The authors examine the moderating effects of conscientiousness on the relationships between agency controls and effort and agency controls and task performance. Results show that less conscientious individuals appear to increase effort through incentive alignment and monitoring, whereas conscientious individuals do not shirk with or without agency controls. Furthermore, results show that less conscientious individuals increase task performance through incentive alignment, but not through monitoring. The study confirms that motivation to act opportunistically differs between individuals unlike what is assumed by agency theory. Also, incentive alignment may be more effective than monitoring when attempting to align principal and agent interests.
Alchian, A.
, &
Demsetz, H.1972.
Production, information costs, and economic organization
. American Economic Review, 62:
777-795
.
2.
Amihud, Y.
, &
Lev, B.1981.
Risk reduction as a managerial motive for conglomerate mergers
. Bell Journal of Economics, 12:
605-617
.
3.
Anderson, E.
, &
Oliver, R.L.1987.
Perspective on behavior-based versus outcome-based sales force control systems
. Journal of Marketing,51:
76-88
.
4.
Baiman, S.1990.
Agency research in managerial accounting: A second look
. Accounting, Organizations, and Society, 15:
341-371
.
5.
Banker, R.D.
,
Lee, S.
,
Potter, G.
, &
Srinivasan, D.1996.
Contextual analysis of performance impacts of outcome-based incentive compensation
. Academy of Management Journal, 39:
920-948
.
6.
Barber, A.E.
, &
Bretz, R.D.2000. Compensation, attraction, and retention. In
S. L. Rynes
&
B. Gerhart
(Eds.), Compensation in organizations: 32-60.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
7.
Barrick, M.R.
, &
Mount, M.K.1991.
The Big Five personality dimensions and job performance: A meta-analysis
. Personnel Psychology, 44:
1-26
.
8.
Barrick, M.R.
,
Mount, M.K.
, &
Strauss, J.P.1993.
Conscientiousness and performance of sales representatives: Test of the mediating effects of goal setting
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 78:
715-722
.
9.
Barrick, M.R.
,
Stewart, G.L.
, &
Piotrowski, M.2002.
Personality and job performance: Test of the mediating effects of motivation among sales representatives
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87:
43-51
.
10.
Begley, T.
, &
Lee, C.2005.
The role of negative affectivity in pay-at-risk reactions: A longitudinal study
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 90:
382-388
.
11.
Benet-Martinez, V.
, &
John, O.P.1998.
Los cinco grandes across cultures and ethnic groups: Multitrait multimethod analyses of the Big Five in Spanish and English
. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75:
729-751
.
12.
Botwin, M.D.
, &
Buss, D.M.1989.
Structure of act-report data: Is the five-factor model of personality recaptured?Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 56:
988-1001
.
13.
Cohen, J.
, &
Cohen, P.1975. Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavior sciences.
Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum
.
14.
Conlon, E.J.
, &
Parks, J.M.1990.
Effects of monitoring and tradition on compensation arrangements: An experiment with principal-agent dyads
. Academy of Management Journal, 33:
603-622
.
15.
Coombs, J.E.
, &
Gilley, K.M.2005.
Stakeholder management as a predictor of CEO compensation: Main effects and interactions with financial performance
. Strategic Management Journal, 26:
827-840
.
16.
Costa, P.T.
, &
McCrae, R.R.1992.
Four ways five factors are basic
. Personality and Individual Differences, 13:
653-665
.
17.
Costa, P.T.
,
McCrae, R.R.
, &
Dye, D.A.1991.
Facet scales for agreeableness and conscientiousness: A revision of the NEO Personality Inventory
. Personality and Individual Differences, 12:
887-898
.
18.
Christen, M.
,
Iyer, G.
, &
Soberman, D.2006.
Job satisfaction, job performance, and effort: A reexamination using agency theory
. Journal of Marketing,70:
137-150
.
19.
Daily, C.M.
,
Dalton, D.R.
, &
Cannella, A.A.2003.
Corporate governance: Decades of dialogue and data
. Academy of Management Review, 28:
371-382
.
20.
Dalton, D.R.
,
Daily, C.M.
,
Certo, S.T.
, &
Roengpitya, R.2003.
Meta-analyses of financial performance and equity: Fusion or confusion?Academy of Management Journal, 46:
13-26
.
Deckop, J.R.
,
Mangel, R.
, &
Cirka, C.C.1999.
Getting more than you pay for: Organizational citizenship behavior and pay-for-performance plans
. Academy of Management Journal, 42:
420-428
.
23.
Dees, J.G.1992. Principals, agents, and ethics. In
N. E. Bowie
&
R. E. Freeman
(Eds.), Ethics and agency theory: 25-58.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
24.
Demski, J.S.
, &
Feltham, G.A.1978.
Economic incentives in budgetary control systems
. The Accounting Review, 53:
336-359
.
25.
Donaldson, L.1990a.
The ethereal hand: Organizational economics and management theory
. Academy of Management Review, 15:
369-381
.
26.
Donaldson, L.1990b.
A rational basis for criticism of organizational economics: A reply to Barney
. Academy of Management Review, 15:
394-401
.
27.
Doucouliagos, C.1994.
A note on the evolution of homo economicus
. Journal of Economic Issues, 28:
877-883
.
Eisenhardt, K.M.1988.
Agency- and institutional-theory explanations: The case of retail sales compensation
. Academy of Management Journal , 31:
488-511
.
30.
Eisenhardt, K.M.1989.
Agency theory: An assessment and review
. Academy of Management Review, 14:
57-74
.
31.
Etzioni, A.1988. The moral dimension: Toward a new economics.
New York: Free Press
.
32.
Fama, E.F.1980.
Agency problems and the theory of the firm
. Journal of Political Economy, 88:
288-307
.
33.
Fama, E.F.
, &
Jensen, M.C.1983.
Separation of ownership and control
. Journal of Law & Economics, 26:
301-325
.
34.
Frey, M.C.
, &
Detterman, D.K.2004.
Scholastic assessment or g? The relationship between the Scholastic Assessment Test and general cognitive ability
. Psychological Science, 15:
373-378
.
35.
Gerhart, B.
, &
Milkovich, G.T.1992. Employee compensation: Research and practice. In
M. D. Dunnette
&
L. M. Hough
(Eds.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology (2nd ed.), Vol. 3: 481-569.
Palo Alto, CA : Consulting Psychologists Press
.
36.
Gilbert, D.R.1996.
The Prisoner's Dilemma and the prisoners of the Prisoner's Dilemma
. Business Ethics Quarterly, 6:
165-178
.
37.
Gittell, J.H.2001.
Supervisory span, relational coordination and flight departure performance: A reassessment of postbureaucracy theory
. Organization Science, 12:
468-483
.
38.
Gomez-Mejia, L.R.
, &
Balkin, D.B.1992.
Determinants of faculty pay: An agency theory perspective
. Academy of Management Journal, 35:
921-955
.
39.
Govindarajan, V.
, &
Fisher, J.1990.
Strategy, control systems, and resource sharing: Effects on business-unit performance
. Academy of Management Journal , 33:
259-285
.
40.
Groff, J.E.
, &
Wright, C.J.1989. The market for corporate control and its implications for accounting policy choice. In
B. N. Schwartz
& Associates (Eds.), Advances in accounting, Vol. 7: 13-21.
Greenwich, CT: JAI
.
41.
Hambrick, D.C.
,
Finkelstein, S.
, &
Mooney, A.C.2005.
Executives sometimes lose it, just like the rest of us
. Academy of Management Review, 30:
503-508
.
42.
Harris, M.
, &
Raviv, A.1978.
Some results on incentive contracts with applications to education and employment, health insurance, and law enforcement
. American Economic Review, 68:
20-30
.
43.
Heneman, H.G.
, &
Judge, T.A.2000. Compensation attitudes. In
S. L. Rynes
&
B. Gerhart
(Eds.), Compensation in organizations: 61-103.
San Francisco : Jossey-Bass
.
44.
Hill, C.W.
, &
Hoskisson, R.E.1987.
Strategy and structure in the multiproduct firm
. Academy of Management Review, 12:
331-341
.
45.
Hogan, J.
, &
Ones, D.S.1997. Conscientiousness and integrity at work. In
R. Hogan
,
J. Johnson
, &
S. Briggs
(Eds.), Handbook of personality psychology: 849-870.
San Diego: Academic Press
.
46.
Hollenbeck, J.R.
,
Klein, H.J.
,
O'Leary, A.M.
, &
Wright, P.M.1989.
Investigation of the construct validity of a self-report measure of goal commitment
. Journal of Applied Psychology , 74:
951-956
.
47.
Hurtz, G.M.
, &
Donovan, J.J.2000.
Personality and job performance: The Big Five revisited
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85:
869-879
.
48.
Jensen, M.C.
, &
Meckling, W.H.1976.
Theory of firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure
. Journal of Financial Economics, 3:
305-360
.
49.
John, O.P.
,
Donahue, E.M.
, &
Kentle, R.L.1991. The Big Five Inventory: Versions 4a and 54.
Berkeley: University of California, Berkeley, Institute of Personality and Social Research
.
50.
Judge, T.A.
,
Higgins, C.A.
,
Thoresen, C.J.
, &
Barrick, M.R.1999.
The Big Five personality traits, general mental ability, and career success across the life span
. Personnel Psychology , 52:
621-652
.
51.
Judge, T.A.
, &
Ilies, R.2002.
Relationship of personality to performance motivation: A meta-analytic review
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87:
797-807
.
52.
Judge, T.A.
,
Martocchio, J.J.
, &
Thoresen, C.J.1997.
Five-factor model of personality and employee absence
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 82:
745-755
.
53.
Kanfer, R.
, &
Heggestad, E.D.1997.
Motivation traits and skills: A person-centered approach to work motivation
. Research in Organizational Behavior, 19:
1-56
.
54.
Miller, G.1992. Ethics and the new game theory. In
N. E. Bowie
&
R. E. Freeman
(Eds.), Ethics and agency theory: 117-126.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
55.
Moon, H.2001.
The two faces of conscientiousness: Duty and achievement striving in escalation of commitment dilemmas
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86:
533-540
.
56.
Mount, M.K.
, &
Barrick, M.R.1998.
Five reasons why the “Big Five” article has been frequently cited
. Personnel Psychology, 51:
849-857
.
57.
Noller, P.
,
Law, H.
, &
Comrey, A.L.1987.
Cattell, Comrey, and Eysenck personality factors compared: More evidence for the five robust factors?Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53:
775-782
.
58.
Pearce, J.L.
,
Stevenson, W.B.
, &
Perry, J.L.1985.
Managerial compensation based on organizational performance: A time series analysis of the effects of merit pay
. Academy of Management Journal, 28:
261-278
.
59.
Perrow, C.
(1986). Complex organizations: A critical essay (3rd ed.).
New York: McGraw-Hill
.
60.
Riordan, M.
, &
Sappington, D.1987.
Awarding monopoly franchises
. American Economic Review, 77:
375-388
.
61.
Ross, S.A.1973.
Economic theory of agency: Principal's problem
. American Economic Review, 63:
134-139
.
62.
Salgado, J.F.1997.
The five factor model of personality and job performance in the European Community
. Journal of Applied Psychology, 82(1):
30-43
.
Spreitzer, G.M.1996.
Social structural characteristics of psychological empowerment
. Academy of Management Journal, 39:
483-504
.
65.
Stearns, L.B.
, &
Mizruchi, M.S.1993.
Board composition and corporate financing: The impact of financial institution representation on borrowing
. Academy of Management Journal, 36:
603-618
.
66.
Stone, E.F.
, &
Hollenbeck, J.R.1984.
Some issues associated with moderated regression
. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance , 34:
195-213
.
67.
Stroh, L.K.
,
Brett, J.M.
,
Baumann, J.P.
, &
Reilly, A.H.1996.
Agency theory and variable pay compensation strategies
. Academy of Management Journal, 39:
751-767
.
68.
Tosi, H.L.
,
Katz, J.P.
, &
Gomez-Mejia, L.R.1997.
Disaggregating the agency contract: The effects of monitoring, incentive alignment, and term in office on agent decision making
. Academy of Management Journal, 40:
584-602
.
69.
Tosi, H.L.
,
Werner, S.
,
Katz, J.P.
, &
Gomez-Mejia, L.R.2000.
How much does performance matter? A meta-analysis of CEO pay studies
. Journal of Management , 26:
301-339
.
70.
Zajac, E.J.
, &
Westphal, J.D.1994.
The costs and benefits of managerial incentives and monitoring in large U.S. corporations: When is more not better
. Strategic Management Journal, 15:
121-142
.
71.
Zenger, T.R.
, &
Marshall, C.R.2000.
Determinants of incentive intensity in group-based rewards
. Academy of Management Journal , 43:
149-163
.
