Students often identify research methods classes as one of the most difficult and intimidating classes of their academic career. The objectives of this study were twofold. The first was to ascertain whether the use of group-centered, collaborative learning would improve student mastery of material compared to traditional, lecture-based classes. The second objective was to examine a possible differential impact of collaborative learning by race. The study measured students’ mastery of basic concepts in research methods as well as their application of the material to novel situations by comparing their competence at the beginning to their performance on the same measures at the midterm and final exams. Findings highlight the importance of examining race as a factor in the study of the effectiveness of collaborative learning and, more specifically, point to a need to further test the hypothesis that collaborative learning pedagogy techniques can ameliorate race-based achievement gaps in student performance.
AronsonJoshuaFriedCarrie B.GoodCatherine. 2001. “Reducing the Effects of Stereotype Threat on African American College Students by Shaping Theories of Intelligence.”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology38:113–25.
2.
BalanPeterClarkMicheleRestallGregory. 2015. “Preparing Students for Flipped or Team-Based Learning Methods.”Education + Training57(6):639–57.
3.
BanksJames A.McGee BanksCherry A., eds. 2004. Handbook of Research on Multicultural Education. New York: Macmillian.
4.
BensimonEstela MaraMalcom-PiqueuxLindsey E.2012. Confronting Equity Issues on Campus: Implementing the Equity Scorecard in Theory and Practice. Sterling, VA: Stylus.
5.
BloomBenjamin S.1956. Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: The Classification of Educational Goals. New York: Longman.
6.
CarmichaelJeffery. 2009. “Team-Based Learning Enhances Performance in Introductory Biology.”Journal of College Science Teaching38(4):54–61.
7.
ChyrWen-LiShenPei-DiChiangYi-ChunLinJau-BiTsaiChia-Wen. 2017. “Exploring the Effects of Online Academic Help-Seeking and Flipped Learning on Improving Students’ Learning.”Journal of Educational Technology & Society20(3):11–23.
8.
ChungEun-KyungRheeJung-AeBaikYoung-HongOh-SunA.2009. “The Effect of Team-Based Learning in Medical Ethics Education.”Medical Teacher31(11):1013–17.
9.
CohenElizabeth G.1994. “Restructuring the Classroom: Conditions for Productive Small Groups.” Review of Educational Research64(1):1–35.
10.
DavisClaytieAronsonJoshuaSalinasMoises. 2006. “Shades of Threat: Racial Identity as a Moderator of Stereotype Threat.” Journal of Black Psychology32(4):399–417.
11.
DunhamRogerWilsonGeorge. 2007. “Race, Within-Family Social Capital and School Drop Out: An Analysis of Whites, Blacks, Hispanics, and Asians.” Sociological Spectrum27(2):207–24.
12.
EddySarah L.HoganKelly A.2014. “Getting under the Hood: How and for Whom Does Increasing Course Structure Work?Life Sciences Education13(3):453–68.
13.
EspeyMolly. 2018. “Diversity, Effort, and Cooperation in Team-Based Learning.”Journal of Economic Education49(1):8–21.
14.
FarleyJohn E.2003. “Contesting Our Everyday Work Lives: The Retention of Minority and Working-Class Sociology Undergraduates.”Sociological Quarterly43(1):1–25.
15.
FinkL. Dee. 2004. “Beyond Small Groups: Harnessing the Extraordinary Power of Learning Teams.” Pp. 3–26 in Team-Based Learning: A Transformative Use of Small Groups in College Teaching, edited by MichaelsenL. K.KnightA. B.FinkL. D.Sterling, VA: Stylus.
16.
GangulyAnishaFaulknerChristopherSendelbachDorothy. 2019. “Association of Group Composition Diversity and Performance Outcomes in a Pre-clerkship Team-Based Learning Program.”Medical Teacher41(9):1060–64.
17.
GecasViktorSchwalbeMichael L.1983. “Beyond the Looking-Glass Self: Social Structure and Efficacy-Based Self-Esteem.”Social Psychology Quarterly46(2):77–88.
18.
GreenStephen R.2001. “Closing the Achievement Gap: Lessons Learned and Challenges Ahead.”Teaching and Change8(2):215–24.
19.
GroverSarah S.ItoTiffany A.ParkBernadette. 2017. “The Effects of Gender Composition on Women’s Experience in Math Work Groups.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology112(6):877–900.
20.
HaidetPaulKubitzKarlaMcCormackWayne T.2014. “Analysis of the Team-Based Learning Literature: TBL Comes of Age.”Journal on Excellence in College Teaching25:303–33.
21.
HarveyWilliam B.2008. “The Weakest Link: A Commentary on the Connections between K–12 and Higher Education.”American Behavioral Scientist51(7):972–83.
22.
HaycockKati. 2001. “Closing the Achievement Gap.”Educational Leadership58(6):6–11.
23.
HettlerPaul L.2015. “Student Demographics and the Impact of Team-Based Learning.”International Advances in Economic Research21(4):413–22.
24.
HeyborneWilliam H.PerrettJamis J.2016. “To Flip or Not to Flip? Analysis of a Flipped Classroom Pedagogy in a General Biology Course.”Journal of College Science Teaching45(4):31–37.
25.
HoffmanEllen S.2014. “Beyond the Flipped Classroom: Redesigning a Research Methods Course for e3 Instruction.” Contemporary Issues in Education Research7(1):51–62.
26.
HrynchakPatriciaBattyHelen. 2012. “The Educational Theory Basis of Team-Based Learning.”Medical Teacher34:796–801.
27.
HugginsChristopher M.StamatelJanet P.2015. “An Exploratory Study Comparing the Effectiveness of Lecturing versus Team-Based Learning.”Teaching Sociology43(3):227–35.
28.
HunnVanessa. 2014. “African American Students, Retention, and Team-Based Learning: A Review of the Literature and Recommendations for Retention at Predominately White Institutions.”Journal of Black Studies45(4):301–14.
29.
JeynesWilliam. 2011. Parental Involvement and Academic Success. New York: Routledge.
30.
KellerJohannesDauenheimerDirk. 2012. “Stereotype Threat in the Classroom: Dejection Mediates the Disrupting Threat Effect on Women’s Math Performance.”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin29(3):371–81.
31.
MacheskiGinger E.BuhrmannJanLowneyKathleen S.BushMelanie E.L.2008. “Overcoming Student Disengagement and Anxiety in Theory, Methods, and Statistics Courses by Building a Community of Learners.”Teaching Sociology36:42–48.
32.
MackeCarolineCanfieldJamesTappKarenHunnVanessa. 2019. “Outcomes for Black Students in Team-Based Learning Courses.”Journal of Black Studies50(1):66–86.
33.
MahlerSarah J.2012. “Team-Based Learning in Social Sciences Research Methods Classes.” Pp. 113–28 in Team-Based Learning in the Social Sciences and Humanities: Group Work That Works to Generate Critical Thinking and Engagement, edited by SweetM.MichaelsenL. K.Sterling, VA: Stylus.
34.
MichaelsenLarry K.KnightArletta BaumanDee FinkL.2004. Team-Based Learning: A Transformative Use of Small Groups in College Teaching. Sterling, VA: Stylus.
35.
MonsonRenee. 2017. “Groups That Work: Student Achievement in Group Research Projects and Effects on Individual Learning.”Teaching Sociology45(3):240–51.
36.
OgbuJohn U.1993. “Differences in Cultural Frame of Reference.”International Journal of Behavioral Development16(3):483–506.
37.
PedersenDaphne. 2010. “Active and Collaborative Learning in an Undergraduate Sociological Theory Course.”Teaching Sociology38(3):197–206.
38.
PenningtonCharlotte R.HeimDerekLwvyAndrew R.LarkinDerek T.2016. “Twenty Years of Stereotype Threat Research: A Review of Psychological Mediators.”PLOS ONE11(1):1–25.
39.
PetrilliMichael. 2013. “The Diversity Dilemma.”Educational Leadership70(8):44–48.
40.
RamnananChristopher J.PoundLynley D.2017. “Advances in Medical Education and Practice: Student Perceptions of the Flipped Classroom.”Advances in Medical Education and Practice8:63–73.
41.
RothsteinRichard. 2004. Class and Schools: Using Social, Economic, and Educational Reform to Close the Black-White Achievement Gap. New York: Columbia University.
42.
RydellRobertRydellMichaelBoucherKatheryn. 2010. “The Effect of Negative Performance Stereotypes on Learning.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology99(6):883–96.
43.
SalehMohammadLazonderArd W.de JongTon. 2007. “Structuring Collaboration in Mixed-Ability Groups to Promote Verbal Interaction, Learning, and Motivation of Average-Ability Students.”Contemporary Educational Psychology32(3):314–31.
44.
SalikutlukZerrinHeyneStefanie. 2017. “Do Gender Roles and Norms Affect Performance in Math? The Impact of Adolescents’ and their Peers’ Gender Conceptions on Math Grades.”European Sociological Review33(3):368–81.
SteeleClaude M.1997. “A Threat in the Air: How Stereotypes Shape Intellectual Identity and Performance.”American Psychologist52:613–29.
49.
SteeleClaude M.AronsonJoshua. 1995. “Stereotype Threat and the Intellectual Test Performance of African Americans.”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology69(5):797–811.
StoetGijsbertGearyDavid C.2012. “Can Stereotype Threat Explain the Gender Gap in Mathematics Performance and Achievement?”Review of General Psychology16(1):93–102.
52.
SweetMichaelMichaelsenLarry K., eds. 2012. Team-Based Learning in the Social Sciences and Humanities: Group Work That Works to Generate Critical Thinking and Engagement. Sterling, VA: Stylus.
53.
WilsonStephanie Gray. 2013. “The Flipped Class: A Method to Address the Challenges of an Undergraduate Statistics Course.”Teaching of Psychology40(3):193–99.
54.
WolfeConnie T.SpencerSteven J.1996. “Stereotypes and Prejudice: Their Overt and Subtle Influence in the Classroom.”American Behavioral Scientist40(2):176–85.
