This paper presents the results of an empirical assessment of different living environments (community, senior citizens' subsidized housing, and care institutions) for the overall well-being of the elderly. The data refer to an area probability sample of 4,344 elderly in Manitoba, Canada. Multiple regression and t tests are utilized. The findings reveal that residents of conventional housing in the community and those of senior citizens' subsidized housing are similar to one another but different from those living in care institutions. In addition, lower overall well-being is evident in care institutions than in the other two settings. The implications of the findings are discussed in terms of the current trend away from institutionalizing the elderly.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bennett, R.1963"The meaning of institutional life."Gerontologist3: 117-125.
2.
Blalock, H. M., Jr.1972Social Statistics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
3.
Brody, E. M.1978"Community housing for the elderly: the program, the people, the decision making process, and the research."Gerontologist18: 121-128.
4.
Bultena, G. L.1974"Structural effects on the morale of the aged: a comparison of age-segregated and age-integrated communities," in J. F. Gubrium (ed.) Late Life, Communities, and Environmental Policy. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
5.
Chatfield, W. F.1977"Economic and sociological factors influencing life satisfaction of the aged."J. of Gerontology32: 593-599.
6.
Cohen, J.
and R. Cohen1975Applied Multiple Regression Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: John Wiley.
7.
Cumming, E.
and W. E. Henry1961Growing Old. New York: Basic Books.
8.
Dick, H. R.
and H. J. Freidson1964"Adjustment of residents of two homes for the aged."Social Problems11: 282-290.
9.
Erickson, R.
and K. Eckert1977"The elderly poor in downtown San Diego hotels."Gerontologist17: 440-446.
10.
Goffman, E.1961Asylums. New York: Doubleday.
11.
Gubrium, J. F.1974Late Life, Communities, and Environmental Policy. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
12.
Gutman, G. M.1978"Issues and findings relating to multilevel accommodation for seniors."J. of Gerontology33: 592-600.
13.
Harel, Z.
and B. B. Harel1978"On-site coordinated services in age-segregated and age-integrated public housing."Gerontologist18: 153-158.
14.
Havens, B.
and E. Thompson 1975 "Research results: ethnic variations in needs of the elderly." Presented at the meeting of the Canadian Association on Gerontology, Toronto.
15.
Hays, W. L.1963Statistics. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
16.
Henley, B.
and M. S. Davis1967"Satisfaction and dissatisfaction: a study of the chronicallyill aged patient."J. of Health and Social Behavior8: 65-75.
17.
Heumann, T. F.1978"Planning assisted independent living programs for the semiindependent elderly."Gerontologist18: 145-152.
18.
Hochschild, A. R.1973The Unexpected Community, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
19.
Hurtado, A. V.
, M. R. Greenlick, M. McCabe, and E. W. Saward1972"The utilization and cost of home care and extended care facility services in a comprehensive, prepaid group practice program."Medical Care10: 8-15.
20.
Kahn, K. A.
, W. Hines, A. S. Woodson, and G. Burkham-Armstrong1977"A multidisciplinary approach to assessing the quality of care in long-term care facilities."Gerontologist17: 61-65.
21.
Kerlinger, F. W.
and E. J. Pedhazur1973Multiple Regression and Behavioral Research. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
22.
Kleban, M. H.
and P. Turner-Massey1978"Short-range effects of community housing."Gerontologist18: 129-132.
23.
Lalonde, A.1974A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians. Ottawa, Canada: National Health and Welfare Working Document.
24.
Larson, R.1978"Thirty years of research on the subjective well-being of older Americans."J. of Gerontology33: 109-125.
25.
Lawton, M. P.
, E. M. Brody, and P. Turner-Massey1978"The relationships of environmental factors to changes in well-being."Gerontologist18: 133-137.
26.
Lemon, B. W.1972"An exploration of the activity theory of aging: activity types and life satisfaction among in-movers to a retirement community."J. of Gerontology27: 511-523.
27.
Lipman, A.
and R. Slater1977"Homes for old people, toward a positive environment."Gerontologist17: 146-156.
28.
Lopata, H. Z.1973Widowhood in an American City. Cambridge, MA: Schenkman.
29.
Marshall, V. W.1975"Organizational features of terminal status passage in residential facilities for the aged."Urban Life4: 349-368.
30.
Mason, C. P.1954"Some correlates of self judgments of the aged."J. of Gerontology9: 324-327.
31.
Maxwell, R. J.
, J. E. Bader, and W. H. Watson1972"Territory and self in a geriatric setting."Gerontologist12: 413-417.
32.
Miller, D. B.
and S. Beer1977"Patterns of friendship among patients in a nursing home setting."Gerontologist17: 269-275.
33.
Morris, R.
and E. Harris1976"Home health services in Massachusetts, 1971: their role in care of the long-term sick."Amer. J. of Public Health62: 1,088-1,093.
34.
1978"Institutionalization and sick role identification among the elderly."Amer. Soc. Rev.43: 508-521.
35.
Neugarten, B. L.
, R. J. Havighurst, and S. S. Tobin1961"The measurement of life satisfaction."J. of Gerontology16: 134-143.
36.
Noelker, L.
and Z. Harel1978"Aged excluded from home health care: an interorganizational solution."Gerontologist18: 37-41.
37.
Palmore, E.
and C. Luikart1972"Health and social factors related to life satisfaction."J. of Health and Social Behavior13: 68-80.
38.
Penning, M. J. 1978 "Institutionalization of the elderly: an assessment of competing perspectives." Master's thesis, Univ. of Manitoba.
39.
Penning, M. J.
and N. L. Chappell forthcoming "A reformulation of basic assumptions about institutions for the elderly." In V. Marshall (ed.) Aging in Canada: Social Perspectives. Toronto: Fitzhenry and Whiteside.
40.
Pihlblad, C. T.
and D. L. Adams1972"Widowhood, social participation and life satisfaction."Aging and Human Development3: 323-330.
41.
Pincus, A.
and V. Wood1970"Methodological issues in measuring the environment in institutions for the aged and its impact on residents."Aging and Human Development1: 117-126.
42.
Pollack, M.1962"Perceptions of self in institutionalized aged subjects: response patterns to mirror reflection."J. of Gerontology17: 405-408.
43.
Powell, C.
and A. Crombie1974"The Kilsyth Questionnaire: a method of screening elderly people at home."Age and Ageing23: 23-28.
44.
Province of Manitoba1973Aging in Manitoba (vol. 1). Winnipeg, Canada: Department of Health and Social Development.
45.
Riley, M. W.
, J. W. Riley, and M. E. Johnson1969Aging and Society (vol. 2): Aging and the Professions. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
46.
1975b"Patterns of contacts for residents of age-segregated and ageintegrated housing."J. of Gerontology30: 103-107.
47.
Smith, K. J.
and A. Lipman1972"Constraint and life satisfaction."J. of Gerontology27: 77-82.
48.
Smith, R. F.
and F. N. Brand1975"Effects of enforced relocation on life adjustment in a nursing home."J. of Aging and Human Development6: 249-259.
49.
Spasoff, R. A.
, A. S. Kraus, E. J. Beattie, D.E. W. Holden, J. S. Lawson, M. Rodenburg, and G. M. Woodcock1978"A longitudinal study of elderly residents of long-stay institutions."Gerontologist18: 282-292.
50.
Spreitzer, E.
and E. E. Snyder1974"Correlates of life satisfaction among the aged."J. of Gerontology29: 454-458.
51.
Stephens, J.1975"Society of the alone: freedom, privacy, and utilitarianism as dominant norms in the SRO."J. of Gerontology30: 230-235.
52.
Struyk, R. J.1977"The housing situation of elderly Americans."Gerontologist17: 131-139.
53.
Toseland, R.
and J. Sykes1977"Senior citizens center participation and other correlates of life satisfaction."Gerontologist17: 235-241.
54.
Weiner, M. B.
, A. J. Brok, and A. M. Snadowsky1978Working with the Aged. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
55.
Wolk, S.
and S. Telleen1976"Psychological and social correlates of life satisfaction as a function of residential constraint."J. of Gerontology31: 89-98.
