This essay assesses the evolution of the way in which spatial data analytical methods have been incorporated into software tools over the past two decades. It is part retrospective and prospective, going beyond a historical review to outline some ideas about important factors that drove the software development, such as methodological advances, the open source movement and the advent of the Internet and cyberinfrastructure. The review highlights activities carried out by the author and his collaborators and uses SpaceStat, GeoDa, PySAL, and recent spatial analytical web services developed at the ASU GeoDa Center as illustrative examples. It outlines a vision for a spatial econometrics workbench as an example of the incorporation of spatial analytical functionality in a cyberGIS.
AblerR.1987. “The National Science Foundation National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis.”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems1:303–26.
2.
ACLS (American Council of Learned Societies).2006. Our Cultural Commonwealth. The Report of the American Council of Learned Societies Commission on Cyberinfrastructure for the Humanities and Social Sciences. Washington, DC: American Council of Learned Societies.
3.
AndrienkoG.AndrienkoN.1999. “Interactive maps for Visual Data Exploration.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science13:355–74.
4.
AndrienkoG.AndrienkoN.DemsarU.DranschD.DykesJ.FabrikantS.JernM.KraakM-JSchumannH.TominskiC.2010b. “Space, time and Visual Analytics.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science24:1577–600.
5.
AndrienkoG.AndrienkoN.DykesJ.KraakM.-J.SchumannH.2010a. “GeoVA(t)–Geospatial Visual Analytics: Focus on time.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science24:1453–7.
6.
AndrienkoG.AndrienkoN.JankowskiP.KeimD.KraakM.-J.MacEachrenA.WrobelS.2007. “Geovisual Analytics for Spatial Decision Support: Setting the Research Agenda.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science21:839–57.
7.
AndrienkoG.AndrienkoN.KeimD.MacEachrenA.WrobelS.2011. “Challenging Problems of Geospatial Visual Analytics.”Journal of Visual Languages and Computing22:251–6.
8.
AnselinL.1988. Spatial Econometrics, Methods and Models. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Kluwer Academic.
9.
AnselinL.1989. Spatial Regression Analysis on the PC: Spatial Econometrics Using GAUSS. Santa Barbara, CA: Department of Geography, University of California.
10.
AnselinL.1992. SpaceStatTutorial: A Workbook for Using SpaceStat in the Analysis of Spatial Data, Technical Sofware Series S-92-1. Santa Barbara, CA: National Center for Geographic Information and Analysis.
11.
AnselinL.1995a. “Local Indicators of Spatial Association–LISA.”Geographical Analysis27:93–115.
12.
AnselinL.1995b. SpaceStat Version 1.80 User’s Guide. Morgantown, WV: Regional Research Institute, West Virginia University.
13.
AnselinL.1999. “Interactive techniques and exploratory spatial data analysis.” In Geographical Information Systems: Principles, Techniques, Management and Applications, edited by LongleyP.GoodchildM.MaguireD.RhindD., pp. 251–264. New York: John Wiley.
14.
AnselinL.2000. “Computing Environments for Spatial Data Analysis.”Journal of Geographical Systems2:201–20.
15.
AnselinL.2005. “Spatial Statistical Modeling in a GIS Environment.” In GIS, Spatial Analysis and Modeling, edited by MaguireD.BattyM.GoodchildM., pp. 93–111. Redlands, CA, ESRI Press.
16.
AnselinL.2010. “Thirty years of Spatial Econometrics.”Papers in Regional Science89:2–25.
17.
AnselinL.GetisA.1992. “Spatial Statistical Analysis and Geographic Information Systems.”The Annals of Regional Science26:19–33.
18.
AnselinL.SmirnovO.1997. SpaceStat Extension for ArcView 3.0. Morgantown, WV: Regional Research Institute, West Virginia University.
19.
AnselinL.BaoS.1997. “Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis: Linking SpaceStat and Arcview.” In Recent Developments in Spatial Analysis, edited by FischerM.GetisA., 35–59. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
20.
AnselinL.HudakS.1992. “Spatial Econometrics in Practice: A Review of Software Options.”Regional Science and Urban Economics22:509–36.
21.
AnselinL.KimY.-W.SyabriI.2004. “Web-based Analytical Tools for the Exploration of Spatial Data.”Journal of Geographical Systems6:197–218.
22.
AnselinL.SyabriI.KhoY.2006. “Geoda, an Introduction to Spatial Data Analysis.”Geographical Analysis38:5–22.
23.
BaileyT.GatrellA.1995. Interactive Spatial Data Analysis. New York, NY: Wiley.
24.
BanerjeeS.CarlinB.GelfandA.2004. Hierarchical Modeling and Analysis for Spatial Data. Boca Raton, FL: Chapman and Hall/CRC.
25.
BaoS.MartinD.1997. User’s Reference for the S+ArcView Link. Seattle, WA: Mathsoft Inc.
26.
BaoS.AnselinL.MartinD.StralbergD.2000. “Seamless Integration of Spatial Statistics and GIS: the S-Plus for ArcView and the S+Grassland links.”Journal of Geographical Systems2:287–306.
27.
BattyM.Hudson-SmithA.MiltonR.CrooksA.2010. “Map Mashups, Web 2.0 and the GIS Revolution.”Annals of GIS16:1–13.
28.
BeckerR.ClevelandW.WilksA.1987. “Dynamic Graphics for Data Analysis.”Statistical Science2:355–95.
29.
BivandR.2006. “Implementing Spatial Data Analysis Software in R.”Geographical Analysis38:23–40.
30.
BivandR.GebhardtA.2000. “Implementing Functions for Spatial Statistical Analysis using the R Language.”Journal of Geographical Systems2:307–17.
31.
BivandR.PebesmaE.Gomez-RubioV.2008. Applied Spatial Data Analysis with R. New York, NY: Springer.
32.
BradleyR.HaslettJ.1992. “High Interaction Diagnostics for Geostatisticial Models of Spatial Referenced Data.”The Statistician41:371–80.
33.
BrunsdonC.1998. “Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis and Local Indicators of Spatial Association with XLISP-STAT.”The Statistician47:471–84.
34.
BujaA.CookD.SwayneD.1996. “Interactive High Dimensional Data Visualization.”Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics5:78–99.
35.
CaldeweyherD.ZhangJ.PhamB.2006. “OpenCIS–Open source GIS-based web Community Information System.”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems20:885–98.
36.
ChenJ.MacEachrenA.GuoD.2008. “Supporting the Process of Exploring and Interpreting Space-time, Multivariate Patterns: The Visual Inquiry Toolkit.”Cartography and Geographic Information Science35:33–50.
37.
ClevelandW.McGillM.1988. Dynamic Graphics for Statistics. Pacific Grove, CA: Wadsworth.
38.
CressieN.1993. Statistics for Spatial Data. New York: Wiley.
39.
CressieN.WikleC.2011. Statistics for Spatio-Temporal Data. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
40.
DiBiaseD.1990. “Visualization in the Earth Sciences.”Earth and Mineral Sciences Bulletin59:13–8.
41.
DingY.FotheringhamS.1992. “The Integration of Spatial Analysis and GIS.”Computers, Environment and Urban Systems16:3–19.
42.
DragicevicS.2004. “The Potential of Web-based GIS.”Journal of Geographical Systems6:79–81.
43.
DragicevicS.LiS.BrovelliM.VeenendaalB.2011. “Pervasive Web Mapping, Geoprocessing and Services.”Transactions in GIS15:125–7.
44.
DrukkerD.PruchaI.RaciborskiR.2011. “A command for Estimating Spatial-Autoregressive Models with Spatial-autoregressive Disturbances and Additional Endogenous Variables.”Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of Maryland, College Park, MD.
45.
DykesJ.1997. “Exploring Spatial Data Representation with Dynamic Graphics.”Computers and Geosciences23:345–70.
46.
DykesJ.1998. “Cartographic Visualization: Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis with Local Indicators of Spatial Association using Tcl/Tk and cdv.”The Statistician47:485–97.
47.
FarleyJ.LimpW.LockhartJ.1990. “The Archeologist’s Workbench: Integrating GIS, Remote Sensing, EDA and Database Management.” In Interpreting Space: GIS and Archeology, edited by AllenK.GreenF.ZubrowE., 141–64. London: Taylor & Francis.
48.
FotheringhamS.BrunsdonC.CharltonM.2002. Geographically Weighted Regression. Chichester, England: John Wiley.
49.
GaheganM.TakatsukaM.WheelerM.HardistyF.2002. “Introducing GeoVISTA Studio: An Integrated Suite of Visualization and Computational Methods for Exploration and Knowledge Construction in Geography.”Computers, Environment and Urban Systems26:267–92.
50.
GaheganM.HardistyF.DemsarU.TakatsukaM.2008. “GeoVISTA Studio: Reusability by Design.” In Open Source Approaches to Spatial Data Handling, edited by HallB.LeahyM., 201–20. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
51.
GoodchildM.1987. “A Spatial Analytical Perspective on Geographical Information Systems.”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems1:31–45.
52.
GoodchildM.2007. “Citizens as Sensors: The World of Volunteered Geography.”Geojournal69:211–21.
53.
GoodchildM.2010. “Whose Hand on the Tiller? Revisiting Spatial Statistical Analysis and GIS.” In Perspectives on Spatial Analysis, edited by AnselinL.ReyS., 49–59. Heidelberg, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
54.
GoodchildM.HainingR.WiseS.1992. “Integrating GIS and Spatial Analysis–Problems and Possibilities.”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems6:31–45.
55.
GoodchildM.AnselinL.AppelbaumR.HarthornB.2000. “Towards Spatially Integrated Social Science.”International Regional Science Review23:139–59.
56.
GoodchildM.FuP.RichP.2007. “Sharing Geographic Information: An Assessment of the Geospatial One-Stop.”Annals of the Association of American Geographers97:249–65.
57.
HainingR.1989. “Geography and Spatial Statistics: Current Positions, Future Developments.” In Remodeling Geography, edited by MacmillanB., 191–203. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
58.
HainingR.MaJ.WiseS.1996. “Design of a Software System for Interactive Spatial Statistical Analysis Linked to a GIS.”Computational Statistics11:449–66.
59.
HallB.LeahyM.2008. Open Source Approaches in Spatial Data Handling. Berlin, Germany: Springer-Verlag.
60.
HardistyF.KlippelA.2010. “Analysing Spatio-Temporal Autocorrelation with LISTA-Viz.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science24:1515–26.
61.
HardistyF.RobinsonA.2011. “The Geoviz Toolkit: Using Component-Oriented Coordination Methods for Geographic Visualization and Analysis.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science25:191–210.
62.
HarrisR.GroseD.LongleyP.SingletonA.BrunsdonC.2010. “Grid-enabling Geographically Weighted Regression: A Case Study of Participation in Higher Education in England.”Transactions in GIS14:43–61.
63.
HaslettJ.WillsG.UnwinA.1990. “SPIDER–An Interactive Statistical Tool for the Analysis of Spatially Distributed Data.”International Journal of Geographical Information Systems4:285–96.
64.
HaslettJ.BradleyR.CraigP.UnwinA.WillsG.1991. “Dynamic Graphics for Exploring Spatial Data with Applications to Locating Global and Local Anomalies.”The American Statistician45:234–42.
65.
IhakaR.GentlemanR.1996. “R: A Language for Data Analysis and Graphics.”Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics5:299–314.
66.
KelejianH.PruchaI.2007. “HAC Estimation in a Spatial Framework.”Journal of Econometrics140:131–54.
67.
KelejianH.PruchaI.2010. “Specification and Estimation of Spatial Autoregressive Models and Heteroskedastic Disturbances.”Journal of Econometrics157:53–67.
68.
KielmanJ.ThomasJ.MayR.2009. “Foundations and Frontiers in Visual Analytics.”Information Visualization8:239–46.
69.
KraakM.-J.MacEachrenA.2005. “Geovisualization and GIScience.”Cartography and Geographic Information Science32:67–68.
LaurentT.Ruiz-GazenA.Thomas-AgnanC.2009. “GeoXP: an R Package for Exploratory Spatial Data Analysis.”TSE Working Paper Series 99-099, Toulouse School of Economics. Toulouse, France.
72.
LeeL-F.2007. “GMM and 2SLS Estimation of Mixed Regressive, Spatial Autoregressive Models.”Journal of Econometrics137:489–514.
73.
LeSageJ.1999. “Spatial Econometrics.” In The Web Book of Regional Science, Regional Research Institute. Morgantown, WV: West Virginia University.
74.
LeSageJ.PaceK.2009. Introduction to Spatial Econometrics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
75.
LevineN.2006. “Crime Mapping and the CrimeStat program.”Geographical Analysis38:41–55.
76.
LevineN.2010. CrimeStat III: A Spatial Statistics Program for the Analysis of Crime Incident Locations. Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
77.
LiS.DragicevicS.VeenendaalB.2011a. Advances in Web-based GIS, Mapping Services and Applications. London: Taylor & Francis.
78.
LiZ.YangC.WuH.LiW.MiaoL.2011b. “An Optimized Framework for Seamlessly Integrating OGC Web Services to Support Geospatial Sciences.”International Journal of Geographical Information Sciences25:595–613.
79.
LiuX.LeSageJ.2010. “Arc_Mat: A Matlab-based Spatial Data Analysis Toolbox.”Journal of Geographical Systems12:69–87.
80.
LunnD.SpiegelhalterD.ThomasA.BestN.2009. “The BUGS Project: Evolution, Critique and Future Directions.”Statistics in Medicine28:3049–82.
81.
MacEachrenA.1995. How Maps Work: Representation, Visualization and Design. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
82.
MacEachrenA.KraakM.-J.1997. “Exploratory Cartographic Visualization: Advancing the Agenda.”Computers and Geosciences23:335–43.
83.
MacEachrenA. M.CrawfordS.MamataA.LengerichG.2008. “Design and Implementation of a Model, Web-based, GIS-Enabled Cancer Atlas.”The Cartographic Journal45:246–260.
84.
Mathsoft. 1996. S+SpatialStats User Manual, Version 1.0. Seattle, WA: Mathsoft Inc.
85.
MichaelisC. D.AmesD. P.2009. “Evaluation and Implementation of the OGC web Processing Service for use in Client-side GIS.”GeoInformatica13:109–20.
86.
MonmonierM.1989. “Geographic Brushing: Enhancing Exploratory Analysis of the Scatterplot Matrix.”Geographical Analysis21:81–4.
87.
NetelerM.MitasovaH.2008. Open Source GIS: A GRASS GIS Approach. Berlin, Germany: Springer.
88.
NSF (National Science Foundation).2003. Revolutionizing Science and Engineering Through Cyberinfrastructure. Report of the National Science Foundation Blue-Ribbon Advisory Panel on Cyberinfrastructure. Washington, DC: National Science Foundation.
89.
OpenshawS.1990. “Spatial Analysis and Geographical Information Systems: A Review of Progress and Possibilities.” In Geographical Information Systems for Urban and Regional Planning, edited by ScholtenH.StillwellJ., 153–63. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Kluwer.
90.
OrdK.1975. “Estimation Methods for Models of Spatial Interaction.”Journal of the American Statistical Association70:120–6.
91.
PaceK.LeSageJ.2004. “Chebyshev Approximation of Log-determinants of Spatial Weights Matrices.”Computational Statistics and Data Analysis45:179–96.
92.
PaceK.LeSageJ.2009. “A Sampling Approach to Estimate the Log Determinant used in Spatial Likelihood Problems.”Journal of Geographical Systems11:209–25.
93.
PengZ.TsouM-H.2003. Internet GIS: Distributed Geographic Information Services for the Internet and Wireless Networks. New York, NY: Wiley.
94.
PengZ.-R.ZhangC.2004. “The Roles of Geography Markup Language (GML), Scalable Vector Graphics (SVG) and Web Feature Service (WFS) Specifications in the Development of Internet Geographic Information Systems.”Journal of Geographical Systems6:95–116.
95.
PirasG.2010. “Sphet: Spatial Models with Heteroskedastic Innovations in R.”Journal of Statistical Software35:1–21.
96.
PleweB.1997. GIS Online. Information Retrieval, Mapping and the Internet. Santa Fe, NM: OnWorld Press.
97.
RaymondE.1999. The Cathedral and the Bazaar. Sebastopol, CA: O’Reilly.
98.
ReyS.2009. “Show me the Code: Spatial Analysis and Open Source.”Journal of Geographical Systems11:191–207.
99.
ReyS.AnselinL.2006. “Recent Advances in Software for Spatial Analysis in the Social Sciences.”Geographical Analysis38:1–4.
100.
ReyS.JanikasM.2006. “STARS: Space-time Analysis of Regional Systems.”Geographical Analysis38:67–86.
101.
RhyneT.-M.MacEachrenA.DykesJ.2006. “Exploring Geovisualization.”IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications26:20–1.
102.
ScharlA.TochtermannK.2007. The Geospatial Web: How Geobrowsers, Social Software and the Web 2.0 are Shaping the Network Society. London, England: Springer.
103.
SmirnovO.2005. “Computation of the Information Matrix for Models with Spatial Interaction on a Lattice.”Computational and Graphical Statistics14:910–27.
104.
SmirnovO.AnselinL.2001. “Fast Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Very Large Spatial Autoregressive Models: A Characteristic Polynomial Approach.”Computational Statistics and Data Analysis35:301–19.
105.
SmirnovO.AnselinL.2009. “A O(N) Parallel Method of Computing the Log-Jacobian of the Variable Transformation for Models with Spatial Interaction on a Lattice.”Computational Statistics and Data Analysis53:2980–88.
106.
SteingerS.BocherE.2009. “An Overview of Current Free and Open Source Desktop GIS Developments.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science23:1345–70.
107.
StuetzleW.1987. “Plot Windows.”Journal of the American Statistical Association82:466–75.
108.
SymanzikJ.MajureJ.CookD.1994a. “Dynamic Graphics in a GIS: A Bidirectional link Between ArcView 2.0 and XGobi.”Computing Science and Statistics27:299–303.
109.
SymanzikJ.MajureJ.CookD.CressieN.1994b. “Dynamic Graphics in a GIS: A link Between Arc/Info and XGobi.”Computing Science and Statistics26:431–5.
110.
SymanzikJ.CookD.Lewin-KohN.MajureJ.MegretskaiaI.2000. “Linking ArcView and XGobi: Insight behind the Front End.”Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics9:470–90.
111.
TaitM.2005. “Implementing Geoportals: Applications of Distributed GIS.”Computers, Environment and Urban Systems29:33–47.
112.
TakahashiK.KulldorffM.TangoT.YihK.2008. “A Flexibly Shaped Space-time Scan Statistic for Disease Outbreak Detection and Monitoring.”International Journal of Health Geographics7:14.
113.
ThomasJ.CookK.2005. Illuminating the Path; The Research and Development Agenda for Visual Analytics. Los Alamitos, CA: IEEE Computer Society Press.
114.
TiwariC.RushtonG.2010. “A Spatial Analysis System for Integrating Data, Methods and Models on Environmental Risks and Health Outcomes.”Transactions in GIS14:177–95.
115.
TukeyJ.1977. Exploratory Data Analysis. Reading, MA: Addison Wesley.
116.
TurtonI.2008. “Geotools.” In Open Source Approaches to Spatial Data Handling, edited by HallB.LeahyM., 153–70. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
117.
UngererM.GoodchildM.2002. “Integrating Spatial Data Analysis and GIS: A New Implementation using the Component Object Model (COM).”International Journal of Geographical Information Science16:41–53.
118.
UnwinA.1994. “REGARDing Geographic Data.” In Computational Statistics, edited by DirschedlP.OstermanR., 345–54. Heidelberg, Germany: Physica Verlag.
119.
VenablesW.RipleyB.1994. Modern Applied Statistics with S-Plus. New York, NY, Springer-Verlag.
120.
WangS.2010. “A CyberGIS Framework for the Synthesis of Cyberinfrastructure, GIS and Spatial Analysis.”Annals of the Association of American Geographers100:535–57.
121.
WangS.ArmstrongM.2009. “A Theoretical Approach to the use of Cyberinfrastructure in Geographical Analysis.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science23:169–93.
122.
WangS.CowlesM.ArmstrongM.2008. “Grid Computing and Spatial Statistics: Using the TeraGrid for Gi*(d) Analysis.”Concurrency and Computation: Practice and Experience20:1697–720.
123.
WangS.LiuY.2009. “TeraGrid GIScience Gateway: Bridging Cyberinfrastructure and GIScience.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science23:631–56.
124.
WangS.LiuY.Wilkins-DiehrN.MartinS.2009. “SimpleGrid Toolkit: Enabling Geosciences Gateways to Cyberinfrastructure.”Computers and Geosciences35:2283–94.
125.
WiegandN.KolasD.Berg-CrossG.2010. “Intersecting Semantic Web and Geospatial Technologies.”Transactions in GIS14:93–5.
126.
WiseS.HainingR.MaJ.2001. “Providing Spatial Statistical Data Analysis Functionality for the GIS user: The SAGE Project.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science15:239–54.
127.
WrightD.WangS.2011. “The Emergence of Spatial Cyberinfrastructure.”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences108:5488–91.
128.
YaltaA. T.YaltaA. Y.2010. “Should Economists use Open Source Software for doing Research.”Computational Economics35:371–94.
129.
YanJ.CowlesM.WangS.ArmstrongM.2007. “Parallelizing MCMC for Bayesian Spatiotemporal Statistical Models.”Statistics and Computing17:323–35.
130.
YangC.LiW.XieJ.ZhouB.2008. “Distributed Geospatial Information Processing: Sharing Distributed Geospatial Resources to Support Digital Earth.”International Journal of Digital Earth1:259–78.
131.
YangC.RaskinR.2009. “Introduction to Distributed Geographic Information Processing Research.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science23:553–60.
132.
YangC.RaskinR.GoodchildM.GaheganM.2010. “Geospatial Cyberinfrastructure: Past, Present and Future.”Computers, Environment and Urban Systems34:264–77.
133.
YangC.GoodchildM.HuangQ.NebertD.RaskinR.XuY.BambacusM.FrayD.2011. “Spatial Cloud Computing: How can the Geospatial Sciences use and help Shape Cloud Computing?”International Journal of Digital Earth4:305–29.
134.
YueP.DiL.SunL.WangQ.GongJ.YuanJ.SunZ.2010. “GeoPW: Laying Blocks for the Geospatial Processing Web.”Transactions in GIS14:755–72.
135.
ZhangZ.GriffithD.2000. “Integrating GIS Components and Spatial Statistical Analysis in DBMSs.”International Journal of Geographical Information Science14:543–66.
