Studies have identified that police officers often support and value evidence-based policing (EBP), but nevertheless prefer relying on experience when making decisions. Yet, policing scholars have paid little attention to the generality of this proclivity, the psychological mechanisms behind it, or to its implications for implementing EBP. The present study illuminates this phenomenon. We review its psychological foundations and use a survey of high-ranking officers from the Israel Police to examine its prevalence. We find that while officers support EBP overall, they believe that decisions should be based primarily on experience, not research. The two were found to be separate (although correlated) constructs. Furthermore, we find that the preference for experience as the basis for decision making is an overarching trait, not associated with personal-level characteristics. We discuss the implications of our findings and argue that attempts to implement EBP should recognize and work with this inherent psychological inclination.
AndresenL.BoudD.CohenR. (2000). Experience-based learning. In FoleyG. (Ed.), Understanding adult education and training (2nd ed., pp. 225-239). Sydney, Australia: Allen & Unwin.
2.
BayleyD. H.BittnerE. (1984). Learning the skills of policing. Law & Contemporary Problems, 47, 35-59.
3.
CaseyY. (2017). “Classic policing”: The empirical basis for the “Emun” reform in the Israel Police. In ZisoM. (Ed.), The essence of research (pp. 13-39). Jerusalem: The Israel Police, Planning and Organization Department, Strategic Division. (In Hebrew)
4.
ClarkeR. V. (1980). “Situational” crime prevention: Theory and practice. British Journal of Criminology, 20, 136-147.
5.
CrankJ. P. (2003). Institutional theory of police: A review of the state of the art. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 26, 186-207.
6.
EckJ. E.SpelmanW. (1987). Problem-solving: Problem-oriented policing in Newport News. Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.
7.
EinhornH. J. (1986). Accepting error to make less error. Journal of Personality Assessment, 50, 387-395.
8.
EpsteinS. (1973). The self-concept revisited: Or a theory of a theory. American Psychologist, 28, 404-416.
9.
FestingerL. (1957). A theory of cognitive dissonance. Evanston, IL: Row Peterson.
10.
FlemingJ.RhodesR. (2018). Can experience be evidence? Craft knowledge and evidence-based policing. Policy & Politics, 46(1), 3-26.
11.
GilukT. L.RynesS. L. (2012). Research findings practitioners resist: Lessons for management academics from evidence-based medicine. In RousseauD. M. (Ed.), The Oxford hand-book of evidence-based management (pp. 130-164). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
GreeneJ. (2014). New directions in policing: Balancing prediction and meaning in police research. Justice Quarterly, 31, 193-228.
14.
GroveW. M.MeehlP. E. (1996). Comparative efficiency of informal (subjective, impressionistic) and formal (mechanical, algorithmic) prediction procedures: The clinical–statistical controversy. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2, 293-323.
15.
HannesK.PietersG.GoedhuysJ.AertgeertsB. (2010). Exploring barriers to the implementation of evidence-based practice in psychiatry to inform health policy: A focus group based study. Community Mental Health Journal, 46, 423-432.
16.
HighhouseS. (2008). Stubborn reliance on intuition and subjectivity in employee selection. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 1, 333-342.
17.
HodgkinsonG. P.Sadler-SmithE.BurkeL. A.ClaxtonG.SparrowP. R. (2009). Intuition in organizations: Implications for strategic management. Long Range Planning, 42, 277-297.
18.
HunterG.WigzellA.MayT.McSweeneyT. (2015). An evaluation of the “What Works Centre for Crime Reduction”: Year 1: Baseline. London, England: Institute for Criminal Policy Research.
19.
Jonathan-ZamirT.HarpazA. (2018). Predicting support for procedurally just treatment: The case of the Israel National Police. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 45, 840-862.
20.
Jonathan-ZamirT.WeisburdD.HasisiB. (2015). Editors introduction. In Jonathan-ZamirT.WeisburdD.HasisiB. (Eds.), Policing in Israel: Studying crime control, community and counterterrorism (pp. 1-6). Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
21.
KahnemanD.TverskyA. (1973). On the psychology of prediction. Psychological Review, 80, 237-251.
22.
KuhnK. (1997). Communicating uncertainty: Framing effects on responses to vague probabilities. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 71, 55-83.
23.
Laufman-GavriL.HasisiB. (2017, November15). “Let my station go”: Reforming police practices in Israel. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Philadelphia, PA.
LumC. (2009). Translating police research into practice. Ideas in American Policing, 11, 1-15.
26.
LumC.KoperC. S. (2017). Evidence-based policing: Translating research into practice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
27.
LumC.TelepC. W.KoperC.GriecoJ. (2012). Receptivity to research in policing. Justice Research and Policy, 14, 61-95.
28.
MillsJ.FieldJ.CantR. (2009). The place of knowledge and evidence in the context of Australian general practice nursing. Worldviews on Evidence-based Nursing, 6, 219-228.
29.
MinkL. O. (1978). Narrative form as a cognitive instrument. In CanaryR. H.KozickiH. (Eds.), The writing of history: Literary form and historical understanding (pp. 129-149). Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
30.
MuirW. K. (1977). Police: Streetcorner politicians. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
31.
NeyroudP.WeisburdD. (2014). Transforming the police through science: The challenge of ownership. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 8, 287-293.
32.
NixJ.PickettJ. T.BaekH.AlpertG. P. (2017). Police research, officer surveys, and response rates. Policing & Society. Advance online publication. doi:10.1080/10439463.2017.1394300
33.
O’BrienR. M. (2007). A caution regarding rules of thumb for variance inflation factors. Quality & Quantity, 41, 673-690.
President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. (2015). Final report. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
36.
RousseauD. M.GuniaB. C. (2016). Evidence-based practice: The psychology of evidence-based policing implementation. Annual Review of Psychology, 67, 667-692.
37.
RuscioJ. (2010). Irrational beliefs stemming from judgment errors: Cognitive limitations, biases, and experiential learning. In DavidD.LynnS. J.EllisA. (Eds.), Rational and irrational beliefs: Research, theory, and clinical practice (pp. 291-312). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
38.
SalasE.RosenM. A.Diaz GranadosD. (2010). Expertise-based intuition and decision making in organizations. Journal of Management, 36, 941-973.
39.
SchreiberJ.SternP. (2005). A review of the literature on evidence-based practice in physical therapy. The Internet Journal of Allied Health Sciences and Practice, 3, 2-10.
40.
ShermanL. W. (1984). Experiments in police discretion: Scientific boon or dangerous knowledge?Law and Contemporary Problems, 47, 61-81.
41.
ShermanL. W. (1998). Evidence-based policing. Ideas in American Policing, 2, 1-15.
42.
ShermanL. W. (2015). A tipping point for “totally evidenced policing”: Ten ideas for building an evidence-based police agency. International Criminal Justice Review, 25(1), 11-29.
43.
SkolnickJ. H.BayleyD. H. (1988). Theme and variation in community policing. Crime and Justice, 10, 1-37.
44.
SparrowM. K. (2011). Governing science: New perspectives in policing. Washington, DC: Department of Justice, National Institute of Justice.
45.
StewardR. E.StirmanS. W.ChamblessD. L. (2012). A qualitative investigation of practicing psychologists’ attitudes toward research-informed practice: Implications for dissemination strategies. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 43, 100-109.
46.
SwennenM. H.van der HeijdenG. J.BoeijeH. R.van RheenenN.VerheulF. J.van der GraafY.KalkmanC. J. (2013). Doctors’ perceptions and use of evidence-based medicine: A systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative studies. Academic Medicine, 88, 1384-1396.
47.
TelepC. W. (2016). Expanding the scope of evidence-based policing. Criminology & Public Policy, 15(1), 243-252.
48.
TelepC. W. (2017). Police officer receptivity to research and evidence-based policing: Examining variability within and across agencies. Crime & Delinquency, 63, 976-999.
49.
TelepC. W.LumC. (2014). The receptivity of officers to empirical research and evidence-based policing: An examination of survey data from three agencies. Police Quarterly, 17, 359-385.
50.
TelepC. W.WinegarS. (2015). Police executive receptivity to research: A survey of chiefs and sheriffs in Oregon. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 10, 241-249.
51.
ThomasA.LawM. (2013). Research utilization and evidence-based practice in occupational therapy: A scoping study. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 67(4), e55-e65.
52.
TonelliM. R.CurtisJ. R.GuntupalliK. K.RubenfeldG. D.ArroligaA. C.BrochardL.ManceboJ. (2012). An official multi-society statement: The role of clinical research results in the practice of critical care medicine. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 185, 1117-1124.
53.
TverskyA.KahnemanD. (1973). Availability: A heuristic for judging frequency and probability. Cognitive Psychology, 5, 207-232.
54.
TylerT. R. (2009). Legitimacy and criminal justice: The benefits of self-regulation. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, 7, 307-359.
55.
WeisburdD.JonathanT.PerryS. (2009). The Israeli model for policing terrorism: Goals, strategies, and open questions. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 36, 1259-1278.
56.
WeisburdD.MajmundarK. (Eds.) (2018). Proactive policing: Effects on crime and communities. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
WillisJ. J. (2013). Improving police: What’s craft got to do with it?Ideas in American Policing, 16, 1-13.
59.
WillisJ. J.MastrofskiS. D. (2014). Pulling together: Integrating craft and science. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice, 8, 321-329.
60.
WillisJ. J.MastrofskiS. D.WeisburdD. (2007). Making sense of COMPSTAT: A theory-based analysis of organizational change in three police departments. Law & Society Review, 41(1), 147-188.
61.
WilsonJ. Q. (1978). Varieties of police behavior: The management of law and order in eight communities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
62.
ZissoM. (2017). “High policing”: The empirical basis for the “Emun” reform in the Israel Police. In ZissoM. (Ed.), The essence of research (pp. 41-58). Jerusalem: The Israel Police, Planning and Organization Department, Strategic Division. (In Hebrew)
