Development and Utilization of Vignettes in Assessing Medical Students’ Support of Older and Younger Patients’ Medical Decisions

Abstract

Currently no appropriate vignettes exist to examine issues of age-based care among students early in their medical careers. This paper addresses that issue in two parts. First, as the development of vignettes, widely used in medical research, is rarely described, suggestions for developing reliable and valid vignettes are presented. These suggestions are derived from the development of a series of vignettes assessing the support of older and younger patients’ medical decisions among first year medical students. Second, the responses to the vignettes were analyzed quantitatively and qualitatively to assess potential age-based biases. Results indicate that students do not differ in their level of support for older and younger patients’ medical decisions. However, students are more supportive of patients who desired aggressive treatments than of those who wished to end treatment. Many students did not focus on the age of the patient, but instead on the patient’s quality of life.

Keywords

vignettes older adults age differences in medical care medical students medical decisions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Beisecker, A. , Murden, R. A. , Moore, W. P. , Graham, D. , & Nelmig, L. (1996). Attitudes of medical students and primary care physicians regarding input of older and younger patients in medical decisions. Medical Care, 34(2), 126-137.

Corbin, J. , & Strauss, A. (1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Ford, C. V. , & Sbordone, R. J. (1980). Attitudes of psychiatrists toward elderly patients. American Journal of Psychiatry, 137(5), 571-575.

Goetzler, R. M. , & Moskowitz, M. A. (1991).Changesin physician attitudes toward limiting care of critically ill patients. Archives of Internal Medicine, 151, 1537-1540.

Goldie, J. , Schwartz, L. , McConnachie, A. , & Morrison, J. (2001).Impact of a new course on students’ potential behavior on encountering ethical dilemmas. Medical Education, 35, 295-302.

Green, M. , Farber, N. J. , Ubel, P. , Mauger, D. T. , Aboff, B. M. , Sosman, J. M. , et al. (2000). Lying to each other: When internal medicine residents use deception with their colleagues. Archives of Internal Medicine, 16(15), 2317-2323.

Hebert, P. , Meslin, E. M. , Dunn, E. V. , Byrne, N. , & Reid, S. R. (1990). Evaluating ethical sensitivity in medical students: Using vignettes as an instrument. Journal of Medical Ethics, 16(3), 141-145.

Hughes, R. (1998). Considering the vignette technique and its application to a study of drug injecting and HIV risk and safer behavior. Sociology of Health and Illness, 20(3), 381-400.

James, J. W. , & Haley, W. E. (1995). Age and health bias in practicing clinical psychologists. Psychology and Aging, 10(4), 610-616.

10.

John, A. , & Steel, K. (1978). Interest in geriatrics at a university department of medicine. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 26(4), 149-156.

11.

Kalf, A. J. H. , & Spruijt-Metz, D. (1996). Variation in diagnoses: Influence of specialists’ training on selecting and ranking relevant information in geriatric case vignettes. Social Science and Medicine, 42(5), 705-712.

12.

Nigam, T. , Cameron, P. M. , & Leverette, J. S. (1997).Impasses in the supervisory process: A resident’s perspective. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 51(2), 252-272.

13.

Pearlman, R. A. , Inui, T. S. , & Carter, W. B. (1982). Variability in physician bioethical decision making. Annals of Internal Medicine, 97, 420-425.

14.

Reuben, D. B. , Fullerton, J. T. , Tschann, J. M. , & Croughan-Minihane, M. (1995). Attitudes of beginning medical students toward older persons: A five-campus study. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 43, 1430-1436.

15.

Rose, J. H. , O’Toole, E. E. , Dawson, N. V. , Thomas, C. , Connors, A. F. , Wenger, N. S. , et al. (2000). Age differences in care practices and outcomes for hospitalized patients with cancer. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 48(5), S25-S32.

16.

Tanaka, T. , & Gotay, C. (1998). Physicians’ and medical students’ perspectives on patients’ quality of life. Academic Medicine, 73, 1003-1005.

17.

Werner, T. D. , Roberts, L. W. , Smithpeter, M. , Rogers, M. , Roberts, B. , McCarty, T. , et al. (2001). Uncertainty and opposition of medical students toward assisted death practices. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 22(2), 657-667.