Abstract
This article discusses the importance of training program evaluation in increasing the effectiveness of agency training efforts. The article describes a framework available to the personnelist to plan, design, conduct and implement training program evaluations that more clearly identify the effectiveness of training programs.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alliger
G. M.
Janak
E.
(1989 ). Kilpatrick's levels of training criteria: Thirty years later . Personnel Psychology , 42 , 331 –342 .
2.
American Society for Training and Development.
(1988 ). Gaining the competitive edge.
Alexandria, VA : American Society for Training and Development .
3.
Bell
J.D.
Kerr
D.L.
(1987 ). Measuring training results: Key to managerial commitment . Training and Development Journal , 41 (1 ), 70 –73 .
4.
Birnbrauer
H.
(1987 ). Evaluation techniques that work . Training and Development Journal , 41 (1 ), 53 –55 .
5.
Brethower
S.
Rummler
G.A.
, (1979 , May). Evaluating training . Training and Development Journal.
14 –22 .
6.
Brooks
M.
(1971 ). The community action program as a setting for applied research . In
Caro
F.
(Ed.) Readings in evaluation research (pp. 53 –62 ). New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
7.
Burke
M.J.
Day
R. R.
(1986a ). A cumulative study of the effectiveness of managerial training . Journal of Applied Psychology , 71 , 232 –45 .
8.
Burke
M. J.
Day
R. R.
(1986b , August 21). Cost-effective training techniques . Bulletin to Management , p. 284 .
9.
Cascio
W. F.
(1989 ). Using utility analysis to assess training outcomes . In
Goldstein
I. L.
(Ed.), Training and development in organizations (pp. 63 –88 ). San Francisco, CA : Jossey-Bass Publishers .
10.
Cook
T. D.
Campbell
D. T.
(1979 ). Quasi-Experimentation: Design & analysis issues for field settings.
Boston, MA : Houghton Mifflin Company .
11.
Fisher
H. E.
Weinberg
R.
(1988 , January). Make training accountable: Assess its impact . Personnel Journal , 67 , 73 –75 .
12.
Fitzens
J.
(1988 , March). Proving the value of training . Personnel , 65 , 17 –23 .
13.
Ford
J. K.
Wroten
S. P.
(1984 , Winter). Introducing new methods for conducting training evaluation and for linking training evaluation to program redesign . Personnel Psychology , 651 –66 .
14.
Galagan
P.
(1983 ). The numbers game: Putting value on HRD . Training and Development Journal , 37 (8 ), 48 –51 .
15.
Glass
G.V.
(1976 ). Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis research . Educational Researcher , 5 (10 ), 3 –8 .
16.
Goldstein
I. L.
(1974 ). Training: Program development and evaluation.
Monterey, CA : Brooks/Cole .
17.
Goldstein
I. L.
(1986 ). Training in organizations: Needs assessment, development, and evaluation (2nd ed. ). Monterey, CA : Brooks/Cole .
18.
Goldstein
I. L.
(Ed.) (1989 ). Training and development in organizations.
San Francisco, CA : Jossey-Bass Publishers .
19.
Hamlin
A.C.
(1970 , November). Evaluatiotraining . Industrial Training International , 33 .
20.
Hoffman
F. O.
(1984 , February). A responsive training department cuts costs . Personnel Journal , 63 , 48 –53 .
21.
Kaman
V. S.
Mohr
J. D.
(1984 , October). Training needs assessment in the eighties: Five guideposts . Personnel Administrator , 29 , 47 –53 .
22.
Kilpatrick
D. L.
(1983 , November). Four steps to measuring training effectiveness . Personnel Administrator , 28 , 19 –25 .
23.
Lee
C.
(1989 , October). 1989 Industry Report . Training , 35 , 49 –64 .
24.
Lusterman
S.
(1985 ). Trends in corporate education and training. The Conference Board, Report No. 870.
25.
McGehee
W.
Thayer
P. W.
(1961 ). Training in business and industry.
New York : Wiley .
26.
Mathis
R. L.
Jackson
J. H.
(1991 ). Personnel/Human Resource Management.
St. Paul, MN .: West Publishing Co.
27.
Nicholas
J.M.
(1977 ). A systems analysis approach for planning evaluations of OD interventions . Academy of Management Proceedings , 358 –362 .
28.
Rao
T.V.
Abraham
E.
(1986 ). Human resource development . Management Labour Studies , 2 , 73 –85 .
29.
Russ-Eft
F.
Zenger
J. H.
(1985 , April). Common mistakes in evaluating training effectiveness . Personnel Administrator , 30 , 57 –62 .
30.
Schuler
R. S.
Huber
V. L.
(1990 ). Personnel and human resource management (4th ed. ). West Publishing Company . St. Paul, MN .
31.
Sims
R.R.
(1990 ). An experiential learning approach to employee training systems.
Westport, CT .: Quorum/Greenwood Press .
32.
Smith
H. W.
George
C. E.
(1984 , August). Evaluating internal advanced management programs . Personnel Administrator , 29 , 118 –31 .
33.
Stufflebeam
D.
Foley
W.
Gepart
W.
Guba
E.
Hammond
R.
Merriman
H.
Provus
M.
(1971 ). Educational evaluation and decision making.
Itasca, IL : Peacock Publishers .
34.
Suchman
E.
(1967 ). Evaluative research.
New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
35.
Swiercaek
F. W.
Carmichael
L.
(1985 , January). The quantity and quality of evaluating training . Training and Development Journal , 95 –99 .
36.
Tracey
W.R.
(1984 ). Designing training and development systems.
Washington, D.C. : American Management Association .
37.
Tracey
W.R.
(1971 ). Designing training and development systems.
Washington, D.C. : American Management Association .
38.
Wehrenberg
S. B.
(1983 ). Evaluation of training: Part I . Personnel Journal , 62 , 608 –10 .
39.
Wehrenberg
S. B.
(1983 ). Evaluation of training: Part II . Personnel Journal , 62 , 698 –702 .
40.
Wexley
K. N.
Latham
G. P.
(1981 ). Developing and training human resources in organizations.
Glenview, IL : Scott, Foresman .