There are several differences between the public and private sectors which are referred to frequently in the public administration literature. However, there are few studies which verify these differences. This article reports the findings from a study of three “classic” differences between the public and private sectors that are relevant to public personnel management. It also examines the impact of these differences on employee motivation. The findings indicate that the classic differences do exist, but are not as substantial as the literature would lead one to believe. They also indicate the public-private differences do not have a substantial impact on employee motivation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllisonGraham T.1983. “Public and Private Management: Are They Fundamentally Alike in All Unimportant Respects?” in PerryJames L.KraemerKenneth L. (eds.) Public Management: Public and Private Perspectives.Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield Publishing: 72–92.
2.
BanfieldEdward C.1975. “Corruption as a Feature of Governmental Organization,”Journal of Law and Economics18: 587–605.
3.
BartonFrankM.WaldronDarryl G.. 1978. “Differences in Risk Preferences Between the Public and Private Sectors,”Human Resource Management17(Winter): 2–4.
4.
BellanteDanLinkAlbert N.. 1981. “Are Public Sector Workers More Risk Averse than Private Sector Workers?”Industrial and Labor Relations Review34: 408–412.
5.
BerkleyGeorge E.1984. The Craft of Public Administration.Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
6.
BlumenthalMichael W.1979. “Reflections of a Businessman in Washington,”Fortune (January): 36–50.
7.
BuchananBruceII. 1975. “Governmental Managers, Business Executive and Organizational Commitment,”Public Administration Review35(July/August): 339–347.
8.
BurkheadJesseMinerJerry. 1975. Public Expenditure.Chicago: Aldine.
9.
CaidenGerald E.1982. Public Administration, 2nd ed.Palisades, CA:Pacific Palisades.
DahlRobert A.LindblomCharles E.. 1976. Politics, Economics and Welfare.New York: Harper and Row.
12.
De AllesiLouis. 1974. “Management Tenure under Private and Government Ownership in the Electric Power Industry,”Journal of Political Economy82: 645–653.
13.
DimockMarshal E.DimockGladys O.FoxDouglas M.. 1983. Public Administration, 5th ed.New York:Holt, Rhinehart and Winston.
14.
DownsAnthony. 1967. Inside Bureaucracy.Boston: Little Brown.
15.
FeslerJames W.1980. Public Administration: Theory and Practice.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
16.
FottlerMyron D.1981. “Is Management Really Generic?”Academy of Management Review6: 1–12.
17.
GawthropLouis C.1969. Bureaucratic Behavior in the Executive Branch.New York: Free Press.
18.
GordonGeorge J.1982. Public Administration in America.New York: St. Martin's Press.
19.
HallRobert E.1972. “Turnover in the Labor Force,”Brookings Papers on Economic Activities3: 709–756.
20.
HarmanHarry H.1967. Modern Factor Analysis, 2nd ed.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
KilpatrickFranklin P.CummingsMilton C.JenningsKent M.. 1964. Sourcebook of a Study of Occupational Values and Images of the Federal Service.Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
23.
LevineCharles H.BackoffRobert W.CahoonAllan R.SiffinWilliam J.. 1975. “Organization Design: A Post-Minnowbrook Perspective for the ‘New’ Public Administration,”Public Administration Review35(July/August): 425–435.
24.
LockeEdwin A.FerenD. B.McCalebV. M.ShawK. N.DennyA. T.1980. “The Relative Effectiveness of Four Methods of Motivating Employee Performance” in DuncanKenneth D.GrunebergM. M.WallisD. (eds.) Changes in Working Life.London: Wiley, Ltd.: 363–383.
25.
LongJames E.1982. “Are American Government Workers Overpaid? Alternative Evidence,”The Journal of Human Resources16: 1236131.
26.
MainzerLewis C.1973. Political Bureacracy.Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman.
27.
National Center for Productivity and Quality of Working Life.1978. Employee Attitudes and Productivity Differences Between the Public and Private Sectors.Washington, D.C.: National Center for Productivity and Quality of Working Life.
28.
NewstromJohn W.ReifWilliam E.MonczkaRobert M.. 1976. “Motiving the Public Employee: Fact vs. Fiction,”Public Personnel Management5: 67–72.
29.
NigroFelix A.NigroLloyd G.. 1984. Modern Public Administration5th ed.New York:Harper and Row.
30.
PatchenMartin. 1965. Some Questionnaire Measures of Employee Motivation and Morale.Ann Arbor, MI: Survey Research Center, Institute for Social Science Research, Univ. of Michigan.
31.
PerryJames L.PorterLyman W.. 1982. “Factors Affecting the Context of Motivation in Public Organizations,”The Academy of Management Review7: 89–98.
32.
PursleyRobert D.SnortlandNeil. 1980. Managing Government Organizations.North Scituate, MA: Duxbury Press.
33.
QuinnRobert P.StainesGraham L.. 1977. The 1977 Quality of Employment Survey.Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan.
34.
RaineyHal G.1976. “Conceptual and Empirical Analysis of Incentives and Motivation Among Government and Business Managers.” Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio State University.
35.
RaineyHal G.BackoffRobert W.LevineCharles H.. 1976. “Comparing Public and Private Organizations,”Public Administration Review36 (March/April): 233–244.
36.
RogersDavid. 1981. “Managing in the Public and Private Sectors: Similarities and Differences,”Management Review7: 48–54.
37.
SavasE. S.GinsburgSigmund G., 1973. “The Civil Service: A Meritless System?”The Public Interest32(Summer): 70–85.
38.
SiedmanEileen. 1984. “Of Games and Gains …”The Bureaucrat13: 4–8.
39.
StahlO. Glenn. 1976. Public Personnel Administration, 7th ed.New York:Harper and Row.
40.
Survey Research Center.1972. Panel Study of Income Dynamics.Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Survey Research Center.
41.
U.S. Office of Personnel Management.1979. 1979 Federal Employees Attitude Survey.Washington, D.C.: U.S. Office of Personnel Management.
42.
UtgoffKathleen. 1983. “Compensation Levels and Quit Rates in the Public Sector,”The Journal of Human Resources18: 394–406.
43.
WamsleyGary L.ZaldMayer N.. 1973. The Political Economy of Public Organizations.Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.
44.
WhiteLeonard D.1955. Introduction to the Study of Public Administration.New York: Crowell, Collier & Macmillan.
45.
WilliamsJ. D.1980. Public Administration: The People's Business.Boston: Little, Brown.
