The article aims to study the actions of the network of elite members of a society in diverting financial flows. It is about the way the judiciary elite of a postcommunist and transitional society of Albania has practiced corruption. Prior and during the vetting or reevaluation process of the judges and prosecutors for integrity, ethics, and competence launched in 2017, it has uncovered the scale and luxury involved in the corruptive practices of judges and prosecutors. More than half of reevaluated judges and prosecutors have been dismissed due to past corruptive behavior. The vetting process has shown that over the last three decades of the transition history of Albania, a particular corruption scheme has emerged, catering to the needs of the corrupt judges and prosecutors. Based on fieldwork, this article examines the stories of the corruptive practices by judges and prosecutors of Albania. The article examines the complex mix of legal and illegal dynamics that were combined to produce defiance regime for the corruption within the judiciary of Albania. The article aims to conceptualize how this corruption regime was constructed and maintained. It also examines how interventions undertaken in fighting the corruption failed to deal with the defiance phenomenon within the Albanian judiciary.
AbrahamsF. C. (2015). Modern Albania: From dictatorship to democracy in Europe. NYU Press.
2.
BajramemajA. (2021, August30). Kriza e magjistratëve rrezikon rimëkëmbjen e drejtësisë në Shqipëri [The crisis of magistrates endangers the recovery of justice in Albania]. Reporter.al.
3.
BakillariL. (2015, April17). Si i shpëtojnë drejtësisë gjyqtarët milionerë [How millionaire judges escape justice]. Reporter.al.
BogdaniA. (2016, July19). Nga Gjin Gjoni te Sinojmeri; lista e 10 gjyqtarëve më të kamur në Shqipëri [From Gjin Gjoni to Sinojmeri; the list of the 10 most corrupt judges in Albania]. Reporter.al.
6.
BogdaniA. (2017a, September13). Dhjetë anëtarë të Gjykatës së Lartë dështojnë në testin e justifikimit të pasurisë [Ten members of the Supreme Court fail the wealth justification test]. Reporter.al.
7.
BogdaniA. (2017b, May24). Pasuri të pajustifikuara; anëtarët e Gjykatës Kushtetuese deklarojnë miliona lekë cash [Unjustified assets; members of the Constitutional Court declare millions of Lek in cash]. Reporter.al.
8.
BogdaniA. (2018a, May24). Testi i pasurisë rrëzon 56% të korpusit të prokurorëve në Shqipëri [The wealth test disqualifies 56% of the corps of prosecutors in Albania]. Reporter.al.
9.
BogdaniA. (2018b, February21). Testi i pasurisë “ngel në klasë” 57 % të gjyqtarëve të shkallës së parë në Shqipëri [The wealth test “leaves in the classroom” 57% of judges of the first instance in Albania]. Reporter.al.
10.
CalaveraG. R. (2017). To whomever it may concern. Explanatory note. EEAS.
11.
CelaL. (2018, April5). Mund të jem ‘një fermer i zoti’: Si u bë milioner ish-kryeprokurori Adriatik Llalla [I can be ‘a good farmer’: How former chief prosecutor Adriatik Llalla became a millionaire]. Reporter.al.
12.
Constitution of the Republic of Albania. (1998). Law no. 8417, 21.10.1998; Law no. 76/2016, 22.07.2016.
13.
ElbasaniA., & Šabic´S. Š. (2018). Rule of law, corruption and democratic accountability in the course of EU enlargement. Journal of European Public Policy, 25(9), 1317–1335. 10.1080/13501763.2017.1315162
14.
ErebaraG. (2021a, June22). US, EU monitors urge dismissal of Tirana’s top prosecutor. Balkan Insight.
15.
ErebaraG. (2021b, May31). Albania investigates Chief Judge over TikTok videos. Balkan Insight.
16.
ErebaraG. (2021c, February11). Albania arrests ‘corrupt’ judge and aides over suspicious prison releases. Balkan Insight.
17.
ErebaraG. (2021d, February9). European Court rejects Albanian ex-judge’s appeal against sacking. Balkan Insight.
18.
ErebaraG. (2022, April27). Tirana prosecutor fired under Albania’s vetting process. Balkan Insight.
19.
Euralius. (2020). Justice reform Albania. Ministry of Justice, Tirana.
20.
European Commission. (2011, 2018). Albania—Progress report. European Commission, Brussels.
21.
European External Action Service (EEAS). (2017). Joint press release announcing the constitution of the International Monitoring Operation Management Board.
22.
European Western Balkans. (2017, November20). Calavera: All prosecutors to be subjected to vetting.
23.
Exit News. (2021, September22). Ish-kryeprokurori Llalla shpallet në kërkim, nuk ndodhet në Shqipëri [The former chief prosecutor Llalla is declared wanted, he is not in Albania]. Exit News.
24.
Freedom House. (2014, 2015, 2016, 2018, 2021). Albania – Nations in transit. Freedom House, Washington DC.
25.
HoxhajE. (2021a, December28). Gjyqtari Ervin Trashi u penalizua për balancat negative dhe mosdeklarimin e një procedimi [Judge Ervin Trashi was penalized for negative balances and failure to declare a proceeding]. Reporter.al.
26.
HoxhajE. (2021b, December17). SPAK sekuestron apartamentin e ish-gjyqtarit Admir Thanza [SPAK seizes the apartment of former judge Admir Thanza]. Reporter.al.
27.
HoxhajE. (2021c, August6). Accusations of conflicts of interest overshadow Albania’s Justice Reform. Balkan Insight.
28.
HoxhajE. (2022a, February11). Isuf Shehu nuk arriti të kundërshtojë në KPA balancat negative [Isuf Shehu failed to oppose the negative balances in KPA]. Reporter.al.
29.
HoxhajE. (2022b, January7). Një sponsor privat financoi aktivitetin e KPK në një resort luksoz në Vlorë [A private sponsor financed the KPK activity in a luxury resort in Vlora]. Reporter.al.
30.
LalaK. (2017, October23). Gjyqtarët deklarojnë miliona lekë cash, ligjvënësit ndajnë qëndrime të ndryshme për kufizimet ligjore [Judges declare millions of lek in cash, legislators share different positions on legal restrictions]. Reporter.al.
31.
LalaK. (2016, November15). Ngërçi i ligjit “Antimafia” ndihmon gjyqtarët e korruptuar të fshehin pasurinë [The impasse of the “Antimafia” law helps corrupt judges hide their wealth]. Reporter.al.
32.
LikmetaB. (2013, July8). Albania judicial appointments cause controversy. Balkan Insight.
33.
LikmetaB. (2016a, June14). Integriteti i munguar: 80% e gjyqtarëve të karrierës nuk e justifikojnë pasurinë [Lack of integrity: 80% of career judges do not justify wealth]. Reporter.al.
34.
LikmetaB. (2016b, March31). Pasuria e një gjyqtari ‘milioner’ në skanerin e drejtësisë [The wealth of a ‘millionaire’ judge in the scanner of justice]. Reporter.al.
35.
LikmetaB. (2019, March8). Adriatik Llalla punëson lobistë në SHBA për të shpëtuar nga ‘lista e zezë’ [Adriatik Llalla hires lobbyists in the USA to escape from the “black list”]. Reporter.al.
36.
LikmetaB., & BogdaniA. (2018, October12). Si e ‘fshehu’ gjyqtari Artur Malaj vilën 3-katëshe nga vetingu [How did judge Artur Malaj “hide” the 3-story villa from the vetingu]. Reporter.al.
37.
PriftiA. (2022, May22). U shkarkuan nga vetting-u, dhjetëra prokurorë e gjyqtarë “bëhen” avokatë [Dismissed from vetting, dozens of prosecutors and judges “became” lawyers]. Investigative Network Albania.
38.
QynoE. (2016a, July20). ‘Njëra dorë lan tjetrën’ kur gjyqtarët përballen me drejtësinë [“One hand washes the other” when judges face justice]. Reporter.al.
39.
QynoE. (2016b, June17). Amnezia juridike e gjyqtarëve: Harrojnë pasurinë kur përballen me drejtësinë [Judges’ legal amnesia: They forget wealth when faced with justice]. Reporter.al.
40.
Republika e Shqipërisë Kuvendi. (2015). Analizë e Sistemit të Drejtësisë në Shqipëri [Analysis of the Justice System in Albania].
41.
SinorukaF. (2021, October8). Albania issues international arrest warrant for fugitive ex-prosecutor. Balkan Insight.
42.
Tvklan.al. (2021, September22). Adriatik Llalla nuk ndodhet në Shqipëri, u largua nga Rinasi 2 javë më pare [Adriatik Llalla is not in Albania, he left Rinas 2 weeks ago]. Tvklan.al.
43.
Vetting Law. (2016). Ligj për Rivlerësimin Kalimtar të Gjyqtarëve dhe Prokurorëve në Republikën e Shqipërisë. Law no. 84/2016, 30.08.2016.
44.
VezajF. (2015, September22). Gardianë dhe shkelës të ligjit: gjyqtarët i shpëtojnë drejtësisë në KLD [Guardians and lawbreakers: judges escape justice in KLD]. Reporter.al.
