Given that so many college students take Introduction to Sociology or Social Problems or both, we wondered about the amount of content overlap in these courses. We designed a study that used content analysis of syllabi from these courses in order to measure the amount of convergence between the two classes. In our sample, nearly 70 percent of the content was similar. More worrisome, some significant concepts, such as research methods and symbolic interactionism, were barely mentioned in either course. Given the new political economy of general education and more specifically higher education, we raise questions about the implications of such course content convergence and encourage the discipline to begin to address these issues.
ArumRichardRoskaJosipa. 2010. Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
5.
BaberRay Erwin. 1931. “A Discussion of the Introductory Course.”Social Forces9(3):325–31.
6.
D’AntonioWillilam V.1983. “Nibbling at the Core.”Teaching Sociology10(2):169–85.
7.
EbertsPaulHoweryCarlaBerheideCatherine WhiteCrittendenKathleenDavisRobertGamsonZeldaWagenaarTheodore C.1990. Liberal Learning and the Sociology Major. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association.
8.
FergusonSusan J.CarbonaroWilliam. 2016. “Measuring College Learning in Sociology.” Pp. 135–87 in Improving Quality in American Higher Education: Learning Outcomes and Assessments for the 21st Century, edited by ArumR.RoskaJ.CookA.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
9.
GrauerholzLizGibsonGreg. 2006. “Articulation of Goals and Means in Sociology Courses: What We Can Learn from Syllabi.”Teaching Sociology34(1):5–22.
10.
HolmCharles F.2008. “Sociology in the Academy: How the Discipline Is Viewed by Deans.”Sociological Perspectives51(2):235–58.
11.
HuddSuzanne S.2003. “Syllabus under Construction: Involving Students in the Creation of Class Assignments.”Teaching Sociology31(2):195–202.
12.
JohnsonEarl S.1940. “The Place of Sociology in General Education.”Social Forces19(1):41–44.
13.
KainEdward L.ContrerasLauren R.HendleyAlexandra O.Wyatt-BaxterKrystal K.2007. “Sociology in Two-year Institutions.”Teaching Sociology35(4):350–59.
14.
KeithBruceEnderMorten G.2004. “The Sociological Core: Conceptual Patterns and Idiosyncrasies in the Structure and Content of Introductory Sociology Textbooks, 1940–2000.”Teaching Sociology32(1):19–36.
15.
KeithBruceEnderMorten G.2005. “Search Not for the Core in the Knowledge Frontier: A Reply to Schweingruber.”Teaching Sociology33(1):90–94.
16.
LeeAlfred Mcclung. 1958. “The Place of Introductory Sociology in General Education.”The Journal of Higher Education29(5):251–56.
17.
LynchMichaelBogenDavid. 1997. “Sociology’s Asociological ‘Core’: An Examination of Textbook Sociology in Light of the Sociology of Scientific Knowledge.”American Sociological Review62(3):481–93.
18.
MatejkaKenKurkeLance B.1994. “Designing a Great Syllabus.”College Teaching42(3):115–17.
19.
McKinneyKathleenHoweryCarla B.StrandKerry J.KainEdward L.BerheideCatherine White. 2004. Liberal Learning and the Sociology Major Updated: Meeting the Challenge of Teaching Sociology in the Twenty-first Century. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association.
20.
OlzakSusan. 1981. “Bringing Sociology Back in: Conveying the Sociological Imagination in a Changing Undergraduate Climate.”Teaching Sociology8(2):213–25.
RowellKatherine R.ThisCraig. 2013. “Exploring the Sociology Curriculum at Community Colleges in the United States.”American Sociologist44(4):329–40.
24.
RuggieroJosephine A.WestonLouise C.1991. “Teaching Introductory Sociology Students about the Practice of Sociology: The Practitioner’s Perspective.”Teaching Sociology19(2):211–22.
25.
SchwartzMichaelSmithR. Tyson. 2010. “Beyond the Core: The Hot Topic(al) Alternative to the Survey-based Introduction to Sociology Course.”American Sociologist41(3):249–76.
26.
SchweingruberDavid. 2004. “Looking for the Core in the Wrong Place.”Teaching Sociology33(1):81–89.
27.
ShidelerErnest H.1920. “A Course in Modern Social Problems for the High School.”The School Review28(8):615–26.
28.
TrachenbergStephen JoelKauvarGerald. 2010. “A Degree in Three.”The New York Times. May25, p. A27.
29.
TuchmanGaye. 2011. Wannabe U: Inside the Corporate University. Chicago: University of Chicago.
30.
WagenaarTheodore C.2004. “Is There a Core in Sociology: Results from a Survey.”Teaching Sociology32(1):1–18.
31.
YoderFred R.1933. “The Introductory Course in Sociology in the Separate Land-grant Colleges and in Colleges of Agriculture in the State Universities.”The Journal of Educational Sociology17(1):48–53.
