How is office cleaning work organized? Is cleaning work undergoing changes similar to those in workplaces in other in dustries? This article answers these questions by investigating the building cleaning workplace in Toronto, Canada. It argues that the organization of work has shifted from a 'traditional zone cleaning'approach to one of 'gang cleaning'. The latter stresses the tool of 'sientific management'in the reorganization of the building cleaning labour process. The implication of this change for cleaners is discussed.
Agisar, Luis L.M. (1999) 'The "Dirt" on the Contract Building Cleaning Industry in Toronto- Work Reorganization and Cleanliness'unpublished PhD dissrtation, York University.
2.
Agusar
, Luis L.M. (2000) 'Restructuring and Employment Inritie The Cas of Building Cleaners', Canadian Journal of Urban Research9(1)- 64-93.
3.
Anderson
, Grace (1974) Noetworks of Contact The Portuguese and Toronto. Waterloo, OntarioWilfrid Launer University Press.
4.
Armstrong
, Pat (1994) 'The 90 Second Minute- Total Quality Management and Health Care', paper presented at the Conference on Labour and Social Policy The Experience of the 1980s and the 1990s. Stockholm, 16-19 May.
5.
Armstrong
, Pat and Hugh Armstrong (1990) Theorizing Women'Work. Toronto: Garamond Press.
6.
Beck
, Ulrich (1992) Risk Society. London: Sage.
7.
Berry
, Michael (1993) Protecting the Built Enviroment- Cleaningfor Health. Chapel Hill, NC: Triconmin 21st Press.
8.
BOMA (Building Owners and Managers Association international)
(1990) Office Building Cleaning Operaztiom in North America A Study of Cstodial Manazgement Practises and Cost. Washington, DCBOMA.
9.
Brown
, Richard (ad.) (1997a) The Changing Shape of Work, London: Macmillan.
10.
Brown
, Richard (1997b) 'Introduction: Wor and Employment in the 199Os', pp. 1-19 in Richard Brown (ed.) The Changing Shape of Work. London: Macmfllan.
11.
Burawoy
, nichael (1979) Manufacturing Cosent. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
12.
Chatigny, Cline, Julie Courie and Karen Messing (1994) Proyet ICMI UQAlM Mr l'entretzen sanitaire: Rapport et recommandazon. Montreal: CINBOISE, UQAM.
Crompton
, Rosemary (1997) Women and Work in Modern Britain. New York: Oxford University Press.
16.
Delbridge Rick
, Peter Tnbull and Barry Wilkinson (1992) 'Pushing Bak the Frontiers- Management Control and Work Intensification u-nder JITjTQM Factory Regimes', New Tchno logy, Work and Employment7(2): 97-106.
17.
Duffy
, Ann (1997)'The Part-Time Solution Toward Entrapment or Empowerment?t, pp. 166-155 in Ann Duffy, Daniel Glenday and Norene Pupo(eds) Good Jobs, Bad Jobs, No Jobs. Toronto: H arcourt Brace.
18.
Elger
, Tony (1991) 'Task Flexibility and the Intensification of Labour in UK Manufacturing in the 1980s', pp. 46-66 in Anna Pollert (ed.) Farewell to Flexibility?London: Blackwell.
19.
Fudge
, Judy (1997) Precariou Work and Families, Working Paper No. 15. Toronto: Centre for Research on Work and Society, York University.
20.
Hamper
, Ben (1986) Rivethead Tales from the Assembly fine. New YorkWarner Books.
21.
Harvey
, David (1989) The Condition of Postmodernity An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultfural Change. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
22.
Hobsbawm
, Eric (1994) Age of Extreme. London: Abacus.
23.
Hodson
, Randy (1995) 'Worker Resistance An Underdeveloped Concept in the Sociology of Work', Economic and lndsrial Democracy16(1) 79- 110.
24.
Hood
, Jane (1988) 'From Night to Day Timing and the Management of Custodial Work', Journal of Contemporary Ethnography17(1) 96-116.
25.
Her
, Wendy (1982) 'A Look at the Cleaning Industry', Canadian Woman Studies4(2) 70-71.
26.
Jenson
, Jane (1989)'The Talents of Women, the Skills of Men Flexible Sp ialization and Women', pp. 141-155 in S. Wood (ed.) The Tranformation of Work? Skill, Flexibility and the bour Proeess. London: Unwin Hyman.
27.
Kauss
, Jo dy (1998) o dular Mass Pro dution High Performance on the L ow Ro ad', Poitics and Soiety26(2) 273- 296.
28.
Knight
, Sheilagh (1996) Chid Lab our in Canada. Toronto: Christian Children's Fund of Canada and the International Working Group on Child Labour.
29.
Krahn
, Harvey J. and Graham S. Lowe (1998) Work, Indusry, and Canadian Society. Toronto: Nelson.
30.
Lado, Karen M. (1994) 'Immigrant Workers in the Cleaning Industry: The Central American Experience in Boston'MA thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
31.
Lash
, Scott and John Urry (1987) The End of Organized Capitalism. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press.
32.
Leach
, Belinda (1993) " Flexible" Work, Precarious Future= Some Lessons from the Canadian Clothing Industry', Canadian Renlew of Sociology and Anthropology30(1}) 64-82.
33.
Leonard
, Madeleine (1998) 'The Long-Term Unemployed, [n.formal Economic Activity and the "Underclass" in Belfast- Rejecting or Reinstating the Work Ethic', Internaztonal Journal of Urban and Regional Research22(1) 42-59.
34.
Leslie
, Deborah and David Butz (1998) G M Suicide: Flexibility, Space, and the Injured Body', Economic Geography74(4)- 360-378.
35.
Li
, Peter S. (1996) The Making of Post-War Canada. TorontoOxord University Press.
36.
Lipsig- Mummn
, Carla (1995) Lab ow s Challenges Canadian Unions in the New Work Order, Working Paper Series, No. 10. TorontoCentre for Research on Work and Society, York University.
37.
Lowe
, Donald (1995) The Body in Late -Captalist USA. Durham, NC: Duke University Press
38.
McBride
, Stephen and John Shields (1997) Dismantling a Nation: The Transition to Corporate Rule in Canada. Halifax, Nova Scotia: Fernwood Publishing.
39.
Macdonald
, Cameron Lynne and Carmen Sinanni (eds) (1996a) Working in the Service Society. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
40.
Macdonald
, Cameron Lynne and Carmen Sirianni (1996b) 'The Serice Society and the Changing Experience of Work', pp. 1-26 in Cameron LynneMacdonald and Carmen Sirianni (eds) Working in the Serviee Soeiety. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
41.
MacInnes
, John (1987) Thatcherism at Work. Milton KeynesOpen University Pres.
42.
Mandel
, Enest (1978) Late Capitalism. Londdo: Verso.
43.
Martinello
, Felice (1999) 'Mr. Hamis, Mr. Rae, and Union Activity in Ontario', paper presented at the Organizing and Reorganizing Unions Meet the Millenniium Confermee-nc McMhster T Iiiverity, Hamiltoi, Cn tari, 12-13 March.
44.
Messing, Karen, C. Haentjens and G. Domnol-Shaw (1992) 'LInvisible Necessaire: I'activite de nettoyage de toilettes sur le trains de voyageurs en gare', Le Travil huma In 55(4)- 353 70.
45.
Mines
, Richard and Jeffrey Avina (1992)'Immigrants and Labor Standards: The Case of California Janitors', in Jorge A. Bustamante, Clark W. Reynolds and Raul A. Hinojosa Ojeda (eds) US Mexico Relations Labor Market Interdependence. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
46.
Neal, Rusty (1987) 'Cleaning Up in Public- Women's Expariences as Subcontracted Cleaners', MA thesis, Ontaro Institute for Studies in Education.
47.
Neal, Rusty
and Virginia Neale (1987) '"As Long As You Know H ow To D o Homework" Portuguese-Canadian Women and the Office Cleaning Industry in Toronto', Resourcesfor Feminist Research16(1) 39-41.
48.
Palmer, Bryan
(1992) Working-Class Experience: Rethinking the History of Canadian Labour, 1800 1990. Toronto: Mc.Clelland and Stewart.
49.
Parker, Nike
and Jane Slaughter (1988) Choosing Sides Unizon and the Team Concept. Boston, MA: Labour Notes/South End Press.
50.
Phillips, Paul
and Enm Phillips (1993) Women and Work: Ineuazlity in the Labour Market. Toronto: James Lonimer.
51.
Piore, Michael
and Charles Sabel (1984) The Second Industrial Divide. New York: Basic Books.
52.
Pollert, Anna
(1988) 'Dismantling Flexibility', Capital and Clss34: 42-75.
53.
Pollert, Anna
(ed.) (1991) Farewell to Flexibility?London: Blackwell.
54.
Pupo, Norene
(1997) 'Always Working, Never Done- The Expansion of the Double Day' pp. 144-165 in Ann Duffy, Daniel Glenday and Norene Pupo (eds) Good Jobs, Bad Jobs, No Jobs. Toronto: MclCelland and Stewart.
55.
Rankin, Tom
(1990) New Forms of Work Organization: The Challenge for North American Unios. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
56.
Reitz, Jeffrey
(1990) 'Ethnic Concentration in Labour Markets and thein Implications for Ethnic Inequality, pp. 135-195 in Raymond Breton, Wsevolod Isajiw, Warren Kalbach and Jeffrey Reits (eds) Ethnic Identity and Equality Varieties of Experience in a Canadian City. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
57.
Rinehart, James W.
(1996) The Tyranny of Work Alienation and the Labour Process. Toronto: Harcourt Brace.
58.
Rinehart, James
, D. Robertson, Chris Huxley and Jeff Wareham (1994) 'Reunifying Conception and Execution of Work Under Japanese Production Management? A Canadian Case Study', in Tony Elger and Chris Smith (eds) Global Japanzation? The Trannational Transformation of the Labour Process. London: Routledge.
59.
Rinehart James
, Christopher Huxley and David Robertson (1997) Just another Car Factory Lean Production and its Discontents. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Pres.
60.
Robertson, David
, James Rinehart and Chris Huxley (1992) 'Team Concept and "Kaizen" Japanese Production Management in an Unionised Canadian Auto Plant', Studies in Political Economy3977-108.
61.
Russell, Bob
(1999) More with Less- Work Reorganization at the Canadian Mining Indstry. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
62.
Schenk, Christopher
(1997) 'New Organizing Strategies'Canadian DLmenmion31: 15-16.
63.
Sears, Alan
(1999) 'The "Lean" State and Capitalist Restmcturing- Towards a Theoretical Aceount', Studies in Political Economy5991-114.
64.
Shapiro-Peaarl Nina
. (1979) 'The Piece Rate: Class Struggle on the Shop Floor. Evidence from the Costume Jewelry Industry in Providence, Rhode Island' pp. 277-298 in Andrew Zimbalist (ed.) Cae Studies on the Labor Process. New York: Monthly Review Prets.
65.
Spiers, Rosemary
(1975) 'Office Cleaning: Big Busines or an "Evil Industry"Toronto Star 27 September: B3-B3.
66.
Stasiulis, Daiva
(1997) 'International Migration, Rights, and the Decline of " Actually Existing Liberal Democracy" ', New Commuity23(2) 197-214.
67.
Talbot, Gerard (1989) 'Une travailleuse. qui n'en peut plus', CLSC Nouvelles Sante an travail 8(3)- 1, 3.
68.
Teple, Gary
(1995) Globalization and the Deeline of Soeial Reform. Toronto/Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Garamond Press/Humanities Press.
69.
Tomaney, John
(1990) 'The Reaity of Workplae Flexibility', Capital and Class4029-60.
70.
Toronto Star
(1994) '"Sky Dome University" Teaches Staff the Ropes', 20 January: A1-A1.
71.
Toronto Star
(1996) 'Two Cleaners Beaten in Late-Night Attack', 17 October: A32-A32.
72.
Toronto Star
(1997) 'Photographer Caught in the Act' 20 February: J6-J6.
73.
Walby, Sylvia
(1989) 'Flexibility and the Changing Sexual Division of Labour' pp. 127-140 in S. Wood (ed.) The Tranformation of Work Skill, Flexibility and the Labour Process. London: Unwin Hyman.
74.
Waldinger, Roger
, C. Erickson, R. Milkman, D. Mitchell, A. Valenzuela, K. Wong and M. Zeitlin (1998) 'Helots No More- A Case Study of the Jstice for Janitors Campaign in Los Angeles', in Kate Bronfenbrenner, S. Friedman, R. Hurd, R. Oswald and R. Seeber (eds) Organizing to Win. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
75.
White, Jerry
(1990) Hospital Strike:R Women, Unions, and Public Sector Conflict. Toronto: Thompson Educational Publishing.
76.
Womack, James P.
, Daniel T. Jones and Daniel Roos (1991) The Machine that Changed the World. New York: HarperPerennial.
