Social movement unionism emerged in the democratic struggle against authoritarian
states in South Africa and other developing countries and is increasingly promoted
to revive unions in advanced industrialized societies. The article tests a model of
the underlying conceptual foundations of support for social movement unionism using
survey data from interviews with members in South African auto and clothing plants.
Despite the demobilizing effects of the country's transition to democracy,
union democracy and member participation are found to persist on the shopfloor. The
article partially counters the ‘democratic rupture’ thesis as
worker control remains effective over annual industry-level bargaining, although
weaker over political and industrial policy issues.
Adler, G. (1994) ‘The Factory Belongs to All Who Work in it: Race,
Class and Collective Action in the South African Motor Industry,
1967–1986’, unpublished PhD dissertation, Columbia University,
New York.
2.
Adler, G.
and
E. Webster
(1995)
‘Challenging Transition Theory: The Labor Movement, Radical
Reform, and Transition to Democracy in South Africa’
, Politics and Society23(1):
75–100
.
3.
Ajzen, I.
(1988) Attitudes, Personality and Behavior.
Homewood, IL: Dorsey Press
.
4.
Anderson, J.
(1978)
‘A Comparative Analysis of Local Union Democracy’
, Industrial Relations17(3):
278–295
.
5.
Anderson, J.
(1979)
‘Local Union Participation: A Re-Examination’
, Industrial Relations18(1):
18–31
.
6.
Barling, J.
,
C. Fullagar
,
E. Kelloway
and
L. McElvie
(1992)
‘Union Loyalty and Strike Propensity’
, Journal of Social Psychology132(5):
581–590
.
7.
Bernickow, R.
(1988)
‘Unions Merge to Form Giant Garment Union’
, South African Labour Bulletin13(2):
74–83
.
8.
Bluen, S.
and
C. Donald
(1991)
‘The Nature and Measurement of In-Company Industrial Relations Climate’
, South African Journal of Psychology21(1):
12–20
.
9.
Boreham, P.
and
R. Hall
(1994)
‘Trade Union Strategy in Contemporary Capitalism: The
Microeconomic and Macroeconomic Implications of Political Unionism’
, Economic and Industrial Democracy15(3):
313–353
.
10.
Bramble, T.
(2003) ‘Social Movement Unionism since the Fall
of Apartheid: The Case of NUMSA on the East Rand’, pp.
187–204 in
T. Bramble
and
F. Barchiesi
(eds) Rethinking the Labour Movement in the ‘New South
Africa’.
Aldershot: Ashgate
.
11.
Buchholz, R.
(1978)
‘An Empirical Study of Contemporary Beliefs about Work in
American Society’
, Journal of Applied Psychology63(2):
219–227
.
12.
Buhlungu, S.
(2004)
‘The Building of the Democratic Tradition in South
Africa's Trade Unions after 1973’
, Democratization11(3):
133–158
.
13.
Byrne, B.
(1994) Structural Equation Modeling with EQS and EQS/Windows:
Basic Concepts, Applications, and Programming.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
14.
Byrne, B.
(1995) ‘One Application of Structural Equation
Modeling from Two Perspectives: Exploring the EQS and Lisrel
Strategies’, pp. 138–157 in
Rick H. Hoyle
(ed.) Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues, and
Applications.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
15.
Chacko, T.
(1985)
‘Member Participation in Union Activities: Perceptions of Union
Priorities, Performance and Satisfaction’
, Journal of Labor Research6(4):
363–373
.
16.
Child, J.
,
R. Loveridge
and
M. Warner
(1973)
‘Towards an Organizational Study of Trade Unions’
, Sociology7(1):
71–91
.
17.
COSATU
(2001)
‘COSATU CEC Political Discussion Paper’
, The Shopsteward10(4):
i–xiv
.
18.
Fields, M.
,
M. Masters
and
J. Thacker
(1987)
‘Union Commitment and Membership Support for Political Action: An
Exploratory Analysis’
, Journal of Labor Research8(2):
143–155
.
19.
Fine, R.
(1992)
‘Civil Society Theory and the Politics of Transition in South Africa’
, Review of African Political Economy55:
71–83
.
20.
Flanders, A.
(1970) Management and Unions: Theory and Reform in Industrial
Relations.
London: Faber and Faber
.
21.
Flood, P.
,
T. Turner
and
P. Willman
(1996)
‘Union Presence, Union Service and Membership Participation’
, British Journal of Industrial Relations34(3):
415–431
.
22.
Friedman, L.
and
R. Harvey
(1986)
‘Factors of Union Commitment: The Case for a Lower Dimensionality’
, Journal of Applied Psychology71(3):
371–376
.
23.
Fullagar, C.
(1986)
‘A Factor Analytic Study on the Validity of a Union Commitment Scale’
, Journal of Applied Psychology71(1):
129–136
.
24.
Fullagar, C.
and
J. Barling
(1987) ‘Toward a Model of Union
Commitment’, pp. 43–78 in
D. Lewin
,
D. Lipsky
and
D. Sockell
(eds) Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations 4.
Greenwich, CT: JAI Press
.
25.
Fullagar, C.
and
J. Barling
(1989)
‘A Longitudinal Test of a Model of the Antecedents and
Consequences of Union Loyalty’
, Journal of Applied Psychology74(2):
213–227
.
26.
Gallagher, D.
and
G. Strauss
(1991) ‘Union Membership Attitudes and
Participation’, pp. 139–174 in
G. Strauss
,
D. Gallagher
and
J. Fiorito
(eds) The State of the Unions.
Madison, WI: Industrial Relations Research Association
.
27.
Garonna, P.
and
E. Pisani
(1986) ‘Italian Unions in Transition: The Crisis
of Political Unionism’, in
R. Edwards
,
P. Garonna
and
F. Todling
(eds) Unions in Crisis and Beyond: Perspectives from Six
Countries.
Dover, MA: Auburn House
.
28.
GAWU (Garment and Allied Workers Union)
(1988)
‘Garment Workers Rush into Action’
, South African Labour Bulletin13(7):
84–92
.
29.
Ginsburg, D.
,
E. Webster
,
R. Southall
,
G. Wood
,
S. Buhlungu
,
J. Maree
,
J. Cherry
,
R. Haines
and
G. Klerck
(1995) Taking Democracy Seriously: Worker Expectations and
Parliamentary Democracy in South Africa.
Durban: Indicator Press
.
30.
Goodwyn, L.
(1978) The Populist Moment: A Short History of the Agrarian
Revolt in America.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
31.
Gordon, M.
,
J. Philpot
,
R. Burt
,
C. Thompson
and
W. Spiller
(1980)
‘Commitment to the Union: Development of a Measure and an
Examination of its Correlates’
, Journal of Applied Psychology Monograph65(4):
479–499
.
32.
Hirschsohn, P.
(1998a)
‘From Grassroots Democracy to National Mobilization: COSATU as a
Model of Social Movement Unionism’
, Economic and Industrial Democracy19(4):
633–666
.
33.
Hirschsohn, P. (1998b) ‘Social Movement Unionism in Transition:
COSATU, Shop-floor Democracy and Industrial Policy in South Africa's Auto
and Clothing Sectors’, unpublished PhD dissertation, Massachusetts
Institute of Technology.
34.
Hirschsohn, P.
,
S. Godfrey
and
J. Maree
(2000)
‘Industrial Policy-Making in the Auto, Textile and Clothing
Sectors: Labour's Strategic Ambivalence’
, Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa41:
55–88
.
35.
Hochner, A.
,
K. Koziara
and
S. Schmidt
(1980)
‘Thinking about Democracy and Participation in Unions’
, pp.
12–19
in Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Meeting of the Industrial
Relations Research Association. Madison, WI: IIRA.
36.
Hoyle, R.
and
A. Panter
(1995) ‘Writing About Structural Equation
Models’, pp. 158–176 in
R. Hoyle
(ed.) Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues, and
Applications.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
37.
Hoyman, M.
and
L. Stallworth
(1987)
‘Participation in Local Unions: A Comparison of Black and White Members’
, Industrial and Labor Relations Review40(3):
323–335
.
38.
Hu, L.
and
P. Bentler
(1995) ‘Evaluating Model
Fit’, pp. 76–99 in
R. Hoyle
(ed.) Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues, and
Applications.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
39.
Iverson, R.
and
S. Kuruvilla
(1995)
‘Antecedents of Union Loyalty: The Influence of Individual
Dispositions and Organizational Context’
, Journal of Organizational Behavior16:
557–582
.
40.
Jarley, P.
,
S. Kuruvilla
and
D. Casteel
(1990)
‘Member–Union Relations and Union Satisfaction’
, Industrial Relations29(1):
128–134
.
41.
Keet, D.
(1992)
‘Shop Stewards and Worker Control’
, South African Labour Bulletin16(5):
29–38
.
42.
Kelloway, E.
and
J. Barling
(1993)
‘Members' Participation in Local Union Activities:
Measurement, Prediction and Replication’
, Journal of Applied Psychology78(2):
262–279
.
43.
Kelloway, E.
,
V. Catano
and
R. Southwell
(1992)
‘The Construct Validity of Union Commitment: Development and
Dimensionality of a Shorter Scale’
, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology65:
197–212
.
44.
Kelly, J.
(1996) ‘Union Militancy and Social
Partnership’, pp. 77–109 in
P. Ackers
,
C. Smith
and
P. Smith
(eds) The New Workplace and Trade Unionism.
London: Routledge
.
45.
King, S. (1989) ‘An Investigation of the Relationship between Union
Loyalty, Industrial Relations Climate and Stress’, unpublished masters
dissertation, University of the Witwatersrand.
46.
Klandermans, B.
(1986)
‘Psychology and Trade Union Participation: Joining, Acting, Quitting’
, Journal of Occupational Psychology59:
189–204
.
47.
Kochan, T.
(1979) ‘How American Workers View Labor
Unions’, Monthly Labor Review April: 23–31.
48.
Kolchin, M.
and
T. Hyclak
(1984)
‘Participation in Union Activities: A Multivariate Analysis’
, Journal of Labor Research5(3):
255–262
.
49.
Labour Study Group
(1985)
‘Clothing Workers in Natal: A Reply to Gool’
, South African Labour Bulletin10(6):
35–42
.
50.
Lambert, R. (1988) ‘Political Unionism in South Africa: The South
African Congress of Trade Unions, 1955–1965’, unpublished PhD
dissertation, University of the Witwatersrand.
51.
Lipset, S.
,
M. Trow
and
J. Coleman
(1962) Union Democracy.
New York: Anchor Books
.
52.
McAdam, D.
(1982) Political Process and the Development of Black
Insurgency 1930–1970.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
53.
McLean Parks, J.
,
D. Gallagher
and
C. Fullagar
(1995)
‘Operationalizing the Outcomes of Union Commitment: The
Dimensionality of Participation’
, Journal of Organizational Behavior16(5):
33–55
.
54.
McShane, S.
(1986)
‘The Multidimensionality of Union Participation’
, Journal of Occupational Psychology59:
177–187
.
55.
Maller, J.
(1992) Conflict and Co-operation: Case Studies in Worker
Participation.
Johannesburg: Ravan Press
.
56.
Maree, J.
(1998)
‘The COSATU Participatory Democracy Tradition and South
Africa's New Parliament: Are They Reconcilable?’
, African Affairs97:
29–51
.
57.
Marie, B.
(1992)
‘COSATU Faces Crisis: “Quick Fix” Methods and
Organizational Contradictions’
, South African Labour Bulletin16(5):
20–26
.
58.
Martin, J.
(1986)
‘Predictors of Individual Propensity to Strike’
, Industrial and Labor Relations Review39(2):
214–227
.
59.
Michels, R.
(1962) Political Parties: A Sociological Study of the
Oligarchical Tendencies of Modern Democracies, trans. Eden and Cedar Paul.
New York: Free Press
.
60.
Moodie, T.D.
(1994) Going for Gold: Men, Mines and Migration.
Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press
.
61.
Mowday, R.
,
L. Porter
and
R. Steers
(1982) Employee–Organization Linkages: The
Psychology of Commitment, Absenteeism and Turnover.
New York: Academic Press
.
62.
Munck, R.
(1988) The New International Labor Studies: An
Introduction.
London: Zed Books
.
63.
Nicholson, N.
,
G. Ursell
and
J. Lubbock
(1981)
‘Membership Participation in a White-Collar Union’
, Industrial Relations20(2):
162–177
.
64.
Nissen, B.
(2003)
‘Alternative Strategic Directions for the US Labor Movement:
Recent Scholarship’
, Labor Studies Journal28(1):
133–155
.
65.
O'Donnell, G.
and
P. Schmitter
(1986) ‘Tentative Conclusions about Uncertain
Democracies’, pp. 48–56 in
G. O'Donnell
,
P. Schmitter
and
L. Whitehead
(eds) Transitions from Authoritarian Rule: Prospects for
Democracy.
Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press
.
66.
Oommen, T.
(1990) Protest and Change–Studies in Social
Movements.
New Delhi: Sage
.
67.
Patel, E.
(1993) Engine of Development? South Africa's
National Economic Forum.
Cape Town: Juta
.
68.
Pateman, C.
(1970) Participation and Democratic Theory.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
69.
Sabel, C.
(1981) ‘The Internal Politics of Trade
Unions’, pp. 209–244 in
S. Berger
(ed.) Organizing Interests in Western Europe: Pluralism, Corporatism and
the Transformation of Politics.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
70.
Saul, J.
and
S. Gelb
(1986) The Crisis in South Africa: Class Defense, Class
Revolution.
London: Zed Books
.
71.
Schmitter, P.
(1981) ‘Interest Intermediation and Regime
Governability in Contemporary Western Europe and North
America’, pp. 285–327 in
S. Berger
(ed.) Organizing Interests in Western Europe.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
72.
Scipes, K.
(1992)
‘Understanding the New Labor Movements in the “Third
World”: The Emergence of Social Movement Unionism’
, Critical Sociology19(2):
81–101
.
73.
Seidman, G.
(1994) Manufacturing Militancy: Workers' Movements
in Brazil and South Africa, 1970–85.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
74.
Sitas, A.
(1985)
‘Moral Formations and Struggles amongst Migrant Workers on the
East Rand’
, Labor, Capital and Society18(2):
372–401
.
75.
Streeck, W.
(1991) ‘On the Institutional Conditions of
Diversified Quality Production’, pp.
21–61 in
E. Matzner
and
W. Streeck
(eds) Beyond Keynesianism: The Socio Economics of Production and Full
Employment.
London: Edward Elgar
.
76.
Tannenbaum, A.
and
R. Kahn
(1958) Participation in Union Locals.
Evanston, IL: Row, Peterson
.
77.
Thacker, J.
,
M. Fields
and
L. Barclay
(1990)
‘Union Commitment: An Examination of Antecedent and Outcome Factors’
, Journal of Occupational Psychology63(1):
33–48
.
78.
Tilly, C.
(1984) ‘Social Movements and National
Politics’, pp. 297–317 in
C. Bright
and
S. Harding
(eds) Statemaking and Social Movements.
Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press
.
79.
Touraine, A.
(1987) ‘Unionism as a Social
Movement’, pp. 151–173 in
S. Lipset
(ed.) Unions in Transition.
San Francisco, CA: Institute for Contemporary
Studies Press
.
80.
Valenzuela, J.
(1989)
‘Labor Movements in Transitions to Democracy: A Framework for Analysis’
, Comparative Politics21(4):
445–471
.
81.
Van der Veen, G.
and
S. Goslinga
(1995) ‘Taking Part in Industrial Action:
General versus Specific Readiness to Engage’, pp.
273–288 in
L. Tetrick
and
J. Barling
(eds) Changing Employment Relations: Behavioral and Social
Perspectives.
Washington, DC: American Psychological Association
.
82.
Von Holdt, K.
(1992)
‘What is the Future of Labour?’
, South African Labour Bulletin16(8):
30–37
.
83.
Von Holdt, K.
(2002)
‘Social Movement Unionism: The Case of South Africa’
, Work, Employment and Society16(2):
283–304
.
84.
Von Holdt, K.
(2003) Transition from Below: Forging Trade Unionism and
Workplace Change in South Africa.
Pietermaritzburg: University of Natal Press
.
85.
Waterman, P. (1988) ‘ “Social Movement
Unionism”: A Brief Note’, unpublished manuscript, Institute of
Social Studies, The Hague.
86.
Waterman, P.
(1993)
‘Social-Movement Unionism: A New Model for a New World Order?’
, Review16(3):
245–278
.
87.
Webster, E.
(1988) ‘The Rise of Social Movement Unionism:
The Two Faces of the Black Trade Union Movement in South
Africa’, pp. 174–196 in
P. Frankel
,
N. Pines
and
M. Swilling
(eds) State, Resistance and Change in South Africa.
London: Croom Helm
.
88.
Webster, E.
(1998)
‘The Politics of Economic Reform: Trade Unions and
Democratization in South Africa’
, Journal of Contemporary African Studies16(1):
39–64
.
89.
Wood, G.
(2002)
‘Organizing Unionism and the Possibilities for Perpetuating a
Social Movement Role: Representivity, Politics, and the Congress of South
African Trade Unions’
, Labor Studies Journal26(4):
29–50
.
90.
Wood, G.
(2003)
‘Solidarity, Representativity and Accountability: The Origins,
State and Implications of Shopfloor Democracy within the Congress of South
African Trade Unions’
, The Journal of Industrial Relations45(3):
326–343
.
91.
Wood, G.
and
C. Psoulis
(2001)
‘Globalization, Democratization and Organized Labour in
Transitional Economies: The Case of COSATU’
, Work and Occupations28(3):
293–314
.
