. Sanchez 1993 'The effect of physician and corporate interests on the formation of health maintenance organizations' . American Journal of Sociology 99: 164-200.

68.

Womack, James P. , Daniel T. Jones , and Daniel Roos 1990 The machine that changed th world New York: Rawlson Associates.