More than 100 years ago, Robert Michels laid out his theory of the ‘iron law of oligarchy’. The main, and crucial, point Michels made is that oligarchy will always emerge; even in the case of genuine attempts to organise and run organisations in non-oligarchic or non-hierarchical ways, the iron law allegedly holds sway. This paper critically examines, and refutes, Michels’ theory on theoretical and methodological grounds. It argues that his theory is in many ways insufficient and that his dictum of the unavoidability of oligarchisation is not as compelling and cogent as stereotypical references to it might imply. Moreover, the paper shows that alternative/democratic organisations actually have a whole range of means to avoid oligarchisation.
AckoffR. (1994). The democratic corporation: A radical prescription for recreating corporate America and rediscovering success. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.
2.
ArcherR. (1995). Economic democracy: The politics of feasible socialism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
ArnsteinS. R. (1969). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Planning Association, 35, 216–224.
4.
BachrachP.BotwinickA. (1992). Power and empowerment: A radical theory of participatory democracy. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
5.
BeethamD. (1991). The legitimation of power. Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan Education.
6.
BogasonP.MussoJ. A. (2006). The democratic prospects of network governance. American Review of Public Administration, 36, 3–18.
7.
BowlesS.GintisH.GustafssonB. (Eds.) (1993). Markets and democracy: Participation, accountability and efficiency. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
8.
CarlyleT. (1841/1888). On heroes, hero-worship and the heroic in history. New York: Fredrick A. Stokes & Brother.
9.
CasparyW. R. (2004). Prospects and limits of a democratic economy. Humanity & Society, 28, 235–253.
10.
CheneyG. (1995). Democracy in the workplace: Theory and practice from the perspective of communication. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 23, 167–200.
11.
CongerJ. A.KanungoR. N. (1998). Charismatic leadership in organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
12.
CornforthC. (1995). Patterns of cooperative management: Beyond the degeneration thesis. Economic and Industrial Democracy, 16, 487–523, pre-publication version, Milton Keynes: Open University Business School, 1–38.
DachlerP. H.WilpertB. (1978). Conceptual dimensions and boundaries of participation in organizations: A critical evaluation. Administrative Science Quarterly, 23, 1–39.
15.
DahlR. A. (1970). After the revolution? Authority in a good society. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
16.
DahlR. A. (1971). Polyarchy: Participation and opposition. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
17.
DahlR. A. (1985). A preface to economic democracy. Berkeley: University of California Press.
18.
de JongG.van WitteloostuijinA. (2004). Successful corporate democracy: Sustainable cooperation of capital and labor in the Dutch Breman Group. Academy of Management Executive, 18(3), 54–66.
19.
DiefenbachT. (2013). Hierarchy and organisation: Toward a general theory of hierarchical social systems. London: Routledge.
20.
DruckerP. F. (1954). The practice of management. New York: Harper & Row.
21.
EpsteinR. (1987/1998). Self-interest and the constitution. In: BoazD. (Ed.) (1998). The Libertarian Reader (first paperback edition) (pp. 42–48). New York: Free Press.
22.
ErdalD. (2011). Beyond the corporation: Humanity working. London: Bodley Head.
23.
FairtloughG. (2005). The three ways of getting things done: Hierarchy, heterarchy and responsible autonomy in organizations. Bridport, UK: Triarchy.
24.
GirardM.StarkD. (2002). Distributing intelligence and organising diversity in new-media projects. Environment and Planning A, 34, 1927–1949.
25.
GrintK. (2010). The sacred in leadership: Separation, sacrifice and silence. Organization Studies, 31, 89–107.
26.
HernandezS. (2006). Striving for control: Democracy and oligarchy at a Mexican cooperative. Economic and Industrial Democracy, 27, 105–135.
27.
International Co-operative Alliance (2013). Blueprint for a co-operative decade. Planning Work Group of the International Co-operative Alliance, Cliff Mills and Will Davies, Centre for Mutual and Employee-owned Business, University of Oxford.
28.
JaquesE. (1990). In praise of hierarchy. Harvard Business Review, 68(1), 127–133.
29.
JaumierS. (2017). Preventing chiefs from being chiefs: An ethnography of a co-operative sheet-metal factory. Organization, 24, 218–239. First published online 19 August 2016.
30.
JostJ. T.HunyadyO. (2005). Antecedents and consequences of system-justifying ideologies. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 14(5), 260–265.
31.
KanterR. M. (1972). Commitment and community. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
32.
KerrS.JermierJ. M. (1978). Substitutes for leadership: Their meaning and measurement. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 22, 375–403.
33.
LangmeadK. (2016). Challenging the degeneration thesis: The role of democracy in worker cooperatives?Journal of Entrepreneurial and Organizational Diversity, 5(1), 79–98.
34.
LeachD. K. (2005). The iron law of what again? Conceptualizing oligarchy across organizational forms. Sociological Theory, 23, 312–337.
35.
LeachD. K. (2013). The structure of tyrannylessness: Assessing resistance to oligarchy in the German nonviolence and autonomous movements. Conference papers – American Sociological Association, 1–41.
36.
LipsetS. M. (1952/2010). Democracy in private government: A case study of the International Typographical Union. British Journal of Sociology61, Supplement s1 – The BJS: Shaping Sociology Over 60 Years: 9–27.
37.
LipsetS. M.TrowM.ColemanJ. S. (1956). Union democracy: The internal politics of the International Typographical Union. New York: Free Press.
38.
MallesonT. (2014). After Occupy: Economic democracy for the 21st century. New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
MansbridgeJ. J. (1980). Beyond adversary democracy. New York: Basic Books.
40.
MantzavinosC. (2004). Individuals, institutions, and markets. New York: Cambridge University Press.
41.
MartinE. J. (2015). Oligarchy, anarchy, and social justice. Contemporary Justice Review, 18, 55–67.
42.
Mateos-GarciaJ.SteinmuellerE. (2008). The institutions of open source software: Examining the Debian community. Information Economics and Policy, 20, 333–344.
43.
MeisterA. (1984). Participation, associations, development and change. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Inc.
44.
MelmanS. (2001). After capitalism: From managerialism to workplace democracy. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
45.
MichelsR. (1915/2001). Political parties: A sociological study of the oligarchical tendencies of modern democracy. Original 1911 in German: Zur Soziologie des Parteiwesens in der modernen Demokratie; Untersuchungen über die oligarchischen Tendenzen des Gruppenlebens. Transl. PaulEdenPaulCedar1915. Kitchener, ON: Batoche Books.
46.
MintzbergH. (1985). The organization as political arena. Journal of Management Studies, 22, 133–154.
47.
MulderM. (1971). Power equalization through participation?Administrative Science Quarterly, 16, 31–38.
48.
O’MahonyS.FerraroF. (2007). The emergence of governance in an open source community. Academy of Management Journal, 50, 1079–1106.
49.
OstergaardG. N.HalseyA. H. (1965). Power in co-operatives: A study of democratic control in British retail societies. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
50.
OstermanP. (2006). Overcoming oligarchy: Culture and agency in social movement organizations. Administrative Science Quarterly, 51, 622–649.
51.
OstromV. (1971/1987). The political theory of a compound republic (2nd edition). Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
52.
PatemanC. (1970). Participation and democratic theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
53.
PopperK. R. (1945/1980). Die offene Gesellschaft und ihre Feinde (6th edition) (first published 1945 as The Open Society and Its Enemies). Muenchen: UTB.
54.
RestakisJ. (2010). Humanizing the economy: Co-operatives in the age of capital. Gabriola Island, Canada: New Society Publishers.
55.
RohrschneiderR. (1994). How iron is the iron law of oligarchy? Robert Michels and national party delegates in eleven West European democracies. European Journal of Political Research, 25, 207–238.
56.
RommeA. G. L. (1999). Domination, self-determination and circular organizing. Organization Studies, 20, 801–832.
57.
RothschildJ.OllilainenM. (1999). Obscuring but not reducing managerial control: Does TQM measure up to democracy standards?Economic and Industrial Democracy, 20, 583–623.
58.
RothschildJ.WhittJ. A. (1986). The cooperative workplace: Potentials and dilemmas of organizational democracy and participation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rothschild-WhittJ. (1979). The collectivist organization: An alternative to rational-bureaucratic models. American Sociological Review, 44, 509–527.
61.
Rothschild-WhittJ.LindenfeldF. (1982). Reshaping work: Prospects and problems of workplace democracy. In LindenfeldF.Rothschild-WhittJ. (Eds.), Workplace democracy and social change (pp. 1–18). Boston, MA: Porter Sargent Publications.
62.
SauserW. I. (2009). Sustaining employee-owned companies: Seven recommendations. Journal of Business Ethics, 84, 151–164.
63.
ScottJ. C. (1990). Domination and the arts of resistance: Hidden transcripts. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
64.
ScottJ. (2003). Transformations in the British economic elite. In DoganM. (Ed.), Elite configurations at the apex of power (pp. 155–173). Leiden: Brill.
65.
SpencerH. (1897/2017). The principles of sociology. London: Forgotten Books.
66.
SrivastvaS.CooperriderD. L. (1986). The emergence of the egalitarian organization. Human Relations, 39, 683–724.
67.
SutherlandN.LandC.BöhmS. (2014). Anti-leaders(hip) in social movement organizations: The case of autonomous grassroots groups. Organization, 21, 759–781.
68.
TaylorF. W. (1911/1967). The principles of scientific management. New York: Norton & Company.
69.
ThompsonV. A. (1961). Hierarchy, specialization, and organizational conflict. Administrative Science Quarterly, 5, 485–521.
VanekJ. (1971). The participatory economy. London: Cornell University Press.
72.
VarmanR.ChakrabartiM. (2004). Contradictions of democracy in a workers’ cooperative. Organization Studies, 25, 183–208.
73.
VossK.ShermanR. (2000). Breaking the iron law of oligarchy: Union revitalization in the American Labor Movement. American Journal of Sociology, 106, 303–349.
74.
ZaleznikA. (1989). The managerial mystique: Restoring leadership in business. New York: Harper & Row.
