We analyzed a data set containing 7,216 hostage and barricade incidents that had been reported to the Federal Bureau of Investigation over a 35-year period. From two subsamples of the data set, we identified potential predictors of important outcomes—resolution by negotiation or surrender and violence after onset. In a third subsample, we combined and weighted the potential predictors to form two actuarial tools. We used three additional subsamples in the data set to cross-validate and calibrate the scores of each tool. Predictive validity was acceptable across all subsamples.
AaklA. E.OxmanA. D.HerrinJ.VistG. E.TerrenatoI.SperatiF.CostiniukC.BlankD.SchunemannH. (2011). Using alternative statistical formats for presenting risks and risk reductions. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3, Article CD006776.
2.
ÆgisdottirS.WhiteM.SpenglerP.MaughermanA.AndersonL. A.CookR. S.NicholsC. N.LampropoulosG. K.WalkerB. S.CohenG.RushJ. D. (2006). The meta-analysis of clinical judgment project: Fifty-six years of accumulated research on clinical versus statistical accuracy. The Counseling Psychologist, 34, 341–382.
3.
AmmanM.MacKizerM. (2017). A crisis threat assessment: The boy in the bunker. Journal of Threat Assessment and Management, 4(2), 77–97.
4.
ArinK. P.FeessE.KuhlenkasperT.ReichO. F. M. (2019). Negotiating with terrorists: The costs of compliance. Southern Economic Journal, 86(1), 305–317.
5.
BatastiniA. B.VitaccoM. J.CoakerL. C.LesterM. E. (2019). Communicating violence risk during testimony: Do different formats lead to different perceptions among jurors?Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 25(2), 92–106.
6.
BeauregardE.MichaudP. (2015). “HIGH-RISK”: A useful tool for improving police decision-making in hostage and barricade incidents. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 30, 125–138.
7.
BerkR. A.SorensonS. B. (2020). Algorithmic approach to forecasting rare violent events: An illustration based on intimate partner violence perpetration. Criminology & Public Policy, 19(1), 213–233.
8.
BolzF. A. (2001). Intelligence requirements in hostage situations. The Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 1, 61–68.
9.
BoothB.VecchiG. M.AnglemanA. J.FinneyE. J.MarkerC.RomanoS. J.Van HasseltV. B. (2010). Captive-taking incidents in the context of domestic violence: A descriptive analysis. Victims & Offenders, 5(2), 183–198.
10.
BoothB.VecchiG. M.FinneyE. J.Van HasseltV. B.RomanoS. J. (2009). Captive-taking incidents in the context of workplace violence: Descriptive analysis and case examples. Victims & Offenders, 4(1), 76–92.
11.
BuchterR. B.FechtelpeterD.KnelangenM.EhrlichM.WalteringA. (2014). Words or numbers? Communicating risk of adverse effects in written consumer health information: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 14, Article e76.
12.
ButlerW. M.LeitenbergH.FuselierG. D. (1993). The use of mental health professional consultants to police hostage negotiation teams. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 11, 213–221.
13.
CampbellM. A.FrenchS.GendreauP. (2009). The prediction of violence in adult offenders: A meta-analytic comparison of instruments and methods of assessment. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 36(6), 567–590.
14.
CanterD.YoungsD. (2009). Investigative psychology: Offender profiling and the analysis of criminal action. Wiley.
15.
CookeD. J.MichieC. (2010). Limitations of diagnostic precision and predictive utility in the individual case: A challenge for forensic practice. Law and Human Behavior, 34, 259–210.
16.
CorsiJ. R. (1981). Terrorism as a desperate game: Fear, bargaining, and communication in the terrorist event. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 25, 47–85.
17.
DanielsJ. A.AnglemanA. J.GrinnanE. (2015). Standardizing research methods on violent offenders: Perpetrator-motive research design and consensual qualitative research. Aggression and Violence Behavior, 21, 125–132.
18.
DanielsJ. A.BradleyM. C.CramerD. P.WinklerA. J.KinebrewK.CrockettD. (2007). The successful resolution of armed hostage/barricade events in schools: A qualitative analysis. Psychology in the Schools, 44(6), 601–613.
19.
DawesR. M. (1979). The robust beauty of improper linear models in decision making. American Psychologist, 34(7), 571–582.
20.
DawesR. M.FaustD.MeehlP. E. (1989). Clinical versus actuarial judgment. Science, 243, 1668–1674.
DonohueW. A.TaylorP. J. (2003). Testing the role effect in terrorist organizations. International Negotiations, 8(3), 527–547.
23.
DuganL.LaFreeG.PiqueroA. R. (2005). Testing a rational choice model of airline hijackings. Criminology, 43(4), 1031–1065.
24.
FagerlinA.Zikmund-FisherB. J.UbelP. A. (2011). Helping patients decide: Ten steps to better risk communication. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 103(19), 1436–1443.
25.
FarringtonD.MacLeodJ.PiqueroA. (2016). Mathematical models of criminal careers: Deriving and testing quantitative predictions. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 53(3), 336–355.
26.
FaureG. (2003). Negotiating with terrorists: The hostage case. International Negotiation: A Journal of Theory and Practice, 8(3), 469–494.
27.
FeldmannT. B. (2001). Characteristics of hostage and barricade incidents: Implications for negotiation strategies and training. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 1(1), 3–33.
28.
FreilichJ. D.ChermakS. M.KleinB. R. (2020). Investigating the applicability of situational crime prevention to the public mass violence context. Criminology & Public Policy, 19(1), 271–293.
29.
FuselierG. D. (1999). Placing the Stockholm syndrome in perspective. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 68, 22–25.
30.
GelmanA.HillJ.YajimaM. (2012). Why we (usually) don’t have to worry about multiple comparisons. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 5(2), 189–211.
31.
GroveW. M.MeehlP. E. (1996). Comparative efficiency of informal (subjective, impressionistic) and formal (mechanical, logarithmic) prediction procedures: The clinical-statistical controversy. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2, 293–323.
32.
GroveW. M.ZaldD. H.LebowB. S.SnitzB. E.NelsonC. (2000). Clinical versus mechanical prediction: A meta-analysis. Psychological Assessment, 12(1), 19–30.
33.
GrubbA. R. (2020). Understanding the prevalence and situational characteristics of hostage and crisis negotiation in England: An analysis of pilot data from the National Negotiator Deployment Database. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 35, 98–111.
34.
HansonR. K.Morton-BourgonK. E. (2009). The accuracy of recidivism risk assessments for sexual offenders: A meta-analysis of 118 prediction studies. Psychological Assessment, 21(1), 1–21.
35.
HarrisG. T.LowenkampC. T.HiltonN. Z. (2015). Evidence for risk estimate precision: Implications for individual risk communication. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 33(1), 111–127.
36.
HarrisG. T.RiceM. E.QuinseyV. L. (2008). Shall evidence-based risk assessment be abandoned?The British Journal of Psychiatry, 192, 154.
37.
HarrisG. T.RiceM. E.QuinseyV. L.CormierC. (2015). Violent offenders: Appraising and managing risk (3rd ed.). American Psychological Association.
38.
HartS. D.CookeD. J. (2013). Another look at the (im-)precision of individual risk estimates made using actuarial risk assessment instruments. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 31(1), 81–102.
39.
HartS. D.MichieC.CookeD. J. (2007). Precision of actuarial risk assessment instruments: Evaluating the “margins of error” of group v. individual predictions of violence. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 190(Suppl. 49), s60–s65.
40.
HeilbrunK. (2009). Evaluation of violence risk in adults. Oxford University Press.
41.
HeppenstallL.HammondS. (2018). Differentiating crisis incidents: A replication study using the action systems model. Journal of Investigative Psychology and Offender Profiling, 15(2), 162–174.
42.
ImreyP.DawidA. P. (2015). A commentary on statistical assessment of violence recidivism risk. Statistics and Public Policy, 2(1), 1–18.
43.
JoslynS. L.LeClercJ. E. (2012). Uncertainty forecasts improve weather-related decisions and attenuate the effects of forecast error. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 18(1), 126–140.
44.
KatzE. (2017). Using crisis negotiation team methods to decrease violence in prisons. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 18(3), 883–904.
45.
KerstenG. E.MichalowskiW.MatwinS.SzpakowiczS. (1988). Representing the negotiation process with a rule-based formalism. Theory and Decision, 25, 225–257.
46.
KerstenG. E.ZhangG. (2003). Mining Inspire data for the determinants of successful internet negotiations. Central European Journal of Operations Research, 11(3), 297–316.
47.
LipetskerA. (2004). Evaluating the hostage barricade database system (HOBAS). Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 4, 3–27.
48.
McDowellM.JacobsP. (2017). Meta-analysis of the effect of natural frequencies on Bayesian reasoning. Psychological Bulletin, 143(12), 1273–1312.
49.
McGowanH. M. (2004). Context, containment and conversation model: A study of the New York City Police Department’s hostage and barricade resolution strategies [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. City University of New York.
50.
McGowanH. M. (2007). A prediction model for incident resolution. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 7(2), 53–83.
51.
MeehlP. E.RosenA. (1955). Antecedent probability and the efficiency of psychometric signs, patterns, or cutting scores. Psychological Bulletin, 52(3), 194–216.
52.
MichaudP.St-YvesM.GuayJ.-P. (2008). Predictive modeling in hostage and barricade incidents. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 35(9), 1136–1155.
53.
MohandieK.MeloyJ. R. (2010). Hostage and barricade incidents within an officer-involved shooting sample: Suicide by cop, intervention efficacy, and descriptive characteristics. Journal of Police Crisis Negotiations, 10, 101–115.
54.
MossmanD. (2015). From group data to useful probabilities: The relevance of actuarial risk assessment in individual instances. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 43(1), 93–102.
55.
MossmanD.SellkeT. (2007). Avoiding errors about “margins of error.”The British Journal of Psychiatry, 191(6), 561.
56.
MradD. F.NellerD. J. (2015). Legal, clinical, and scientific foundations of violence risk assessment. In PietzC.MattsonC. (Eds.), Violent offenders: Understanding and assessment (pp. 329–341). Oxford University Press.
57.
MurphyR. A. (2001). Hostage and barricade incidents: A profiling perspective [Unpublished master’s thesis]. Columbus State University.
58.
NellerD. J.FrederickR. I. (2013). Classification accuracy of actuarial risk assessment instruments. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 31(1), 141–153.
59.
NellerD. J.VitaccoM. J. (2015). Institutional violence risk: Theory, assessment, and management. In PietzC.MattsonC. (Eds.), Violent offenders: Understanding and assessment (pp. 269–289). Oxford University Press.
60.
NoesnerG. W. (1999). Negotiation concepts for commanders. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 68, 6–14.
61.
O’NeilC. (2016). Weapons of math destruction: How big data increases inequality and threatens democracy. Broadway Books.
62.
PaulosJ. A. (1988). Innumeracy: Mathematical illiteracy and its consequences. Hill & Wang.
63.
PetersE. (2008). Numeracy and the perception and communication of risk. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1128, 1–7.
64.
PhillipsE. (2015). How do kidnappers kill hostages? A comparison of terrorist and criminal groups. Homicide Studies, 19(2), 123–148.
65.
PiresS.GueretteR.ShariatiA. (2017). Specifying kidnapping for ransom epidemics at the global level: A matched-case control design. Studies in Conflict and Terrorism, 40(2), 139–156.
66.
ReginiC. (2002). Crisis intervention for law enforcement negotiators. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 73(10), 1–6.
67.
RichardF. D.BondC. F.Stokes-ZootaJ. J. (2003). One hundred years of social psychology quantitatively described. Review of General Psychology, 7(4), 331–363.
68.
SharmaS.BottomW. P.ElfenbeinH. A. (2013). On the role of personality, cognitive ability, and emotional intelligence on negotiation outcomes: A meta-analysis. Organizational Psychology Review, 3(4), 293–336.
69.
SinghJ. P.FazelS.GueorguievaR.BuchananA. (2014). Rates of violence in patients classified as high risk by structured risk assessment instruments. British Journal of Psychiatry, 204(3), 180–187.
70.
SlatkinA. A. (2003). Suicide risk and hostage/barricade situations involving older persons. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 72(4), 26–32.
71.
TrevenaL. J.Zikmund-FisherB. J.EdwardsA.GaissmaierW.GalesicM.HanP. K.KingJ.LawsonM. L.LinderS. K.KipkinsI.OzanneE.PetersE.TimmermansD.WoloshinS. (2013). Presenting quantitative information about decision outcomes: A risk communication primer for patient decision aid developers. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 13, S7.
72.
TurnerJ. T. (1988). Hostage-takers in health care settings. Psychiatric Clinics, 11(4), 649–664.
73.
Van HasseltV. B.FloodJ. J.RomanoS. J.VecchiV. M.de FabriqueN.DalfonzoV. A. (2005). Hostage-taking in the context of domestic violence: Some case examples. Journal of Family Violence, 20, 21–27.
74.
VecchiG. M. (2002). Hostage/barricade management: A hidden conflict within law enforcement. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, 71(5), 1–7.
75.
VecchiG. M.Van HasseltV. B.AnglemanA. J. (2013). The perpetrator-motive research design: A strategy for understanding motivations, values, and tactics of criminal offenders. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 18, 11–18.
76.
VecchiG. M.Van HasseltV. B.RomanoS. J. (2005). Crisis (hostage) negotiation: Current strategies and issues in high-risk conflict resolution. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 10, 533–551.
77.
VollmB. A.BickleA.GibbonS. (2013). Incidents of hostage-taking in an English high-secure hospital. The Journal of Forensic Psychiatry & Psychology, 24(1), 16–30.
78.
WesseliusC. L.DeSarnoJ. V. (1983). The anatomy of a hostage situation. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 1, 33–45.
79.
WestS. L.SquiersL. B.McCormackL.SouthwellB. G.BrouwerE. S.AshokM.LuxL.BoudewynsV.O’DonoghueA.SullivanH. W. (2013). Communicating quantitative risks and benefits in promotional prescription drug labeling or print advertising. Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 22(5), 447–458.
80.
WilsonE. B. (1927). Probable inference, the law of succession, and statistical inference. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 22, 158, 209–212.
81.
WilsonM. A. (2000). Toward a model of terrorist behavior in hostage-taking incidents. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 44, 403–424.
82.
WrightS. A. (1999). Anatomy of a government massacre: Abuses of hostage-barricade protocols during the Waco standoff. Terrorism and Political Violence, 11(2), 39–68.
83.
YunM.RothM. (2008). Terrorist hostage-taking and kidnapping: Using script theory to predict the fate of a hostage. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 31(8), 736–748.
84.
ZipkinD.UnscheldC. A.KeatingN. L.AllenE.AungK.BeythR.KaatzS.MannD. M.SussmanJ. B.KorensteinD.SchardtC.NagiA.SloanR.FeinsteinD. A. (2014). Evidence-based risk communication: A systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine, 161(4), 270–280.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
