The Comparative Efficacy of a Hybrid Guilt-Fear Appeal and a Traditional Fear Appeal to Influence HPV Vaccination Intentions

Abstract

Recent research on persuasion has explored the utility of incorporating alternative emotional appeals within a fear-appeal framework to achieve persuasive outcomes. The current study contributes to this growing body of research by developing and assessing a hybrid guilt-fear message to increase human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination intentions and comparing it to a standard fear appeal. An online experiment among men and women of vaccination age (N = 407) was conducted. Results detail the paths through which people processed the hybrid and fear appeals differently, and clarify the conditions in which utilizing guilt-based messaging strategies within a fear-appeal framework can facilitate or inhibit persuasive effectiveness. Implications for future research on multiemotion intervention messages are discussed.

Keywords

guilt fear emotional appeals fear appeals HPV cancer prevention

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aiken

L. S.

West

S. G.

(1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Basil

D. Z.

Ridgway

N. M.

Basil

M. D.

(2006). Guilt appeals: The mediating effect of responsibility. Psychology and Marketing, 23, 1035-1054. doi:10.1002/mar.20145

Berinsky

A. J.

Huber

G. A.

Lenz

G. S.

(2012). Evaluating online labor markets for experimental research: Amazon.com’s Mechanical Turk. Political Analysis, 20, 351-368. doi:10.1093/pan/mpr057

Buhrmester

Kwang

Gosling

S. D.

(2011). Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A new source of inexpensive, yet high-quality, data? Perspectives on Psychological Science, 6, 3-5. doi:10.1177/1745691610393980

Byrne

B. M.

(2011). Structural equation modeling with Mplus: Basic concepts, applications, and programming. New York, NY: Routledge.

Caprara

G. V.

Barbaranelli

Pastorelli

Cermak

Rosza

(2001). Facing guilt: Role of negative affectivity, need for reparation, and fear of punishment in leading to prosocial behaviour and aggression. European Journal of Personality, 15, 219-237. doi:10.1002/per.402

Carcioppolo

Jensen

J. D.

Wilson

S. R.

Collins

W. B.

Carrion

Linnemeier

(2013). Examining HPV threat-to-efficacy ratios in the extended parallel process model. Health Communication, 28, 20-28. doi:10.1080/10410236.2012.719478

Caskey

Lindau

S. T.

Alexander

G. C.

(2009). Knowledge and early adoption of the HPV vaccine among girls and young women: Results of a national survey. Journal of Adolescent Health, 45, 453-462. doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2009.04.021

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2014). Recommended adult immunization schedule, by vaccine and age group. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/schedules/hcp/imz/adult.html

10.

Chang

C.-T.

(2012). Are guilt appeals a panacea in green advertising? The right formula of issue proximity and environmental consciousness. International Journal of Advertising, 31, 741-771. doi:10.2501/IJA-31-4-741-771

11.

Coulter

R. H.

Pinto

M. B.

(1995). Guilt appeals in advertising: What are their effects? Journal of Applied Psychology, 80, 697-705. doi:10.1037/0021-9010.80.6.697

12.

Dillard

J. P.

Shen

(2005). On the nature of reactance and its role in persuasive health communication. Communication Monographs, 72, 144-168. doi:10.1080/03637750500111815

13.

Englis

B. G.

(1990). Consumer emotional reactions to television advertising and their effects on message recall. In Agres

S. J.

Edee

J. A.

Dubitsky

T. M.

(Eds.), Emotion in advertising: Theoretical and practical applications (pp. 231-253). New York, NY: Quorum Books.

14.

Ferenidou

Salakos

Vaidakis

Paltoglou

Bakalianou

Papadimitriou

Creatsas

(2012). The impact of HPV diagnosis on women’s sexual and mental health: Preliminary findings. Clinical and Experimental Obstetrics & Gynecology, 39, 79-82.

15.

Friedman

A. L.

Shepeard

(2007). Exploring the knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and communication preferences of the general public regarding HPV: Findings from CDC focus group research and implications for practice. Health Education & Behavior, 34, 471-485. doi:10.1177/1090198106292022

16.

Gerend

M. A.

Lee

S. C.

Shepherd

J. E.

(2007). Predictors of human papillomavirus vaccination acceptability among underserved women. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 34, 468-471. doi:10.1097/1001.olq.0000245915.0000238315.bd

17.

Hayes

A. F.

(2013). Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

18.

Hayes

A. F.

Matthes

(2009). Computational procedures for probing interactions in OLS and logistic regression: SPSS and SAS implementations. Behavior Research Methods, 41, 924-936.

19.

Hibbert

Smith

Davies

Ireland

(2007). Guilt appeals: Persuasion knowledge and charitable giving. Psychology & Marketing, 24, 723-742. doi:10.1002/mar.20181

20.

Hovland

Janis

Kelly

(1953). Communication and persuasion. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

21.

Bentler

P. M.

(1999). Fit indices in covariance structure modeling: Sensitivity to underparameterized model misspecification. Psychological Methods, 3, 424-453. doi:10.1037/1082-989X.7.1.83

22.

Huhmann

B. A.

Brotherton

T. P.

(1997). A content analysis of guilt appeals in popular magazine advertisements. Journal of Advertising, 26, 35-46. doi:10.1080/00913367.1997.10673521

23.

Izard

C. E.

(1977). Human emotions. New York, NY: Plenum Press.

24.

Janis

I. L.

(1967). Effects of fear arousal on attitude change: Recent developments in theory and experimental research. In Berkowitz

(Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (pp. 166-225). New York, NY: Academic Press.

25.

Krieger

J. L.

Sarge

M. A.

(2013). A serial mediation model of message framing on intentions to receive the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine: Revisiting the role of threat and efficacy perceptions. Health Communication, 28, 5-19. doi:10.1080/10410236.2012.734914

26.

Lee-Wingate

S. N.

Moon

J. Y.

Bose

(2014). The influence of mortality focus on guilt advertising effectiveness. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 22, 103-114. doi:10.2753/MTP1069-6679220107

27.

Leippe

M. R.

Elkin

R. A.

(1987). When motives clash: Issue involvement and response involvement as determinants of persuasion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52, 269-278. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.52.2.269

28.

Leventhal

(1970). Findings and theory from fear communications. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 5, 119-186.

29.

Lewis

Watson

White

K. M.

(2013). Extending the explanatory utility of the EPPM beyond fear-based persuasion. Health Communication, 28, 84-98. doi:10.1080/10410236.2013.743430

30.

Lindsey

L. L. M.

Yun

K. A.

Hill

J. B.

(2007). Anticipated guilt as motivation to help unknown others: An examination of empathy as a moderator. Communication Research, 34, 468-480. doi:10.1177/0093650207302789

31.

Maddux

J. E.

Rogers

R. W.

(1983). Protection motivation and self-efficacy: A revised theory of fear appeals and attitude change. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 19, 469-479. doi:10.1016/0022-1031(83)90023-9

32.

McCaffery

Waller

Nazroo

Wardle

(2006). Social and psychological impact of HPV testing in cervical screening: A qualitative study. Sexually Transmitted Infections, 82, 169-174. doi:10.1136/sti.2005.016436

33.

Mukherjee

Dubé

(2012). Mixing emotions: The use of humor in fear advertising. Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 11, 147-161. doi:10.1002/cb.389

34.

O’Keefe

D. J.

(2002). Guilt as a mechanism of persuasion. In Dillard

J. P.

Pfau

M. V.

(Eds.), The persuasion handbook: Developments in theory and practice (pp. 329-344). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

35.

Petty

R. E.

Cacioppo

J. T.

(1979). Issue involvement can increase or decrease persuasion by enhancing message-relevant cognitive responses. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37, 1915-1926.

36.

Pinto

M. B.

Priest

(1991). Guilt appeals in advertising: An exploratory study. Psychological Reports, 69, 375-385. doi:10.2466/pr0.1991.69.2.375

37.

Plutchik

(1994). The psychology and biology of emotion. New York, NY: HarperCollins.

38.

Preacher

K. J.

Hayes

A. F.

(2008). Contemporary approaches to assessing mediation in communication research. In Hayes

A. F.

Slater

M. D.

Snyder

L. B.

(Eds.), The Sage sourcebook of advanced data analysis methods for communication research (pp. 13-54). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

39.

Quick

B. L.

Bates

B. R.

Romina

(2009). Examining antecedents of clean indoor air policy support: Implications for campaigns promoting clean indoor air. Health Communication, 24, 50-59. doi:10.1080/10410230802606992

40.

Quick

B. L.

Kam

J. A.

Morgan

S. E.

Montero Liberona

C. A.

Smith

R. A.

(2015). Prospect theory, discrete emotions, and freedom threats: An extension of psychological reactance theory. Journal of Communication, 65, 40-61. doi:10.1111/jcom.12134

41.

Rawlings

E. L.

(1970). Reactive guilt and anticipatory guilt in altruistic behavior. In Macaulay

Berkowitz

(Eds.), Altruism and helping behavior (pp. 163-177). New York, NY: Academic Press.

42.

Rimal

R. N.

Real

(2003). Perceived risk and efficacy beliefs as motivators of change. Human Communication Research, 29, 370-399.

43.

Rogers

R. W.

(1975). A protection motivation theory of fear appeals and attitude change. The Journal of Psychology, 91, 93-114.

44.

Rosenstock

I. M.

Strecher

V. J.

Becker

M. H.

(1988). Social learning theory and the health belief model. Health Education and Behavior, 15, 175-183. doi:10.1177/109019818801500203

45.

Sutton

S. R.

(1982). Fear-arousing communications: A critical examination of theory and research. In Eiser

J. R.

(Ed.), Social psychology and behavioral medicine (pp. 303-337). London, England: Wiley.

46.

Turner

M. M.

(2012). Using emotional appeals in health messages. In Cho

(Ed.), Health message design: Theory and practice (pp. 59-71). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

47.

Vansteelandt

Van Mechelen

Nezlek

J. B.

(2005). The co-occurrence of emotions in daily life: A multilevel approach. Journal of Research in Personality, 39, 325-335. doi:10.1016/j.jrp.2004.05.006

48.

Voss

K. E.

(2009). Using humor in conjunction with negative consequences in advertising. Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising, 31, 25-39.

49.

Witte

(1994). Fear control and danger control: A test of the extended parallel process model (EPPM). Communication Monographs, 61, 113-134. doi:10.1080/03637759409376328

50.

Witte

Cameron

K. A.

McKeon

J. K.

Berkowitz

J. M.

(1996). Predicting risk behaviors: Development and validation of a Diagnostic Scale. Journal of Health Communication, 1, 317-341.