The process of socialist transformation in a democratic context presents many quandaries including walking a tightrope between pursuing substantive transformation that challenges existing social relations and remaining in power in view of political opposition stemming from such a challenge. The experiences of twenty-first-century socialism in Ecuador, Bolivia, and Venezuela provide different examples of ways of balancing the two imperatives. Nicos Poulantzas’s writings on the state shed light on the importance of deepening democracy as part of any process of socialist transformation and on the limits of such a strategy.
El proceso de transformación socialista en un contexto democrático presenta muchos dilemas que incluyen caminar en la cuerda floja entre perseguir una transformación sustantiva que desafía las relaciones sociales existentes y permanecer en el poder en vista de la oposición política que surge de tal desafío. Las experiencias del socialismo del siglo XXI en Ecuador, Bolivia y Venezuela proporcionan diferentes ejemplos de formas de equilibrar los dos imperativos. Los escritos de Nicos Poulantzas sobre el estado arrojan luz sobre la importancia de profundizar la democracia como parte de cualquier proceso de transformación socialista y los límites de dicha estrategia.
AnriaSantiago2013 “Social movements, party organization, and populism: insights from the Bolivian MAS.” Latin American Politics and Society, no. 55 (Fall), 19–46.
3.
AzzeliniDario2015 “Venezuela’s social transformation and growing class struggle,” pp. 138–162 in SpronkSusanWebberJeffery (eds.), Crisis and Contradiction: Marxist Perspectives on Latin America in the Global Political Economy. Chicago: Haymarket.
4.
BarrosSebastian2014 “Populismo, pueblo y liderazgo en América Latina.” Colombia Internacional, no. 82 (September–December), 297–302.
5.
BeckerMarc2016 “The Correa coup.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 71–92.
6.
BradingRyan2014 “From passive to radical revolution in Venezuela’s populist project.” Latin American Perspectives41 (6): 48–64.
7.
CariaSaraDomínguezRafael2016 “Ecuador’s buen vivir: a new ideology for development.” Latin American Perspectives41 (6): 48–64.
8.
CyrJennifer2015 “Making or breaking politics: social conflicts and party-system change in democratic Bolivia.” Studies in Comparative International Development50 (September): 283–303.
9.
EllnerSteve2008Rethinking Venezuelan Politics: Class, Conflict, and the Chávez Phenomenon. Boulder: Lynne Rienner.
ErrejónÍñigoGuijarroJuan2016 “Post-neoliberalism’s difficult hegemonic consolidation: a comparative analysis of the Ecuadorean and Bolivian processes.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 34–52.
13.
FuentesFrederico2007 “The struggle for Bolivia’s future.” Monthly Review59 (July-August): 95–109.
14.
GamsoJonas2016 “A case of diversified dependency: macrostructural change and policy alternatives in Ecuador.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 109–123.
15.
GudynasEduardo2012 “Estado compensador y nuevos extractivismos: las ambivalencias del progresismosudamericano.” Nueva Sociedad, no. 237 (January-February), 128–146.
16.
GudynasEduardo2013 “Development alternatives in Bolivia: the impulse, the resistance, and the restoration.” NACLA Report on the Americas46 (1): 22–26.
17.
HellingerDaniel2016 “Oil and the Chávez legacy.” Latin American Perspectives44 (1): 54–77.
18.
HolstJoshua2016 “Colonial histories and decolonial dreams in the Ecuadorean Amazon: natural resources and the politics of post-neoliberalism.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 200–220.
19.
JessopBob2002 “Globalization and the national state,” pp. 185–220 in AronowitzStanleyBratsisPeter (eds.), Paradigm Lost: State Theory Reconsidered. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
20.
KatzClaudio2015 “Dualities of Latin America.” Latin American Perspectives42 (4): 10–42.
KitzbergerPhilip2016 “Counterhegemony in the media under Rafael Correa’s Citizens’ Revolution.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 53–70.
23.
LehoucqFabrice2008 “Bolivia’s constitutional breakdown.” Journal of Democracy19 (October): 110–124.
24.
NorthLiisa2013 “New left regimes in the Andes? Ecuador in comparative perspective.” Studies in Political Economy, no. 91 (Spring), 113–136.
25.
PoulantzasNicos1975Classes in Contemporary Capitalism. London: New Left Books.
26.
PoulantzasNicos2014State, Power, Socialism. New York: Verso.
27.
PurcellThomas2011 “The Bolivarian process in Venezuela: A left forum.” Historical Materialism19 (1): 233–270.
28.
PurcellThomas2015 “Socialist management and natural resources based industrial production: a critique of cogestión in Venezuela,” pp. 163–189 in SpronkSusanWebberJeffery (eds.), Crisis and Contradiction: Marxist Perspectives on Latin America in the Global Political Economy. Chicago: Haymarket.
29.
RamírezGallegos Franklin2016 “Political change, state autonomy, and post-neoliberalism in Ecuador, 2007–2012.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 143–157.
30.
ReanoAriana2014 “Populismo (en) democracia: repensando los sentidos de la emancipación en el Sur de América Latina.” Colombia Internacional, no. 82 (September–December), 99–128.
31.
RegalskyPablo2010 “Political processes and the reconfiguration of the state in Bolivia.” Latin American Perspectives37 (3): 35–50.
RetamozoMartin2014 “Populismo en América Latina: desde la teoría hacia el análisis político, discurso, sujeto e inclusión en el caso argentino.” Colombia Internacional, no. 82 (September–December), 221–258.
34.
Schilling-VacaflorAlmut2011 “Bolivia’s new constitution: towards participatory democracy and political pluralism?” European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies, no. 90 (April), 3–22.
35.
SilvaVeronica2016 “The return of the state, new social actors, and post-neoliberalism in Ecuador.” Latin American Perspectives43 (1): 4–17.
36.
SpronkSusan2015 “Roots of resistance to urban water privatisation in Bolivia: the ‘new working class,’ the crisis of neoliberalism, and public services,” pp. 29–51 in SpronkSusanWebberJeffery (eds.), Crisis and Contradiction: Marxist Perspectives on Latin America in the Global Political Economy. Chicago: Haymarket.
TockmanJasonCameronJohn2014 “Indigenous autonomy and the contradictions of plurinationalism in Bolivia.” Latin American Politics and Society56 (3): 46–69.
39.
WacasterSusan2013 “The mineral industry of Ecuador.” U.S. Geological Survey Minerals Yearbook, no. 9 (April), 1–4.
40.
WebberJeffery2015 “Revolution against ‘progress’: neo-extractivism, the compensatory state, and the TIPNIS conflict in Bolivia,” pp. 302–333 in SpronkSusanWebberJeffery (eds.), Crisis and Contradiction: Marxist Perspectives on Latin America in the Global Political Economy. Chicago: Haymarket.
41.
WeylandKurt2013 “The threat from the populist left.” Journal of Democracy24 (July): 18–32.
42.
WolffJonas2016 “Business power and the politics of postneoliberalism: relations between governments and economic elites in Bolivia and Ecuador.” Latin American Politics and Society58 (2): 124–147.
