Unions divided? Trade union attitudes towards the European Union’s Directive on Adequate Minimum Wages

Abstract

In October 2022, the European Union adopted a directive on adequate minimum wages in the European Union (AMWD). This directive has sparked considerable controversy. While employers uniformly oppose the AMWD, unions are divided. In many EU countries, unions support the AMWD, while in Denmark and Sweden, they oppose it. This article aims to answer the question: Why do unions in some member states support the AMWD, while unions in other countries oppose it? Drawing on 27 semi-structured interviews with union representatives from 13 EU countries, the article presents a typology of union positions towards AMWD consisting of three types: domestically-oriented opposition, domestically-oriented support, and externally-oriented support. The article proposes an explanation for these three different types that is based on two variables: bargaining coverage, and the role of state institutions in protecting it.

Keywords

Collective bargaining coverage European Union Minimum Wage Directive statutory minimum wages trade unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam

(2022) Die Entwicklung der gesetzlichen Mindestlohnsetzung in der EU und ihre Bedeutung für die Gewerkschaften. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft 48(3): 365–406.

Addison

Portugal

Vilares

(2017) Unions and collective bargaining in the wake of the Great Recession: Evidence from Portugal. British Journal of Industrial Relations 55(3): 551–576.

Ahlberg

(2023) Denmark takes minimum wage directive to the EU Court. Nordic Labour Journal. Epub ahead of print 19 January 2023.

Arnholtz

(2019) Eventful sense-making and divergent responses to labour and service mobility in Nordic construction. Unpublished Manuscript, University of Copenhagen.

Beskæftigelsesministeriet [Danish Ministry of Employment] (2023) Regeringen har anlagt annullationssøgsmål mod mindstelønsdirektivet. Copenhagen.

Busemeyer

Kellermann

Petring

, et al. (2007) Overstretching Solidarity? Trade Unions’ National Perspectives on the European Economic and Social Model. Berlin: Friedrich Ebert Foundation.

CISL (2022) Direttiva europea su salari minimi adeguati, 14 sett. 2022 (Position paper). Available at: www.cisl.it/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/SchedadiletturaDirettivasalariominimo.pdf (accessed 28 October 2023).

Costa

(2006) Portuguese trade unions and European integration lessons from a dual vision. Lusotopie XIII(1): 7–35.

Council of the European Union (2022) Council adopts EU law on adequate minimum wages. Brussels: Council of the European Union.

10.

de la Porte

(2019) The European Pillar of Social Rights meets the Nordic model. Stockholm: Swedish Institute for European Policy Studies.

11.

Dingeldey

Nussbaum Bitran

(2023) The European Minimum Wage Directive – and why it is a challenge to trade unions’ but not employers’ unity. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 28 March 2023. https://doi.org/10.1177/0143831X2311618

12.

ETUI (2016a) Finland: Key facts. Available at: www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Countries/Finland (accessed 30 June 2023).

13.

ETUI (2016b) Italy. Available at: www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Countries/Italy (accessed 30 June 2023).

14.

ETUI (2016c) Denmark. Available at: www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Countries/Denmark (accessed 30 June 2023).

15.

ETUI and ETUC (2021) Benchmarking Working Europe 2021: Unequal Europe. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.

16.

European Commission (2020) Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on adequate minimum wages in the European Union. COM/2020/682 final (accessed 28 October 2023).

17.

Fernández-Macías

Vacas-Soriano

(2016) A coordinated European Union minimum wage policy? European Journal of Industrial Relations 22(2): 97–113.

18.

Furåker

(2020) The issue of statutory minimum wages: Views among Nordic trade unions. Economic and Industrial Democracy 41(2): 419–435.

19.

Furåker

Larsson

(2020) Trade Union Cooperation in Europe: Patterns, Conditions, Issues. Singapore: Springer.

20.

Furåker

Lovén Seldén

(2013) Trade union cooperation on statutory minimum wages? A study of European trade union positions. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 19(4): 507–520.

21.

Guardiancich

Terlizzi

Natali

(2023) The social policy preferences of EU employers’ organizations: An exploratory analysis. European Journal of Industrial Relations. Epub ahead of print 30 January 2023.

22.

Günther

Höpner

(2022) Why does Germany abstain from statutory bargaining extensions? Explaining the exceptional German erosion of collective wage bargaining. Economic and Industrial Democracy 44(1): 88–108.

23.

Hall

(2005) Preference formation as a political process: The case of Monetary Union in Europe. In: Katznelson

Weingast

(eds) Preferences and Situations: Points of Intersection between Historical and Rational Choice Institutionalism. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

24.

Hassel

(2023) Round Table. Mission impossible? How to increase collective bargaining coverage in Germany and the EU. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 28(4): 491–497.

25.

Haverland

(2010) If similarity is the challenge – congruence analysis should be part of the answer. European Political Science 9(1): 68–73.

26.

Höpner

Schäfer

(2012) Embeddedness and regional integration: Waiting for Polanyi in a Hayekian setting. International Organization 66(3): 429–455.

27.

Hyman

(2005) Trade unions and the politics of the European Social Model. Economic and Industrial Democracy 26(1): 9–40.

28.

ILO (2021) Collective bargaining in Germany and Ukraine: Lessons learned and recommendations for Ukraine. Geneva: International Labor Organization.

29.

Katznelson

Weingast

(eds) (2005) Preferences and Situations: Points of Intersection between Historical and Rational Choice Institutionalism. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

30.

Kozák

Picot

Starke

(2022) Do minimum wages crowd out union density? Unpublished manuscript.

31.

Lillie

(2023) Round Table. Nordic unions and the European Minimum Wage Directive. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 28(4): 499–504.

32.

Lima

MDPC

Martins

Costa

, et al. (2021) Internal devaluation and economic inequality in Portugal: Challenges to industrial relations in times of crisis and recovery. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 27(1): 47–73.

33.

Lovén Seldén

(2020) Challenges posed by the EU minimum wage initiative to the ETUC and European trade union cooperation. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 26(3): 325–343.

34.

Lübker

Schulten

(2022) WSI-Mindestlohnbericht 2022: Aufbruch zu einer neuen Mindestlohnpolitik in Deutschland und Europa. Düsseldorf: Wirtschafts- und Sozialwissenschaftliches Institut.

35.

Mallia

(2021) EU minimum wage directive risks legal quagmire. Available at: https://euobserver.com/opinion/151327 (accessed 24 March 2021).

36.

Marx

Starke

(2017) Dualization as destiny? The political economy of the German minimum wage reform. Politics & Society 45(4): 559–584.

37.

Ministry of Social Security and Labour (Lithuania) (2020) Collective labour relations. Available at: https://socmin.lrv.lt/en/activities/labour-and-employment/labour-law/collective-labour-relations (accessed 30 June 2023).

38.

Molina

(2014) Self-regulation and the state in industrial relations in Southern Europe: Back to the future? European Journal of Industrial Relations 20(1): 21–34.

39.

Müller

Schulten

(2018) The role of extension in German collective bargaining. In: Hayter

Visser

(eds) Collective Agreements: Extending Labour Protection. Geneva: ILO, pp. 65–94.

40.

Müller

Schulten

(2022) Die Europäische Mindestlohnrichtlinie – Paradigmenwechsel hin zu einem Sozialen Europa. Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft 48(3): 335–364.

41.

Natili

Ronchi

(2023) The politics of the European Minimum Wage: Overcoming ideological, territorial and institutional conflicts in the EU multi-level arena. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies. Epub ahead of print 29 August 2023.

42.

Noticias ao minuto (2020) UGT escreve a Costa a defender diretiva para salário mínimo na Europa. Available at: www.noticiasaominuto.com/economia/1577369/ugt-escreve-a-costa-a-defender-diretiva-para-salario-minimo-na-europa (accessed 30 June 2023).

43.

Noticias ao minuto (2021) UGT alerta para necessidade da diretiva sobre o Salário Mínimo Europeu. Available at: www.noticiasaominuto.com/economia/1739150/ugt-alerta-para-necessidade-da-diretiva-sobre-o-salario-minimo-europeu (accessed 30 June 2023).

44.

OECD and AIAS (2023) Institutional characteristics of trade unions, wage setting, state intervention and social pacts. OECD/AIAS ICTWSS Database v1.1. Paris: OECD.

45.

OeGB (2022) Europas Gewerkschaften machen Druck für Mindestlohn-Richtlinie. Vienna: OeGB.

46.

Paster

(2023) Die EU-Mindestlohnrichtlinie: Ein Paradigmenwechsel in der EU-Arbeitsmarktpolitik? Kurswechsel 2: 81–85.

47.

Paster

Oude Nijhuis

Kiecker

(2020) To extend or not to extend: Explaining the divergent use of statutory bargaining extensions in the Netherlands and Germany. British Journal of Industrial Relations 58(3): 532–557.

48.

Risgaard

(2020) EU legislation on minimum wages is not the solution. In: Social Europe (ed.) EU legislation on minimum wages is not the solution. Brussels.

49.

Seeliger

(2018) Why do (some) European trade unions reject minimum wage regulation? Culture, Practice & Europeanization 3(1): 37–46.

50.

Seeliger

(2019) Trade Unions in the Course of European Integration: The Social Construction of Organized Interests (Routledge Research in Employment Relations). New York and Abingdon: Routledge.

51.

Seikel

(2015) Class struggle in the shadow of Luxembourg: The domestic impact of the European Court of Justice’s case law on the regulation of working conditions. Journal of European Public Policy 22(8): 1166–1185.

52.

Thelen

Steinmo

(1992) Historical institutionalism in comparative politics. In: Steinmo

Thelen

Longstreth

(eds) Structuring Politics: Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

53.

Tomev

Daskalova

Mihailova

, et al. (2008) Wages and collective bargaining in Bulgaria. Journal for Labour and Social Affairs in Eastern Europe 2: 219–237.

54.

Vesan

Corti

(2019) New tensions over Social Europe? The European Pillar of Social Rights and the debate within the European Parliament. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 57(5): 977–994.