Eight "myths"-that is, commonly held assumptions-about small group processes and outcomes are presented and matched against research and practice evidence. These myths are found wanting; and conclusions are drawn concerning benefits of group experience, group composition, leader impact, role of structural exercises, function of the "here-and-now, "self-disclosure andfeedback, understandinggroup processes, and the long-term effects of group experiences.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ANCHOR, K. N. (1979) "High-and low-risk self-disclosure in group psychotherapy."Small Group Behavior10: 279-283.
2.
ANDERSON, J. D. (1979) "Social work with groups in the generic base of social work practice."Social Work with Groups2: 281-293.
3.
ANDERSON, J. D. (1978) "Growth groups and alienation: a comparative study of Rogerian encounter, self-directed encounter, and gestalt."Group and Organizational Studies3: 85-107.
4.
ASHKENAS, R. and R. TANDON (1979) "Eclectic approach to small group facilitation."Small Group Behavior10: 224-241.
5.
BEAN, B. W. and B. K. HOUSTON (1978) "Self-concept and self-disclosure in encounter groups."Small Group Behavior9: 549-554.
6.
BEDNAR, R. and G. LAWLIS (1971) "Empirical research in group psychotherapy," pp. 420-439 in A. Bergin and S. Garfield (eds.) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change. New York: John Wiley.
7.
BERTCHER, H. J. and F. E MAPLE (1977) Creating Groups. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
8.
BERZON, B. , C. PIOUS, and R. FARSON (1963) "The therapeutic event in group psychotherapy: a study of subjective reports by group members."J. of Individual Psychology19: 203-212.
9.
BUTLER, T. and A. FUHRIMAN (1980) "Patient perspective on the curative process: a comparison of day treatment and outpatient psychotherapy groups."Small Group Behavior11: 371-388.
10.
CARKHUFF, R. R. (1969) Helping and Human Relations: A Primer for Lay and Professional Helpers, Vol. II: Practice and Research. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
11.
COHEN, A. M. and D. R. SMITH (1976) The Critical Incident in Growth Groups: Theory and Techniques. La Jolla, CA: University Associates.
12.
CORSINI, R. and B. ROSENBERG (1955) "Mechanisms of group psychotherapy: processes and dynamics."J. of Abnormal and Social Psychology51: 406-411.
13.
COZBY, P. C. (1973) "Self-disclosure: a literature review."Psych. Bull.79: 73-91.
14.
DEJULIO, S. , J. BENTLEY, and T. COCKAYNE (1979) "Pregroup norm setting: effects on encounter group interaction."Small Group Behavior10: 368-388.
15.
DICKHOFF, H. and M. LAKIN (1963) "Patients views of group psychotherapy: retrospections and interpretations."J. of Group Psychotherapy14: 61-73.
16.
DIES, R. R. and A. K. HESS (1971) "An experimental investigation of cohesiveness in marathon and conventional group psychotherapy."J. of Abnormal Psychology77: 258-262.
17.
DREIKURS, R. (1951) "The unique social climate experienced in group psychotherapy."Group Psychotherapy3: 292-299.
18.
ESTES, R. H. and S. HENRY (1979) "The therapeutic contract in work with groups."Social Service Rev.50: 611-632.
19.
EVANS, N.J. and P. A. JARVIS (1980) "Group cohesion: a review and reevaluation."Small Group Behavior11: 359-370.
20.
FRANK, J. and E. ASCHER (1951) "The corrective emotional experience in group therapy."Amer. J. of Psychiatry108: 126-131.
21.
FREEDMAN, S. M. and J. R. HURLEY (1980) " Perceptions of helpfulness and behavior in groups."Groups4: 51-58.
22.
GAZDA, G. M. and R. W. PETERS (1975) "An analysis of research in group psychotherapy, group counseling and human relations training", pp. 38-54 in G. M. Gazda (ed.) Basic Approaches to Group Psychotherapy and Group Counseling. Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
23.
GOLDSTEIN, M. J. , R. L. BEDNAR, and B. YANELL (1979) "Personal risk associated with self-disclosure, interpersonal feedback, and group confrontation in group psychotherapy."Small Group Behavior9: 579-587.
24.
GROTJOHN, M. (1972) " Learning From dropout patients: a clinical view of patients who discontinued group psychotherapy."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy22: 306-319.
25.
HALL, J. and W. H. WATSON (1970) "The effects of a normative intervention on group decision making performance."Human Relations23: 299-317.
26.
HILL, W. E (1975) " Further considerations of therapeutic mechanisms in group therapy."Small Group Behavior6: 421-429.
27.
JACOBS, A. (1974) "The use of feedback in groups," pp. 31-49 in A. Jacobs and W. W. Spradline (eds.) The Group as an Agent of Change. New York: Behavioral Publications.
28.
LACOURSIERE, R. (1980) The Life-Cycle of Groups: Group Development Stage Theory. New York: Human Sciences.
29.
LEVIN, E. M. and R. P. KURTZ (1974) "Participant perceptions following structured and nonstructured human relations training."J. of Counseling Psychology21: 514-532.
30.
LEVINE, N. (1971) "Emotional factors in group development."Human Relations24: 65-89.
31.
LIEBERMAN, M. A. , I. D. YALOM, and M. B. MILES (1973) Encounter Groups: First Facts. New York: Basic Books.
32.
LONG, L. D. and C. S. COPE (1980) "Curative factors in a male felony offender group."Small Group Behavior11: 389-398.
33.
LUNGREN, D. C. (1971) "Trainer style and patterns of group development."J. of Applied Behavioral Sci.: 689-709.
34.
MARTIN, L. and M. JACOBS (1980) "Structured feedback delivered in small groups."Small Group Behavior11: 88-107.
35.
MYERS, G. ET AL. (1969) "Effect of feedback in interpersonal sensitivity in laboratory training groups."J. of Applied Behavioral Science5: 175-185.
36.
PARLOFF, M. B. and R. R. DIES (1978) "Group therapy outcome instrument: guidelines for conducting research."Small Group Behavior9: 243-286.
37.
PERLS, F (1969) Gestalt Therapy Verbatim. New York: Bantom.
38.
PSATHAS, G. and R. HARDERT (1966) "Trainer interventions and normative patterns in the T-Group."J. of Applied Behavioral Sci.2: 149-169.
39.
ROSENZWEIG, S. P. and R. FOLMAN (1980) "The psychology of leadership revisited: an overview."Group4: 5-17.
40.
ROSENZWEIG, S. P. and R. FOLMAN (1974) "Patient and therapist variables affecting premature termination in group psychotherapy."Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, and Practice11: 76-79.
41.
SCHEIDLINGER, S. (1966) "The concept of empathy in group psychotherapy."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy16: 413-424.
42.
SIBERGELD, S. , E. S. THUNE, and R. N. MANDERSCHEID (1979) "The group therapist leadership roles: assessment in adolescent coping courses."Small Group Behavior10:176-199.
43.
SLAVSON, S. R. (1955) "Criteria for selection and rejection of patients for various kinds of group therapy."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy5: 3-30.
44.
SNORTUM, J. R. and H. F. MYERS (1971) "Intensity of T-Group relations as function of interaction."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy21: 190-201.
45.
STAVA, L. J. and R. L. BEDNAR (1979) "Process and outc-ome in encounter groups: the effect of group composition."Small Group Behavior10: 200-213.
46.
TRUAX, C. and K. MITCHELL (1971) "Research on certain therapist interpersonal skills in relation to process and outcome," pp. 521-540 in A. Bergin and S. Garfield (eds.) Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change. New York: John Wiley.
47.
TUCKMAN, B. W. (1965) "Developmental sequences in small groups."Psych. Bull.63: 384-389.
48.
TUCKMAN, B. W. and M.A.C. JENSEN (1977) "Stages of group development revisited."Group and Organizational Studies2: 419-427.
49.
WOGAN, M. ET AL. (1977) "Influencing interaction and outcomes in group psychotherapy."Small Group Behavior8: 25-46.
50.
WOODS, M. and J. MELNICK (1979) "Review of group therapy selection criteria."Small Group Behavior10: 155-175.
51.
YALOM, I. D. (1975) The Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy. New York: Basic Books.
52.
ZIMPFER, D. G. (1967) "Expression of feelings in group counseling."Personnel and Guidance J.45: 703-708.
