Should parents be encouraged to teach their hearing infants to communicate using
gestural signs? Does signing in infancy advance child behaviour and development as
claimed by many commercially available products for parents? To answer these
questions, a review was undertaken to evaluate currently available research studies
that examined the effectiveness of prelingual signing for normally developing,
hearing infants. Databases, reference lists and the Internet were searched for
relevant documents using a pre-determined search protocol. Seventeen reports met the
review’s inclusion criteria and were retrieved and evaluated. The review
failed to support claims that signing facilitates language development, due to
insufficiencies in scientific methods and to equivocal results.
Abrahamson, A.
,
Cavallo, M. M.
&
McCluer, J. A.
(1985).
Is the sign advantage a robust phenomenon? From gesture to language in two modalities
. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 31,
177–209
.
2.
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Goodwyn, S. W.
(1988).
Symbolic gesturing in language development: A case study
. Human Development, 28,
40–49
.
3.
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Goodwyn, S. W.
(1990).
Sign language in babies: The significance of symbolic gesturing for
understanding language development
. Annals of Child Development, 7,
1–42
.
4.
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Goodwyn, S. W.
(2000).
The longterm impact of symbolic gesturing during infancy on IQ at age 8
. Paper presented at International Conference on Infant
Studies, Brighton, UK.
5.
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Goodwyn, S. W.
(2003). The Baby Signs Research. Retrieved 8 January
2005 from http://www.babysigns.com/index.cfm/fuseaction/institute.research_extensive/extensive_research.cfm
6.
Acredolo, L. P.
,
Goodwyn, S. W.
,
Horobin, K. D.
&
Emmons, Y. D.
(1999). The signs and sounds of early language
development. In
L. Balter
and
C. Tamis-LeMonda
(Eds), Child Psychology: A Handbook of Contemporary Issues (pp.
116–139).
New York: Psychology Press
.
7.
Baby BumbleBee
(2003). BeeSmart Baby Videos. Retrieved 4 August 2003
from http://www.babybumblebee.com/store/asl.cfm.
8.
Bates, E.
,
O’Connell, B.
&
Shore, C.
(1987). Language and communication in infancy. In
J. D. Osofsky
(Ed.), Handbook of Infant Development (2nd ed., pp.
149–203).
New York: Wiley
.
9.
Bloom, K.
(1990). Selectivity and early vocalization. In
J. T. Enns
(Ed.), The Development of Attention: Research and Theory (pp.
121–136).
Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publications
.
10.
Bonvillian, J. D.
,
Orlansky, M. D.
&
Novack, L. L.
(1983a).
Developmental milestones: Sign language acquisition and motor development
. Child Development, 54,
1435–1445
.
11.
Bonvillian, J. D.
,
Orlansky, M. D.
,
Novack, L. L.
&
Folven, R. J.
(1983b). Early sign language acquisition and cognitive
development. In
D. Rogers
&
J. A. Sloboda
(Eds), The Acquisition of Symbolic Symbols (pp.
207–214).
Chicago: Plenum
.
12.
Capirci, O.
,
Montanari, S.
&
Volterra, V.
(1998). Gestures, signs, and words in early language
development. In
J. M. E.Iverson
&
S. E. Goldin-Meadow
(Eds), The Nature and Functions of Gesture in Children’s
Communication (pp. 45–59).
Rome: Italian National Council of Research,
Institute of Psychology
.
13.
Daniels, M.
(1993).
ASL as a factor in acquiring English
. Sign Language Studies, 78,
23–29
.
14.
Dunn, L. M.
,
Dunn, L. M.
,
Robertson, G. J.
&
Eisenberg, J. L.
(1991). Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test –
Revised Edition.
Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Company
.
15.
Folven, R. J. (1988). The transition from nonreferential to referential
language in children acquiring American Sign Language. Unpublished doctoral
dissertation, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA.
16.
Folven, R. J.
,
Bonvillian, J. D.
&
Orlansky, M. D.
(1984).
Communicative gestures and early sign language acquisition
. First Language, 5,
129–143
.
17.
Garcia, J.
(2003). Sign 2 Me: About our Program. Retrieved 1
August 2003 from http://www.sign2me.com/about.htm
18.
Goodwyn, S. W.
&
Acredolo, L. P.
(1993).
Symbolic gesture versus word: Is there a modality advantage for onset of
symbol use?Child Development, 64,
688–701
.
19.
Goodwyn, S. W.
&
Acredolo, L. P.
(1998).
Encouraging symbolic gestures: A new perspective on the relationship
between gesture and speech
. New Directions for Child Development, 79,
61–73
.
20.
Goodwyn, S. W.
,
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Brown, C. A.
(2000).
Impact of symbolic gesturing on early language development
. Journal of Nonverbal Behavior, 24,
81–103
.
21.
Gregory, S.
(1994). The first signs and words: Language development in
a bilingual environment. In
J. Kyle
(Ed.), Growing Up in Sign and Word.
Bristol: Centre for Deaf Studies
.
22.
Hart, B.
&
Risley, T.
(1995). Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of
Young American Children.
Baltimore, MD: Brooks Publishing Company
.
23.
Holmes, K. M.
&
Holmes, D. W.
(1980).
Signed and spoken language development in a hearing child of hearing parents
. Sign Language Studies, 28,
239–254
.
24.
Holowka, S.
,
Brosseau-Lapre, F.
&
Petitto, L. A.
(2002).
Semantic and conceptual knowledge underlying bilingual babies’
first signs and words
. Language Learning, 52,
205–262
.
25.
ISI ResearchSoft
(2001). Reference Manager® Professional Edition
Version 10 for Windows [computer software].
Thomson Scientific, USA
.
26.
Moore, B.
,
Acredolo, L. P.
&
Goodwyn, S. W.
(2001).
Symbolic gesturing and joint attention: Partners in facilitating verbal development
. Paper presented at April meeting of the Society for Research in
Child Development.
27.
Morales, M.
,
Mundy, P.
,
Delgado, C. E. F.
,
Yale, M.
,
Messinger, D.
,
Neal, R.
&
Schwartz, H. K.
(2000).
Responding to joint attention across the 6- to 24-month age period and
early language acquisition
. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 21,
283–298
.
28.
Orlansky, M. D.
&
Bonvillian, J. D.
(1984).
The role of iconicity in early sign language acquisition
. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 49,
287–292
.
29.
Orlansky, M. D.
&
Bonvillian, J. D.
(1988). Early sign language acquisition. In
M. D. Smith
&
J. L. Locke
(Eds), The Emergent Lexicon: The Child’s Development of a
Linguis Vocabulary (pp. 263–292).
San Diego: Academic Press Inc.
30.
Petitto, L. A.
(1994).
Are signed languages “real” languages? Evidence from
American Sign Language and Langue des Signes Quebecoise
. Signpost (International Quarterly of the Sign Linguistics
Association), 7,
1–10
31.
Petitto, L. A.
(2000). On the biological foundations of human
language. In
K. Emmorey
&
H. Lane
(Eds), The Signs of Language Revisited: An Anthology in Honor of Ursula
Bellugi and Edward Klima (pp. 447–471).
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
.
32.
Petitto, L. A.
(2003). Laura-Ann Petitto Homepage. Retrieved 1 August
2003 from http://www.dartmouth.edu/%7Elpetitto/
33.
Petitto, L. A.
,
Katerelos, M.
,
Levy, B. G.
,
Gauna, K.
,
Tetreault, K.
&
Ferraro, V.
(2001).
Bilingual signed and spoken language acquisition from birth: Implications
for the mechanisms underlying early bilingual language acquisition
. Journal of Child Language, 28,
453–496
.
34.
Wetherby, A. M.
,
Warren, S. F.
&
Reichle, J.
(Eds) (1998). Transitions in Prelinguistic
Communication.
Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes
.
