Drug Screening in the Public Sector: A Focus on Law Enforcement

Abstract

The academic and legal literature has clearly established a set of policies suited for inclusion in a comprehensive drug screening program. The employment of urinanalysis, random drug tests, reasonable suspicion tests, and chain of custody procedures are mixed with employee safeguards such as test interpretation by medical review officers, analysis in NIDA certified labs, and confirmatory tests for initial positive results. This paper provides a two-fold, empirical examination of those policies.

First, the International Association of Directors of Law Enforcement Standards and Testing were surveyed. The IADLEST members' recommendations represent the standards that law enforcement agencies in each state would consider as their most appropriate professional guidelines. Inasmuch as they fall short of what the literature recommends (and they do in regard to a number of items), it is unlikely that individual police departments would find either the support or courage for recommending stronger policies.

Second, a North Carolina survey examines the implementation of these recommendations by municipalities in one of the more advanced states included in the IADLEST survey. In general, municipal police departments are found to follow the North Carolina Criminal Justice Standards Division's recommendations.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Management Institute (“AMA”) (1987) “Drug Abuse: The Workplace Issues,” NIDA, at (1987).

Bureau of National Affairs (1986) Alcohol and Drugs in the Workplace: Costs, Controls, and Controversies. Washington, DC: Bureau of National Affairs.

Caplan

Yale H.

(1987) “Drug Testing in Urine: Understanding the Factors and the Process.” Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, Baltimore, Maryland.

Elliott

Robert E.

(1990) “Contemporary Health Care Dilemma in Public Personnel Management.” Review of Public Personnel Administration, 9,3 (Summer): 15–31.

Finkle

B. S.

Blanke

R. V.

Walsh

J. M.

(1990) “Technical, Scientific and Procedural Issues of Employee Drug Testing.” National Institute on Drug Abuse. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Rockville, Maryland.

Higginbotham

Jeffrey

(1986, 1987) “Urinanalysis Drug Testing Programs for Law Enforcement.” FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, U.S. Department of Justice, Washington, DC. October and November 1986, January 1987.

Johnson

Arthur

(1986) “A Comparison of Employee Assistance Programs in Corporate and Governmental Organizations.” Review of Public Personnel Administration, 6,2 (Spring): 28–42.

Johnson

Arthur

O'Neill

Nancy

(1989) “Employee Assistance Programs and the Troubled Employee in the Public Sector Workplace.” Review of Public Personnel Administration, 9,3 (Summer): 66–80.

Klingner

Donald

O'Neill

Nancy G.

Sabet

Mohamed G.

(1987) “Drug Testing in the Public Workplace.” Section on Public Personnel Administration and Labor Relations (SPALR) News Letter (October).

10.

Klingner

Donald

O'Neill

Nancy G.

Sabet

Mohamed G.

(1989) “Drug Testing in Public Agencies: Public Policy Issues and Managerial Responses.” Review of Public Personnel Administration, 10,1 (Fall): 1–10.

11.

Klingner

Donald E.

O'Neill

Nancy G.

Sabet

Mohamed G.

(1990) “Drug Testing in Public Agencies: Are Personnel Directors Doing Things Right?” Public Personnel Management, 19,4 (I): 391–397. Law Enforcement News (1990) 16, 311 (March 31).

12.

Masi

Dale A.

(1986) “Employee Assistance Programs,” Occupational Medicine: State of the Art Reviews, 1, 4 (October/December).

13.

National Commission on the Public Service (1989) “Leadership for America: Rebuilding the Public Service—The Report.” Washington, DC.

14.

National Treasury Employees Union, et. al.: Petitioners vs. William Von Raab, Commissioner, U.S. Customs Service, 489 U.S.-,103L ED 2D 685, 109SCT Argued November 2 , 1988. Decided March 21, 1989.

15.

Neikin

Dorothy

Tancredi

Laurence

(1989) Dangerous Diagnostics. New York, NY: Basic Books.

16.

North Carolina Criminal Justice Advisory Council (1986) Recommendations as to Drug Testing of Law Enforcement Applicants, Trainees and Currently Employed Law Enforcement Officers (September).

17.

North Carolina Criminal Justice Education and Training Standards Commission (1990) “Implementation Guide-Drug Screening Through Urinanalysis for North Carolina Criminal Justice Agencies.” Raleigh, North Carolina.

18.

Riccucci

Norma

(1990) “Drug Testing in the Public Sector: A Legal Analysis.” American Review of Public Administration, 20,2 (June): 95–106.

19.

Skinner

Samuel K.

, Secretary of Transportation, et. al., Petitioners v. Railway Labor Executives Association, et. al. No. 87–1555, Argued November 2, 1988. Decided March 21, 1989.

20.

Stewart

James K.

(1986) “Police and Drug Testing: A Look at Some Issues,” The Police Chief. National Institute of Justice (October).

21.

Strickland

Ruth Ann

Whicker

Marsha Lynn

(1989) “Comparing City Policies on Mandatory Drug Testing: A Process Evaluation of a Policy.” Paper presented at the Southern Political Science Association.

22.

Thompson

Frank J.

Riccucci

Norma M.

Ban

Carolyn

(1990) “Biological Testing and Personnel Policy: Drugs in the Federal Workplace.” in Ban

Carolyn

Riccucci

Norma

(eds) Public Personnel Management: Current Concerns — Future Challenges. New York, NY: Longman., 156–171

23.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (1988) “Mandatory Guidelines for Federal Workplace Drug Testing Programs.” Federal Register, 53 (April 11): 11970–11989.

24.

U.S. General Accounting Office (1989) “Drug Testing: Federal Agency Plans for Testing Employees.” Washington, DC GAO/GGD-89-51.

25.

U.S. House Committee on Post Office and Civil Service (1988) “Oversight Hearings on Administration Plans to Drug Test Federal Work Force.” Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.

26.

US. Office of Personnel Management (1989) “Federal Personnel Manual Letter 792–19, Establishing a Drug-Free Federal Workplace.” Federal Register, 54 (April 6): 14024–14033.

27.

U.S. Public Health Service, Alcohol, Drug Abuse, and Mental Health Administration (1986) Q & A Drug Screening. HE20. 8202: EM7V1988.

28.

U.S. White House (1989) “National Drug Control Strategy.” Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.

29.

Weeks

J. Devereau

(1990) “Public Employee Drug Testing Under Fourth Amendment Limitations After Skinner and Von Raab.” Paper presented at the Southeastern Conference on Public Administration.