To explore the benefits and limitations of registered apprenticeships for Oregon workers, our research team conducted a survey of Oregon apprentices and analyzed apprenticeship data from the Bureau of Labor and Industries. Our study is driven by credentialization theory and how it relates to the Oregon legislation “Future Ready Oregon” that passed in 2022 which invested $200 million dollars in the trades. In our analysis, we assess access to entering apprenticeship, earnings during and after apprenticeship, completion rates and reasons for leaving apprenticeship, and access to jobs after apprenticeship. We find that there are rewards for those who obtain this type of non-degree credential; however, there are barriers to accessing apprenticeship, especially for those historically excluded from white male-dominated occupations. Ultimately, Future Ready Oregon will help provide access to the trades for people of color and women, but it has limitations for transforming the trades, for example, not directly addressing job site culture.
AdamsTracey L.DemaiterErin I.. 2008. “Skills, Education, and Credentials in the New Economy: The Case of Information Technology Workers.” Work, Employment and Society22 (23): 351–62.
2.
AlbertKyle. 2019. “What We Know About Non-Degree Credentials: A Literature Scan.” The George Washington Institute of Public Policy (GWIPP).
3.
AngristJoshua D.GuryanJonathan. 2008. “Does Teacher Testing Raise Teacher Quality? Evidence from State Certification Requirements.” Economics of Education Review27 (5): 483–503.
4.
BairdMatthewBozickRobertZaberMelanie. 2021. Beyond Traditional Academic Degrees: The Labor Market Returns to Occupational Credentials in the United States. RAND Corporation.
5.
BechtoldtFelicia. 2020. Oregon Jobs Projected to Increase by 9 Percent by 2029. State of Oregon Employment Department.
6.
BerikGunseliBilginsoyCihanWilliamsLarry S.. 2011. “Gender and Racial Training Gaps in Oregon Apprenticeship Programs.” Labor Studies Journal36 (2): 221–44.
7.
CarpenterDick M.KnepperLisaSweetlandKyleMcDonaldJennifer. 2018. “The Continuing Burden of Occupational Licensing in the United States.” Economic Affairs38 (30): 380–405.
8.
CronenStephanieMcQuigganMeghanIsenbergEmily. 2017. Adult Training and Education: Results from the National Household Education Surveys Program of 2016. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
9.
CunninghamE.2019. “Professional Certifications and Occupational Licenses: Evidence from the Current Population Survey.” Monthly Labor Review.
10.
DadgerMinaTrimbleMadeline Joy. 2015. “Labor Market Returns to Sub-Baccalaureate Credentials: How Much Does a Community College Degree or Certificate Pay?” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis37 (4): 399–418.
11.
DemingDavid J.YuchtmanNoamAbulafiAmiraKatzLawrence F.GoldinClaudia. 2016. “The Value of Postsecondary Credentials in the Labor Market: An Experimental Study.” American Economic Review106 (3): 778–806.
12.
DenissenAmy M.SaguyAbigail C.. 2014. “Gendered Homophobia and the Contradictions Workplace Discrimination for Women in the Building Trades.” Gender & Society28 (3): 381–403.
13.
Department of the Treasury Office of Economics, Council of Economic Advisors, and Department of Labor. 2015. Occupational Licensing: A Framework for Policymakers.
14.
DillJanetteMorganJennifer Craft. 2018. “Employability among Low-Skill Workers: Organizational Expectations and Practices in the US Health Care Sector.” Human Relations71 (7): 1001–22.
15.
DillJannetteMorganJennifer CraftVan HeuvelenJaneGingoldMeredith. 2022. “Professional Certification and Earnings of Health Care Workers in Low Social Closure Occupations.” Social Science & Medicine303: 115000.
16.
DrangeIdaHellandHåvard. 2018. “The Sheltering Effect of Occupational Closure? Consequences for Ethnic Minorities’ Earnings.” Work and Occupations46 (1): 45–89.
17.
Duke-BenfieldAmy Ellen. 2019. “Defining Quality Non-Degree Credentials Is Crucial to Putting Students on a Path to Success.” National Skills Coalition.
18.
FigueroaMariaGrabelskyJeffLamareJ. R.. 2013. “Community Workforce Agreements: A Tool to Grow the Union Market and to Expand Access to Lifetime Careers in the Unionized Building Trades.” Labor Studies Journal38 (1): 7–31.
19.
FullerJosephSigelmanMatthew. 2017. Room to Grow: Identifying New Frontiers for Apprenticeship. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School.
20.
GabersonKathleen B.SchroeterKathrynKillenAileen R.ValentineWendelyn A.. 2003. “The Perceived Value of Certification by Certified Perioperative Nurses.” Nursing Outlook51 (6): 272–76.
21.
GaleaNataliePowellAbigailLoosemoreMartinChappellLouise. 2015. “Designing Robust and Revisable Policies for Gender Equality: Lessons from the Australian Construction Industry.” Construction Management and Economics33 (5–6): 375–89.
22.
GittlemanMauryKleeMark A.KleinerMorris M.. 2017. Analyzing the Labor Market Outcomes of Occupational Licensing.” Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society57 (1): 57–100.
23.
HainesKellyWooleyJeanaThompsonTiffanyAshbrookConnieKellyMaura. 2018. Portland Metro Region Construction Workforce Market Study.
HegewischArianeHenriciJane M.ShawElyseHooperThomas. 2014. Untapped Resources, Untapped Labor Pool: Using Federal Highway Funds to Prepare Women for Careers in Construction. Institute for Women’s Policy Research.
26.
HegewischArianeO’FarrellBrigid. 2014. Women in Construction and the Economic Recovery Results from the 2013 IWPR Tradeswomen Survey. Washington, DC: Institute for Women’s Policy Research.
27.
HegewischArianeO’FarrellBrigid. 2015. Women in the Construction Trades: Earnings, Workplace Discrimination, and the Promise of Green Jobs. Institute for Women’s Policy Research.
28.
HunteRoberta.2016. “Black Women and Race and Gender Tensions in the Trades.” Peace Review28 (4): 436–43.
29.
IbanezMarta.2017. “Women in the Construction Trades: Career Types and Associated Barriers.” Women’s Studies International Forum60: 39–48.
30.
JacobsonLou.2011. Improving Community College Outcomes Measures Using Florida Longitudinal Schooling and Earnings Data. Washington, DC: New Horizons Economic Research.
31.
JepsenChristopherTroskeKennethCoomesPaul. 2014. “The Labor-Market Returns to Community College Degrees, Diplomas, and Certificates.” Journal of Labor Economics32 (1): 95–121.
32.
JohanssonErinWoodsBenjamin. 2016. Building Career Opportunities for Women and People of Color: Breakthroughs in Construction. Washington, DC: Jobs With Justice Education Fund and North America’s Building Trades Unions Tradeswomen Committee.
33.
KellyMaura. 2022. Evaluation of the Highway Construction Workforce Development Program. Final report submitted to Oregon Labor and Industries and Oregon Department of Transportation.
34.
KellyMauraBenitezMolly. 2022. Needs Assessment for Oregon’s Highway Trades Apprenticeship. Final report submitted to Oregon Labor and Industries and Oregon Department of Transportation.
35.
KellyMauraWilkinsonLindsey. 2020. Evaluation of Green Dot for the Trades. Final report submitted to Oregon Tradeswomen.
36.
KellyMauraWilkinsonLindseyEyo-IdahoAffiongWilliamsLarry. 2022. “Improving the Recruitment and Retention of Construction Apprentices through Oregon’s Highway Construction Workforce Development Program.” Journal of Applied Social Science16 (2): 459–81.
37.
KellyMauraWilkinsonLindseyPisciottaMauraWilliamsLarry S.. 2015. “When Working Hard is not enough for Female and Racial/Ethnic Minority Apprentices in the Highway Trades.” Sociological Forum30 (2): 415–38.
38.
KleinerMorris M.KruegerAlan B.. 2010. “The Prevalence and Effects of Occupational Licensing.” British Journal of Industrial Relations48 (4): 676–87.
39.
KleinerMorris M.KruegerAlan B.. 2013. “Analyzing the Extent and Influence of Occupational Licensing on the Labor Market.” Journal of Labor Economics31 (1): S173–202.
40.
LermanRobertEysterLaurenChambersKate. 2010. The Benefits and Challenges of Registered Apprenticeship: The Sponsors’ Perspective. Washington, DC: Urban Institute.
41.
LermanRobert I.EysterLaurenKuehnDaniel. 2014. “Can We Upgrade Low-Skill, Low-Wage Occupations? The Case of Apprenticeships in the Long-Term Care Occupations.” Journal of Women, Politics & Policy35 (2): 110–32.
42.
LesterScott W.FertigJasonDwyerDale J.. 2011. “Do Business Leaders Value Human Resource Certification?” Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies18 (3): 408–14.
43.
MacIsaacKatherine M. R.DomeneJose F.. 2014. “Learning the Tricks of the Trades: Women’s Experiences.” Canadian Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy48 (1): 1–21.
44.
McCarthyMary AlicePrebilMike. 2018. Building Better Degrees Using Industry Certifications. Washington, DC: New America.
45.
MoirSusanThomsonMerylKelleherChrista. 2011. Unfinished Business: Building Equality for Women in the Construction Trades. Labor Resource Center Publications.
46.
My Oregon News. 2022. “Future Ready Oregon 2022: Addressing Oregon’s Workforce Demands with an Equity Lens.”
47.
NessKate.2012. “Constructing Masculinity in the Building Trades: ‘Most Jobs in the Construction Industry Can Be Done by Women.” Gender, Work & Organization19 (6): 654–76.
48.
RedbirdBeth.2017. “The New Closed Shop? The Economic and Structural Effects of Occupational Licensure.” American Sociological Review82 (3): 600–24.
49.
ReedDebbieYung-Hsu LiuAlbertKleinmanRebeccaMastriAnnalisaReedDavinSattarSaminaZieglerJessica. 2012. An Effectiveness Assessment and Cost-Benefit Analysis of Registered Apprenticeship in 10 States. Oakland, CA: Mathematica Policy Research.
50.
RenskiHenry.2018. “Estimating the Returns to Professional Certifications and Licenses in the U.S. Manufacturing Sector.” Economic Development Quarterly32 (4): 341–56.
51.
SimonLindaClarkeKira. 2016. “Apprenticeships Should Work for Women Too!” Education + Training58 (6): 578–96.
52.
TaylorAlisonHammZaneRaykovMilosh. 2015. “The Experiences of Female Youth Apprentices in Canada: Just Passing Through?” Journal of Vocational Education & Training67 (1): 93–108.
53.
TesfaiLulDancyKimMcCarthyMary Alice. 2018. Paying More and Getting Less: How Nondegree Credentials Reflect Labor Market Inequality Between Men and Women. Washington, DC: New America.
54.
WeedenKim A.2002. “Why Do Some Occupations Pay More Than Others? Social Closure and Earnings Inequality in the United States.” American Journal of Sociology108 (1): 55–101.
55.
Workcred Institute. 2018. Examining the Quality, Market Value, and Effectiveness of Manufacturing Credentials in the United States.
56.
Worksystems Inc., Clackamas Workforce Partnership, Estolano Advisors, Workforce Southwest Washington, and Portland State University. 2024. Interstate Bridge Replacement Program Regional Infrastructure Workforce Market Study. Final report submitted to the Interstate Bridge Replacement Program.
57.
Worthen, Helena and Anthony Haynes. 2009. “Outcomes of Two Construction Trades Pre-Apprenticeship Programs: A Comparison” Journal of Community Practice, 17 (1): 207–222.
58.
WrightTessa.2013. “Uncovering Sexuality and Gender: An Intersectional Examination of Women’s Experience in UK Construction.” Construction Management and Economics31 (8): 832–44.
59.
XuDiTrimbleMadeline. 2016. “What About Certificates? Evidence on the Labor Market Returns to Nondegree Community College Awards in Two States.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis38 (2): 272–92.
60.
ZanvilleHollyPorterKellyGanzglassEvelyn. 2017. Report on Phase I Study: Embedding Industry and Professional Certifications in Higher Education. Indianapolis, IN: Lumina Foundation.
61.
ZhangTingting.2018. “Does Occupational Licensing Increase Income Inequality?” Academy of Management Proceedings2018 (1): 10816.
