Parasomnias,Violence and the Law

Abstract

In this review, we trace the parallel development of scientific understanding of parasomnias and the jurisprudence of violent behavior during sleep. Before sleep physiology was studied, it was generally self-evident that sleeping persons would not be criminally responsible. Though the problem of malingering was acknowledged in early American forensic psychiatry, the defendant with sleepwalking or sleep drunkenness was treated leniently. Over the past half century, sleep physiology has been examined and there is a developing nomenclature for sleep disorders. Though there is no clear-cut correlation between violence and sleep, several parasomnias have been implicated. We discuss contemporary concepts of parasomnias and suggest how expert witnesses might apply this knowledge to the difficult matter of assessing criminal intent and responsibility.

Keywords

Criminal responsibility parasomnias sleepwalking violence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Academy of Sleep Medicine. (2005). International classification of sleep disorders. Westchester, IL: Author.

American Law Institute. (1962). Model penal code. Philadelphia, PA: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (1968). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (2nd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (1987). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed. rev.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed. rev.). Washington, DC: Author.

Andersen

M. L.

Poyares

Alves

R. S.

Skomro

, & Tufik

(2007). Sexsomnia: Abnormal sexual behavior during sleep. Brain Research Reviews, 56, 271–282.

Anonymous. (1804). A short view of the craniognomic system of Dr. Gall of Vienna. The Literary Magazine and American Register, 2, 238.

10.

Arboleda-Florez

(2002). On automatism. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 15, 569–576.

11.

Aserinsky

, & Kleitman

(1953). Regularly occurring periods of eye motility, and concomitant phenomena, during sleep. Science, 118, 273–274.

12.

BBC News. (2005, March 10). “Sleepwalker” accused of murder. Retrieved July 1, 2011 from, http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/uk_news/england/manchester/4337309.stm

13.

Barr

(2007, April 27). “Ambien” defense causing headaches for prosecutors. San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/04/27/EDGJEPG7DP1.DTL

14.

Besset

, & Espa

(2001). Disorders of arousal. Reviews in Neurology, 157, 107–111.

15.

Blair

(1977). The medical legal aspects of automatism. Medicine, Science, and the Law, 17, 167–182.

16.

Bondy

S. J.

(1996). A summary of public consultation on reform of the Criminal Code of Canada as related to a defense of self-induced intoxication resulting in automatism. Contemporary Drug Problems, 23, 583–593.

17.

Bonkalo

(1974). Impulsive acts and confusion will states during incomplete arousal from sleep: Criminological and forensic implications. Psychiatric Quarterly, 48, 400–409.

18.

Bourget

, & Whitehurst

(2007). Amnesia and crime. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 35, 469–480.

19.

Bradley v. State, 277 S.W. 147 (Tex. Crim. App. 1925).

20.

Brower

K. J.

Aldrich

M. S.

, & Hall

J. M.

(1998). Polysomnographic and subjective sleep predictors of alcoholic relapse. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, 22, 1864–1871.

21.

Brown

S. G.

(1898). The life of Rufus Choate (6th ed.). Boston: Little, Brown & Co.

22.

Broughton

R.J.

(2000). NREM arousal parasomnias. In Kryger

M. H.

Roth

, & Dement

W. C.

(Eds.), Principles and practice of sleep medicine (pp. 693–706). Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co.

23.

Broughton

Billings

Cartwright

Doucette

Edmeads

Edwardh

(1994). Homicidal somnambulism: A case report. Sleep, 17, 253–264.

24.

Buchanan

(1991). Sleepwalking and indecent exposure. Medicine, Science and the Law, 31, 38–40.

25.

Carskadon

M. A.

, & Dement

W. C.

(2005). In Kryger

M. H.

Roth

, & Dement

W. C.

(Eds.), Principles and practice of sleep medicine (pp. 13–23). Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co.

26.

Cartwright

(2004). Sleepwalking violence: A sleep disorder, a legal dilemma, and a psychological challenge. American Journal of Psychiatry, 161, 1149–1158.

27.

Chelf

(2007, December 1). Lawyer who took sleeping pill cleared of vehicle homicide. Eagle-Tribune. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.eagletribune.com/punews/local_story_335094424

28.

Doghramji

(2005, January 27). Medscape family medicine. Retrieved from http://cme.medscape.com/viewarticle/497982

29.

Ebrahim

I. O.

(2006). Somnambulistic sexual behaviour (sexsomnia). Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine, 13, 219–224.

30.

Espa

Ondze

Deglise

Billiard

, & Besset

(2000). Sleep architecture, slow wave activity, and sleep spindles in adult patients with sleepwalking and sleep terrors. Clinical Neurophysiology, 111, 929–939.

31.

Fain v. Commonwealth, 78 Ky. 183 (1879).

32.

Fenwick

(1987). Somnambulism and the law: A review. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 5, 343–347.

33.

Food and Drug Administration. (2007, April 23). FDA approves first generic versions of Ambien (Zolpidem Tartrate) for the treatment of insomnia. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/NEWS/2007/NEW01587.html

34.

Freud

(1917/1957). A metapsychological supplement to the theory of dreams. In Strachey

(Ed.), The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud: Vol. 14 (pp. 222–235). London: Hogarth Press.

35.

Fulcher v. State, 633 P.2d 142 (Wy. 1981).

36.

Good

M. I.

(1976). The concept of drug automatism. American Journal of Psychiatry, 133, 948–952.

37.

Grant

(2000). While you were sleeping or addicted: A suggested expansion of the automatism doctrine to include an addiction defense. University of Illinois Law Review, 2000, 997–1023.

38.

Guilleminault

Moscovitch

Yuen

, & Poyares

(2002). Atypical sexual behavior during sleep. Psychosomatic Medicine, 64, 328–336.

39.

Harris

, & Kerr

J. M.

(1890). Before and at trial: What should be done by counsel, solicitor and client. Northport, NY: Edward Thompson Co.

40.

Hempel

A. G.

Felthous

A. R.

, & Meloy

J. R.

(2003). Psychotic dream-related aggression: A critical review and proposal. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 8, 599–620.

41.

Hill

C. H.

(1896). Memoir of the Hon. Rufus Choate. Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society, 11, 124–155.

42.

Hobson

J. A.

, & Wohl

(1885/2005). From angels to neurones. Fidenza, Italy: Mattioli.

43.

Horn

(2004). A rude awakening: What to do with the sleepwalking defense? Boston College Law Review, 46, 149–182.

44.

Huapaya

L. V.

(1979). Seven cases of somnambulism induced by drugs. American Journal of Psychiatry, 136, 985–986.

45.

Insanity, crime and the medical expert [Editorial]. (1901, November 2). Medical News, p. 702.

46.

J.M.S. (1846, April 1). The trial of Albert John Tirrell. Prisoner's Friend, p. 50.

47.

Kalant

(1996). Intoxicated automatism: Legal concept vs. scientific evidence. Contemporary Drug Problems, 23, 631–648.

48.

Kales

Jacobson

Paulson

Kales

, & Walter

(1966). Somnambulism: Psychophysiological correlates. I. All-night EEG studies. Archives of General Psychiatry, 14, 586–594.

49.

Klackenberg

(1982). Somnambulism in childhood—Prevalence, course and behavioral correlations. A prospective longitudinal study (6–16 years). Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica, 71, 495–499.

50.

Kotagal

, & Pianosi

(2006). Sleep disorders in children and adolescents. British Medical Journal, 332, 828–832.

51.

Lindsay

(2005, March 26). Man charged with child molestations. The Milford Daily News. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.milforddailynews.com/archive/x1612084296

52.

Lyon

(2009, May 8). 7 criminal cases that invoked the “sleepwalking defense.” U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://health.usnews.com/articles/health/sleep/2009/05/08/7-criminal-cases-that-invoked-the-sleepwalking-defense.html

53.

Mahowald

M.W.

, & Cramer-Bornemann

M. A.

(2005). NREM sleep-arousal parasomnias. In Kryger

M. H.

Roth

, & Dement

W. C.

(Eds.), Principles and practice of sleep medicine (pp. 889–896). Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co.

54.

Mahowald

M.W.

, & Schenck

C.H.

(2005). REM sleep parasomnias. In Kryger

M. H.

Roth

, & Dement

W. C.

(Eds.), Principles and practice of sleep medicine (pp. 897–916). Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co.

55.

Makin

(2009, May 2). Judge rejects “sexsomnia” defence. The Globe and Mail. Retrieved July 1, 2001, from http://www.allvoices.com/news/3126667/s/32249427-globe-and-mail-canada-judge-rejectssexsomnia-defence

56.

Mangan

M. A.

(2004). A phenomenology of problematic sexual behavior occurring in sleep. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 33, 287–293.

57.

Martin

(2009). Can sleepwalking be a murder defense? Retrieved from http://www.lakesidepress.com/pulmonary/sleep/sleep-murder.htm

58.

Mason

, & Pack

(2005). Sleep terrors in childhood. The Journal of Pediatrics, 147, 388–392.

59.

Mason

, & Pack

(2007). Pediatric parasomnias. Sleep, 30, 141–151.

60.

McCarley

R.W.

, & Hobson

J.A.

(1977). The neurobiological origins of psychoanalytic dream theory. American Journal of Psychiatry, 134, 1211–1221.

61.

McClain v. Indiana, 678 N.E.2d 104 (Ind. 1997).

62.

Mills

C. K.

(1886). Lectures on insanity. Medical and Surgical Reporter, 54, 33–37.

63.

Morgan

(2006, April). Are you raping your wife in your sleep? Details. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://charmandrigor.com/clips/details-rapesleep.html.

64.

Nofzinger

E. A.

, & Wettstein

R. M.

(1995). Homicidal behavior and sleep apnea: A case report and medicolegal discussion. Sleep, 18, 776–782.

65.

Nunberg

, & Federn

(Eds). (1962). Minutes of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society: Vol. I: 1906–1908. New York: International Universities Press.

66.

Ohayon

M. M.

Caulet

, & Priest

R.G.

(1997). Violent behavior during sleep. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 58, 369–376.

67.

Ohayon

M. M.

Guilleminault

, & Priest

R. G.

(1999). Night terrors, sleepwalking, and confusional arousals in the general population: Their frequency and relationship to other sleep and mental disorders. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 60, 268–276.

68.

Parker

E. G.

(1860). Reminiscences of Rufus Choate, the great American advocate. New York: Mason Brothers.

69.

People v. Sedeno, 518 P.2d 913 (Cal. 1974).

70.

Petit

Touchette

Tremblay

R. E.

Boivin

, & Montplasir

(2007). Dysomnias and parasomnias in early childhood. Pediatrics, 119, 1016–1025.

71.

Plante

D. T.

, & Winkelman

J. W.

(2008). Parasomnias: Psychiatric considerations. Sleep Medicine Clinics, 3, 217–229.

72.

Podolsky

(1959). Somnambulistic homicide. Diseases of the Nervous System, 20, 534–536.

73.

Podolsky

(1964). Somnambulistic homicide. American Journal of Psychiatry, 121, 191–192.

74.

Pressman

M. R.

(2007a). Factors that predispose, prime and precipitate NREM parasomnias in adults: Clinical and forensic implications. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 11, 5–33.

75.

Pressman

M. R.

(2007b). Response to Rosalind Cartwright's letter to the editor. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 11, 329–333.

76.

Pressman

M. R.

Mahowald

M.W.

Schenck

C. H.

, & Cramer-Bornemann

M. A.

(2007). Alcohol-induced sleepwalking or confusional arousal as a defense to criminal behavior: A review of scientific evidence, methods and forensic considerations. Journal of Sleep Research, 16, 198–212.

77.

Ray

(1853). A treatise on the medical jurisprudence of insanity (3rd ed.). Boston: Little, Brown & Co.

78.

R. v. Parks, 2 SCR 871 (1992).

79.

R. v. Quick, QB 910 (1973).

80.

R. v. Teepell, Walkerton 05–543 (2009).

81.

Rosenfeld

, & Elhajjar

(1998). Sleepsex: A variant of sleepwalking. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 27, 269–278.

82.

Rubin

(1999a, July 1). Wake-up call. Phoenix New Times. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/1999-07-01/news/wake-up-call

83.

Rubin

(1999b, July 8). Silent witness. Phoenix New Times. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/1999-07-08/news/silent-witness

84.

Rubin

(2002, February 14). The big sleep. Phoenix New Times. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/2002-02-14/news/the-big-sleep

85.

Rush

(1812/1835). Medical inquiries and observations upon the diseases of the mind (5th ed.). Philadelphia: Grigg and Elliot.

86.

Samuels

O'Driscoll

, & Allnutt

(2007). When killing isn't murder: Psychiatric and psychological defences to murder when the insanity defence is not applicable. Australian Psychiatry, 15, 474–479.

87.

Schenck

C. H.

(2007). Sleep: The mysteries, the problems, and the solutions. New York: Avery.

88.

Schenck

C. H.

Arnulf

, & Mahowald

M. W.

(2007). Sleep and sex: What can go wrong? A review of the literature on sleep related disorders and abnormal sexual behaviors and experiences. Sleep, 30, 683–702.

89.

Shapiro

Federoff

, & Trajanovic

(1996). Sexual behaviour in sleep—A newly described parasomnia. Sleep Research, 25, 367.

90.

Shapiro

Trajanovic

, & Federoff

(2003). Sexsomnia—A new parasomnia. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 48, 311–317.

91.

Smith-Spark

(2005, March 18). How sleepwalking can lead to killing. BBC News. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4362081.stm

92.

State v. Caddell, 215 S.E.2d 348 (N.C. 1975).

93.

State of New Jersey v. Marie D. Connelly. (2009, March 11). Municipal Appeal No. 24–08-C-T-13. Retrieved July 1, 2011, from www.njptoa.org/IMPORTANT_ALERTS.html

94.

Stores

(2007). Parasomnias of childhood and adolescence. Sleep Medicine Clinics, 2, 405–417.

95.

Tibbs v. Commonwealth, 128 S.W. 871 (Ky. 1910).

96.

Wharton

(1855). A monograph on mental unsoundness. Philadelphia: Kay & Brother.

97.

Winkelman

J. W.

Herzog

D. B.

, & Fava

(1999). The prevalence of sleep-related eating disorder in psychiatric and non-psychiatric populations. Psychological Medicine, 29, 1461–1466.

98.

Yellowlees

(1878). Homicide by a somnambulist. Journal of Mental Science, 24, 451–458.

99.

Zaharna

Budur

, & Noffsinger

(2008). Sexual behavior during sleep: Convenient alibi or parasomnia. Current Psychiatry, 7, 21–30.