The international literature on the economic and fiscal crisis that heralded the Great Recession emphasizes the negative effects of ‘disorganized decentralization’ on unions’ capacities for pay coordination and ultimately on their effectiveness in representing their members. These effects are seen as particularly pronounced in countries on the ‘European periphery’ such as Ireland. The article challenges this view by showing how the collapse of social partnership and centralized bargaining in Ireland was soon followed in the private sector by a new form of coordinated decentralized pattern bargaining. Coordinated sectoral bargaining emerged and was sustained in the public service. The durability of pay coordination is attributed to the strategic postures of unions, combined with embedded features of industrial relations institutions. The comparative import of the Irish case arises less from ‘disorganized decentralization’ than from the resilience of coordination following one of the most severe economic and fiscal shocks experienced by any advanced economy.
Aumayr-PintarCCabritaJFernandez-MaciasEVacas-SorianoC (2014) Pay in Europe in the Twenty-First Century. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.
2.
BaccaroLHowellC (2011) A common neoliberal trajectory. Politics and Society39(4): 521–563.
3.
BaccaroLSimoniM (2007) Centralized wage bargaining and the ‘Celtic Tiger’ phenomenon. Industrial Relations46(3): 426–455.
4.
BarrettAMcGuinnessS (2012) The Irish Labour Market and the Great Recession. Munich: CESifo DICE Report.
5.
BerginAKellyEMcGuinnessS (2012) Explaining Changes in Earnings and Labour Costs During the Recession. Renewal Series Paper 9. Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute.
6.
CappelliP (1990) Is pattern bargaining dead? A discussion. Industrial and Labor Relations Review44(1): 152–155.
7.
Central Bank of Ireland (2009) Quarterly Bulletin, October. Dublin.
8.
ChagnyOHussonM (2015) Looking for an ‘optimal wage regime’ for the Eurozone. In: Van GyesGSchultenT (eds) Wage Bargaining Under the New Economic Governance: Alternative Strategies for Inclusive Growth. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
D’ArtDTurnerT (2005) Union recognition and partnership at work: A new legitimacy for Irish trade unions?Industrial Relations Journal36(2): 121–139.
11.
Department of Finance (2009) Supplementary Budget. Dublin: Department of Finance.
12.
Department of Finance (2010) EU/IMF Programme of Financial Support for Ireland. Dublin: Department of Finance.
13.
Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation (2014) Membership of trade unions with negotiating licences as of 31st December 2014. Dublin (unpublished).
14.
Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation (2015) Membership of trade unions with negotiating licences as of 31st December 2014. Dublin (unpublished).
15.
DorisAO’NeillDSweetmanO (2014) Recession: The Response of the Irish Labour Market. Maynooth: Maynooth University, Department of Economics, Finance and Accounting.
16.
DuffyKWalshF (2011) Report of Independent Review of Employment Regulation Orders and Registered Employment Agreement Wage Setting Mechanisms. Dublin: Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation.
17.
ESRI (Economic and Social Research Institute) (2015) Quarterly Economic Commentary, Winter. Dublin.
18.
ESRI (Economic and Social Research Institute) (2016) Quarterly Economic Commentary, Autumn. Dublin.
19.
HaipeterT (2011) ‘Unbound’ employers’ associations and derogations: Erosion and renewal of collective bargaining in the German metalworking industry. Industrial Relations Journal42(2): 174–194.
20.
HicklandEDundonT (2016a) Reform of joint regulation and labour market policy during the crisis: The manufacturing sector in the Republic of Ireland. In: KoukiadakiATávoraIMartinez LucioM (eds) Joint Regulation and Labour Market Policy in Europe During the Crisis. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
21.
HicklandEDundonT (2016b) The shifting contours of collective bargaining in the manufacturing sector in the Republic of Ireland: Government, employer and union responses since the economic crisis. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(3): 235–249.
22.
HigginsCRocheWK (2014) Networked pay coordination and the containment of second-tier pay bargaining: Social partnership in Ireland at the height of the boom. Economic and Industrial Democracy35(4): 667–693.
23.
IBEC (Irish Business and Employers’ Confederation) (2015) IBEC pay update survey 2015. Dublin.
24.
IBEC (Irish Business and Employers’ Confederation) (2016) HR update survey 2016, Issue 2. Dublin.
25.
IbsenCL (2016) The role of mediation institutions in Sweden and Denmark after centralized bargaining. British Journal of Industrial Relations54(2): 285–310.
26.
ICTU (Irish Congress of Trade Unions) (2011) Report of the Commission on the Irish Trade Union Movement: A Call to Action. Dublin: ICTU.
27.
ICTU (Irish Congress of Trade Unions) (2015) Matters for consideration in pay bargaining negotiations in the private sector in 2016. Private Sector Committee Bulletin. Dublin.
28.
ICTU (Irish Congress of Trade Unions) and IBEC (Irish Business and Employers’ Confederation) (2010) Private Sector Protocol. Dublin: ICTU and IBEC.
29.
Industrial Relations News (various dates).
30.
IRN (Industrial Relations News) and CIPD (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development) (2015) Private sector pay 2015. In: IRN Annual Conference, What’s the Deal?, Dublin, O’Reilly Hall UCD, 12 March.
31.
IRN (Industrial Relations News) and CIPD (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development) (2016) Private sector pay 2016. In: IRN Annual Conference, Great Expectations: Resetting Employment Relations in Recovery, Dublin, O’Reilly Hall UCD, 10 March.
32.
IRN (Industrial Relations News) and CIPD (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development) (2017) Private sector pay 2017. In: IRN Annual Conference, Where Are We Now? Employment Relations in a Time of Heightened Expectations, Dublin, O’Reilly Hall UCD, 9 March.
33.
KatzH (1993) The decentralization of collective bargaining: A literature review and comparative analysis. Industrial and Labor Relations Review47(1): 3–22.
34.
KeuneM (2015) Less governance capacity and more inequality: The effects of the assault on collective bargaining. In: Van GyesGSchultenT (eds) Wage Bargaining Under the New Economic Governance: Alternative Strategies for Inclusive Growth. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
35.
KinsellaS (2016) Economic and fiscal policy. In: RocheWKO’ConnellPProtheroA (eds) Austerity and Recovery in Ireland: Europe’s Poster Child and the Great Recession. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
36.
KoukiadakiATávoraIMartinez LucioM (2016a) Joint regulation and labour market policy in Europe during the crisis: A seven-country comparison. In: KoukiadakiATávoraIMartinez LucioM (eds) Joint Regulation and Labour Market Policy in Europe During the Crisis. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
37.
KoukiadakiATávoraIMartinez LucioM (2016b) Continuity and change in joint regulation in Europe: Structural reforms and collective bargaining in manufacturing. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(3): 189–203.
38.
Labour Relations Commission (2010) Public Service Agreement 2010–2014. Dublin: Labour Relations Commission.
39.
Labour Relations Commission (2013) Public Service Stability Agreement 2013–2016. Dublin: Labour Relations Commission.
40.
Labour Relations Commission (2015) Public Service Stability Agreement 2013–2018: The Lansdowne Road Agreement. Dublin: Labour Relations Commission.
41.
LaffanB (2016) International actors and agencies. In: RocheWKO’ConnellPProtheroA (eds) Austerity and Recovery in Ireland: Europe’s Poster Child and the Great Recession. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
42.
McCarthyWEJO’BrienJFDowdV (1975) Wage Inflation and Wage Leadership: A Study of the Role of Key Wage Bargains in the Irish System of Collective Bargaining. Dublin: Economic and Social Research Institute.
43.
McDonaghTDundonT (2010) Thatcherism delayed? The Irish crisis and the paradox of social partnership. Industrial Relations Journal41(6): 544–562.
44.
McPartlinB (1997) The development of trade union organization. In: MurphyTRocheWK (eds) Irish Industrial Relations in Practice. Dublin: Oak Tree Press.
45.
MarginsonP (2015) Coordinated bargaining in Europe: From incremental corrosion to frontal assault?European Journal of Industrial Relations21(2): 97–114.
46.
MarginsonPWelzC (2014) Changes to Wage-Setting Mechanisms in the Context of the Crisis and the EU’s New Economic Governance Regime. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.
47.
MeyerW (1995) Is pattern bargaining dead? An empirical investigation with micro data for West Germany. Konjunkturpolitik41(3): 228–243.
48.
National Competitiveness Council (2016) Ireland’s Competitiveness Scorecard 2016. Dublin: National Competitiveness Council.
49.
NERI (Nevin Institute of Economic Research) (2016) Private sector wages: Trends, prospects and issues. Dublin (unpublished).
50.
O’ConnellP (2013) Cautious adjustment in a context of economic collapse: The public sector in the Irish crises. In: Vaughan WhiteheadD (ed.) Public Sector Shock: The Impact of Policy Retrenchment in Europe. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
51.
PurcellJ (1995) Ideology and the end of institutional industrial relations: Evidence from the UK. In: CrouchCTraxlerF (eds) Organized Industrial Relations in Europe: What Future?Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 101–119.
52.
RibeiroAT (2015) Recent trends in collective bargaining in Europe. In: Conference on The Great Transformation at Work, University of Bergamo/ADAPT, November.
53.
RocheWK (2007) Social partnership in Ireland and new social pacts. Industrial Relations46(3): 395–425.
54.
RocheWK (2011) The breakdown of social partnership. Administration59(1): 23–38.
55.
RocheWK (2013) Human resource management and public service reform. Administration60(3): 211–218.
56.
RocheWK (2016) Workplaces. In: RocheWKO’ConnellPProtheroA (eds) Austerity and Recovery in Ireland: Europe’s Poster Child and the Great Recession. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
57.
RocheWKHigginsC (2016) Networked dispute resolution: The National Implementation Body in Irish industrial relations. In: LipskyDBAvgarACLamareJR (eds) Managing and Resolving Workplace Conflict (Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, Vol. 22). Bingley: Emerald, pp. 161–188.
58.
RocheWKTeagueP (2014) Effective but unappealing: Fifteen years of workplace partnership in Ireland. International Journal of Human Resource Management25(6): 781–794.
59.
RocheWKTeagueP (2015) Antecedents of concession bargaining in the Great Recession: Evidence from Ireland. Industrial Relations Journal46(5–6): 434–445.
60.
RocheWKTeaguePCoughlanAFahyM (2013) Recession at Work: HRM in the Irish Crisis. New York and Oxford: Routledge.
61.
RTE (2016) Interview with Danny McCoy, Director General, IBEC and Bernard Harbor, Communications Officer, Mandate, On the Issue of Public Pay Restoration. RTE News at One, 17November. Available at: www.rte.ie/radio1/podcast/podcast_newsatone.xml
62.
SanzPWelzCRodriguez ContrerasR (2016) Role of the Social Partners in the European Semester. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.
63.
SissonKMarginsonP (2002) Coordinated collective bargaining: A process for our times. British Journal of Industrial Relations40(2): 197–220.
64.
TeaguePDonagheyJ (2009) Why has Irish social partnership survived?British Journal of Industrial Relations47(1): 55–78.
65.
TraxlerF (1995) Farewell to labour market associations? Organized versus disorganized decentralization as a map for industrial relations. In: TraxlerFCrouchC (eds) Organized Industrial Relations in Europe: What Future?Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 3–19.
66.
TraxlerFBrandlBGlassnerV (2008) Pattern bargaining: An investigation into its agency and context and evidence. British Journal of Industrial Relations46(1): 33–58.
67.
TurnerTWalshM (2014) Economic crisis and the restructuring of wage setting mechanisms for vulnerable workers in Ireland. Economic and Social Review44(2): 197–219.
68.
Van GyesGSchultenT (eds) (2015) Wage Bargaining Under the New Economic Governance: Alternative Strategies for Inclusive Growth. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
69.
VisserJHayterSGammaranoR (2015) Trends in Collective Bargaining Coverage: Stability, Erosion or Decline. Geneva: International Labour Office.
70.
VossESchoenbergKRodriguez ContrerasR (2014) Collective Bargaining in Europe in the Twenty-First Century. Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions.
71.
WalshAM (2016) Bank workers’ union set to demand at least four per cent pay increase following new guidelines. Irish Independent, 19November.
72.
WalshK (2012) Wage bill change in Ireland during recession – How have employers reacted to the downturn. Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland41: 39–70.
