The employment of foreign seasonal workers is often advocated as a win–win situation for both employers and workers, as labor shortages can be filled and at the same time foreign workers are able to access labor opportunities. However, these schemes are also being criticized for being prone to exploiting migrants as cheap labor without granting them sufficient rights. This article analyzes the impact of seasonal worker schemes in Australia and New Zealand, researching under what conditions these schemes constitute a win–win situation. This article will first outline the main features of the seasonal worker schemes in New Zealand and Australia. Subsequent sections will cover social protection rights, the characteristics of relevant agricultural industries and the interests of employers. The article concludes with an analysis of critical aspects that can be considered as good practice.
AndersonB (2008) Migrants and work-related rights. Ethics and International Affairs22: 199–203.
2.
Australian Council of Trade Unions (2006) ACTU Submission to the Senate Employment, Workplace Relations and Education Committee Inquiry into Pacific Region Seasonal Contract Labour.
3.
Australian Department of Education Employment and Workplace Relations (2013) Pacific Seasonal Worker Pilot Scheme Data Summary February 2009 to September 2012. Canberra: DEEWR.
BallR (2010) Australia’s Pacific seasonal worker pilot scheme and its interface with the Australian horticultural labour market: Is it time to refine the policy?Pacific Economic Bulletin25(1): 114–130.
6.
Bedford R and Bedford C (2012) Productivity gains from Pacific seasonal workers in NZ. Paper presented at the Inaugural Seasonal Worker Program Conference. Sydney, Australia, 01-03 August 2012.
7.
Bell S (2012) Roy Hill can bring 1715 workers from overseas over next three years. The Australian, 25 May.
ChandaR (2008) Low-Skilled Workers and Bilateral, Regional, and Unilateral Initiatives: Lessons for the GATS Mode 4 Negotiations and Other Agreements, Geneva: United Nations Development Programme.
13.
Coutts G (2012) NZ business benefit from seasonal workers scheme. Radio Australia, 07 June.
Evalue Research (2010) Final Evaluation Report of the Recognised Seasonal Employer Policy (2007-2009), Wellington: New Zealand Department of Labour.
16.
Hay D and Howes S (2012) Australia’s Pacific Seasonal Worker Pilot Scheme: Why Has Take-up Been so Low? Development Policy Centre Discussion Paper 17. Canberra: Crawford School of Public Policy, The Australian National University.
17.
Holzmann R and Pouget Y (2010) Social Protection for Temporary Migrant Workers: Conceptual Framework, Country Inventory, Assessment and Guidance. A study prepared for the Global Forum of Migration and Development. World Bank and Marseille Center for Mediterranean Integration. Marseille, France, 27 October.
18.
Holzmann R, Koettl J and Chernetsky T (2005) Portability Regimes of Pension and Health Care Benefits for International Migrants: An Analysis of Issues and Good Practices. SP Discussion Paper No 0519. Washington, DC: The World Bank.
19.
Howells S (2011) The Report of the 2010 Review of the Migration Amendment (Employer Sanctions) Act 2007. Report prepared for the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, Commonwealth of Australia. Canberra: DIAC.
20.
Howes S and Berry A (2012) Illegal labour and red tape: Another industry perspective on the Pacific Seasonal Worker Program. In: Development Policy Blog. Available at: http://devpolicy.org/illegal-labour-and-red-tape/.
International Labour Organization (2006) ILO’s Multilateral Framework on Labour Migration; Non-binding Principles and Guidelines for a Rights-based Approach, Geneva: International Labour Office.
KerrKB (1996) Unemployment Compensation Systems and Reforms in Selected OECD Countries, Ottawa: Library of Parliament, Research Branch, Organisation for Economic Co-operation Development.
25.
LamarcheL (2014) Human rights, social security and migrant workers. In: BlanpainR (eds) Social Security and Migrant Workers: Selected Studies of Cross-Border Social Security Mechanisms, Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International, pp. 9–30.
MaresP (2006) Labour Shortages in Murray Valley Horticulture: A Survey of Growers’ Needs and Attitudes, Melbourne: Institute for Social Research, Swinburne University of Technology.
28.
MaresPMaclellanN (2006) Neighbours: Making bilateral worker schemes a win-win. In: LuthriaM (eds) At Home & Away: Expanding Job Opportunities for Pacific Islanders through Labour Mobility, Washington, DC: World Bank, pp. 101–142.
29.
MartinP (2003) Managing Labour Migration: Temporary Worker Programs for the 21st Century, Geneva: International Institute for Labour Studies.
30.
National Farmers' Federation (2008) Summary of Labour Shortages in the Agricultural Sector, Canberra: NFF.
31.
National Farmers' Federation (2010) Population Policy: Labour Pains, Canberra: NFF.
32.
New Zealand Department of Labour (2013) Industry Profile: Agriculture and Horticulture, Wellington: DOL.
33.
OlivierM (2011) Political and regulatory dimensions of access, portability and exclusion: Social security for migrants, with an emphasis on migrants in Southern Africa. In: Sabates-WheelerRFeldmanR (eds) Migration and Social Protection: Claiming Social Rights beyond Borders, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 117–139.
34.
Radio New Zealand (2014) NZ negotiating with Fiji over RSE participation. Radio New Zealand International, 23 July.
35.
RamasamySKrishnanVBedfordR (2008) The Recognised Seasonal Employer Policy: Seeking the elusive triple wins for development through international migration. Pacific Economic Bulletin23: 171–186.
36.
Ruhs M (2002) Temporary foreign worker programmes: Policies, adverse consequences and the need to make them work. Perspectives on Labour Migration 6. Geneva: International Labour Office.
37.
RuhsM (2006) The potential of temporary migration programmes in future international migration policy. International Labour Review145: 7–36.
38.
RuhsMMartinP (2008) Numbers vs. rights: Trade-offs and guest worker programs. International Migration Review42(1): 249–265.
39.
Sabates-Wheeler R (2009) Extending Social Security Coverage: Good Practices, Lessons Learnt and Ways Forward. ISSA Working Paper No 12. Geneva: International Social Security Association.
Van GinnekenW (2013) Social protection for migrant workers: National and international policy challenges. European Journal of Social Security15(2): 209–221.
42.
World Bank (2006) At Home and Away: Expanding Job Opportunities for Pacific Islanders through Labour Mobility, Washington, DC: World Bank.
