There is a long history of dissonance between the (so-called) Old and New Consensuses with regard to the early Christians’ socio-economic status. The composition of the Thessalonian congregation, however, has been barely explored. Not only has some valuable evidence in 1 Thessalonians been neglected or underplayed, but also the Thessalonians’ socio-economic status has been deemed the same as that of the Corinthians or other Pauline Christians. In this regard, this article explores clues in the Pauline letters for the membership of the Thessalonian church in light of the Roman economy, while keeping open the possibility of its difference from other Pauline communities. It concludes that the Thessalonian church was a fairly homogeneous community of free/freed casual workers who lived around subsistence level (mostly PS6 and partly PS5 or PS7).
AscoughRichard S.2010 ‘Of Memories and Meals: Greco-Roman Associations and the Early Jesus-Group at Thessalonike’, in NasrallahLaura S.BakirtzēsCh.FriesenSteven J. (eds.), From Roman to Early Christian Thessalonikē: Studies in Religion and Archaeology (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press): 49-68.
5.
AubertJ.-J.2001 ‘The Fourth Factors: Managing Non-agricultural Production in the Roman World’, in MattinglyD.J.SalmonJ. (eds.), Economies beyond Agriculture in the Classical World (London: Routledge): 90-112.
6.
BammerA.2010 ‘An Approach to the Papyrological Understanding of Paul’s Laboring “Night and Day” (1 Thess. 2.9)’, in GagosT. (ed.), Proceedings of the 25th International Congress of Papyrology, Ann Arbor 2007 (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Library): 47-52.
7.
BarclayJohn M.G.1992 ‘Thessalonica and Corinth: Social Contrasts in Pauline Christianity’, JSNT47: 49-74.
8.
BarclayJohn M.G.1993 ‘Conflict in Thessalonica’, CBQ55: 512-30.
9.
BarclayJohn M.G.2004 ‘Poverty in Pauline Studies: A Response to Steven Friesen’, JSNT26: 363-66.
10.
BestErnest1972A Commentary on the First and Second Epistles to the Thessalonians (London: Black).
11.
BradleyKeith R.1991Discovering the Roman Family (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
12.
BradleyKeith R.1994Slavery and Society at Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
13.
BroekaertWimZuiderhoekArjan2013 ‘Industries and Services’, in ErdkampPaul (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 317-35.
14.
BrookinsTimothy A.2017 ‘Economic Profiling of Early Christian Communities’, in BlantonT.R.IVPickettR. (eds.), Paul and Economics (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press): 57-87.
15.
BruceF.F.19821 and 2 Thessalonian (Waco, TX: Word).
16.
BruntP.A.1980 ‘Free Labour and Public Works at Rome’, JRS70: 81-100.
17.
BurfordAlison1988 ‘Crafts and Craftsmen’, in GrantM.KitzingerR. (eds.), Civilization of the Ancient Mediterranean: Greece and Rome (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons): 367-88.
18.
DeissmannAdolf1908Das Urchristentum und die unteren Schichten (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht).
19.
DeissmannAdolf1910Light from the Ancient East: The New Testament Illustrated by Recently Discovered Texts of the Graeco-Roman World (London: Hodder & Stoughton).
20.
DeissmannAdolf1957Paul: A Study in Social and Religious History (2nd edn; New York: Harper & Brothers).
21.
DeLaineJanet1997The Baths of Caracalla: A Study in the Design, Construction, and Economics of Large-scale Building Projects in Imperial Rome (Portsmouth: Journal of Roman Archaeology).
22.
de VosCraig S.1999Church and Community Conflicts: The Relationships of the Thessalonian, Corinthian, and Philippian Churches with their Wider Civic Communities (Atlanta: Scholars Press).
23.
EdsonCharles1948 ‘Cults of Thessalonica (Macedonica III)’, HTR41: 153-204.
24.
ErdkampPaul (ed.) 2005The Grain Market in the Roman Empire: A Social, Political and Economic Study (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
25.
ErdkampPaul (ed.) 2013The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
26.
FlohrMiko2012a The World of the Fullo: Work, Economy, and Society in Roman Italy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
27.
FlohrMiko2012b ‘Working and Living under One Roof: Workshops in Pompeian Atrium Houses’, in AnguissolaA. (ed.), Privata Luxuria – Towards an Archaeology of Intimacy: Pompeii and Beyond (Munich: UTZ): 51-72.
28.
FriesenSteven J.2004 ‘Poverty in Pauline Studies: Beyond the So-called New Testament Consensus’, JSNT26: 323-61.
GarnseyPeter1980 ‘Non-Slave Labour in the Roman Word’, in Non-Slave Labour in the Greco-Roman World (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
31.
GarnseyPeter1988Famine and Food Supply in the Graeco-Roman World: Responses to Risk and Crisis (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
32.
GoodmanPenelope2016 ‘Working Together: Clusters of Artisans in the Roman City’, in WilsonA.I.FlohrM. (eds.), Urban Craftsmen and Traders in the Roman World (Oxford: Oxford University Press): 301-33.
33.
HarlandPhilip2003Associations, Synagogues, and Congregations: Claiming a Place in Ancient Mediterranean Society (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press).
34.
Harry-McCoyDaniel E.2012Artemidorus’ Oneirocritica: Text, Translation, and Commentary (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
35.
HawkinsCameron2012 ‘Manufacturing’, in ScheidelW. (ed.), Cambridge Companion to the Roman Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 175-94.
36.
HawkinsCameron2016Roman Artisans and the Urban Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
37.
HillJ.L.1990 ‘Establishing the Church in Thessalonica’ (Unpublished PhD thesis, Duke University).
38.
HockRonald F.1980The Social Context of Paul’s Ministry: Tentmaking and Apostleship (Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
39.
HolleranClaire2011 ‘Migration and the Urban Economy of Rome’, in HolleranC.PudseyA. (eds.), Demography and the Graeco-Roman World: New Insights and Approaches (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 155-80.
40.
HolleranClaire2012Shopping in Ancient Rome: The Retail Trade in the Late Republic and the Principate (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
41.
HolmbergBengt1990Sociology and the New Testament (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press).
42.
HuebnerSabine R.2013The Family in Roman Egypt: A Comparative Approach to Intergenerational Solidarity and Conflict (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
JoshelSandra R.1992Work, Identity, and Legal Status at Rome: A Study of the Occupational Inscriptions (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press).
45.
JudgeEdwin A.1960The Social Pattern of the Christian Groups in the First Century: Some Prolegomena to the Study of New Testament Ideas of Social Obligation (London: Tyndale).
46.
KautskyKarl1908Der Ursprung des Christentums: Eine historische Untersuchung (Stuttgart: J.H.W. Dietz).
47.
KehoeDennis2012 ‘Contract Labor’, in ScheidelW. (ed.), Cambridge Companion to the Roman Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 114-30.
48.
KloppenborgJohn S.2019Christ’s Associations: Connecting and Belonging in the Ancient City (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
LiuJ.2013 ‘Professional Associations’, in ErdkampP. (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 352-68.
51.
LongeneckerBruce W.2009 ‘Socio-Economic Profiling of the First Urban Christians’, in StillToddHorrellDavid (eds.), After the First Urban Christians: The Socio-Historical Study of Pauline Christianity Twenty-Five Years Later (London: Continuum): 36-59.
52.
LongeneckerBruce W.2010Remember the Poor: Paul, Poverty, and the Greco-Roman World (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans).
53.
MacMahonA.PriceJ.2005Roman Working Lives and Urban Living (Oxford: Oxbow Books).
54.
MalherbeAbraham J.1977Social Aspects of Early Christianity (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press).
55.
MalherbeAbraham J.1987Paul and the Thessalonians: The Philosophic Tradition of Pastoral Care (Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
56.
MalherbeAbraham J.2000The Letters to the Thessalonians (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
57.
MarxsenWilli1979Der erste Brief an die Thessalonicher (Zürich: Theologischer Verlag).
58.
MattinglyD.J.SalmonJ. (eds.) 2001Economies beyond Agriculture in the Classical World (London: Routledge).
59.
MeeksWayne A.2003The First Urban Christians: The Social World of the Apostle Paul (2nd edn; New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
60.
MeggittJustin J.1998Paul, Poverty and Survival (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1998).
61.
MeggittJustin J.2001 ‘Response to Martin and Theissen’, JSNT84: 85-94.
62.
MíguezNéstor O. 2012The Practice of Hope: Ideology and Intention in First Thessalonians (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press).
63.
MouritsenHenrik2011The Freedman in the Roman World (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
64.
NigdelisPantelis M.2010 ‘Voluntary Associations in Roman Thessalonikē: in Search of Identity and Support in a Cosmopolitan Society’, in NasrallahLaura S.BakirtzēsCh.FriesenSteven J. (eds.), From Roman to Early Christian Thessalonikē: Studies in Religion and Archaeology (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press): 13-47.
65.
OakesPeter2001Philippians: From People to Letter (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
66.
OakesPeter2004 ‘Constructing Poverty Scales for Graeco-Roman Society: A Response to Steven Friesen’s “Poverty in Pauline Studies”’, JSNT26.3: 367-71.
67.
OakesPeter2009Reading Romans in Pompeii: Paul’s Letter at Ground Level (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press).
68.
OsgoodJosiah2011 ‘Making Romans in the Family’, in PeachinMichael (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Social Relations in the Roman World (Oxford: Oxford University Press): 69-83.
69.
PomeroyArthur J.1991 ‘Status and Status-Concern in the Greco-Roman Dream-Books’, Ancient Society22: 51-74.
70.
RathboneDominic1991Economic Rationalism and Rural Society in Third-century A.D. Egypt: The Heroninos Archive and the Appianus Estate (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
71.
RigauxBeda1956Saint Paul (Paris: Gabalda).
72.
RussellR.1998 ‘The Idle in 2 Thess. 3.6-12: An Eschatological or a Social Problem?’, NTS34: 105-19.
73.
SallerRichard P.2011 ‘The Roman Family as Productive Unit’, in RawsonBeryl (ed.), A Companion to Families in the Greek and Roman Worlds (Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell): 116-28.
74.
ScheidelWalter2005 ‘A Model of Real Income Growth in Roman Italy’, Historia56: 322-46.
75.
ScheidelWalter (ed.) 2012Cambridge Companion to the Roman Economy (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
76.
ScheidelWalterFriesenSteve J.2009 ‘The Size of the Economy and the Distribution of Income in the Roman Empire’, JRS99: 61-91.
77.
SchellenbergRyan S.2018 ‘Subsistence, Swapping, and Paul’s Rhetoric of Generosity’, JBL137: 215-34.
78.
SchmithalsWalter1972Paul and the Gnostics (Nashville: Abingdon Press).
79.
SchöllgenG.1988 ‘Was wissen wir über die Sozialstruktur der paulinischen Gemeinden?’, NTS34: 71-82.
80.
ScottJames C.1976The Moral Economy of the Peasants: Rebellion and Subsistence in Southeast Asia (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
81.
StowersStanley K.1984 ‘Social Status, Public Speaking and Private Teaching: The Circumstances of Paul’s Preaching Activity’, NovT26.1: 59-82.
82.
TheissenGerd1982The Social Setting of Pauline Christianity: Essays on Corinth (Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
83.
TheissenGerd1993Social Reality and the Early Christians: Theology, Ethics and the World of the New Testament (Edinburgh: T&T Clark).
84.
TheissenGerd2001 ‘The Social Structure of Pauline Communities: Some Critical Remarks on J.J. Meggitt, Paul, Poverty and Survival’, JSNT84: 65-84.
85.
TheissenGerd2003 ‘Social Conflicts in the Corinthian Community: Further Remarks on J.J. Meggitt, Paul, Poverty and Survival’, JSNT25.3: 371-91.
86.
TonerJerry2009Popular Culture in Ancient Rome (Cambridge: Polity).
87.
TreggiariSusan M.1979 ‘Lower Class Women in the Roman Economy’, Florilegium1: 65-86.
88.
TreggiariSusan M.1980 ‘Urban Labour in Rome: Mercennarii and Tabernarii’, in GarnseyP. (ed.), Non-Slave Labour in the Greco-Roman World (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 48-64.
89.
van NijfOnno M.1997The Civic World of Professional Associations in the Roman East (Amsterdam: Gieben).
90.
VenticinquePhilip F.2009 ‘Common Causes: Guilds, Craftsmen and Merchants in the Economy and Society of Roman and Late Roman Egypt’ (Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Chicago)
91.
VenticinquePhilip F.2010 ‘Family Affairs: Guild Regulations and Family Relationships in Roman Egypt’, GRBS50: 273-94.
WhiteJoel R.2014 ‘“Peace” and “Security” (1 Thess. 5.3): Roman Ideology and Greek Aspiration’, NTS60: 499-510.
98.
WilsonA.I.FlohrM. (eds.) 2016Urban Craftsmen and Traders in the Roman World (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
99.
WinterBruce W.1994Seek the Welfare of the City: Christians as Benefactors and Citizens (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans).
100.
Zelnick-AbramovitzRachel2005Not Wholly Free: The Concept of Manumission and the Status of Manumitted Slaves in the Ancient Greek World (Leiden: Brill).
