To understand public discourse in the United States on genetic causation of behavioral disorders, we analyzed media representations of genetic research on addiction published between 1990 and 2010. We conclude first that the media simplistically represent biological bases of addiction and willpower as being mutually exclusive: behaviors are either genetically determined, or they are a choice. Second, most articles provide only cursory or no treatment of the environmental contribution. A media focus on genetics directs attention away from environmental factors. Rhetorically, media neglect the complexity underlying the etiology the addiction and direct focus back toward individual causation and responsibility.
AckerCaroline Jean. 2010. “How Crack Found a Niche in the American Ghetto: The Historical Epidemiology of Drug-related Harm.” BioSocieties5 (1): 70–88.
2.
AgrawalArpanaLynskeyMichael T.. 2008. “Are There Genetic Influences on Addiction: Evidence from Family, Adoption and Twin Studies.” Addiction103 (7): 1069–81.
3.
AltheideDavid L.1997. “The News Media, the Problem Frame, and the Production of Fear.” The Sociological Quarterly38 (4): 647–68.
4.
American Lung Association. 2012. State of Tobacco Control. Washington, DC: American Lung Association.
5.
Associated Press. 1992. “Genetic Smoking Link Studied; Inclination to Start, Stop Cigarettes May be Inherited.” Chicago Tribune, September 17, 1992, 25.
6.
Associated Press. 2008. “Studies Find Genetic Link to Smoking.” New York Times, April 3, 2008, A21.
7.
Barkley-LevensonAmanda M.CrabbeJohn C.. 2012. “Bridging Animal and Human Models Translating From (and to) Animal Genetics.” Alcohol Research-Current Reviews34 (3): 325–35.
8.
BarnesBarryDupreJohn. 2008. Genomes and What to Make of Them. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
9.
BarrettA. E.TurnerR. J.. 2006. “Family Structure and Substance Use Problems in Adolescence and Early Adulthood: Examining Explanations for the Relationship.” Addiction101 (1): 109–20.
10.
BierutLaura JeanMaddenPamela A. F.BreslauNaomiJohnsonEric O.HatsukamiDorothyPomerleauOvideSwanGary E.RutterJoniBertelsenSarahFoxLouisFugmanDouglasGoateAlison M.HinrichsAnthony L.KonvickaKarelMartinNicholas G.MontgomeryGrant W.SacconeNancy L.SacconeScott F.WangJen C.ChaseGary A.RiceJohn P.BallingerDennis G.. 2007. “Novel Genes Identified in a High Density Genome Wide Association Study for Nicotine Dependence.” Journal of Human Molecular Genetics16 (1): 24–35.
11.
BizeRaphaëlBurnandBernardMuellerYolandaWaltherMyriam RègeCornuzJaques. 2009. “Biomedical Risk Assessment as an Aid for Smoking Cessation.” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews2009 (2): 1–29. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD004705.pub3.
BrechmanJeanLeeChui-jooCappellaJoseph N.. 2009. “Lost in Translation? A Comparison of Cancer-genetics Reporting in the Press Release and its Subsequent Coverage in the Press.” Science Communication30 (4): 453–74.
14.
BuuA.DipiazzaC.WangJ.PuttlerL. I.FitzgeraldH. E.ZuckerR. A.. 2009. “Parent, Family, and Neighborhood Effects on the Development of Child Substance Use and Other Psychopathology from Preschool to the Start of Adulthood.” Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs70 (4): 489–98.
15.
CampbellNancy D.2010. “Toward a Critical Neuroscience of ‘Addiction’.” BioSocieties5 (1): 89–104.
16.
CarlstenChrisBurkeWylie. 2006. “Potential for Genetics to Promote Public Health: Genetics Research on Smoking Suggests Caution about Expectations.” Journal of the American Medical Association296 (20): 2480–82.
17.
CaronLorraineKarkazisKatrinaRaffinThomas A.SwanGaryKoenigBarbara A.. 2005. “Nicotine Addiction through a Neurogenetic Prism: Ethics, Public Health, and Smoking.” Nicotine & Tobacco Research7 (2): 181–97.
18.
CarpenterMatthew J.StrangeCharlieJonesYongeDicksonMarguerite R.CarterCindyAllison MoseleyM.GilbertGregory E.. 2007. “Does Genetic Testing Result in Behavioral Health Change? Changes in Smoking Behavior Following Testing for Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency.” Annals of Behavioral Medicine33 (1): 22–8.
19.
CarrollKathleen M.OnkenLisa S.. 2005. “Behavioral Therapies for Drug Abuse.” American Journal of Psychiatry162 (8): 1452–60.
20.
CarrollLinda. 2000. “Genetic Studies Promise a Path to Better Treatments of Addictions.”New York Times, November 14, 2000, F6.
21.
Centers for Disease Control. 2011. “Current Cigarette Smoking Prevalence among Working Adults—United States, 2004-2010.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report60 (38): 1305–9.
22.
ChalabyJean. 1996. “Beyond the Prison-house of Language: Discourse as a Sociological Concept.” British Journal of Sociology47 (4): 684–98.
23.
ClarkeAdele E.ShimJanet K.MamoLauraFosketJennifer RuthFishmanJennifer R.. 2003. “Biomedicalization: Technoscientific Transformations of Health, Illness, and U.S. Biomedicine.” American Sociological Review68 (2): 161–94.
24.
CohenCarl I.1993. “The Biomedicalization of Psychiatry: A Critical Overview.” Community Mental Health Journal29 (6): 509–21.
25.
CollinsFrancis S.2010. “Has the Revolution Arrived?” Nature464 (7289): 674–5.
26.
CollinsFrancis S.GreenEric D.GuttmacherAlan E.GuyerMark S.. 2003. “A Vision for the Future of Genomics Research.” Nature422 (6934): 835–47.
27.
ConditC. M.2007. “How Geneticists Can Help Reporters Get their Story Right.” Nature Reviews Genetics8 (10): 815–20.
28.
ConradPeter. 2001. “Genetic Optimism: Framing Genes and Mental Illness in the News.” Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry25 (2): 225–47.
29.
CourtwrightDavid T.2001. Forces of Habit: Drugs and the Making of the Modern World. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
30.
CourtwrightDavid T.2012. “Addiction and the Science of History.” Addiction107 (3): 486–92.
31.
CrabbeJohn C.2002. “Genetic Contributions to Addiction.” Annual Review of Psychology53 (1): 435–62.
32.
CuiWen-YanSeneviratneChamindiGuJunLiMing D.. 2012. “Genetics of GABAergic Signaling in Nicotine and Alcohol Dependence.” Human Genetics131 (6): 843–55.
DeunwaldMary. 2003. “A Scientist's Lifetime of Study into the Mysteries of Addiction.”New York Times, August 19, 2003, F5.
35.
DickDanielle M.2011. “An Interdisciplinary Approach to Studying Gene-environment Interactions: From Twin Studies to Gene Identification and Back.” Research in Human Development8 (3-4): 211–26.
36.
DingelMolly J.2005. ““A Window into the Soul”: Gender and News Coverage of Genetic Research.” Doctoral Dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Kansas, Lawrence.
37.
DingelMolly J.KarkazisKatrinaKoenigBarbara A.. 2011. “Framing Nicotine Addiction as a “Disease of the Brain”: Social and Ethical Consequences.” Social Science Quarterly92 (5): 1363–88.
38.
DrausPaul J.2009. “Substance Abuse and Slow-motion Disasters: The Case of Detroit.” The Sociological Quarterly50 (2): 360–82.
39.
EasterMichele. 2010. ““Some Sort of Larger Force at Work”: Meanings and Implications of Genetics for Women with Eating Disorders.” Doctoral Dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC.
40.
EdelmanMurray J.1988. Constructing the Political Spectacle. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
41.
EliasMarilyn. 1999. “Ability to Quit Smoking Linked to Genetic Profile.” USA Today, January 25, 1999, 6D.
42.
EntmanRobert M.2007. “Framing Bias: Media in the Distribution of Power.” Journal of Communication57 (2): 163–73.
43.
FaircloughNorman. 1985. “Critical and Descriptive Goals in Discourse Analysis.” Journal of Pragmatics9 (6):739–63.
44.
FaircloughNorman. 1995. Media Discourse. New York: Edward Arnold.
45.
FlintA. J.NovotnyT. E.. 1997. “Poverty Status and Cigarette Smoking Prevalence and Cessation in the United States, 1983-1993: The Independent Risk of Being Poor.” Tobacco Control6 (1): 14–8.
46.
ForemanJudy. 2004. “Many Genes Play Role in Alcoholism; Genetics Can Work Two Ways, Researchers Say, Protecting Some from the Disease While Raising the Odds for Others.” Los Angeles Times, November 15, 2004, F1.
47.
KellerEvelyn Fox. 2010. The Mirage of a Space between Nature and Nurture. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
48.
GamsonWilliam A.ModiglianiAndre. 1989. “Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power: A Constructionist Approach.” American Journal of Sociology95 (1): 1–37.
49.
GENEVA Consortium. 2012. “CHRNB3 is More Strongly Associated with Fagerstrom Test for Cigarette Dependence-based Nicotine Dependence than Cigarettes Per Day: Phenotype Definition Changes Genome-wide Association Studies Results.” Addiction107 (11): 2019–28.
50.
GivelM. S.GlantzS. A.. 2000. “Failure to Defend a Successful State Tobacco Control Program: Policy Lessons from Florida.” American Journal of Public Health90 (5): 762–67.
51.
GladwellMalcolm. 2010. “Drinking Games.” The New Yorker, February 15, 22, 2010, 70-76.
52.
GoldmanDavidOrosziGaborDucciFrancesca. 2005. “The Genetics of Addictions: Uncovering the Genes.” Nature Reviews Genetics6 (7): 521–32.
53.
GorwoodPhilipStratYann LeRamozNicolasDubertretCarolineMoalicJean-MarieSimonneauMichel. 2012. “Genetics of Dopamine Receptors and Drug Addiction.” Human Genetics131 (6): 803–22.
54.
GriswoldWendy. 1987. “A Methodological Framework for the Sociology of Culture.” Sociological Methodology17:1–35.
55.
GuttmacherAlan E.CollinsFrancis S.. 2005. “Realizing the Promise of Genomics in Biomedical Research.” Journal of the American Medical Association294 (11): 1399–402.
56.
HallStuart. 1992. “Encoding/Decoding.” In Culture, Media, Language, edited by HallStuartHobsonDorothyLoweAndrewWillisPaul, 128–38. New York: Routledge/Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies.
57.
HallWayneCarterAdrian. 2013. “Anticipating Possible Policy Uses of Addiction Neuroscience Research.” Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy20 (3): 249–57.
58.
HallWayne D.GartnerC. E.CarterA.. 2008. “The Genetics of Nicotine Addiction Liability: Ethical and Social Policy Implications.” Addiction103 (3):650–59.
59.
HammerR. R.OstergrenJ. E.KoenigB. A.McCormickJ. B.. 2012. “Addiction Etiology According to Current Addiction Scientists: How Do Scientists Talk about Addiction?” Paper presented at the annual meeting for the Research Society on Alcoholism, San Francisco, CA. June 23-27.
60.
HillTerrence D.RossCatherine E.AngelRonald J.. 2005. “Neighborhood Disorder, Psychophysiological Distress, and Health.” Journal of Health and Social Behavior46 (2): 170–86.
61.
HumphreysKeithSatelSally. 2005. “Some Gene Research Just isn’t Worth the Money.” New York Times, January 18, 2005, F5.
62.
IllesJudyFanEllenKoenigBarbara A.RaffinThomas A.KannDylanAtlasScott W.. 2003. “Self-referred Whole-body CT Imaging: Current Implications for Health Care consUmers.” Radiology228 (2): 346–51.
63.
IllesJudyMoserMary AnneMcCormickJ. B.RacineEricBlakesleeSandraCaplanArthurHaydenErika CheckIIngramJayLohwaterTiffanyMcKnightPeterNicholsonChristiePhillipsAnthonySauveKevin D.SnellElaineWeissSamuel. 2010. “Neurotalk: Improving the Communication of Neuroscience Research.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience11 (1): 61–9.
64.
KalivasPeter W.VolkowNora D.. 2005. “The Neural Basis of Addiction: A Pathology of Motivation and Choice.” American Journal of Psychiatry162 (8): 1403–13.
65.
KandelEric R.1998. “A New Intellectual Framework for Psychiatry.” American Journal of Psychiatry155 (1): 457–69.
66.
KeaneHelenHamillKelly. 2010. “Variations in Addiction: The Molecular and the Molar in Neuroscience and Pain Medicine.” BioSocieties5 (1): 52–69.
67.
KellerEvelyn Fox. 2000. The Century of the Gene. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
68.
KhouryM. J.ThrasherJ. F.BurkeW.GettigE. A.FridingerF.JacksonR.. 2000. “Challenges in Communicating Genetics: A Public Health Approach.” Genet Med2 (3): 198–202.
69.
KotulakRonald. 2002. “Alcohol Addiction; Just Say: Know; Traffic Signal: Red Light, Green Light and Booze.” Chicago Tribune, September 29, 2002, 2.1.
70.
KushnerH. I.2010. “Toward a Cultural Biology of Addiction.” Biosocieties5 (1): 8–24.
71.
LachmanH. M.2006. “An Overview of the Genetics of Substance use Disorders.” Current Psychiatry Reports8 (2): 133–43.
72.
LaPelleN. R.ZapkaJ.OckeneJ. K.. 2006. “Sustainability of Public Health Programs: The Example of Tobacco Treatment Services in Massachusetts.” American Journal of Public Health96 (8): 1363–69.
73.
LehrmanSally. 2008. “Cops, Sports, and Schools: How the News Media Frames the Coverage of Genetics and Race.” In Revisiting Race in a Genomic Age, edited by KoenigBarbara A.Soo-Jin LeeSandraRichardsonSarah S., 285–303. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
74.
LeshnerAlan I.1997. “Addiction Is a Brain Disease, and It Matters.” Science278 (5335): 45–47.
75.
LiChiang-shan RaySinhaRajita. 2008. “Inhibitory Control and Emotional Stress Regulation: Neuroimaging Evidence for Frontal-limbic Dysfunction in Psycho-stimulant Addiction.” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews32 (3): 581–97.
76.
LiChuan-YunZhouWei-ZhenZhangPing-WuJohnsonCatherineWeiLipingUhlGeorge R.. 2011. “Meta-analysis and Genome-wide Interpretation of Genetic Susceptibility to Drug Addiction.” BMC Genomics12 (October): 508. doi:10.1186/1471-2164-12-508.
77.
LiuJ. Z.TozziF.WaterworthD. M.PillaiS. G.MugliaP.MiddletonL.BerrettiniW.. 2010. “Meta-analysis and Imputation Refines the Association of 15q25 with Smoking Quantity.” Nature Genetics42 (5): 436–40.
78.
LockMargaret. 2013. “The Epigenome and Nature/Nurture Reunification: A Challenge for Anthropology.” Medical Anthropology: Cross-Cultural Studies in Health and Illness32 (4): 291–308.
79.
MarteauT.SeniorV.HumphriesS. E.BobrowM.CranstonT.CrookM. A.DayL.FernandezM.HorneR.IversenA.JacksonZ.LynasJ.Middleton-PriceH.SavineR.SikorskiJ.WatsonM.WeinmanJ.WierzbickiA. S.WrayR.. 2004. “Psychological Impact of Genetic Testing for Familial Hypercholesterolemia within a Previously Aware Population: A Randomized Controlled Trial.” American Journal of Medical Genetics128A (3): 285–93.
80.
MarteauT.WeinmanJ.. 2006. “Self-regulation and the Behavioural Response to DNA Risk Information: A Theoretical Analysis and Framework for Future Research.” Social Science and Medicine62 (6): 1360–68.
81.
McLoydVonnie C.1990. “The Impact of Economic Hardship on Black Families and Children: Psychological Distress, Parenting, and Socioeconomic Development.” Child Development61 (2): 311–46.
82.
MerikangasK. R.RischN.. 2003. “Genomic Priorities and Public Health.” Science302 (5645): 599–601.
83.
MidanikLorraine T.2004. “Biomedicalization and Alcohol Studies: Implications for Policy.” Journal of Public Health Policy25 (2): 211–28.
84.
NashJ. MadeleineParkAlice. 1997. “Addicted: Why Do People Get Hooked?” Time, May 5: 36–43.
85.
NIDA (National Institute on Drug Abuse). 2007. Drugs, Brains, and Behavior: The Science of Addiction. Washington, DC: National Institutes of Health, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
NIDA (National Institute on Drug Abuse). 2010. Strategic Plan. Bethesda, MD: National Institute on Drug Abuse, National Institutes of Health, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
88.
NazarioSonia. 1990. “Alcoholism is Linked to a Gene.” Wall Street Journal, April 18, 1990, B1.
89.
NelkinDorothySusan LindeeM.. 1995. The DNA Mystique: The Gene as a Cultural Icon. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company.
90.
NestlerEric J.2005. “Is There a Common Molecular Pathway for Addiction?” Nature Neuroscience8 (11): 1445–49.
91.
NumbergerJohn IJrBierutLaura Jean. 2007. “Seeking the Connections: Alcoholism and Our Genes.” Scientific American, April 1, 46-53.
92.
OlftonEmilyBierutLaura Jean. 2012. “Convergence of Genome-wide Association and Candidate Gene Studies for Alcoholism.” Alcoholism-Clinical and Experimental Research36 (12): 2086–94.
93.
OstergrenJenny E.DingelMolly J.McCormickJennifer B.KoenigBarbara A. Forthcoming “Unwarranted Optimism in Media Portrayals of Genetic Research on Addiction Overshadows Critical Ethical and Social Concerns.” Journal of Health Communication.
94.
PetersenAlan. 2001. “Biofantasies: Genetics and Medicine in the Print News Media.” Social Science & Medicine52 (8): 1255–68.
95.
PhillipsNelsonHardyCynthia. 2002. Discourse Analysis: Investigating Processes of Social Construction. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
96.
PotenzaMarc N.SofugluMiehmetCarrollKathleen M.RounsavilleBruce J.. 2011. “Neuroscience of Behavioral and Pharmacological Treatments for Addictions.” Neuron69 (4): 695–712.
97.
RedonnetB.CholletA.FombonneE.BowesL.MelchiorM.. 2011. “Tobacco, Alcohol, Cannabis and Other Illegal Drug Use among Young Adults: The Socioeconomic Context.” Drug and Alcohol Dependence121 (3): 231–39. doi:10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2011.09.002.
98.
RoseNikolas. 2007. The Politics of Life Itself: Biomedicine, Power, and Subjectivity in the Twenty-first Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
99.
SchnollRobert A.JohnsonTerrance A.LermanCaryn. 2007. “Genetics and Smoking Behavior.” Current Psychiatry Reports9 (5): 349–57.
100.
SchüllNatasha Dow. 2012. Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
101.
ScottJanny. 1990. “Gene May be Tied to Alcoholism Research: If It Is Confirmed that it Predisposes the Carrier to the Condition, It Could Give Credence to the Belief that Uncontrolled Drinking is a Disease.” Los Angeles Times, April 18, 1990, P3.
102.
SeabrookJamie A.AvisonWilliam R.. 2010. “Genotype-environment Interaction and Sociology: Contributions and Complexities.” Social Science & Medicine70 (9): 1277–84.
103.
ShostakSaraConradPeterHorwitzAllan V.. 2008. “Sequencing and Its Consequences: Path Dependence and the Relationships between Genetics and Medicalization.” The American Journal of Sociology114 (S1): S287–316.
104.
SiuWanda. 2009. “Social Construction of Reality. The Tobacco Issue.” Critical Public Health19 (1): 23–44.
105.
TalanJamie. 2001. “The Search for Genetic Keys to Alcoholism; Research: Scientists Hope that by Understanding the Disease Better, They Can Develop More Effective Treatments.” Los Angeles Times, May 21, 2001, S1.
ThorgeirssonT. E.GudbjartssonDaniel F.SurakkaIdaVinkJacqueline M.AminNajafGellerFrankSulemPatrick. 2010. “Sequence Variants at CHRNB3-CHRNA6 and CYP2A6 Affect Smoking Behavior.” Nature Genetics42 (5): 448–53.
108.
TreutleinJ.RietschelM.. 2011. “Genome-wide Association Studies of Alcohol Dependence and Substance Use Disorders.” Current Psychiatry Reports13 (2): 147–55. doi:10.1007/s11920-011-0176-4.
109.
Van DijckJose. 1998. Imagenation: Popular Images of Genetics. New York: New York University Press.
110.
VarmusHarold. 2010. “Ten Years On—The Human Genome and Medicine.” New England Journal of Medicine362 (21): 2028–29.
111.
WangJen-ChyongKapoorManavGoateAlison M.. 2012. “The Genetics of Subsance Dependence.” Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics13 (1): 241–61.
112.
WarnerKennethMendezDavid. 2010. “Tobacco Control Policy in Developed Countries: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow.” Nicotine & Tobacco Research12 (9): 876–87.
113.
WilcoxSarah A.2003. “Cultural Context and the Conventions of Science Journalism: Drama and Contradiction in Media Coverage of Biological Ideas about Sexuality.” Critical Studies in Media Communication20 (3): 223–47.
114.
WingertPat. 2006. “Nora Volkow; Health: A Passionate Advocate for Addicts of All Kinds, She's Determined to Find a Cure.” Newsweek, December 25, 2006, 78.
115.
WrightA. J.WeinmanJ.MarteauT. M.. 2003. “The Impact of Learning of a Genetic Predisposition to Nicotine Dependence: An Analogue Study.” Tobacco Control12 (2): 227–30.
