Intra-European labour migration and deteriorating employment relations in Danish cleaning and agriculture: Industrial relations under pressure from EU8/2 labour inflows?
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online November, 2016
Intra-European labour migration and deteriorating employment relations in Danish cleaning and agriculture: Industrial relations under pressure from EU8/2 labour inflows?
Eastern and Central European labour migration following the EU enlargement has significant impact on the Nordic labour markets. This article demonstrates, through sector-based case studies in Denmark, how labour migration influences working condition and wages in two sectors that have so far only been sparsely studied: the agriculture and cleaning industries. The high inflow of labour migrants is used by some employers to bypass and undermine the institutionalized class compromise, by employing EU8/2-workers at lower wages and often without collective agreements coverage frequently combined with below average working conditions. This put strains on the Danish agreement-based model of industrial relations, potentially leading to a more segmented labour market as well as replacement of native, mainly low-skilled workers with EU8/2-workers.
AfonsoA (2012) Employer strategies, cross-class coalitions and the free movement of labour in the enlarged European Union. Socio-Economic Review10(4): 705–730.
2.
AmableB (2003) The Diversity of Modern Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
AndersenSKArnholtzJ (2013) Udfordringen fra øst – Fagforeningsstrategier og den østeuropæiske arbejdskraft. Økonomi og Politik86(1): 45–57.
4.
AndersenSKFelbo-KoldingJ (2013) Danske virksomheders brug af østeuropæisk arbejdskraft. Copenhagen: FAOS.
5.
AndersenSKDølvikJEIbsenCL (2014) De nordiske aftalemodeller i åbne markeder – udfordringer og perspektiver. Nordmod 2030, delrapport 9. Oslo: Fafo.
6.
AndersenTM (2012) Migration og den nordiske velfærdsmodel. Økonomi og Politik85(4): 16–27.
7.
ArnholtzJHansenNW (2013) Labour market specific institutions and the working conditions of labour migrants : The case of Polish migrant labour in the Danish labour market. Economic and Industrial Democracy34(3): 401–422.
8.
BarrellRFitzgeraldJRileyR (2010) EU enlargement and migration: Assessing the macroeconomic impacts. Journal of Common Market Studies48(2): 373–395.
9.
BauerTKZimmermanKF (1999) Assessment of Possible Migration Pressure and its Labour Market Impact Following EU Enlargement to Central and Eastern Europe. IZA Research Report No. 3, Institute for the Study of Labour, Germany.
10.
BorjasGJGroggerJHansonGH (2008) Imperfect Substitution between Immigrants and Natives: A Reappraisal. NBER Working Paper Series No.13887. Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research.
11.
BrochmannGGrødemAS (2013) Migration and welfare sustainability: The case of Norway, In: BrochmannGJuradoE (eds) Europe’s Immigration Challenge: Reconciling Work, Welfare and Mobility. London: I.B. Tauris, pp. 59–76.
12.
CorbySWhiteG (1999) Employee Relations in the Public Services: Themes and Issues. London: Routledge.
13.
CrouchC (2012) National varieties of labour market exposure. In: MorganGWhitleyR (eds) Capitalisms and Capitalism in the Twenty-first Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 90–115.
14.
DA (2013) Arbejdsmarkedsrapport 2012. Report. Copenhagen: Danish Confederation of Employers.
15.
DI (2012) Renhold og kombinerede serviceydelser. Yearly report 2012 from Confederation of Danish Industry (Service). Available at: www.e-pages.dk/di/1445248852/.
16.
DølvikJE (2013a) Grunnpilarene i de Nordiske modellene. Et tilbakeblikk på arbeidslivs- og velferdsregimenes utvikling. Fafo-report 2013:13. NordMod 2030 report 1. Oslo: Fafo.
17.
DølvikJE (2013b) European movements of labour: Challenges for European social models. In: BrochmannGJuradoE (eds) Europe’s Immigration Challenge: Reconciling Work, Welfare and Mobility. London: I.B. Tauris, pp. 33–58.
18.
DølvikJEVisserJ (2009) Free movement, equal treatment and workers’ rights: Can the European Union solve its trilemma of fundamental principles?Industrial Relations Journal40: 491–509.
19.
EbbinghausB (2006) Trade union movements in post-industrial welfare states: Opening up to new social interests? In: ArmingeonKBonoliG (eds) The Politics of Post-industrial Welfare States. New York: Routledge, pp. 123–145.
20.
EldringLSchultenT (2012) Migrant workers and wage-setting institutions: Experiences from Germany, Norway, Switzerland and United Kingdom. In GalgócziBLeschkeJWattA (eds) EU Labour Migration in Troubled Times. Farnham: Ashgate, pp. 235–260.
21.
EldringLFitzgeraldIArnholtzJ (2012) Post-accession migration in construction and trade union responses in Denmark, Norway and the UK. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(1): 21–36.
22.
Esping-AndersenG (1985) Politics against Markets : The Social Democratic Road to Power. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
23.
Esping-AndersenG (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Oxford: Polity Press.
24.
FleckerJ (2009) Outsourcing, spatial relocation and the fragmentation of employment. Competition and Change13(3): 251–266.
25.
FribergJHEldringL (2013) Labour Migrants from Central and Eastern Europe in the Nordic Countries: Patterns of Migration, Working Conditions and Recruitment Practices. TemaNord 2013:570. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers.
26.
FribergJHTyldumG (2007) Polonia i Oslo – En studie av arbeids- og levekår blant polakker i hovedstadsområdet. Fafo Rapport 2007:27. Oslo: Fafo.
27.
FribergJH. (2013) Labour market regulation, migrant workers and varieties of ‘social dumping’ in Oslo, Copenhagen and Reykjavik. In: FribergJHEldringL (eds) Labour Migrants from Central and Eastern Europe in the Nordic Countries. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers, pp. 43–140.
28.
FribergJH. (2014) Nordic labour market institutions and new migrant workers: Polish migrants in Oslo, Copenhagen and Reykjavik. European Journal of Industrial Relations21(1): 37–53.
29.
GalgócziBLeschkeJWattA (2012) EU Labour Migration in Troubled Times: Skills Mismatch, Return and Policy Responses. Farnham: Ashgate.
30.
GavanasA (2010) Who Cleans the Welfare State? Migration, Informalization, Social Exclusion and Domestic Services in Stockholm. Research report. Stockholm: Institute for Futures Studies.
31.
GerringJ (2007) Case Study Research: Principles and Practices. New York: Cambridge University Press.
32.
GoldthorpeJ (1984) The end of convergence: Corporatist and dualist tendencies in modern western societies. In: GoldthorpeJ (ed.) Order and Conflict in Contemporary Capitalism. Oxford: Clarendon, pp. 315–343.
33.
Goul AndersenJ (2011) Denmark – ambiguous modernisation of an inclusive unemployment protection system. In: ClasenJCleggD (eds) Regulating the Risk of Unemployment. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 187–207.
34.
GreerICiupijusZLillieN (2013) The European Migrant Workers Union and the barriers to transnational industrial citizenship. European Journal of Industrial Relations19(1): 5–20.
35.
HansenJAAndersenSK (2008) Østeuropæiske arbejdere i bygge- og anlægsbranchen. FAOS Research report 92. Copenhagen: FAOS.
36.
HansenJAHansenNW (2009) Polonia i København. Et studie af polske arbejdsmigranters løn-, arbejds- og levevilkår i Storkøbenhavn. Report, LO-Dokumentation nr. 1. Copenhagen: Landsorganisationen i Danmark.
37.
HardyJEldringLSchultenT (2012) Trade union responses to migrant workers from the ‘new Europe’: A three sector comparison in the UK, Norway and Germany. European Journal of Industrial Relations18(4): 347–363.
38.
HermannCFleckerJ (2012) Privatization of Public Services: Impacts for Employment, Working Conditions, and Service Quality in Europe. London: Routledge.
39.
HolstH (2014) ‘Commodifying institutions’: Vertical disintegration and institutional change in German labour relations. Work, Employment and Society28(1): 3–20.
40.
IbsenFHøgedahlLScheuerS (2012) Kollektiv handling : faglig organisering og skift af fagforening. Frederiksberg: Nyt fra Samfundsvidenskaberne.
41.
JensenCA. (2007) Udenlandsk arbejdskraft i landbruget. Working Paper No.17. Copenhagen: Rockwool Fondens Forskningsenhed.
42.
KaczmarczykP (2012) Labour market impacts of post-accession migration from Poland. In: OCEDFree Movement of Workers and Labour Market Adjustment. Paris: OECD, pp. 173–194.
43.
KahanecMZimmermannKF (2010) EU Labor Markets after Post-enlargement Migration. Berlin: Springer.
44.
KahmannM (2006) The posting of workers in the German construction industry: Responses and problems of trade union action. Transfer12(2): 183–196.
45.
KLEMS (2009) EU KLEMS database. November2009 release.
46.
KorpiW (1983) The Democratic Class Struggle. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
47.
KorpiW (2006) Power resources and employer-centered approaches in explanations of welfare states and varieties of capitalism: Protagonists, consenters, and antagonists. World Politics58(2): 167–206.
48.
KorsbyTM (2011) Menneskehandel i rengøringsbranchen?Copenhagen: Center mod menneskehandel.
49.
KringsT (2009) A race to the bottom? Trade unions, EU enlargement and the free movement of labour. European Journal of Industrial Relations15(1): 49–69.
50.
LillieN (2010) Bringing the offshore ashore: Transnational production, industrial relations and the reconfiguration of sovereignty. International Studies Quarterly54(3): 683–704.
51.
LillieNGreerI (2007) Industrial relations, migration, and neoliberal politics: The case of the European construction sector. Politics and Society35(4): 551–581.
52.
LillieNSippolaM (2011) National unions and transnational workers: The case of Olkiluoto 3, Finland. Work, Employment and Society25(2): 292–308.
53.
LisborgA (2011) Menneskehandel i den grønne sektor?Copenhagen: Center mod menneskehandel.
54.
McGovernP (2007) Immigration, labour markets and employment relations: Problems and prospects. British Journal of Industrial Relations45(2): 217–235.
MailandMLarsenTP (2011) Trade Unions and Precarious Work. Danish Country Report to the BARSORI-Project. FAOS Research paper 121. Copenhagen: FAOS.
57.
Malchow-MøllerNMunchJRSkaksenJR (2009) Det danske arbejdsmarked og EU-udvidelsen mod øst. Copenhagen: Gyldendal.
58.
MarchingtonM. (2005) Fragmenting Work : Blurring Organizational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
59.
MeardiG (2012) Social Failures of EU Enlargement: A Case of Workers Voting with Their Feet. London: Routledge.
60.
MenzG (2005) Varieties of Capitalism and Europeanization: National Response Strategies to the Single European Market. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
61.
PedersenLMThomsenTL (2011) Arbejdsmigration fra de nye EU-lande – en kilde til vækst eller trussel mod de (u)faglærte danske arbejdstagere?. Tidsskrift for Arbejdsliv13(3): 45–63.
62.
PioreMJ (1979) Birds of Passage. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
63.
RefslundB (2012) Offshoring Danish slaughterhouse jobs to Germany: Regional effects and challenges to workers’ organisation. Work Organisation, Labour and Globalisation6(2): 113–129.
64.
SassenS (1988) The Mobility of Capital and Labour: A Study in International Investment and Labour Flow. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
StuvøyIAndersenSK (2013) Temporary staffing and labour migration to Denmark. In: FribergJHEldringL (eds) Labour Migrants from Central and Eastern Europe in the Nordic Countries. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers, pp. 231–271.
67.
TillyC (2011) The impact of the economic crisis on international migration: A review. Work, Employment and Society25(4): 675–692.
68.
TrondstedKRJoonaPA (2013) New patterns of migration from Central and Eastern Europe to the Nordic countries. In: FribergJHEldringL (eds) Labour Migrants from Central and Eastern Europe in the Nordic Countries. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers, pp. 19–42.
69.
WillsJ (2009) Subcontracted employment and its challenge to labour. Labour Studies Journal34(4): 441–460.
70.
WoolfsonC (2007) Labour standards and migration in the new Europe: Post-communist legacies and perspectives. European Journal of Industrial Relations13(2): 199–218.
71.
WoolfsonCFudgeJThornqvistC (2013) Migrant precarity and future challenges to labour standards in Sweden. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 29 August 2013. DOI: 10.1177/0143831X13494249.
