Public acceptance is often seen as a key reason why water-recycling technology is (accepted or) rejected. A common assumption is that projects fail because the general public is unable to comprehend specialist information about risk and the belief that if the public were better informed, they would accept change more readily. This article suggests that rhetoric about acceptance is counterproductive in progressing sustainability as it does not address issues relating to institutional arrangements and reinforces a dichotomy between expert and lay groups. Instead, it is argued that institutional change is needed to build opportunities for constructive public engagement. The failure to implement sustainable water use through recycling can be understood as the result of several factors including present cost structures for water, institutional conservatism, administrative fragmentation, and inadequate involvement of communities in planning. Achieving sustainable water use through recycling may require better coordination between agencies and integrated government policies.
ABC News Online. 2004. Qld gives grey water use the green light. June 4. http://www.abc.net.au/ (accessed January 2003).
2.
Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering. 2004. Water recycling in Australia. Melbourne: Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering.
3.
Agence France-Presse. 2003. Technology can quench Asia’s thirst for water. Borneo Bulletin. February 26.
4.
Allison, L.2003. VIC wastewater plan a drop in the ocean (press release number 03/11). Australian Democrats 2003. http://www.democrats.org.au/news/.
5.
Australian Bureau of Statistics. 2002. Australian demographic statistics. http://www.abs.gov.au/ (accessed July 2004).
6.
Australian Water Association. 2003. Submission to the senate enquiry into Australia’s urban water management. Canberra, Australia: Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology and the Arts Committee. http://www.aph.gov.au/senate/committee/ecita_ctte/water/submissions/sub041.pdf.
7.
Beck, U.1992. Risk society. London: Sage.
8.
Booker, N., S. Gray, G. Mitchell, A. Priestley, R. Shipton, A. Speers, M. Young, and G. Syme. 2000. Sustainable alternatives in the provision of urban water services—An Australian approach. Paper presented at Proceedings of Water: The World’s Most Important Resource: 10th World Water Congress, Melbourne, Australia.
Bruvold, W. H. 1984. Research in the societal and institutional issues of water reuse. Paper presented at Future of Water Reuse, Vol. 3, Proceedings of the Water Reuse Symposium III, San Diego, California.
11.
Burkhard, R., A. Deletic, and A. Craig. 2000. Techniques for water and wastewater management: A review of techniques and their integration in planning. Urban Water2:197-221.
12.
Castles, F. G., D. J. Murray, and D. C. Potter. 1971. Decisions, organisations and society. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin.
13.
Codd, M., 1997. Public inquiry into the management of sewage and sewage by-products in the NSW coastal zones. Sydney: NSW Environment Protection Agency.
14.
Commonwealth of Australia. 2002. Inquiry into Australia’s management of urban water. Canberra, Australia: Senate Environment, Communications, Information Technology and the Arts Committee. http://www.aph.gov.au/Senate/committee/ecita_ctte/water/report/index.htm.
15.
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. 2002. National bid to save water. CSIRO Land and Water Link September:1-2.
16.
Coombes, P. J., J. R. Argue, and G. Kuczera. 1999. Figtree place: A case study in water sensitive urban design. Urban Water1 (4): 335-343.
17.
Coombes, P. J., G. Kuczera, J. D. Kalma, and J. R. Argue. 2002. An evaluation of the benefits of source control measures at the regional scale. Urban Water4 (4): 307-320.
18.
Cox, S., and D. Hamlyn-Harris. 2003. Pimpama Coomera Water Futures: Pushing the boundaries. Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, Brisbane, Australia.
19.
Cribb, J. 2003. Will the real Australian please stand up? Address to ATSE Symposium. Paper presented at the Academy Symposium: Water—The Australian Dilemma, Melbourne, Australia.
Curtis, A., and M. Lockwood. 2000. Landcare and catchment management in Australia: Lessons for state-sponsored community participation. Society and Natural Resources13:61-73.
22.
Diaper, C.2004. Innovation in on-site domestic water management systems in Australia: A review of rainwater, greywater, stormwater and wastewater utilisation techniques—CSIRO Urban Water for the Australian Water Conservation and Reuse Research Program (AWCRRP). CSIRO MIT Technical Report 2004-073 April 2004. Victoria, Australia: Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation.
23.
Dillon, P. 2000. Water reuse in Australia: Current, future and research. Paper presented at the Proceedings of Water Recycling Australia 2000, Adelaide, Australia.
24.
Dowsett, B., G. Mather, C. Mercer, B. Pearson, and D. Vincent. 1995. A new course for Sydney Water: The final report of the Sydney Water Project. Sydney: Friends of the Earth (Sydney) Inc.
25.
Department of Natural Resources and Environment. 2002. New water for Victoria: Victoria’s water recycling action plan. Melbourne, Australia: Department of Natural Resources and Environment.
26.
Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet. 2004. National Water Initiative discussion paper. Barton, Australia: Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet.
27.
Department of Urban Affairs and Planning. 1998. Shaping our cities: The planning strategy for the greater metropolitan region of Sydney, Newcastle, Wollongong and the Central Coast. Sydney: Planning NSW.
28.
Environmental Projects Office. 2002. Findings of the Reclaimed Water (Water Recycling) Forum (Western Australia). Coordinated by CSIRO, Environmental Projects Office. Stakeholders: Water and Rivers Commission, Water Corporation, Department of Environmental Protection, Health Department, Murdoch University, Agriculture WA, Department of Infrastructure and Planning. http://www.ourwaterfuture.com.au/community/symposiumpres/Don%2520McFarlane_paper.pdf (accessed July 2003).
29.
Esrey, S.2002. Philosophical, ecological and technical challenges for expanding ecological sanitation into urban areas. Water Science and Technology45 (8): 225-228.
30.
Fane, S. A., N. J. Ashbolt, and S. B. White. 2001. Decentralised urban water reuse: The implications of system scale for cost and pathogen risk. Water Science and Technology46 (6-7): 281-288.
31.
Fritz, B., S. Rinck-Pfeiffer, G. Nuetzmann, and B. Heinzmann. 2003. Conservation of water resources in Berlin, Germany, through different re-use of water. Paper presented at Wastewater Re-use and Groundwater Quality, Sapporo, Japan.
32.
Gibson, H. E, and N. Apostolidis. 2001. Demonstration, the solution to successful community acceptance of water recycling. Water Science and Technology43 (10): 259-266.
33.
Gold Coast City Council. 2004. Pimpama Coomera Waterfuture master plan. Queensland, Australia: Gold Coast Water, Gold Coast City Council.
34.
Gregory, A.2001. Water recycling in Sydney: The options. Water28 (3): 30-36.
35.
Grove-White, R., P. McNaghten, S. Mayer, and B. Wynne. 1997. Uncertain world: Genetically modified organisms, food and public attitudes in Britain. Lancaster, UK: Lancaster University.
36.
Hamlyn-Harris, D. 2003. Integrated urban water management and water recycling in SE Queensland: Recent developments. Paper presented at Institute of Public Works Engineering Australia State Conference, Mackay, Queensland.
37.
Hancock, W. K. [1930] 1961. Australia. Brisbane, Australia: Jacaranda Press.
38.
Hilmer, F. G., M. R. Rayner, and G. Q. Taperell. 1993. National competition policy. Canberra: Australian Government Printing Service, Independent Committee of Inquiry into Competition Policy in Australia.
39.
Ho, G., S. Dallas, M. Anda, and K. Mathew. 2001. On-site wastewater technologies in Australia. Water Science and Technology44 (6): 81-88.
40.
House of Lords. 2000. Select Committee on Science and Technology Third Report. House of Lords, United Kingdom, February 23. http://www.parliament.the-stationery-office.co.uk/pa/ld199900/ldselect/ldsctech/38/3804.htm.
41.
Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of NSW. 2000. Sydney Water Corporation: Prices of water supply, sewerage and drainage services. Medium-term price path from 1 October 2000. Sydney: Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of NSW.
42.
Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of NSW. 2002. Review of Metropolitan Water Agency prices: Issues paper. Sydney: Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal of NSW.
43.
Irwin, A.2001. Institutional judgements and contested decisions: The governance of environmental problems. In Sociology and the environment. Cambridge: Polity Press.
44.
Janssens, J. G. 2003. Tariff regulation and efficiency incentives: Introductory remarks. Paper presented at the True Cost of Water, Towards Economic and Environmental Sustainability, Barcelona, Spain.
45.
Jeffrey, P., and B. Jefferson. 2002. Public receptivity regarding “in-house” water recycling: Results from a UK survey. Paper presented at the International Water Association World Water Congress, Melbourne, Australia.
46.
Jelsma, J.2001. Frame-reflective policy analysis in practice: Co-evolution of a policy regime and an intractable controversy in biotechnology. In Knowledge, power, and participation in environmental policy analysis, ed. M. Hisschemoller, R. Hoppe, W. N. Dunn, and J. R. Ravetz. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishing.
47.
Lash, S., and B. Wynne. 1992. Introd. to Risk society: Towards a new modernity, by U. Beck. London: Sage.
48.
Law, I. B. 1999. Potable reuse: Technologies and trends. Paper presented at the Australian Water and Wastewater Association, 18th Federal Convention, Adelaide, Australia.
49.
Lawrence, I., and P. Cullen. 2002. Australia’s urban water management: Integrating the water cycle. Submission to the Environment, Communications, Information Technology and the Arts Inquiry. Canberra, Australia: Co-operative Research Centre for Freshwater Ecology.
50.
Levidow, L., S. Carr, D. Wield, and R. von Schomberg. 1997. European biotechnology regulation: Framing the risk assessment of a herbicide-tolerant crop. Science, Technology, and Human Values22 (4): 472-505.
51.
Malmqvist, P.-A., N. J. Ashbolt, S. Fane, D. Hellström, U. Jeppsson, and H. Söderberg. 2000. Assessing alternative wastewater systems in Hammarby Sjöstad, Stockholm. In Second International Conference on Decision Making in Urban and Civil Engineering, ed. J.-C. Mangin and M. Miramond, 1-13. Lyon, France: CUST Clermond-Ferrand, LIP6 Paris and Universitie de Valenciennes.
52.
Marks, J. 2003. The sociology of “disgust” towards the use of reclaimed water. Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, Brisbane, Australia.
53.
Marks, J. 2004. Back to the future: Reviewing the findings on acceptance of reclaimed water. Paper presented at Enviro 04, Sydney, Australia.
54.
McClellan, P. (1998). Sydney water inquiry (final report): Introduction, recommendations and actions. Sydney: Premier’s Department, New South Wales Government.
55.
Millis, N. F. 2002. Water quality relative to end use. Paper presented at the 27th Hydrology and Water Resources Symposium, Melbourne, Australia.
56.
Moore, M. R., and H. F Chapman. 2003. Endocrine disruptors in Western society: Are there any health risks in effluent reuse? Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, Brisbane, Australia.
57.
National Land and Water Resources Audit. 2000. Water in a dry land: Issues and challenges for Australia’s key resource. Canberra, Australia: National Land and Water Resources Audit.
58.
Neill, R.2002. As wasters there isn’t a bigger bunch of drips: The selfish country—World champs at conspicuous consumption. The Australian. November 1.
59.
NSW Legislative Assembly. 2002. Interim report on urban water infrastructure. Sydney: NSW Legislative Assembly, Standing Committee on Public Works.
60.
Owens, S., and R. Cowell. 2002. Land and limits: Interpreting sustainability in the planning process. London: Routledge.
61.
Paddock, R. C.2002. Singapore reclaims water, and its self-sufficiency. Los Angeles Times Headlines. August 18.
62.
Peatling, S.2004. NSW tops the national ladder for wasting water. Sydney Morning Herald. March 30.
63.
Po, M., J. Kaercher, and B. E. Nancarrow. 2004. Literature review of factors influencing public perceptions of water reuse: CSIRO land and water for the Australian Water Conservation and Reuse Research Program (AWCRRP). Perth, Australia: Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation.
64.
Price, M.2002. Who needs sustainability? In Sustainable groundwater development, ed. K. M. Hiscock, M. O. Rivett, and R. M. Davison, 75-81. Geological Society of London (GSL) Special Publications 193. London: GSL. (Cited in PMSEIC 2003.)
65.
Prime Minister’s Science, Engineering and Innovation Council. 2003. Recycling water for our cities. Canberra, Australia: Prime Minister’s Science, Engineering and Innovation Council.
66.
Productivity Commission. 1992. Water resources and waste water disposal. Report no. 26. July 17.
67.
Public Information, Education, and Outreach Workgroup. 2003. Better public involvement in the recycled water decision process (draft). Sacramento, CA: Public Information, Education, and Outreach Workgroup for the Department of Water Resources State Water Resources Control Board Department of Health Services.
68.
Queensland Water Recycling Strategy. 2001. Queensland water recycling strategy. Brisbane, Australia: Department of Natural Resources, Queensland State Government.
69.
Radcliffe, J. 2003. An overview of water recycling in Australia: Results from the recent ATSE study. Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, Brisbane, Australia.
70.
Rein, M., and D. Schon. 1994. Frame reflection: Towards the resolution of intractable policy controversies. New York: Basic Books.
71.
Rivermouth Action Group. 1999. Rivermouth Action Group Web site. http://www.rag.org.au/sewage/waste.htm (accessed September 2001).
72.
Ryan, K.2003. Recycled wastewater plan scrapped Redwood City residents objected. San Francisco Chronicle. February 5. http://geocities.com/safewater94065/docs/CHRONICAL_PLAN_SCRAPPED_FEB5.doc.
73.
Scott, W. R.1995. Institutions and organizations, foundations for organizational science. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
74.
Sinclair Knight Mertz. 2000. Sydney Water Corporation audit 1999. Sydney: Sinclair Knight Mertz.
75.
Stenekes, N., H. K. Colebatch, and T. D. Waite. 2003. Water recycling and policy-making. Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, Brisbane, Australia.
76.
Straits Times. 2002. Newater to start flowing in February. September 26.
77.
Swinton, B.2004. Education: The key to sustainable water management. Australian Water Association Journal, Water March:86-91.
78.
Sydney Morning Herald. 2004. Editorial: City’s call on water waste. May 1.
79.
Sydney Water Corporation. 1996. Community views on water reuse: Research report. Sydney: Sydney Water Corporation.
80.
Sydney Water Corporation. 1999a. Community views on water reuse: Research report. Sydney: Sydney Water Corporation.
81.
Sydney Water Corporation. 1999b. Water recycling strategy. Sydney: Sydney Water Corporation.
82.
Uhlmann, V., and L. Luxford. 1999. Education needs background study. Brisbane, Australia: Queensland Water Recycling Strategy by Nexus Australia.
83.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1992. Guidelines for water reuse. Washington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Agency for International Development.
84.
Water Environment Federation/American Waterworks Association. 1998. Using reclaimed water to augment potable water supplies. Denver, CO: Water Environment Federation/American Waterworks Association.
85.
Wegner-Gwidt, J.1998. Public support and education for water reuse. In Wastewater reclamation and reuse, ed. T. Asano, 1417-1462. Lancaster, PA: Technomic Publishing.
86.
Wentworth Group. 2003. Blueprint for a national water plan. Sydney, Australia: Wentworth Group of Concerned Scientists.
87.
West Australian State Government. 2003. Securing our water future: A state water strategy for Western Australia. Summary document. http://www.watercorporation.com.au/Docs/State_Water_Strategy.pdf (accessed July 2003).
88.
West, S. 2001. Centralised management: The key to successful on-site sewerage service. Paper presented at the 2001 On-site Sydney Water Corporation Conference, Armidale, NSW, Australia.
89.
Wettenhall, R. L.1986. Organising government: The uses of ministries and departments. Sydney: Croom Helm.
90.
White, S.2002. The demand for water in Sydney. Sydney, Australia: Hawkesbury-Nepean River Management Forum.
91.
White, S., and A. Turner. 2003. The role of effluent reuse in sustainable urban water systems: Untapped opportunities. Paper presented at the second national conference of Water Recycling Australia, National Conference, Brisbane, Australia.
92.
Wilson, G. A.2004. The Australian Landcare movement: Towards “post-productivist” rural governance?Journal of Rural Studies20 (4): 461-484.
93.
Wynne, B.1996. Misunderstood misunderstandings: Social identities and public uptake of science. In Misunderstanding science? The public reconstruction of science and technology, ed. A. Irwin and B. Wynne, 19-46. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
94.
Wynne, B., and S. Mayer. 1993. How science fails the environment. New Scientist138 (June): 33-35.
