This study highlights significant discrepancies between CO2 market design and the actual operation of CO2 markets. Our findings are based upon an empirical investigation undertaken in the context of the European Emissions Trading Scheme between January 2009 and May 2010. CO2 markets are examined from a practice-based perspective in which actors are engaged in exchange, representational and normalizing practices. Discrepancies between the actual and intended CO2 market practices are explained using the concepts of framing, overflowing and regulatory capture. We argue that the design of the European Emissions Trading Scheme has been influenced in such a way that it does not actually challenge market participants to reduce their CO2 emissions. In this way, the study challenges the near universal reliance upon CO2 markets as the primary policy mechanism for mitigating climate change.
ApaiwongseT. S. (1993). Market responses to EPA policies. Industrial Marketing Management, 22, 319–330.
2.
AraujoL.FinchJ.KjellbergH. (Eds.) (2010). Reconnecting marketing to markets. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
AraujoL.KjellbergH. (2009). Shaping exchanges, performing markets: The study of marketing practices. In MaclaranP.SaranM.SternB.TadajewskiM. (Eds.), Handbook of marketing theory. London: SAGE.
4.
AraujoL. M. (2007). Markets, market-making and marketing. Marketing Theory, 7, 211–226.
5.
AraujoL. M.KjellbergH.SpencerR. (2008). Market practices and forms: Introduction to the special issue. Marketing Theory, 8(1), 5–14.
6.
BanerjeeS. B.IyerE. S.KashyapR. K. (2003). Corporate environmentalism: Antecedents and influence of industry type. Journal of Marketing, 67(2), 106–122.
7.
BazermanM. H. (1984). The relevance of Kahneman and Tversky’s concept of framing to organizational behavior. Journal of Management, 10, 333–343.
8.
BazermanM. H.HoffmanA. J. (1999). Sources of environmentally destructive behavior: Individual, organizational, and institutional perspectives. Research in Organizational Behavior, 21, 39–79.
9.
BebbingtonJ.Larrinaga-GonzalezC. (2008). Carbon trading: Accounting and reporting issues. European Accounting Review, 17, 697–717.
10.
BeckertJ. (2010). How do fields change? The interrelations of institutions, networks, and cognition in the dynamics of markets. Organization Studies, 31, 605–627.
11.
BennettA.ElmanC. (2006). Complex causal relations and case study methods: The example of path dependence. Political Analysis, 14, 250–267.
12.
BiggartN. W.DelbridgeR. (2004). Systems of exchange. Academy of Management Review, 29, 28–49.
13.
BraunM. (2009). The evolution of emissions trading in the European Union: The role of policy networks, knowledge and policy entrepreneurs. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 469–487.
14.
CallonM. (1998). An essay on framing and overflowing: Economic externalities revisited by sociology. In CallonM. (Ed.), The laws of the markets. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers/The Sociological Review.
15.
CallonM. (2009). Civilizing markets: Carbon trading between in vitro and in vivo experiments. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 535–548.
CooperR. (1992). Formal organization as representation: Remote control, displacement and abbreviation. In ReedM.HughesM. (Eds.), Rethinking organization: new directions in organization theory and analysis. London: SAGE.
22.
CornesR.SandlerT. (1986). The Theory of externalities, public goods and club goods. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23.
DalesJ. (1968). Pollution property and prices. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
24.
DemsetzH. (1966). Some aspects of property rights. Journal of Law and Economics, 9, 61–70.
25.
DowneyH. K.HellriegelD.SlogumW. J. (1975). Environmental uncertainty: The construct and its application. Administrative Science Quarterly, 20, 613–629.
26.
DuncanR. B. (1972). Characteristics of organizational environments and perceived environmental uncertainty. Administrative Science Quarterly, 17, 313–327.
27.
EastonG. (2010). Critical realism in case study research. Industrial Marketing Management, 39(1), 118–128.
28.
EastonG.AraujoL. M. (1994). Market exchange, social structures and time. European Journal of Marketing, 28(3), 14.
29.
ElmanC. (2009). Explanatory typologies in qualitative analysis. In ByrneD.RaginC. C. (Eds.), The Sage handbook of case-based methods. London: SAGE.
30.
EngelsA. (2009). The European Emissions Trading Scheme: An exploratory study of how companies learn to account for carbon. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 488–498.
31.
FligsteinN. (1996). Markets as politics: a political-cultural approach to market institutions. American Sociological Review, 61, 656–673.
32.
FordD.MouzasS. (2010). Networking under uncertainty: Concepts and research agenda. Industrial Marketing Management, 39(6), 956–962.
33.
FourcadeM.HealyK. (2007). Moral views of market society. Annual Review of Sociology, 33, 285–311.
34.
GeorgeA. L.BennettA. (2005). Case studies and theory development in the social sciences. London: MIT Press.
GoffmanE. (1971). Frame analysis: an essay on the organization of experience. Chicago, IL: Northeastern University Press.
37.
HagbergJ.KjellbergH. (2010). Who performs marketing? Dimensions of agential variation in market practice. Industrial Marketing Management, 39, 1028–1037.
38.
HalinenA.TörnroosJ.-Å. (2005). Using case methods in the study of contemporary business networks. Journal of Business Research, 58, 1285–1297.
39.
HardieI.MacKenzieD. (2007). Constructing the market frame: Distributed cognition and distributed framing in financial markets. New Political Economy, 12, 389–403.
40.
HardinG. (1968). The tragedy of the commons. Science, 162, 1243–1248.
41.
HealyK. (2004). Sacred markets and secular rituals in the organ transplant industry. In DobbinF. (Ed.), The sociology of the economy. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
42.
HelmD. (2010). Government failure, rent-seeking, and capture: The design of climate change policy. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 26(2), 182–196.
43.
HepburnC. (2010). Environmental policy, government, and the market. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 26(2), 117–136.
44.
HoffmannV. H.TrautmannT.HamprechtJ. (2009). Regulatory uncertainty: A reason to postpone investments? Not necessarily. Journal of Management Studies, 7, 1227–1253.
45.
HopwoodA. (2009). Accounting and the environment. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 433–439.
46.
IPCC (2001). Climate Change 2001: Synthesis Report. Summary for Policymakers. Wembley, United Kingdom: IPCC Plenary XVIII.
47.
JaffeA.NewellR. G.StavinsR. N. (2002). Environmental policy and technological change. Environmental & Resource Economics, 22(1–2), 41–69.
48.
KaltJ. P.ZupanM. A. (1984). Capture and ideology in economic theory of politics. American Economic Review, 74, 279–300.
49.
KeohaneR.HaasP. M.LevyM. A. (1993). The effectiveness of international environmental institutions. In HaasP.KeohaneR.LevyM. (Eds), Institutions for the earth: sources of effective international environmental protection. Cambridge, Mass: MIT.
50.
KjellbergH.HelgessonC.-F. (2006). Multiple versions of markets: Multiplicity and performativity in market practice. Industrial Marketing Management, 35, 839–855.
51.
KjellbergH.HelgessonC.-F. (2007). On the nature of markets and their practices. Marketing Theory, 7(2), 137–162.
52.
KnightF. H. (1921). Risk, uncertainty and profit. New York: Houghton Mifflin.
53.
KolkA.LevyD. L.PinkseJ. (2008). Corporate responses in an emerging climate regime: The institutionalization and commensuration of carbon disclosure. European Accounting Review, 17, 719–745.
54.
KossoyA.AmbrosiP. (2010). State and trends of the carbon market: 2010. Washington: World Bank, Carbon Finance Team.
55.
KrasnerS. D. (1983). Structural causes and regime consequences: Regimes as intervening variables. In KrasnerS. D. (Ed.), International regimes. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
56.
LazonickW. (1991). Business organisation and the myth of the market economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
57.
LeiserowitzA. (2006). Climate change risk perception and policy preferences: The role of affect, imagery, and values. Climatic Change, 77(1), 45–72.
58.
LevyD. L.EganD. (2003). A neo-Gramscian approach to corporate political strategy: Conflict and accommodation in the climate change negotiations. Journal of Management Studies, 40, 803–830.
59.
LevyD. L.KolkA. (2002). Strategic responses to global climate change: Conflicting pressures on multinationals in the oil industry. Business and Politics, 4, 275–300.
60.
LevyD. L.NewellP. (2002). Business strategy and international environmental governance: Toward a neo-Gramscian synthesis. Global Environmental Politics, 2(4), 84–101.
61.
LohmannL. (2005). Marketing and making carbon dumps: Commodification, calculation and counterfactuals in climate change mitigation. Science as Culture, 14, 203–235.
62.
LohmannL. (2009). Toward a different debate in environmental accounting: The cases of carbon and cost/benefit. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 499–534.
63.
MacKenzieD. (2006). An engine, not a camera: how financial models shape markets. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
64.
MacKenzieD. (2007). The political economy of carbon trading. London Review of Books, 29(7), 29–31.
65.
MacKenzieD. (2009). Making things the same: Gases, emission rights and the politics of carbon markets. Accounting, Organizations & Society, 34, 440–455.
66.
MacKenzieD.MilloY. (2003). Constructing a market, performing theory: The historical sociology of a financial derivatives exchange. American Journal of Sociology, 109, 107–145.
67.
MacKenzieD.MuniesaF.SiuL. (Eds.) (2007). Do economists make markets? On the performativity of economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
68.
MaloneyM. T.BradyG. L. (1988). Capital turnover and marketable pollution rights. Journal of Law & Economics, 31, 203–226.
69.
McCubbinsM. D.NollR. G.WeingastB. R. (1989). Structure and process, politics and policy: administrative arrangements and the political control of agencies. Virginia Law Review, 75, 431–482.
70.
McGinnK.KerosA. (2002). Improvisation and the logic of exchange in socially embedded transactions. Administrative Science Quarterly, 47, 442–473.
71.
McKinneyJ. C. (1950). The role of constructive typology in scientific sociological analysis. Social Forces, 28, 235–240.
72.
MeinshausenM.HareB. (2008). Missing the turn towards a low-emission path?Climatic Change, 91, 233–236.
73.
MilesM. B.HubermanA. M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: an expanded sourcebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
74.
MillikenF. (1987). Three types of perceived uncertainty about the environment: State, effect and response uncertainty. Academy of Management Review, 12, 133–143.
75.
MolisaP.WittnebenB. (2008). Sustainable development, the Clean Development Mechanism and business accounting. In HansjuergensB.AntesR. (Eds.), Economics and management of climate change: risks, mitigation and adaptation. Berlin: Springer Verlag.
76.
MoserS. (2010). Communicating climate change: History, challenges, process and future directions. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, 1(1), 31–53.
77.
MouzasS.FordD. (2009). The constitution of networks. Industrial Marketing Management, 38, 495–503.
78.
NelsonR. A.TietenbergT.H.DonihueM. (1993). Differential environmental regulation: Effects on electric utility capital turnover and emissions. Review of Economics and Statistics, 75, 368–373.
NorthD. C. (1990). Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
81.
NumagamiT. (1998). The infeasibility of invariant laws in management studies: A reflective dialogue in defense of case studies. Organization Science, 9, 2–15.
82.
OkerekeC. (2007). An exploration of motivations, drivers and barriers to carbon management: The UK FTSE 100. European Management Journal, 25, 475–486.
83.
OlivierJ. G. J.PetersJ. A. H. W. (2010). No growth in total global CO2 emissions in 2009. The Hague: Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency.
84.
OlsonM. (1965). The logic of collective action: public goods and the theory of groups. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
85.
PearsallJ. (Ed.) (1999). The concise Oxford dictionary. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
86.
PeltzmanS. (1976). Towards a more general theory of regulation. Journal of Law and Economics, 19, 211–248.
87.
PerryC. (1998). Processes of a case study methodology for postgraduate research in marketing. European Journal of Marketing, 32, 785–802.
88.
PosnerR. (1974). Theories of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economic and Management Science, 5, 335–358.
89.
QuinnS. (2008). The transformation of morals in markets: Death, benefits, and the exchange of life insurance policies. American Journal of Sociology, 114, 738–780.
90.
RaginC.BeckerH. (1992). What is a case? Exploring the foundations of social inquiry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ReverdyT. (2010). The unexpected effects of gas market liberalization: Inherited devices and new practices. In AraujoL.FinchJ.KjellbergH. (Eds.), Reconnecting marketing to markets. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
93.
ReveszR. L.StavinsR. N. (2004). Environmental law and policy. In PolinskyA. M.ShavellS. (Eds.), The handbook of law and economics. Amsterdam: North-Holland/Elsevier Science.
RothA. E. (2007). Repugnance as a constraint on markets. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 21(3), 37–58.
96.
RothA. E.PeransonE. (1999). The redesign of the matching market for American physicians: some engineering aspects of economic design. American Economic Review, 89, 748–779.
97.
ShafferB. (1995). Firm-level responses to government regulation: Theoretical and research approaches. Journal of Management Studies, 21, 495–514.
98.
ShiH.PengS.LiuY.ZhongP. (2008). Barriers to the implementation of cleaner production in Chinese SMEs: Government, industry and expert stakeholders’ perspectives. Journal of Cleaner Production, 16, 842–852.
99.
SmaleR.HartleyM.HepburnC.WardJ.GrubbM. (2006). The impact of CO2 emissions trading on firm profits and market prices. Climate Policy, 6, 29–46.
100.
SmithC. (1989). Auctions: the social construction of value. London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
101.
SternN. H. (2006). Stern Review: the economics of climate change. Cambridge: United Kingdom Treasury.
102.
StiglerG. (1971). The theory of economic regulation. Bell Journal of Economic and Management Science, 2(1), 3–21.
103.
SultanianE.van BeukeringP. (2008). Economics of migratory birds: Market creation for the protection of migratory birds in the inner Niger delta (Mali). Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 13(1), 3–15.
104.
SunsteinC. R. (2006). The availability heuristic, intuitive cost-benefit analysis, and climate change. Climatic Change, 77, 195–210.
105.
SutherlandR. J. (1991). Market barriers to energy-efficiency investments. Energy Journal, 12(3), 15.
106.
TsoukasH. (1989). The validity of idiographic research explanations. Academy of Management Review, 14, 551–561.
107.
TsoutsosT. D.StamboulisY. A. (2005). The sustainable diffusion of renewable energy technologies as an example of an innovation-focused policy. Technovation, 25, 753–761.
108.
TverskyA.KahnemanD. (1981). The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science, 211, 453–458.
109.
TverskyA.KahnemanD. (1986). Rational choice and the framing of decisions. Journal of Business, 59, 251–278.
110.
vandeVenA. H. (2007). Engaged scholarship: a guide for organizational and social research. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
111.
vandeVenA. H.JohnsonP. E. (2006). Knowledge for science and practice. Academy of Management Review, 31, 802–821.
112.
VaughanN.LentonT.ShepherdJ. (2009). Climate change mitigation: Trade-offs between delay and strength of action required. Climatic Change, 96(1), 29–43.
113.
VealG.MouzasS. (2010). Learning to collaborate: A study of business networks. Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, 25, 420–434.
114.
VealG.MouzasS. (2011). Changing the rules of the game: Business responses to new regulation. Industrial Marketing Management, 40, 290–300.
115.
VermeulenP.BuchR.GreenwoodR. (2007). The impact of governmental policies in institutional fields: The case of innovation in the Dutch concrete industry. Organization Studies, 28, 515–540.
116.
VineE.HamrinJ.EyreN.CrossleyD.MaloneyM.WattG. (2003). Public policy analysis of energy efficiency and load management in changing electricity businesses. Energy Policy, 31, 405.
117.
WalawalkarR.AptJ.ManciniR. (2007). Economics of electric energy storage for energy arbitrage and regulation in New York. Energy Policy, 35, 2558–2568.
118.
WeberK.HeinzeK.DeSouceyM. (2008). Forage for thought: Mobilizing codes in the movement for grass-fed meat and dairy products. Administrative Science Quarterly, 53, 529–567.
119.
WeberM. (1978). Economy and society. Berkeley: University of California Press.
120.
WittnebenB. (2009). Exxon is right: Let us re-examine our choice for a cap-and-trade system over a carbon tax. Energy Policy, 37, 2462–2464.
121.
YinR. K. (2003). Case study research: design and methods (3rd Edn.). London: SAGE.
