Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2024-12
Millions of Students Are (Still) Above Grade Level: Achievement and Achievement Variability in Mathematics and Reading Before and During COVID-19 in the United States
According to a 2017 article by Peters and colleagues, millions of students have already demonstrated they know the material slated to be taught that year. Consequently, grade-level standards are unlikely to be appropriately challenging for these students. In this paper, we conceptually replicated and extended this prior study. Using data from schools that administered the Renaissance Star assessment in Fall 2018 and Fall 2021, we quantified pre-COVID and mid-COVID average achievement and variance in achievement in mathematics and reading in fifth grade and estimated the grade level of instruction needed for students. Our results indicate that (a) achievement dropped during COVID-19 relative to pre-COVID, but the drop in mathematics was larger, and (b) achievement variability increased during COVID-19, but the variability in reading was slightly more pronounced. Further, our results replicated Peters et al.’s (2017) results showing that large numbers of students still performed above grade level, and substantial variability in achievement was present within schools.
AlexanderK. L.EntwisleD. R.OlsonL. S. (2001). Schools, achievement, and inequality: A seasonal perspective. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 23(2), 171–191. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737023002171
2.
AnsariA. (2018). The persistence of preschool effects from early childhood through adolescence. Journal of Educational Psychology, 110(7), 952–973. https://doi.apa.org/doi/10.1037/edu0000255
3.
BaileyD. H.DuncanG. J.MurnaneR. J.Au YeungN. (2021). Achievement gaps in the wake of COVID-19. Educational Researcher, 50(5), 266–275. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X211011237
4.
CooperH.NyeB.CharltonK.LindsayJ.GreathouseS. (1996). The effects of summer vacation on achievement test scores: A narrative and meta-analytic review. Review of Educational Research, 66(3), 227–268. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543066003227
5.
EngelM.ClaessensA.FinchM. A. (2013). Teaching students what they already know? The (mis)alignment between mathematics instructional content and student knowledge in kindergarten. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 35(2), 157–178. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373712461850
6.
HaderleinS. K.SaavedraA. R.PolikoffM. S.SilverD.RapaportA.GarlandM. (2021). Disparities in educational access in the time of COVID: Evidence from a nationally representative panel of American families. AERA Open, 7(1), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584211041350
MakelM. C.PluckerJ. A. (2015). An introduction to replication research in gifted education: Shiny and new is not the same as useful. Gifted Child Quarterly, 59(3), 157–164. https://doi.org/10.1177/0016986215578747
PedersenB.MakelM. C.Rambo-HernandezK. E.PetersS. J.PluckerJ. A. (2023). Most mathematics classrooms contain wide-ranging achievement levels. Gifted Child Quarterly, 67(3), 220–234. https://doi.org/10.1177/00169862231166074
15.
PetersS. J.Rambo-HernandezK.MakelM. C.MatthewsM. S.PluckerJ. A. (2017). Should millions of students take a gap year? Large numbers of students start the school year above grade level. Gifted Child Quarterly, 61(3), 229–238. https://doi.org/10.1177/0016986217701834
16.
PierL.HoughH. J.ChristianM.BookmanN.WilkenfeldB.MillerR. (2021, January 25). COVID-19 and the educational equity crisis: Evidence on learning loss from the CORE Data Collaborative [Commentary]. Policy Analysis for California Education. https://edpolicyinca.org/newsroom/covid-19-and-educational-equity-crisis
17.
PolikoffM. (2021). Beyond standards: The fragmentation of education governance and the promise of curriculum reform. Harvard Education Press.
18.
Rambo-HernandezK. E.MakelM. C.PetersS. J.WorleyC. (2022). Differential return on investment: Academic growth based on initial achievement. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 92(3), 817–842. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjep.12479
19.
Rambo-HernandezK. E.PetersS. J.PluckerJ. A.MakelM. C.PedersenB. A. (2021, April 8–12). How academically diverse is the “Grade-Level” classroom? In 2021 American educational research association annual conference: Virtual conference. [Conference presentation].
SchultJ.MahlerN.FauthB.LindnerM. A. (2022). Did students learn less during the COVID-19 pandemic? Reading and mathematics competencies before and after the first pandemic wave. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 33(4), 544–563. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2022.2061014
Steenbergen-HuS.MakelM. C.Olszewski-KubiliusP. (2016). What one hundred years of research says about the effects of ability grouping and acceleration on K–12 students’ academic achievement: Findings from two second-order meta-analyses. Review of Educational Research, 86(4), 849–899. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654316675417
27.
U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress. (2022). 1971–2022 long-term trend (LTT) reading and mathematics assessments. https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/highlights/ltt/2022/
28.
von HippelP. T.HamrockC. (2019). Do test score gaps grow before, during, or between the school years? Measurement artifacts and what we can know in spite of them. Sociological Science, 6(1), 43–80. https://doi.org/10.15195/v6.a3
29.
VygotskyL. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. (ColeM.John-SteinerV.ScribnerS.SoubermanE.LuriaA. R.Lopez-MorillasM.ColeM.WertschJ. V.], Trans.). Harvard University Press. (Original manuscripts [ca. 1930–1934]).
30.
WestJ.FlanaganK. D.Germino-HauskenE. (2000). America’s kindergartners: Findings from the early childhood longitudinal study, kindergarten class of 1998-99, fall 1998. Jerry west, Kristin Denton, Elvie Germino-Hausken. U.S. Dept. of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement, National Center for Education Statistics. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000070.pdf
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
