The failure of regional refugee protection and responsibility sharing: Policy neglect in the EU and ASEAN

Abstract

The concurrent refugee crises affecting the European Union (EU) and the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) brought to the fore long-standing issues regarding regional cooperation on refugee protection and responsibility sharing. This article argues that these crises are a culmination of years of policy neglect. By comparing the EU and ASEAN, this article demonstrates the weaknesses of regional bodies in responding to refugee challenges, regardless of the level of institutionalization of refugee norms and practices. In both instances, procedural norms privileging member state interests and consensus have hindered the development of durable regional refugee policies.

Keywords

refugees European Union ASEAN crisis migration

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alink

Boin

T’Hart

(2001) Institutional crises and reforms in policy sectors: The case of asylum policy in Europe. Journal of European Public Policy 8(2): 286–306.

Al Jazeera (2015a) EU asylum rules rendered ‘obsolete’ by refugee crisis, says Merkel. Al Jazeera, 7 October. Available at: http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2015/10/7/eu-asylum-rules-obsolete-merkel-refugees.html.

Al Jazeera (2015b) Indonesia to ‘turn back Rohingya boats’. Al Jazeera 13 May. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/05/150512045951738.html.

Al Jazeera (2016) Malaysia: Myanmar pursues ethnic cleansing of Rohingya. Al Jazeera , 3 December. Available at. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/12/myanmar-ethnic-cleansing-rohingya-161203104609449.html.

Allison

(2015) The EU, ASEAN and Interregionalism. Regionalism Support and Norm Diffusion between the EU and ASEAN, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Allison-Reumann L and Murray P (2017) Should the EU be considered a model for ASEAN?. Pursuit, 22 June. Available at: https://pursuit.unimelb.edu.au/articles/should-the-eu-be-considered-a-model-for-asean.

Amnesty International (2015a) Europe’s borderlands: Violations against refugees and migrants in Macedonia, Serbia and Hungary. Report, Amnesty International, UK, July.

Amnesty International (2015b) Fear and fences: Europe’s approach to keeping refugees at bay. Report Index: EUR 03/2544/2015, Amnesty International, UK, November.

Amnesty International (2016) Trapped in Greece: An avoidable refugee crisis. Report Index: EUR 25/3778/2016, Amnesty International, UK, April.

10.

Associated Press (2015) Malaysia says it will turn away migrants stranded at sea unless boats are sinking. The Guardian, 13 May. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/may/12/malaysia-migrants-boats-rohingya-bangladesh-myanmar-burma.

11.

Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) (2007) Charter of the Association of Southeast Asia Nations. Available at: http://asean.org/storage/2017/07/8.-July-2017-The-ASEAN-Charter-21th-Reprint-with-Updated-Annex-1.pdf.

12.

Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) (2012) ASEAN human rights declaration. Available at: http://asean.org/asean-human-rights-declaration/.

13.

Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) (2018) Press statement by the chairman of the ASEAN foreign ministers’ retreat, 6 February, Singapore. Available at: https://asean.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Press-Statement-by-the-Chairman-of-the-ASEAN-Foreign-Ministers-Retreat-clean.pdf.

14.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) (2015) Malaysia to follow Indonesia in turning back migrant boats; thousands may face starvation at sea. ABC, 13 May. Available at: http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015–05–13/malaysia-to-turn-back-migrant-boats/6466726.

15.

Bast

(2016) Deepening supranational integration: Interstate solidarity in EU migration law. European Public Law 22(2): 289–304.

16.

Belford A and Munawir R (2015) Migrants in ‘maritime ping-pong’ as Asian nations turn them back. Reuters, 16 May. Available at: https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-asia-migrants/migrants-in-maritime-ping-pong-as-asian-nations-turn-them-back-idUKKBN0O105O20150516.

17.

Berkofksy A (2005) Comparing EU and Asia integration processes: The EU as a role model for Asia?. European Policy Centre Issue Paper 23. Available at: http://www.epc.eu/pub_details.php?cat_id=2&pub_id=36.

18.

Boccardi

(2002) Europe and Refugees: Towards an EU Asylum Policy, London: Kluwer Law International.

19.

Boswell

(2000) European values and the asylum crisis. International Affairs 76(3): 537–557.

20.

British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) (2018) Europe and nationalism: A country-by-country guide. BBC, 10 September. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-36130006.

21.

Capannelli G (2009) Asian regionalism: How does it compare to Europe’s. East Asia Forum, 21 April. Available at: http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2009/04/21/asian-regionalism-how-does-it-compare-to-europes/.

22.

Chakelian A (2017) Rise of the nationalists: A guide to Europe’s far-right parties. New Statesman, 8 March. Available at: https://www.newstatesman.com/world/europe/2017/03/rise-nationalists-guide-europe-s-far-right-parties.

23.

Cheung

(2011) Migration control and the solutions impasse in South and Southeast Asia: Implications from the Rohingya experience. Journal of Refugee Studies 25(1): 50–70.

24.

Clayton J and Holland H (2015) Over one million sea arrivals reach Europe in 2015. UNHCR, 30 December. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/en-au/news/latest/2015/12/5683d0b56/million-sea-arrivals-reach-europe-2015.

25.

Collett E (2015) The asylum crisis in Europe: Designed dysfunction. Commentary, Migration Policy Institute, September. Available at: http://www.migrationpolicy.org/news/asylum-crisis-europe-designed-dysfunction.

26.

Costello

Mouzourakis

(2016) The Common European Asylum System – Where did it all go wrong? In: Fletcher

Herlin-Karnell

Matera

(eds) The European Union as an Area of Freedom, Security and Justice, Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 211–238.

27.

Council of the European Union (2000a) Austria delegation: Position on the Commission working paper on revisiting the Dublin Convention. Brussels. (Doc no. 11052/00).

28.

Council of the European Union (2000b) German delegation: Position on Commission working paper on revisiting the Dublin Convention. Brussels. (Doc. 11053/00).

29.

Council of the European Union (2009) Note from the Cyprus, Greek, Italian and Maltese delegations on Combatting illegal immigration in the Mediterranean. Brussels. (Doc. 5689/09).

30.

Council of the European Union (2011a) Note from presidency to permanent representatives committee/Council on the Common European Asylum System. Brussels. (Doc. 7986/11).

31.

Council of the European Union (2011b) Outcome of proceedings asylum working party 2 March 2011. Brussels. (Doc no. 7675/11).

32.

Curley

Wong

(2008) Security and Migration in Asia: The Dynamics of Securitisation, New York: Routledge.

33.

Cusumano

(2018) The sea as humanitarian space: Non-governmental search and rescue dilemmas on the Central Mediterranean migratory route. Mediterranean Politics 23(3): 387–394.

34.

Davies

(2008) Legitimising Rejection: International Refugee Law in Southeast Asia, Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.

35.

Davies

(2014) The 1989 Comprehensive Plan of Action (CPA) and refugee policy in Southeast Asia: Twenty years forward what has changed? In: Abass

Ippolito

Juss

(eds) Regional Approaches to the Protection of Asylum Seekers: An International Legal Perspective, New York: Ashgate, pp. 283–301.

36.

Dearden L (2016) UN report finds no evidence migration causes terror attacks and warns anti-refugee laws could worsen risk. The Independent, 24 October. Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/refugee-crisis-terrorism-link-migration-un-expert-report-no-evidence-isis-uses-route-human-rights-a7377961.html.

37.

Den Heijer

Rijpma

Spijkerboer

(2016) Coercion, prohibition, and great expectations: The continuing failure of the Common European Asylum System. Common Market Law Review 53(3): 607–642.

38.

Dolan-Evans E (2016) The plight of the Rohingya. Australian Outlook, 3 January. The Australian Institute of International Affairs. Available at: http://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/the-plight-of-the-rohingya/.

39.

Ellis-Peterson H (2019) Rohingya crisis: Bangladesh says it will not accept any more Myanmar Refugees. The Guardian, 1 March. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/01/rohingya-crisis-bangladesh-says-it-will-not-accept-any-more-myanmar-refugees.

40.

European Commission (2000) Revisiting the Dublin Convention, Brussels: European Commission (SEC (2000) 522).

41.

European Commission (2007) Green paper on the future Common European Asylum System. Brussels: European Commission (COM (2007) 301 final).

42.

European Commission (2008) Policy plan on asylum: An integrated approach to protection across the EU. Brussels: European Commission (COM (2008) 360 final).

43.

European Commission (2011) An EU agenda for better responsibility-sharing and more mutual trust. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee on the Regions on enhanced intra-EU solidarity in the field of asylum. Brussels: European Commission (COM (2011)835 final).

44.

European Commission (2015a) Proposal for a Council decision establishing provisional measures in the area of international protection for the benefit of Italy and Greece, Brussels: European Commission (COM (2015) 286 final).

45.

European Commission (2015b) More responsibility in managing the refugee crisis: European Commission adopts 40 infringement decisions to make European asylum system work, Brussels: European Commission (IP/15/5699).

46.

European Commission (2016) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council Towards a Reform of the Common European Asylum System and Enhancing Legal Avenues to Europe. Brussels: European Commission (COM (2016) 197 final).

47.

European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE) (2013) Dublin II Regulation: Lives on hold – European comparative report. Report, European Council on Refugees and Exiles. Available at http://www.refworld.org/docid/513ef9632.html.

48.

European Parliament (2008) Resolution of 2 September 2008 on the evaluation of the Dublin system. Brussels: European Parliament (2007/2262/(INI)).

49.

Fekete

(2018) Migrants, borders and the criminalisation of solidarity in the EU. Race and Class 59(4): 65–83.

50.

Gladstone R (2017) U.S. quits migration pact, saying it infringes on sovereignty. The New York Times, 3 December. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/03/world/americas/united-nations-migration-pact.html.

51.

Greider A (2017) Outsourcing migration management: The role of the Western Balkans in the European refugee crisis. Migration Information Source, 17 August. Migration Policy Institute. Available at: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/outsourcing-migration-management-western-balkans-europes-refugee-crisis.

52.

Government of Thailand (2015) Summary: Special meeting on irregular migration in the Indian ocean. 29 May. Available at: https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/media-center-20150529–175942–231858.pdf.

53.

Harding L and agencies (2015) Hungarian police arrest driver of lorry that had 71 dead migrants inside. The Guardian, 28 August, Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/aug/28/more-than-70-dead-austria-migrant-truck-tragedy.

54.

Huguet

(2016) APMJ – Chronicling 25 years of migration in Asia and the Pacific. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 25(4): 357–378.

55.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) (2009) Letter to ASEAN Secretary-General Surin Pitsuwan. 25 February. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/news/2009/02/25/letter-asean-secretary-general-surin-pitsuwan.

56.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) (2018a) Country summary: Burma. January. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/burma.pdf.

57.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) (2018b) Venezuela: Refugee crisis requires concerted regional response. 3 September. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/09/03/venezuela-refugee-crisis-requires-concerted-regional-response.

58.

International Association of Refugee Law Judges (2016) An Introduction to the Common European Asylum System for Courts and Tribunals: A Judicial Analysis, Malta: EASO.

59.

Jones

(2015) Great powers, ASEAN, and security: Reason for optimism? The Pacific Review 28(2): 259–290.

60.

Katsumata

(2009) ASEAN and human rights: Resisting Western pressure or emulating the West? The Pacific Review 22(5): 619–637.

61.

Kneebone

(2011) ASEAN: Setting the agenda for the rights of migrant workers? In: Nasu

Saul

(eds) Human Rights in the Asia-Pacific Region: Towards Institution Building, Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 144–164.

62.

Kneebone

(2014) ASEAN and the conceptualization of refugee protection in Southeast Asian states. In: Abass

Ippolito

Juss

(eds) Regional Approaches to the Protection of Asylum Seekers: An International Legal Perspective, New York: Ashgate, pp. 260–282.

63.

Kneebone

(2016) Comparative regional protection frameworks for refugees: Norms and norm entrepreneurs. The International Journal of Human Rights 20(2): 153–172.

64.

Lavenex

(2001) The Europeanisation of Refugee Policies: Between Human Rights and Internal Security, Hampshire: Ashgate.

65.

Lavenex

(2010) Justice and Home Affairs: Communitarization without hesitation. In: Wallace

Pollack

Young

(eds) Policy-making in the European Union, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 457–477.

66.

Longo

Murray

(2015) Europe’s Legitimacy Crisis: From Causes to Solutions, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

67.

McAuliffe

(2016) Resolving Policy Conundrums: Enhancing Humanitarian Protection in Southeast Asia, Washington DC: Migration Policy Institute.

68.

McDonough

Tsourdi

(2012) The ‘other’ Greek crisis: Asylum and EU solidarity. Refugee Survey Quarterly 31(4): 67–100.

69.

Maiani

(2016) The Dublin III Regulation: A new legal framework for a more humane system? In: Chetail

De Bruycker

Maiani

(eds) Reforming the Common European Asylum System, Leiden: Brill Nijhoff, pp. 101–142.

70.

Marquis C (2018) France approves flawed asylum and immigration law. Human Rights Watch, 4 August. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/08/04/france-approves-flawed-asylum-and-immigration-law.

71.

Mathew

Harley

(2016) Refugee, Regionalism and Responsibility, Northampton: Edward Edgar Publishing.

72.

Mauzy

(1997) The human rights and ‘Asian values’ debate in Southeast Asia: Trying to clarify the key issues. The Pacific Review 10(2): 210–236.

73.

Ministers of Foreign Affairs of Malaysia, Indonesia and Thailand (2015) Joint statement at the Ministerial Meeting on irregular movement of people in Southeast Asia. 20 May. Available at: https://reliefweb.int/report/myanmar/joint-statement-ministerial-meeting-irregular-movement-people-southeast-asia.

74.

Monar

(2011) Justice and Home Affairs. Journal of Common Market Studies 49(S1): 145–164.

75.

Monar

(2012) Justice and Home Affairs. Journal of Common Market Studies 50(S2): 116–131.

76.

Monar

(2013) Justice and Home Affairs. Journal of Common Market Studies 51(S1): 124–138.

77.

Moretti

(2018) Protection in the context of mixed migratory movements by sea: The case of Bay of Bengal and Andaman Sea Crisis. The International Journal of Human Rights 22(2): 237–261.

78.

Murdoch L (2015) Rohingya Muslim boat people land in Indonesia, thousands more stuck at sea. The Sydney Morning Herald, 10 May. Available at: https://www.smh.com.au/world/rohingya-muslim-boat-people-land-in-indonesia-thousands-more-stuck-at-sea-20150510-ggygky.html.

79.

Murray

(2010) Comparative regional integration in the EU and East Asia: Moving beyond integration snobbery. International Politics 47(3–4): 308–323.

80.

Murray

(2015) Europe and the world: The problem of the fourth wall in EU-ASEAN norms promotion. Journal of Contemporary European Studies 23(2): 238–252.

81.

Murray

Moxon-Browne

(2013) The European Union as a template for regional integration? The case of ASEAN and its Committee of Permanent Representatives. Journal of Common Market Studies 51(3): 522–537.

82.

Nah

(2016) Networks and norm entrepreneurship amongst local civil society actors: Advancing refugee protection in the Asia Pacific region. The International Journal of Human Rights 20(2): 223–240.

83.

Nethery

(2014) Australia, ASEAN, and forced migration in Asia. In: Wood

(eds) The Australia- ASEAN Dialogue: Tracing 40 Years of Partnership, New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 107–124.

84.

Nielsen N (2017) EU states tackle Dublin asylum reform ‘line by line.’ EUobserver, 7 March. Available at: https://euobserver.com/migration/141236.

85.

Niemann

Zaun

(2018) EU refugee policies and politics in times of crisis: Theoretical and empirical perspectives. Journal of Common Market Studies 56(1): 3–22.

86.

Papademetriou

Banulescu-Bogdan

(2016) Understanding and Addressing Public Anxiety about Immigration, Washington DC: Migration Policy Institute.

87.

Pepinsky T (2017) Democracy isn’t receding in Southeast Asia, authoritarianism is enduring. East Asia Forum, 4 November. Available at: http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2017/11/04/democracy-isnt-receding-in-southeast-asia-authoritarianism-is-enduring/.

88.

Petcharamesree

(2016) ASEAN and its approach to forced migration issues. The International Journal of Human Rights 20(2): 173–190.

89.

Poli

(2014) Is the European model relevant for ASEAN. Istituto Affari Internazionali 14/13: 1–14.

90.

Remeikis A and Doherty B (2018) Dutton says Australia won’t ‘surrender our sovereignty’ by signing UN migration deal. The Guardian, 25 July. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/jul/25/dutton-says-australia-wont-surrender-our-sovereignty-by-signing-un-migration-deal.

91.

Salleh N (2018) ASEAN foreign ministers look forward to safe repatriation of Rohingya refugees to Myanmar. Straits Times, 6 February. Available at: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/asean-foreign-ministers-look-forward-to-safe-repatriation-of-rohingya-refugees-to-myanmar.

92.

Secretary General of ASEAN (2007) Forty Years of ASEAN: Can the European Union be a model for Asia. Speech at the Konrad Adenauer Foundation, Berlin, 16 July. Available at: http://asean.org/?static_post=forty-years-of-asean-can-the-european-union-be-a-model-for-asia.

93.

Shelton

Carozza

(2013) Regional Protection of Human Rights, New York: Oxford University Press.

94.

Shivakoti

(2017) ASEAN’s role in the Rohingya Refugee Crisis. Forced Migration Review 56: 75–77.

95.

Suder G (2017) As the European Union celebrates 60 years, can Asia use it as a model for economic integration?. The Conversation, 24 March. Available at: https://theconversation.com/as-the-european-union-celebrates-60-years-can-asia-use-it-as-a-model-for-economic-integration-74542.

96.

Tan

(2008) The ASEAN charter as ‘legs to go places’: Ideational norms and pragmatic legalism in community building in Southeast Asia. Singapore Year Book of International Law 12: 171–198.

97.

Thielemann

Armstrong

(2013) Understanding European asylum cooperation under the Schengen/Dublin system: A public goods framework. European Security 22(2): 148–164.

98.

Thomas

Yarnell

(2018) Ensuring that the Global Compacts on Refugees and Migration Deliver, Washington DC: Refugees International.

99.

Thuzar M (2017) The ASEAN ‘Consensus’ on migrant workers: Not ideal but a basis to continue working. ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute commentary, 16 November. Available at: https://www.iseas.edu.sg/medias/commentaries/item/6589-the-asean-consensus-on-migrant-workers-not-ideal-but-a-basis-to-continue-working-b%E2%80%A6.

100.

Trauner

(2016) Asylum policy: The EU’s ‘crises’ and the looming policy regime failure. Journal of European Integration 38(3): 311–325.

101.

Trauner

Ripoll Servent

(2016) The communitarization of the area of freedom, security and justice: Why institutional change does not translate into policy change. Journal of Common Market Studies 54(6): 1417–1432.

102.

Tubakovic T and Rogan K (2017) A ‘real’ fortress Europe. Social Europe, 15 March. Available at: https://www.socialeurope.eu/real-fortress-europe.

103.

Udin N (2018) Ongoing Rohingya repatriation efforts are doomed to failure. Al Jazeera, 22 November. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/ongoing-rohingya-repatriation-efforts-doomed-failure-181122124753014.html.

104.

UN Human Rights (2015) Pushbacks endanger thousands in Bay of Bengal. OHCHR, 15 May. Available at: http://www.ohchr.org/en/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=15960&LangID=E.

105.

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2013) UNHCR global appeal 2014–2015: South East Asia subregional overview. Report, UNHCR, November. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/528a0a31b.pdf.

106.

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2015) UNHCR alarmed at reports of boat pushbacks in Southeast Asia. UNHCR, 13 May. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/555345959.html.

107.

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2017) Mixed Movements in South-East Asia 2016. UNHCR, April. Available at: http://www.refworld.org/country,COI,UNHCR,,MYS,,590b18a14,0.html.

108.

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2019) Population map: UNHCR, Bangladesh, Cox’s Bazar-as of 28 February. 4 March. Available at: https://data2.unhcr.org/en/documents/details/68228.

109.

Villa M, Gruijters R, and Steinhilper E (2018) Outsourcing European border control: Recent trends in departures, deaths and search and rescue activities in the Central Mediterannean. Available at: https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/research-subject-groups/centre-criminology/centreborder-criminologies/blog/2018/09/outsourcing.

110.

Wong

(2012) Model power or reference point? The EU and the ASEAN Charter. Cambridge Review of International Affairs 25(4): 669–682.

111.

Yadav R (2017) ASEAN fragmented on Rohingya crisis. Australian Outlook, 14 January. Australian Institute of International Affairs. Available at: http://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/asean-fragmented-on-rohingya-crisis/.

112.

Zaun

(2017) EU Asylum Policies: The Power of Strong Regulating States, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.