American governments spend $6 billion annually on management consulting, with steady growth. However, public-sector consulting receives little scholarly and public attention—especially for local governments. For which municipal projects are management consultants best suited? Svara asserts that complementarity promotes effective governance between city councils and their managers; sometimes, however, neither has the capability to lead the other. This study explores whether consultants can effectively fill this complementarity void by examining 205 strategic initiatives from 43 US municipalities. The analysis confirms that consultants are helpful when strategic and political-administrative contexts conflict, but only when key stakeholders are supportive.
AdewaleA. R.EstherM. M. (2012). The relationship between stakeholders involvement in strategic planning and organisations performance: A study of the university of Venda. International Business & Economics Research Journal (IBER), 11(11), 1175–1190.
2.
AhernT.LeavyB.ByrneP. J. (2014). Complex project management as complex problem solving: A distributed knowledge management perspective. International Journal of Project Management, 32(8), 1371–1381.
3.
AlfordJ.HartleyJ.YatesS.HughesO. (2017). Into the purple zone: Deconstructing the politics/administration distinction. The American Review of Public Administration, 47(7), 752–763.
4.
AlfordJ.HughesO. (2008). Public value pragmatism as the next phase of public management. The American Review of Public Administration, 38(2), 130–148.
5.
Al-KhouriA. M. (2012). Projects management in reality: Lessons from government projects. Business and Management Review, 2(4), 1–14.
6.
AndrewsR.BoyneG. A.WalkerR. M. (2006). Strategy content and organizational performance: An empirical analysis. Public Administration Review, 66(1), 52–63.
7.
BackoffR.WechslerB.CrewR. E. (1993). The challenge of strategic management in local government. Public Administration Quarterly, 17(2), 127–144.
8.
BankinsS.DennessB.KrizA.MolloyC. (2017). Innovation agents in the public sector: Applying champion and promotor theory to explore innovation in the Australian public service. Australian Journal of Public Administration, 76(1), 122–137.
9.
BenzaquenE. Y. (2016). School bond referenda reloaded: An examination of a school district in passing a subsequent bond referendum after failing to pass previous bond referenda [Doctoral dissertation]. University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.
10.
BianchiC.BovairdT.LoefflerE. (2017). Applying a dynamic performance management framework to wicked issues: How coproduction helps to transform young people’s services in surrey county council, UK. International Journal of Public Administration, 40(10), 833–846.
11.
BoppT. (2012). Strategic management and job satisfaction: Agency-level effects in the Federal Government [Doctoral dissertation]. University of Kentucky.
12.
BouwmeesterO.van WervenR. (2011). Consultants as legitimizers: Exploring their rhetoric. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 24(4), 427–441.
13.
BrysonJ. M. (2004). What to do when stakeholders matter: Stakeholder identification and analysis techniques. Public Management Review, 6(1), 21–53.
14.
BrysonJ. M. (2010). The future of public and nonprofit strategic planning in the United States. Public Administration Review, 70(s1), S255–S267.
15.
BrysonJ. M.BerryF. S.YangK. (2010). The state of public strategic management research: A selective literature review and set of future directions. The American Review of Public Administration, 40(5), 495–521.
16.
ChenS. H. (2017). Who cares: Stakeholder participation and the use of performance information in strategic planning. Chinese Public Administration Review, 8(2), 86–103.
ConnollyJ. M. (2017). The impact of local politics on the principal-agent relationship between council and manager in municipal government. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 27(2), 253–268.
19.
DemirT.NyhanR. C. (2008). The politics-administration dichotomy: An empirical search for correspondence between theory and practice. Public Administration Review, 68(1), 81–96.
DessG. G. (1987). Consensus on strategy formulation and organizational performance: Competitors in a fragmented industry. Strategic Management Journal, 8(3), 259–277.
22.
FernandezS.RaineyH. G. (2006). Managing successful organizational change in the public sector. Public Administration Review, 66(2), 168–176.
23.
FreemanR. E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman.
24.
GeorgeB. (2017). Does strategic planning ‘work’ in public organizations? Insights from Flemish municipalities. Public Money & Management, 37(7), 527–530.
25.
GeorgeB.DesmidtS. (2014). A state of research on strategic management in the public sector. In JoyceP.DramauxA. (Eds.), Strategic management in public organizations: European practices and perspectives (pp. 151–171). Routledge.
26.
GomesR.BermanE. (2020). Senior managers in national strategic planning and management. In SullivanH.DickinsonH.HendersonH. (Eds.), The Palgrave handbook of the public servant (pp. 1–18). Palgrave Macmillan.
27.
GoodsellC. T. (2019). The anti-public administration presidency: The damage Trump has wrought. The American Review of Public Administration, 49(8), 871–883.
HolzerM.BallardA.KimM.PengS.DeatF. (2019). Obstacles and opportunities for sustaining performance management systems. International Journal of Public Administration, 42(2), 132–143.
30.
LinovskiO. (2021). The value of planning: Views from management consultants. Journal of Planning Education and Research.
31.
MarchJ. G.OlsenJ. P. (1995). Democratic governance. Free Press.
32.
MeierK. J.O’TooleL. J.BoyneG. A.WalkerR. M. (2007). Strategic management and the performance of public organizations: Testing venerable ideas against recent theories. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 17(3), 357–377.
33.
MintzbergH. (1990). The design school: Reconsidering the basic premises of strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 11(3), 171–195.
34.
MitchellD. (2019). It all depends, but on what? Testing contingency in public strategic implementation. Public Performance & Management Review, 42(4), 783–807.
35.
MitchellD. (2022). Bought in? The contingent effect of stakeholder support upon strategic implementation success in American municipalities. Public Management Review, 24, 773–798.
36.
MitchellD.KanaanD.StoeckelS. (2021). Put your money where your mouth is: The influence of designated funding upon strategic implementation in US municipalities. Public Administration Quarterly, 45(1), 29–50.
37.
MitchellD.LarsonS. E.ColantonioC.NguyenC. (2018). Planning for change: Incorporating contextual implementation design into strategic planning. State and Local Government Review, 50(2), 110–118.
38.
MomaniB. (2013). Management consultants and the United States’ public sector. Business and Politics, 15(3), 381–399.
39.
MoynihanD. P. (2008). The dynamics of Performance Management: Constructing Information and Reform. Georgetown University Press.
40.
NuttP. C. (1989). Selecting tactics to implement strategic plans. Strategic Management Journal, 10(2), 145–161.
41.
NuttP. C.BackoffR.W. (1993). Organizational publicness and its implications for strategic management. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 3(2), 209–231.
42.
NuttP. C.WilsonD. C. (Eds.). (2010). Handbook of decision making. John Wiley & Sons.
43.
PemerF.BörjesonL.WerrA. (2014). Government agencies’ use of management consulting services in Sweden: An explorative study (Vol.3). Stockholm School of Economics.
44.
PengM. W.Pleggenkuhle-MilesE. G. (2009). Current debates in global strategy. International Journal of Management Reviews, 11(1), 51–68.
45.
PoisterT. H.PittsD. W.Hamilton EdwardsL. (2010). Strategic management research in the public sector: A review, synthesis, and future directions. The American Review of Public Administration, 40(5), 522–545.
46.
PoisterT. H.SlykeVan SlykeD.M. (2002). Strategic management innovations in state transportation departments. Public Performance & Management Review, 26(1), 58–74.
47.
PoisterT. H.StreibG. D. (1999). Strategic management in the public sector: Concepts, models, and processes. Public Productivity & Management Review, 22(3), 308–325.
48.
RadnorZ.O’MahoneyJ. (2013). The role of management consultancy in implementing operations management in the public sector. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 33(11/12), 1555–1578.
49.
RaineyH. G.SteinbauerP. (1999). Galloping elephants: Developing elements of a theory of effective government organizations. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 9(1), 1–32.
50.
RoseJ.FlakL. S.SaeboO. (2018). Stakeholder theory for the E -government context: Framing a value-oriented normative core. Government Information Quarterly, 35(3), 362–374.
51.
SinghJ. V. (1986). Performance, slack, and risk taking in organizational decision making. Academy of Management Journal, 29(3), 562–585.
52.
SoulardJ.KnollenbergW.BoleyB. B.PerdueR. R.McGeheeN. G. (2018). Social capital and destination strategic planning. Tourism Management, 69, 189–200.
53.
StreibG. (1992). Applying strategic decision making in local government. Public Productivity & Management Review, 15(3), 341–354.
54.
SvaraJ. H. (2001). The myth of the dichotomy: Complementarity of politics and administration in the past and future of public administration. Public Administration Review, 61(2), 176–183.
55.
SvaraJ. H. (2006). Introduction: Politicians and administrators in the political process—A review of themes and issues in the literature. International Journal of Public Administration, 29(12), 953–976.
56.
ThomasJ. C.PoisterT. H. (2009). Thinking about stakeholders of public agencies: The Georgia department of transportation stakeholder audit. Public Organization Review, 9(1), 67–82.
57.
VaaraE.WhittingtonR. (2012). Strategy-as-practice: Taking social practices seriously. The Academy of Management Annals, 6(1), 285–336.
58.
VinzantD. H.VinzantJ. C. (1996). Strategy and organizational capacity: Finding a fit. Public Productivity & Management Review, 20(2), 139–157.
59.
WalkerR. M. (2013). Strategic management and performance in public organizations: Findings from the Miles and Snow framework. Public Administration Review, 73(5), 675–685.
60.
WalkerR. M.AndrewsR.BoyneG. A.MeierK. J.O’TooleL. J. (2010). Wakeup call: Strategic management, network alarms and performance. Public Administration Review, 70(5), 731–741.
61.
WalkerR. M.JungC. S.BoyneG. A. (2013). “Marching to different drummers? The performance effects of alignment between political and managerial perceptions of performance management. Public Administration Review, 73(6), 833–844.
62.
WangX. (2002). Assessing performance measurement impact: A study of US local governments. Public Performance & Management Review, 26(1), 26–43.
63.
WeissJ. (2017). Trust as a key for strategic management? The relevance of council–administration relations for NPM-related reforms in German local governments. Public Management Review, 19(10), 1399–1414.
64.
WisemanM. (1993). The ecology of strategic management in small local governments. Public Administration Quarterly, 17, 145–158.
65.
YoungS. L.WileyK. K.SearingE. A. M. (2020). ‘squandered in real time’: How public management theory underestimated the public administration–politics dichotomy. The American Review of Public Administration, 50(6-7), 480–488.
66.
ZomorrodianA. (2011). New approach to strategic planning: The impact of leadership and culture on plan implantation via the three Cs: Cooperation, collaboration and Coordination. Retrieved March 4, 2011, from https://ssrn.com/abstract=1777307
