The relationship between mental state verbs (MSVs) and sentential complements
(S-comps) was investigated in language samples of 40 4-year-old children. MSVs were
coded by function (cognitive, sensory, or pragmatic), complement (simple, simple+,
or S-comp) and expression of certainty. Children produced an average of 14 total and
5 different MSVs; approximately equal numbers of MSVs had cognitive and pragmatic
functions. MSVs referring to cognitive states were more likely to occur with S-comps
than MSVs used as pragmatic markers; S-comps were more likely to occur with
uncertain than certain MSVs. Utterances containing MSVs were longer than utterances
with other matrix verbs, but MSVs and S-comps were strongly correlated after
adjusting for utterance length. Finally, S-comps occurred more often with MSVs than
with other matrix verbs after excluding the predominant MSV (want to) and the
predominant other matrix verb (going to) from analysis. Implications for using MSVs
to investigate the relationship among semantics, cognition and syntax are discussed.
Abbeduto, L.
&
Rosenberg, S.
(1985).
Children’s knowledge of the presuppositions of know and other
cognitive verbs
. Journal of Child Language, 12,
621-641
.
2.
Bloom, L.
,
Rispoli, M.
,
Gartner, B.
&
Hafitz, J.
(1989).
Acquisition of complementation
. Journal of Child Language, 16,
101-120
.
3.
Booth, J. R.
,
Hall, W. S.
,
Robison, G. C.
&
Kim, S. Y.
(1997).
Acquisition of the mental state verb know by 2-to 5-year-old children
. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 26
(6),
581-603
.
4.
Borsley, R. D.
(1999). Syntactic theory: A unified approach (2nd
ed.).
London: Arnold
.
5.
DePoot, C. J.
&
Semin, G. R.
(1995).
Pick your verbs with care when you formulate a question
. Journal of Language and Social Psychology,
14(4),
351-368
.
6.
Diessel, H.
&
Tomasello, M.
(2001).
The acquisition of finite complement clauses in English: A corpus-based analysis
. Cognitive Linguistics, 12 (2),
1-45
.
7.
Dollaghan, C. D.
,
Balason, D.
,
Nash, T. C.
,
Leavy, H.
,
Nixon, S.
,
Smolky, B.
&
Starmer, H.
(2000).
Verb lexicons of three-year-old children
. Poster session presented at the annual meeting of the American
Speech-Language-Hearing Association, Washington, DC (November).
8.
Dollaghan, C. A.
,
Campbell, T. F.
,
Paradise, J. L.
,
Feldman, H. M.
,
Janosky, J. E.
,
Pitcairn, D. N.
&
Kurs-Lasky, M.
(1999).
Maternal education and measures of early speech and language
. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research,
42,
1432-1443
.
9.
Dunn, L. M.
&
Dunn, L. M.
(1981). Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test: Form M
(rev. ed.).
Circle Pines, MN: AGS
.
10.
Field, M.
(1997).
The role of factive predicates in the indexicalization of stance: A
discourse perspective
. Journal of Pragmatics, 27,
799-814
.
11.
Fisher, C.
,
Gleitman, H.
&
Gleitman, R.
(1991).
On the semantic content of subcategorization frames
. Cognitive Psychology, 23,
331-392
.
12.
Gleitman, L.
(1990).
The structural sources of verb meanings
. Language Acquisition, 1 (1),
3-55
.
13.
Hall, W. S.
&
Nagy, W. E.
(1987).
The semantic-pragmatic distinction in the investigation of mental state
words: The role of the situation
. Discourse Processes, 10,
169-180
.
14.
Johnson, C. N.
&
Maratsos, M. P.
(1977).
Early comprehension of mental verbs: Think and know
. Child Development, 48,
1743-1747
.
15.
Kamawar, D.
&
Olson, D. R.
(1999).
Children’s representational theory of language: The problem of
opaque contexts
. Cognitive Development, 14,
531-548
.
16.
Lowry, R.
(2000). VassarStats web site for statistical
computation. Retrieved from http://faculty.vassar.edu/lowry/VassarStats.html.
17.
MacWhinney, B.
(2000). The CHILDES database: Tools for analyzing talk: Vol.
2: The database (3rd ed.).
Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum
.
18.
McCarthy, D.
(1972). McCarthy Scales of Children’s
Abilities.
New York, NY: Psychological Corp
.
19.
Miller, J. F.
(1981). Assessing Language Production in Children.
Baltimore, MD: University Park Press
.
20.
Miller, J. F.
&
Chapman, R. S.
(1999). Systematic analysis of language transcripts (Version
6.0) [Computer software]. Programmed by A. Nockerts.
Madison, WI: Language Analysis Lab, University
of Wisconsin
.
21.
Montgomery, D. E.
(1997).
Wittgenstein’s private language argument and children’s
understanding of the mind
. Developmental Review, 17,
291-320
.
22.
Moore, C.
,
Bryant, D.
&
Furrow, D.
(1989).
Mental terms and the development of certainty
. Child Development, 60,
167-171
.
23.
Naigles, L. R.
(2000). Manipulating the input: Studies in mental verb
acquisition. In
B. Landau
,
J. Sabini
,
J. Jonides
&
E. Newport
(Eds), Perception, cognition, and language: Essays in honor of Henry and
Lila Gleitman (pp. 245-274).
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
24.
Nixon, S. M.
&
Dollaghan, C.
(2001).
Mental state verb use by children with high and low MLUs
. Poster session presented at the annual meeting of the Symposium
on Research in Child Language Disorders (June).
25.
Patterson, J. L.
(2001).
Development of constructed phrases in a child with language impairment
. Clinical Linguistics and Phonetics, 14
(7),
545-556
.
26.
Quirk, R.
&
Greenbaum, S.
(1973). A University Grammar of English.
London: Longman
.
27.
Radford, A.
(1988). Transformational grammar: A first course.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
28.
Schwanenflugel, P. J.
,
Fabricius, W. V.
,
Noyes, C. R.
,
Bigler, K. D.
&
Alexander, J. M.
(1994).
The organization of mental verbs and folk theories of knowing
. Journal of Memory and Language, 33,
376-395
.
29.
Semin, G. R.
,
Rubini, M.
&
Fiedler, K.
(1995).
The answer is in the question: The effect of verb causality on locus of explanation
. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 21
(8),
834-841
.
30.
Shatz, M.
,
Wellman, H. M.
&
Silber, S.
(1983).
The acquisition of mental verbs: A systematic investigation of the first
reference to mental state
. Cognition, 14,
301-321
.
31.
Tardif, T.
&
Wellman, H. M.
(2000).
Acquisition of mental state language in Mandarin- and Cantonese-speaking children
. Developmental Psychology, 36 (1),
25-43
.
32.
Wellman, H. M.
&
Estes, D.
(1987).
Children’s early use of mental verbs and what they mean
. Discourse Processes, 10,
141-156
.
33.
White, K.
&
Dungan, S.
(1997).
Linguistic competence and mental state attribution in children
. Mind Matters, 1 (1). Retrieved 17 June
2004, from http://www.rso.cornell.edu/mbb/journal/white.html.
34.
Wray, A.
&
Perkins, M. R.
(2000).
The functions of formulaic language: An integrated model
. Language and Communication, 20,
1-28
.
