Sociology plays a key role in empathy development, which is central to addressing complex social problems. However, little is known about what types of courses work best to enhance empathy. In parallel, sociological animal studies (SAS) has evolved as a relatively new subfield focused on assessing human and animal relationships. SAS research suggests that our interactions with animals enhance empathy development. Combining these literatures, we assess if SAS compared to non-SAS courses impact affective and cognitive empathy for humans and animals differently. Findings reveal that students who take SAS courses demonstrate greater postcourse human and animal empathy even when controlling for precourse levels of empathy and other factors that drive empathy development. Although SAS remains on the periphery of the discipline, this study suggests that it should be a central component of the sociological curriculum.
ArlukeArnold. 2002. “A Sociology of Sociological Animal Studies.” Society and Animals10(4):369–74.
5.
AscioneFrank R.1992. “Enhancing Children’s Attitudes about the Humane Treatment of Animals: Generalization to Human-Directed Empathy.” Anthrozoös5(3):176–91.
6.
Lisa FeldmanBarrettLewisMichaelHaviland-JonesJeannette M., eds. 2016. Handbook of Emotions. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
7.
BekoffMarc. 2004. “Wild Justice and Fair Play: Cooperation, Forgiveness, and Morality in Animals.” Biology and Philosophy19(4):489–520.
8.
BekoffMarcAllenCollinBurghardtGordon M.2002. The Cognitive Animal: Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives on Animal Cognition. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
9.
BesekJordan F.YorkRichard. 2019. “Toward a Sociology of Biodiversity Loss.” Social Currents6(3):239–54.
10.
BrooksHelen LouiseRushtonKellyLovellKarinaBeePennyWalkerLaurenGrantLauraRogersAnne. 2018. “The Power of Support from Companion Animals for People Living with Mental Health Problems: A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis of the Evidence.” BMC Psychiatry18(1):31. doi:10.1186/s12888-018-1613-2.
11.
BrunnerBrigitta R.ZarkinKimYatesBradford L.2018. “What Do Employers Want? What Should Faculty Teach? A Content Analysis of Entry-Level Employment Ads in Public Relations.” Journal of Public Relations Education4(2):21–50.
12.
BryantBrenda K.1982. “An Index of Empathy for Children and Adolescents.” Child Development53(2):413–25.
13.
BryantClifton D.1979. “The Zoological Connection: Animal-Related Human Behavior.” Social Forces58(2):399–421.
14.
BusenbarkJohn R.FrankKenneth A.MaroulisSpiro J.XuRanLinQinyun. 2021. “Quantifying the Robustness of Empirical Inferences in Strategic Management: The Impact Threshold of a Confounding Variable and Robustness of Inference to Replacement.” Pp. 123–50 in Research in Times of Crisis. Vol. 13, edited by HillA. D.LêJ. K.McKenneyA. F.O’KaneP.ParoutisS.SmithA. D.Leeds, UK: Emerald Publishing Limited.
15.
BusenbarkJohn R.YoonHyunjungGamacheDaniel L.WithersMichael C.2022. “Omitted Variable Bias: Examining Management Research with the Impact Threshold of a Confounding Variable (ITCV).” Journal of Management48(1):17–48.
16.
CloutierAnikaPeetzJohanna. 2016. “Relationships’ Best Friend: Links between Pet Ownership, Empathy, and Romantic Relationship Outcomes.” Anthrozoös29(3):395–408.
17.
ColbyAshleyWhitleyCameron T.2022. “Crisis to Adaptation: Assessing the Drivers of Participation in Sustainable Off-Grid Construction.” Human Ecology Review27(2):51–71.
18.
CooleyCharles Horton. 1902. Human Nature and the Social Order. New York, NY: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
19.
CuffBenjamin M. P.BrownSarah J.TaylorLauraHowatDouglas J.2016. “Empathy: A Review of the Concept.” Emotion Review8(2):144–53.
20.
DalyBethMortonL. L.2006. “An Investigation of Human-Animal Interactions and Empathy as Related to Pet Preference, Ownership, Attachment, and Attitudes in Children.” Anthrozoös19(2):113–27.
21.
DalyBethMortonL. L.2009. “Empathic Differences in Adults as a Function of Childhood and Adult Pet Ownership and Pet Type.” Anthrozoös22(4):371–82.
22.
DalyBethSuggsSuzanne. 2010. “Teachers’ Experiences with Humane Education and Animals in the Elementary Classroom: Implications for Empathy Development.” Journal of Moral Education39(1):101–12.
23.
de BeauvoirSimone. 1953. The Second Sex. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.
24.
DecetyJeanCowellJason M.2014. “The Complex Relation between Morality and Empathy.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences18(7):337–39.
25.
MargoDeMello, ed. 2010. Teaching the Animal: The Humanities. New York, NY: Lentern Books.
26.
DeMelloMargo. 2021. Animals and Society: An Introduction to Human-Animal Studies. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
27.
DietzThomas. 2015. “Environmental Values.” Pp. 329–49 in Oxford Handbook of Values, edited by BroschT.SanderD.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
28.
DietzThomasKalofLindaSternPaul C.2002. “Gender, Values, and Environmentalism.” Social Science Quarterly83(1):353–64. doi:10.1111/1540-6237.00088.
29.
DietzThomasShwomRachael L.WhitleyCameron T.2020. “Climate Change and Society.” Annual Review of Sociology46:135–58.
30.
DolamoreStephanieLovellDarrellCollinsHaleyKlineAngela. 2021. “The Role of Empathy in Organizational Communication during Times of Crisis.” Administrative Theory & Praxis43(3):366–75.
31.
DueñasJorge-ManuelGonzàlezLaiaForcadaRaquelDuran-BonavilaSilviaFerre-ReyGisela. 2021. “The Relationship between Living with Dogs and Social and Emotional Development in Childhood.” Anthrozoös34(1):33–46.
32.
EckerdLizabeth M.BarnettJames E.Jett-DiasLatishia. 2016. “Grief Following Pet and Human Loss: Closeness Is Key.” Death Studies40(5):275–82.
33.
EinolfChristopher J.2012. “Is Cognitive Empathy More Important than Affective Empathy? A Response to ‘Who Helps Natural-Disaster Victims?’” Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy12(1):268–71.
34.
FarmusLindaArpin-CribbieChantal A.CribbieRobert A.2019. “Continuous Predictors of Pretest-Posttest Change: Highlighting the Impact of the Regression Artifact.” Frontiers in Applied Mathematics and Statistics4:64. doi:10.3389/fams.2018.00064.
35.
FitzgeraldAmy J.BarrettBetty JoStevensonRochelleFritzPatti A. Timmons. 2021. “Domestic Violence and Animal Abuse.” Pp. 325–39 in The Routledge International Handbook of Domestic Violence and Abuse, edited by DevaneyJ.Bradbury-JonesC.MacyR. J.OverlienC.HoltS.New York, NY: Routledge.
36.
FlynnClifton P.2010. “Animals and Society.” TRAILS: Teaching Resources and Innovations Library for Sociology. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association. http://trails.asanet.org.
37.
FrankKenneth A.MaroulisSpiro J.DuongMinh Q.KelceyBenjamin M.2013. “What Would It Take to Change an Inference? Using Rubin’s Causal Model to Interpret the Robustness of Causal Inferences.” Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis35(4):437–60.
38.
FrankKenneth A.XuRan. 2020. “Causal Inference for Social Network Analysis.” Pp. 288–310 in The Oxford Handbook of Social Networks, edited by LightR.MoodyJ.New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
39.
GhidinaMarcia. 2019. “Deconstructing Victim-Blaming, Dehumanization, and Othering.” Teaching Sociology47(3):231–42.
40.
GrauerholzLizWeinzimmerJulianneKidderErin N.DuffyNicole Owens. 2020. “Teaching about Animals: Incorporating Nonhuman Animals into Sociology Classrooms.” Teaching Sociology48(2):120–39.
41.
GrauerholzLizWhitleyCameron T.KidderErin N.OrtizKelley J.StolleyKathy Shepherd. Forthcoming. “Teaching Human Animal Studies Courses: Exploring Student Characteristics Across Three Universities.” Society & Animals.
42.
GreenebaumJessica Beth. 2017. “Questioning the Concept of Vegan Privilege: A Commentary.” Humanity & Society41(3):355–72.
43.
HeinGritEngelmannJan B.VollbergMarius C.ToblerPhilippe N.2015. “How Learning Shapes the Empathic Brain.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences113(1):80–85.
44.
HoganRobert. 1969. “Development of an Empathy Scale.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology33(3):307–16.
45.
HopwoodChristopher J.StahlmannAlexander G.BleidornWiebke. 2022. “Personality and Compassion for Animals.” Anthrozoös36(1):69–81.
46.
Hoy-GerlachJanetRauktisMaryNewhillChristina. 2020. “(Non-human) Animal Companionship: A Crucial Support for People during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Society Register4(2):109–20.
47.
IrvineLeslie. 2008. “Animals and Sociology.” Sociology Compass2(6):1954–71.
48.
IrvineLeslie. 2009a. Filling the Ark: Animal Welfare in Disasters. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
49.
IrvineLeslie. 2009b. “Teaching and Learning Guide for: Animals and Sociology.” Sociology Compass3(2):372–80.
50.
JolliffeDarrickFarringtonDavid P.2006. “Development and Validation of the Basic Empathy Scale.” Journal of Adolescence29(4):589–611.
51.
KalofLindaWhitleyCameron T.2021. “Animals in Environmental Sociology.” Pp. 289–313 in Handbook of Environmental Sociology, edited by CanigliaB. SchaeferJorgensonA.MalinS. A.PeekL.PellowD. N.HuangX.New York, NY: Springer.
52.
KhalidAliyaNaqviIrum. 2016. “Relationship between Pet Attachment and Empathy among Young Adults.” Journal of Behavioural Sciences26(1):66–81.
53.
Koop-MonteiroYasmin. 2023. “Including Animals in Sociology.” Current Sociology71(6):1141–58. doi:10.1177/00113921211065492.
54.
LatshawBeth A.2015. “Examining the Impact of a Domestic Violence Simulation on the Development of Empathy in Sociology Classes.” Teaching Sociology43(4):277–89.
55.
LemonNealManahan-VaughanDenise. 2006. “Dopamine D1/D5 Receptors Gate the Acquisition of Novel Information through Hippocampal Long-Term Potentiation and Long-Term Depression.” Journal of Neuroscience26(29):7723–29.
56.
MacNamaraJessicaGlannSarahDurlakPaul. 2017. “Experiencing Misgendered Pronouns: A Classroom Activity to Encourage Empathy.” Teaching Sociology45(3):269–78.
57.
MarkowskiKelly L.2016. “Human/Nonhuman Animal Boundary Maintenance through Language.” TRAILS: Teaching Resources and Innovations Library for Sociology. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association. http://trails.asanet.org.
58.
MayhewMatthew J.FernandezSonia Deluca. 2007. “Pedagogical Practices That Contribute to Social Justice Outcomes.” The Review of Higher Education31(1):55–80.
59.
Mayorga-GalloSarah. 2018. “Whose Best Friend? Dogs and Racial Boundary Maintenance in a Multiracial Neighborhood.” Sociological Forum33(2):505–28.
60.
McCaffreeKevin. 2020. “Towards an Integrative Sociological Theory of Empathy.” European Journal of Social Theory23(4):550–70.
61.
MeadGeorge Herbert. 1934. Mind, Self and Society. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
62.
MessineoMelinda. 2018. “2017 Hans O. Mauksch Address: Using the Science of Learning to Improve Student Learning in Sociology Classes.” Teaching Sociology46(1):1–11.
63.
PaulElizabeth S.2000. “Empathy with Animals and with Humans: Are They Linked?” Anthrozoös13(4):194–202.
64.
PeggsKay. 2012. Animals and Sociology. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
65.
PhillipsClive. 2009. “Empathy towards Animals.” Pp. 47–54 in The Welfare of Animals, edited by PhillipsC.New York, NY: Springer.
66.
ReganTom. 2004. The Case for Animal Rights. Berkley: University of California Press.
67.
RockwellAshleyVidmarChris M.HarveyPennyGreenwoodLeanna. 2019. “Do Sociology Courses Make More Empathetic Students? A Mixed-Methods Study of Empathy Change in Undergraduates.” Teaching Sociology47(4):284–302.
68.
RomeroRachel. 2020. “Poetic Transcription in the Sociology Classroom: Developing Empathy, Analytical Skills, Creativity, and Engagement.” Teaching Sociology48(3):211–19.
69.
Ruiz-JuncoNatalia. 2017. “Advancing the Sociology of Empathy: A Proposal.” Symbolic Interaction40(3):414–35.
70.
Ruiz-JuncoNatalia. 2021. “Empathy, Intersubjectivity, and the Self.” Pp. 543–57 in Handbook of Classical Sociological Theory, edited by SAbrutynLizardoO.Cham, Switzerland: Springer Nature.
71.
Shamay-TsoorySimone G.Aharon-PeretzJudithPerryDaniella. 2009. “Two Systems for Empathy: A Double Dissociation between Emotional and Cognitive Empathy in Inferior Frontal Gyrus versus Ventromedial Prefrontal Lesions.” Brain132(3):617–27.
72.
Smith-HarrisTracey. 2010. “Animals and People.” TRAILS: Teaching Resources and Innovations Library for Sociology. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association. http://trails.asanet.org.
73.
Van BreukelenG. 2006. “ANCOVA versus Change from Baseline: More Power in Randomized Studies, More Bias in Nonrandomized Studies.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology59(9):920–25.
74.
Van BreukelenGerard J. P.2013. “ANCOVA versus CHANGE from Baseline in Nonrandomized Studies: The Difference.” Multivariate Behavioral Research48(6):895–922.
75.
Villafaina-DomínguezBeatrizCollado-MateoDanielMerellano-NavarroEugenioVillafainaSantos. 2020. “Effects of Dog-Based Animal-Assisted Interventions in Prison Population: A Systematic Review.” Animals10(11):2129. doi:10.3390/ani10112129.
76.
VollumScott. 2010. “Sociolgy/Criminal Justice 395 Violence against Animals.” TRAILS: Teaching Resources and Innovations Library for Sociology. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association. http://trails.asanet.org.
77.
WhitleyCameron T.2015. “Trans*-subjectivity: Exploring Research Positionality in the Field.” Qualitative Sociology Review11(4):67–80.
78.
WhitleyCameron T.BowersMelanie M.2023. “Queering Climate Change: Exploring the Influence of LGBTQ Plus Identity on Climate Change Belief and Risk Perceptions.” Sociological Inquiry93(3):413–39.
79.
WhitleyCameron T.CherryElizabeth. 2023. “Environmental Sociology and Sociological Animal Studies.” Pp. 245–58 in Handbook of Sociology, edited by CabreraS. A.SweetS.New York, NY: Elgar Publishing.
80.
WhitleyCameron T.KalofLinda. 2014. “Animal Imagery in the Discourse of Climate Change.” International Journal of Sociology44(1):10–33.
81.
WhitleyCameron T.YoderScot D.2015. “Developing Social Responsibility and Political Engagement: Assessing the Aggregate Impacts of University Civic Engagement on Associated Attitudes and Behaviors.” Education, Citizenship and Social Justice10(3):217–33.
82.
WynnColleen E.ZiffElizabethSnyderAllison H.SchmidtKamryn T.HillLauryn L.2023. “The Sociological Role of Empathy in the Classroom.” Teaching Sociology51(2):181–92. doi:10.1177/0092055X221123338.
83.
XuRanFrankKenneth A.MaroulisSpiro J.RosenbergJoshua M.2019. “Konfound: Command to Quantify Robustness of Causal Inferences.” The Stata Journal19(3):523–50.
84.
YoungAshleyKhalilKathayoon A.WhartonJim. 2018. “Empathy for Animals: A Review of the Existing Literature.” Curator: The Museum Journal61(2):327–43.
85.
ZakiJamil. 2020. The War for Kindness: Building Empathy in a Fractured World. New York, NY: Broadway Books.
