A continuing barrier to the implementation of curriculum fostering higher order thinking skills is the perception that use of these programs inevitably results in lower levels of content acquisition. This assumption was challenged in the current study, which compared high school students' scores on a multiple-choice standardized test after traditional or experimental instruction. Students in the experimental classroom were instructed by using an approach called problem-based learning where an ill-structured problem initiates learning and the teacher serves as a coach instead of an information repository. Results indicate that students in the experimental class did not sacrifice content acquisition when compared to students learning in more traditional settings. Implications regarding the breadth-versus-depth debate are discussed along with questions of research methodology in this area.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarrowsH. (1985). How to design a problem-based learning curriculum in the pre-clinical years. New York: Springer-Verlag.
2.
Bradley Commission on History in the Schools (1989). Building a history curriculum: Guidelines for teaching history in schools. In GagnonP. (Ed.), Historical literacy (pp. 16โ42). New York: Macmillan.
3.
BrownR. (1991). Schools of thought: How the politics of literacy shape thinking in the classroom. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
4.
CarterM. (1988). Problem solving reconsidered: A pluralistic theory of problems. College English, 50, 551โ565.
5.
ChandI.RuncoM. A. (1993). Problem finding skills as components in the creative process. Personality and Individual Differences, 14(1), 155โ162.
6.
Committee for Economic Development (1985). Investing in our children. Washington, DC: Author.
7.
DivineR. A. (1991). America, past and present. New York: Harper Collins.
8.
EhmanL. H. (1969). An analysis of the relationships of selected educational variables with the political socialization of high school students. American Educational Research Journal, 6, 559โ580.
9.
EvansR. W. (1989). A dream unrealized: A brief look at the history of issue-centered approaches. The Social Studies, 80, 178โ184.
10.
GagnonP. (Ed.). (1989). Historical literacy. New York: Macmillan.
11.
GallagherS. A. (1994). Middle school predictors of science persistence. Journal for Research in Science Teaching, 31, 721โ734.
12.
GallagherS. A.SherB. T.StepienW. J.WorkmanD. (1995). Implementing problem-based learning in the science classroom. School Science and Mathematics, 126โ146.
13.
GallagherS. A.StepienW. J.RosenthalH. (1992). Changes in talented students' spontaneously elicited problem solving steps as a result of problem-based instruction. Gifted Child Quarterly, 36, 195โ201.
14.
GiraultE. S. (1971). Current trends in problem solving. In GrossR. E.MuessigR. H. (Eds.), Problem-centered social studies instruction: Approaches to reflective teaching (pp. 70โ82). Washington, DC: National Council for the Social Studies.
15.
GrossR. E. (1989). Reasons for the limited acceptance of the problems approach. The Social Studies, 80, 185โ186.
16.
HuntM. P.MetcalfL. E. (1971). Problems approach โ theory. In GrossR. E.MuessigR. H. (Eds.), Problem-centered social studies instruction: Approaches to reflective teaching (pp. 1โ11). Washington, DC: National Council for the Social Studies.
17.
KnightS. L.WaxmanH. C. (1991). Students' cognition and classroom instruction. In WaxmanH. C.WalbergH. J. (Eds.), Effective teaching: Current research. Berkeley, CA: McCutchan.
18.
MakerC. J. (1982). Curriculum development for the gifted. Rockville, MD: Aspen.
19.
MargetsonD. (1991). Why is problem-based learning a challenge? In BoudD.FelettiG. (Eds.), The challenge of problem-based learning. New York: St. Martin's.
20.
MartorellaP. (1991). Knowledge and concept development in social studies. In ShaverJ. P. (Ed.), Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning (pp. 370โ384). New York: Macmillan.
21.
MullisI. V. S.JenkinsL. B. (1988). The science report card: Elements of risk and recovery. Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service.
22.
MullisI. V.DosseyJ. A.FoertschM. A.JonesL. R.GentileC. A. (1991). Trends in academic programs: Achievement of U. S. students in science, 1969โ1990; Mathematics, 1973โ1990; Reading, 1971โ1990; and Writing, 1984โ1990. Washington, DC: U. S. Department of Education.
23.
National Education Association (1916). The social studies in secondary education. A report of the Committee on Social Studies on the Reorganization of Secondary Education (Bulletin #28). Washington, DC: U. S. Department of the Interior, Bureau of Education.
24.
NewellA. (1980). Reasoning, problem solving, and decision processes: The problem as a fundamental category. In NickersonR. S. (Ed.), Attention and Performance VIII: Proceedings of the Eighth International Symposium on Attention and Performance (pp. 693โ718). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
25.
NewmannF. M. (1990). Higher order thinking in teaching social studies: A rational for the assessment of classroom thoughtfulness. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 22(1), 41โ56.
26.
NorusisM. J. (1991). The SPSS guide to data analysis. Chicago, IL: SPSS.
27.
OkudaS. M.RuncoM. A.BergerD. E. (1991). Creativity and the finding and solving of real-world problems. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 9, 45โ53.
28.
OliverD. W.ShaverJ. P. (1963). The analysis of public controversy: A study of citizenship education. A report to the U. S. Office of Education. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Graduate School of Education, The Laboratory for Research in Instruction.
29.
OnoskoJ. J. (1991). Barriers to the promotion of higher order thinking in social studies. Theory and Research in Social Education, 19, 341โ366.
30.
ParkerW. C. (1991). Achieving thinking and decision-making objectives in social studies. In ShaverJ. P. (Ed.), Handbook of research on social studies teaching and learning (pp. 345โ356). New York: Macmillan.
31.
PatrickJ. J. (1991). Achievement of knowledge by high school students in core subjects of the social studies. Bloomington: Indiana University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. EDO-SO-91โ1).
32.
RutherfordF. J.AhlgrenA. (1990). Science for all Americans. NY: Basic Books.
33.
SpiroR. J.VispoelW.SchmitzJ.SamarapugavanA.BoergerA. (1987). Knowledge acquisitions for application: Cognitive flexibility and transfer in complex content domains. In BrittonB. C. (Ed.), Executive control processes (pp. 177โ199). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
34.
SpiroR. J.FeltovichP. J.CoulsonR. L.AndersonD. K. (1989). Multiple analogies for complex concepts: Antidotes for analogy-induced misconception in advanced knowledge acquisition. In VoaniadovS.OrtonyA. (Eds.), Similarity and analogical reasoning. New York: Cambridge University Press.
35.
StepienW. J.GallagherS. A. (1993). Problem-based learning: As authentic as it gets. Educational Leadership, 50(7), 25โ29.
36.
StepienW. J.GallagherS. A.WorkmanD. (1993). Problem-based learning for traditional and interdisciplinary classrooms. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 16, 338โ357.
37.
SternbergR. J. (1988). The triarchic mind: A new theory of intelligence. New York: Viking.
38.
TabaH. (1962). Curriculum development, theory, and practice. New York: Harcourt, Brace, & World.
39.
PurtaTorney J. (1986). Predictors of global awareness and concern among secondary school students. Columbus: Ohio State University, The Merson Center. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 271 364).
40.
VanSickleR. L.HogeJ. D. (1991). Higher cognitive thinking skills in social studies: Concepts and critiques. Theory and Research in Social Education, 19, 152โ172.
41.
VossJ. F. (1989). Problem solving and the educational process. In LesgoldA.GlaserR. (Eds.), Foundations for a psychology of education (pp. 351โ394). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
42.
WhiteheadA. N. (1967). The aims of education and other essays (2nd ed.). New York: Free Press.
43.
WigginsG. (1989). The futility of trying to teach everything of importance. Educational Leadership, 47(3), 44โ59.
