This paper explores how a particular form of regulation—prior ethical review of research—developed over time in a specific context, testing the claims of standard explanations for such change (which center on the role of exogenous shocks in the form of research scandals) against more recent theoretical approaches to institutional changes, which emphasize the role of gradual change. To makes its case, this paper draws on archival and interview material focusing on the research ethics review system in the UK National Health Service. Key insights center on the minimal role scandals play in shaping changes in this regulatory setting and how these depend upon the absence of a single coherent profession (and accompanying social contract) associated with biomedical research.
AbrahamJ.2009. “Partial Progress: Governing the Pharmaceutical Industry and the NHS, 1948-2008.” Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law34 (6): 931–77.
2.
AlbertiG.1995. “Editorial: Local Research Ethics Committees.” British Medical Journal311 (1995): 639–40.
3.
AldersonP.1996. “Letter to Clive Marritt.” January 10, 1996, NPPA.
4.
AllenP. A.WatersW. E.McGreenA. M.. 1983. “Research Ethical Committees in 1981.” Journal of the Royal College of Physicians17 (2): 96–98.
5.
Anon. 1981. “Local Ethical Committees: Council Approves Revised Report.” British Medical Journal282 (6268): 1010.
6.
Anon. 1983. “Editorial: Research Ethical Committees.” The Lancet321 (8332): 1026.
7.
Anon. 1986. “Research on Healthy Volunteers.” The Lancet18 (2): 900–01.
8.
AshcroftR.2003. “The Ethics and Governance of Medical Research: What Does Regulation Have to Do with Morality?” New Review of Bioethics1 (1): 41–58.
9.
Avery JonesF.DornhorstA. C.LaurenceD. R.. 1966. “Letter to Professor Max Rosenheim, President Royal College of Physicians.” September 5, 1966, Annex 1 of Royal College of Physicians (1967) Report of the Committee on the Supervision of the Ethics of Clinical Investigations in Institutions.
10.
BauchnerB.VinciV.. 2001. “What Have We Learnt from the Alder Hey Affair?” British Medical Journal322 (7301): 309–10.
11.
BiggsH.2010. Healthcare Research Ethics and Law: Regulation, Review and Responsibility. London, UK: Routledge.
12.
BoseleyS.2002. “Alder Hey Scandal Has Hampered Child Cancer Research, Says Charity.” The Guardian, December 17, 6.
13.
BozemanB.HirschP.. 2006. “Science Ethics as a Bureaucratic Problem: IRBs, Rules, and Failures of Control.” Policy Sciences38 (4): 269–91.
14.
CEC (Central Ethical Committee of British Medical Association). 1983. Local Ethical Research Committees & National (UK) Committee for Ethics of Clinical Medical Research. Draft4/December 1983, BMAA Eth42.
15.
ChalmersD.PettitP.. 1998. “Towards a Consensual Culture in the Ethical Review of Research.” Medical Journal of Australia168 (2): 79–82.
16.
ChristianM. C.GoldbergJ. L.KillenJ.AbramsJ. S.McCabeM. S.MauerJ. K.WittesR. E.. 2002. “A Central Institutional Review Board for Multi-institutional Trials.” New England Journal of Medicine346 (18): 1405–08.
17.
CookeE.2007. “Unpacking the Human Tissue Act 2004.” Research Ethics Review3 (1): 61–63.
18.
CurrieE.1990. Lifelines. London, UK: Pan.
19.
DarraghA.KennyM.LambeR.BrickI.. 1985. “Sudden Death of a Volunteer.” The Lancet1 (8420): 93–94.
20.
DH (Department of Health). 1991. Local Research Ethics Committees HSG(91)5. London, UK: HMSO.
21.
DH (Department of Health). 1995. “Review of Ethics of Multi-centre Trials.” February 1995, CMO’s Consultative Group on Research Ethics, RE/95/1, NPA.
22.
DH (Department of Health). 2001a. Governance Arrangements for NHS Research Ethics Committees. London, UK: The Stationary Office.
23.
DH (Department of Health). 2001b. Research Governance Framework for Health and Social Care. London, UK: The Stationary Office.
24.
DewarS.BoddingtonP.. 2004. “Returning to the Alder Hey Report and Its Reporting: Addressing Confusions and Improving Inquiries.” Journal of Medical Ethics30 (5): 463–69.
25.
DHSS (Department of Health and Social Security). 1975. “Supervision of the Ethics of Clinical Research Investigations and Fetal Research,” HSC{IS}153.
26.
DiMaggioP. J.PowellW. W.. 1983. “The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields.” American Sociological Review48 (2): 147–60.
27.
Dixon-WoodsM.AshcroftR. E.. 2008. “Regulation and the Social Licence for Medical Research.” Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy11 (4): 381–91.
28.
Dixon-WoodsM.YeungK.BoskC. L.. 2011. “Why Is UK Medicine No Longer a Self-regulating Profession? The Role of Scandals Involving ‘Bad Apple’ Doctors.” Social Science and Medicine73 (10): 1452–59.
29.
Douglas-JonesR. 2015. “A ‘Good’ Ethical Review: Audit and Professionalism in Research Ethics.” Social Anthropology23 (1): 53–67.
30.
ErvinA. M.TaylorH. A.MeinertC. L.EhrhardtS.. 2015. “Evidence Gaps and Ethical Review of Multicenter Studies.” Science350 (6261): 632–33.
31.
FitzgeraldM. H. 2005. “Punctuated Equilibrium, Moral Panics and the Ethics Review Process.” Journal of Academic Ethics2 (4): 315–38.
32.
GersickC. J. G. 1991. “Revolutionary Change Theories: A Multilevel Exploration of the Punctuated Equilibrium Paradigm.” The Academy of Management Review16 (1): 10–36.
33.
GodfreyM. [MPWG]. 1985. “Letter to Sir James [Gowans]—British Medical Association and Ethical Committees.” March 7, 1985, NA, FD7/3273.
34.
GriffithsR.StaceyT. E.StruthersJ.. 2000. “Commentary: Response from Members of the Griffiths Inquiry.” BMJ321 (7263): 752.
35.
Guardian. 1988. “Leading Article: Advice on Consent.” The Guardian, June 24, 26.
36.
HallD.2001. “Reflecting on Redfern: What Can We Learn from the Alder Hey Story?” Archives Disease Child84 (6): 455–56.
37.
HarrisonS.AhmadW. I. U.. 2000. “Medical Autonomy and the UK State 1975 to 2025.” Sociology34 (1): 129–46.
38.
HarrisonS.LimJ. N. W.. 2003. “The Frontier of Control: Doctors and Managers in the NHS 1966 to 1997.” Clinical Governance: An International Journal8 (1): 13–18.
39.
HarryJ. D.1987. “Research on Healthy Volunteers—A Report of the Royal College of Physicians.” British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology23 (4): 379–81.
40.
HarvardJ. D. J.1985. “Letter to Sir James Gowans,” February 14, 1985 (letter and supporting material), NA, FD7/3273.
41.
HazelgroveJ.2002. “The Old Faith and the New Science: The Nuremberg Code and Human Experimentation Ethics in Britain, 1946–73.” Social History of Medicine15 (1): 109–35.
42.
HedgecoeA. M.2009. “A Form of Practical Machinery’: The Origins of Research Ethics Committees in the UK: 1967-1972.” Medical History53 (3): 331–50.
43.
HedgecoeA. M.2012. “The Problems of Presumed Isomorphism and the Ethics Review of Social Science: A Response to Schrag.” Research Ethics8 (2): 79–86.
44.
HedgecoeA. M.2014. “A Deviation from Standard Design? Clinical Trials, Research Ethics Committees and the Regulatory Co-construction of Organizational Deviance.” Social Studies of Science44 (1): 59–81.
45.
HedgecoeA. M.CarvalhoF.LobmayerP.RakarF.. 2006. “Research Ethics Committees in Europe: Implementing the Directive, Respecting Diversity.” Journal of Medical Ethics32 (8): 483–86.
46.
HeyE.ChalmersI.. 2000. “Investigating Allegations of Research Misconduct: The Vital Need for Due Process.” British Medical Journal321 (7263): 752–55.
47.
HodgsonH. C.1963. “Letter to Maurice Pappworth, Wellcome Library, Archives and Manuscripts.” PP/MHP/C.1/6, c. March 1963.
48.
HowellC.Kolins GivanR.. 2011. “Rethinking Institutions and Institutional Change in European Industrial Relations.” British Journal of Industrial Relations49 (2): 231–55.
49.
HoylandP.1985. “Cash Offer for Drug Test Student’s Death: Pharmaceutical Company Roche Products Offers Compensation to Family of Philip Jones.” The Guardian, April 25, 1–2.
50.
JonesJ.1999. “Government Sets Up Inquiry into Ventilation Trial.” British Medical Journal318 (7183): 533.
51.
KleinR.LewisJ.. 1976. The Politics of Consumer Representation: A Study of Community Health Councils. London, UK: Centre for Studies in Social Policy.
52.
KrapohlS.2007. “Thalidomide, BSE and the Single Market: An Historical-institutionalist Approach to Regulatory Regimes in the European Union.” European Journal of Political Research46 (1): 25–46.
53.
LevineC.CaplanA. L.. 1986. “Beyond Localism: A Proposal for a National Research Review Board.” Institutional Review Board8 (2): 7–9.
54.
MahoneyJ.ThelenK.. 2009. “A Theory of Gradual Institutional Change.” In Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency, and Power, edited by ThelenMahoney, 1–37. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
55.
MarrittC.1997. “Local Research Ethics Committees: A View from the Department of Health.” In Volunteers in Research and Testing, edited by CloseBryonyCoomberR.HubbardAnthonyIllingworthJohn, 53–58. Bristol, PA: Taylor and Francis.
56.
MascetteA. M.BernardG. R.DimicheleD.GoldnerJ. A.HarringtonR.HarrisP. A.LeedsH. A.PearsonT. A.RamseyB.WagnerT. H.. 2012. “Are Central Institutional Review Boards the Solution? The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Working Group’s Report on Optimizing the IRB Process.” Academic Medicine87 (12): 1710–14.
57.
McHaleJ.HabibaM.Dixon-WoodsM.CaversD.HeneyD.Pritchard-JonesK.. 2007. “Consent for Childhood Cancer Tissue Banking in the UK: The Effect of the Human Tissue Act 2004.” Health-care Research8 (3): 266–72.
58.
Medicines Commission. 1987. Advice to Health Ministers on Healthy Volunteer Studies. London, UK: DHSS.
59.
Ministry of Health. 1968. “Supervision of the Ethics of Clinical Investigations,” HM68(33).
60.
MoldA.2010. “Patient Groups and the Construction of the Patient-consumer in Britain: An Historical Overview.” Journal of Social Policy39 (4): 505–21.
61.
MoldA.2011. “Making the Patient-consumer in Margaret Thatcher’s Britain.” Historical Journal54 (2): 509–28.
62.
MoyleR.1977. “Letter to Hugh Jenkins MP.” May 9, 1977, NA, MH160/1291.
NHS (National Health Service) Executive. 1997. Ethics Committee Review of Multi-centre Research: Establishment of Multi-centre Research Ethics Committees. London, UK: Department of Health.
65.
NHS (National Health Service) Executive West Midlands Regional Office. 2000. Report of A Review of the Research Framework in North Staffordshire Hospital NHS Trust (Griffiths report). Leeds, UK: NHS Executive.
66.
NottP. N.SteelE. A.. 1988. “Scrutinising Research Ethics Committees.” British Medical Journal297 (6659): 1333.
67.
Office of the Surgeon General. 1966. “Investigations Involving Human Subjects, Including Clinical Research.” Memo to the Heads of Institutions Receiving Public Health Service Grants from the Surgeon General, July 1, 1966. Policy and Procedure Order 129.
68.
OrmeM.HarryJ.RoutledgeP.HobsonS.. 1989. “Healthy Volunteer Studies in Great Britain: The Results of a Survey into 12 Months Activity in this Field.” British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology27 (2): 125–33.
69.
PA (Patients’ Association). n.d. “A bill.” NA, MH 160/1291.
70.
PappworthM. H.1962. “Human Guinea Pigs: A Warning.” The Twentieth Century1962 (Autumn): 68–71.
71.
PappworthM. H. 1967. Human Guinea Pigs: Experimentation on Man. London, UK: Penguin.
72.
PetrynaA.2009. When Experiments Travel: Clinical Trials and the Global Search for Human Subjects. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
73.
PettitP. 1992. “Instituting a Research Ethic: Chilling and Cautionary Tales.” Bioethics6 (2): 90–112.
74.
PfefferN.2011. “Reflections on CERES (Consumers for Ethics in Research).” In Workshop June 10th 2011, Research Volunteers Workshop. Report on Workshop Proceedings: Discussion, Conclusions and Next Steps, edited by NorrisN.BalmerB.HebdonJ., 34–35. London, UK: University College London.
75.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1967. Report of the Committee on the Supervision of the Ethics of Clinical Investigations in Institutions. London, UK: Royal College of Physicians.
76.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1973. Report of the Committee on the Supervision of the Ethics of Clinical Research Investigations in Institutions. London, UK: Royal College of Physicians.
77.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1974. “Report of a Meeting of Chairmen of Ethical Committees…” October 17, 1974, RCPA, MS4930.
78.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1984. Guidelines on the Practice of Ethics Committees in Medical Research, 1st ed. London, UK: Royal College of Physicians of London.
79.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1986. “Research on Healthy Volunteers: A Report of the Royal College of Physicians.” Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London20 (4): 243–57.
80.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1989. “Minutes of a Meeting of the College Committee on Ethical Issues in Medicine.” November 6, 1989, RCPA, MS5062.
81.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 1990. Guidelines on the Practice of Ethics Committees in Medical Research Involving Human Subjects, 2nd ed. London, UK: Royal College of Physicians of London.
82.
RCP (Royal College of Physicians). 2007. Guidelines on the Practice of Ethics Committees in Medical Research with Human Participants, 4th ed. London, UK: Royal College of Physicians of London.
83.
RedfernM.2001. The Royal Liverpool Children’s Inquiry Report. London, UK: The Stationery Office.
84.
SealeC.CaversD.Dixon-WoodsM.. 2006. “Commodification of Body Parts: By Medicine or by Media?” Body and Society12 (1): 25–42.
85.
ShawS.BoyntonP. M.GreenhalghT.. 2005. “Research Governance: Where Did It Come From, What Does It Mean?” Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine98 (11): 496–502.
86.
ThelenK.2009. “Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies.” British Journal of Industrial Relations47 (3): 471–98.
87.
ToynbeeP.1985. “Phillip Jones was a Healthy Volunteer in the Trial of a New Drug. Now He Is Dead. This Is His Story.” The Guardian, March 25, 1985, p. 10.
88.
UnderwoodJ. C. E.2006. “The Impact on Histopathology Practice of New Human Tissue Legislation in the UK.” Histopathology49 (3): 221–28.
89.
Van den HoonaardW.2001. “Is Research-ethics Review a Moral Panic?” Canadian Review of Sociology/Revue canadienne de sociologie38 (1): 19–36.
90.
VeitchA.1985. “A Watch on the Tests: Human Medical Experiments.” The Guardian, April 26, 15.
91.
VereD. W. 1987. “Research on Healthy Volunteers—A Report of the Royal College of Physicians.” British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology23 (4): 375–77.
92.
WavishW. E.1971. “Memo to Mr. Smith.” December 21, 1971, NA, MH 160/185.
93.
West Birmingham CHC. 1989. “Ethical Committees: Seminar for CHC Members on District Ethical Committees.” A Report. Birmingham, UK: West Birmingham CHC.
