Participatory methods for engaging children and young people in research are becoming more popular and innovative in social research. One example of this is the inclusion of participant photography. Drawing on an ethnographic study conducted in Northern Ireland, this article explores the application of participant photography to research drug use and antisocial behavior among youth. Findings highlight issues surrounding implementation when in the field, building on the existing knowledge base and focusing on recruitment, continuous engagement, image presentation, and analysis. This is followed by an overview of ethical considerations including specific issues relating to researcher and participant safety.
AdamsK.BurnsC.LiebzeitA.RyschkaJ.ThorpeS.BrowneJ.. 2012. “Use of Participatory Research and Photo-voice to Support Urban Aboriginal Healthy Eating.” Health and Social in the Community20:497–505.
AllenQ.2012. “Photographs and Stories: Ethics, Benefits and Dilemmas of Using Participant Photography with Black Middle Class Male Youth.” Qualitative Research12:443–58.
4.
Angstrom-BrannstromC.NorbergA.. 2014. “Children Undergoing Cancer Treatment Describe Their Experiences of Comfort in Interviews and Drawings.” Journal of Pediatric Oncology Nursing31:135–46.
5.
BarkerJ.SmithF.. 2012. “What’s in Focus? A Critical Discussion of Photography, Children and Young People.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology15:91–103.
6.
BarkerM.RichardsC.Bowes-CattonH.. 2012. “Visualizing Experience: Using Creative Research Methods with Members of Sexual and Gender Communities.” Pp. 57–80 in Researching Non-heterosexual Sexualities, edited by PhellasConstantinos N.. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.
7.
Brace-GovanJ.2007. “Participant Photography in Visual Ethnography.” International Journal of Market Research49:735–50.
8.
BrannenJ.1988. “Research Note: The Study of Sensitive Subjects.” The Sociological Review36(3): 552–63.
9.
BrazgT.BekemeiserB.SpignerC.HuebnerC. E.. 2011. “Our Community in Focus: The Use of Photovoice for Youth-driven Substance Abuse Assessment and Health Promotion.” Health Promotion Practice12:502–11.
10.
BrewerJ. D.LockhartB.RodgersP.. 1998. “Informal Social Control and Crime Management in Belfast.” British Journal of Sociology49:570–85.
BrymanA.2008. Social Research Methods. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
13.
CairnsE.DarbyJ.. 1998. “The Conflict in Northern Ireland: Causes, Consequences and Controls.” American Psychologist53:754–60.
14.
CarolanM.2003. “Reflexivity: A Personal Journey during Data Collection.” Nurse Researcher10(3): 7–14.
15.
CloverD. E.2006. “Out of the Dark Room: Participatory Photography as a Critical, Imaginative, and Public, Aesthetic Practice of Transformative Education.” Journal of Transformative Education4:275–90.
16.
CunninghamN.GregoryI.. 2014. “Hard to Miss, Easy to Blame? Peacelines, Interfaces and Political Deaths in Belfast during the Troubles.” Political Geography40:64–78.
17.
DrewS. E.DuncanR. E.SawyerS. M.. 2010. “Visual Storytelling: A Beneficial but Challenging Method for Health Research with Young People.” Qualitative Health Research20(12): 1677–88.
18.
FindholtN. E.MichaelY. L.DavisM. M.. 2011. “Photovoice Engages Rural Youth in Childhood Obesity Prevention.” Public Health Nursing28:186–92.
19.
FisherJ. D.FisherW. A.BryanA. D.MisovichS. J.. 2002. “Information-motivation-behavioral Skills Model-based HIV Risk Behavior Change Intervention for Inner-city High School Youth.” Health Psychology21:177–86.
20.
FlemingJ.MahoneyJ.CarlsonE.EngebretsonJ.. 2009. “An Ethnographic Approach to Interpreting a Mental Illness Photovoice Exhibit.” Archives of Psychiatric Nursing23(1): 16–24.
21.
FrithH.HarcourtD.. 2007. “Using Photographs to Capture Women’s Experiences of Chemotherapy: Reflecting on the Method.” Qualitative Health Research17:1340–50.
22.
GeorgiadiM.KalyvaE.KourkoutasE.TsakirisV.. 2012. “Young Children’s Attitudes toward Peers with Intellectual Disabilities: Effect of the Type of School.” Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities25:531–41.
23.
GillR.BlackA.DumontT.FlemingN.. 2016. “Photovoice: A Strategy to Better Understand the Reproductive and Sexual Health Needs of Young Mothers.” Journal of Pediatric and Adolescent Gynecology29, 467–75.
24.
GoodhartF. W.HsuJ.BaekJ. H.ColemanA. L.MarescaF. M.MillerM. B.. 2006. “A View through a Different Lens: Photovoice as a Tool for Student Advocacy.” Journal of American College Health55:53–56.
25.
GosselinkC. A.MyllykangasS. A.. 2007. “The Leisure Experiences of Older US Women Living with HIV/AIDS.” Health Care for Women International28(1): 3–20.
26.
GrantJ.2014. “Reflexivity: Interviewing Women and Men Formally Addicted to Drugs and/or Alcohol.” The Qualitative Report19, Article 76: 1–15.
27.
GrodinM. A.GlantzL. H.. 1994. Children as Research Subjects. Science, Ethics and Law. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
28.
GurmanT. A.TrapplerR. M.AcostaA.McCrayP. A.CooperC. M.GoodsmithL.. 2014. “‘By Seeing with Our Own Eyes, It Can Remain in Our Mind’: Qualitative Evaluation Findings Suggest the Ability of Participatory Video to Reduce Gender-based Violence in Conflict-affected Settings.” Health Education Research29:690–701.
29.
Haines-SaahR. J.OliffeJ. L.WhiteC. F.BottorffJ. L.. 2013. “It Is Just Not Part of the Culture Here: Young Adults’ Photo-narratives about Smoking, Quitting, and Healthy Lifestyles in Vancouver, Canada.” Health and Place22:19–28.
30.
HeisleyD. D.LevyS. J.. 1991. “Autodriving: A Photoelicitation Technique.” Journal of Consumer Research18:257–72.
31.
HergenratherK. C.RhodesS. D.BardhoshiG.. 2009. “Photovoice as Community-based Participatory Research: A Qualitative Review.” American Journal of Health Behaviours33: 686–98.
32.
JurkowskiJ. M.2008. “Photovoice as Participatory Action Research Tool for Engaging People with Intellectual Disabilities in Research and Programme Development.” Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities46:1–11.
33.
KaplanI.MilesS.HowesA.. 2011. “Images and the Ethics of Inclusion and Exclusion: Learning Through Participatory Photography in Education.” Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs11:195–202.
34.
KearneyK.HyleA.. 2004. “Drawing Out Emotions: The Use of Participant Produced Drawings in Qualitative Enquiry.” Qualitative Research4:361–82.
35.
KirbyP.BrysonS.. 2002. Measuring the Magic: Evaluating and Researching Young People’s Participation in Public Decision Making. London, UK: Carnegie Young People’s Initiative.
36.
KitzingerJ.1994. “The Methodology of Focus Groups: The Importance of Interaction between Research Participants.” Sociology of Health and Illness16:103–21.
37.
KnoxC.2002. “‘See No Evil, Hear No Evil’ Insidious Paramilitary Violence in Northern Ireland.” British Journal of Criminology42:164–85.
38.
KreftingL.1991. “Rigour in Qualitative Research: The Assessment of Trustworthiness.” American Journal of Occupational Therapy45:214–22.
39.
LachalJ.SperanzaM.TaiebO.FalissardB.LefevreH.MoroM. R.Revah-LevyA.. 2012. “Qualitative Research Using Photo-elicitation to Explore the Role of Food in Family Relationships among Obese Adolescents.” Appetite58:1099–05.
40.
LansdownG.2002. Promoting Children’s Participation in Democratic Decision-making. Florence, Italy: Innocenti Research Centre, UNICEF.
41.
LeeR. M.1993. Doing Research on Sensitive Topics. London, UK: Sage.
42.
LiamputtongP.2007. Researching the Vulnerable: A Guide to Sensitive Research Methods. London, UK: Sage.
43.
LomaxH.FinkJ.SinghN.HighC.. 2011. “The Politics of Performance: Methodological Challenges of Researching Children’s Experiences of Childhood through the Lens of Participatory Video.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology14:231–43.
44.
MacDonaldA.2011. “Young Children’s Photographs of Measurement in the Home.” Early Years32(1): 71–85.
45.
MasonJ.HoodS.. 2011. “Exploring Issues of Children as Actors in Social Research.” Children and Youth Services Review33:490–95.
46.
MautherN. S.DoucetA.. 2003. “Reflexive Accounts and Accounts of Reflexivity in Qualitative Data Analysis.” Sociology37:413–31.
47.
McEvoyK.McElrathK.HigginsK.. 1998. “Does Ulster Still Say No? Drugs, Politics and Propaganda in Northern Ireland.” Journal of Drug Issues28:127–84.
48.
MillerG.HappellB.. 2006. “Talking About Hope: The Use of Participant Photography.” Issues in Mental Health Nursing27:1051–65.
49.
MolinaG.MolinaF.TannerT.SeballosF.. 2009. “Child-friendly Participatory Research Tools.” Participatory Learning and Action Notes 60:160–66.
50.
MoriartyJ.O'HaraL.McCannM.MacdonaldG.. 2016. “The Smartphone Study: Using a Smartphone Application to Collect Longitudinal Data. Childcare Research Forum Annual Conference: Made in Northern Ireland. November 16, 2016, Templepatrick Northern Ireland.
51.
MorrowV.2001. “Using Qualitative Methods to Elicit Young People’s Perspectives on Their Environments: Some Ideas for Community Health Initiatives.” Health Education Research16(3): 255–68.
52.
MottweilerC. M.TaylorM.. 2014. “Elaborated Role Play and Creativity in Preschool Age Children.” Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts8:277–86.
53.
MuldoonO. T.2004. “Children of the Troubles: The Impact of Political Violence in Northern Ireland.” Journal of Social Issues60:453–68.
54.
MyersJ.2010. “Health, Sexuality and Place: The Different Geographies of HIV-positive Gay Men in Auckland, New Zealand.” New Zealand Geographer66(3): 218–27.
55.
NewburyJ.HoskinsM.. 2011. “Relational Research and the Use of Photography in Understanding Substance Use among Adolescent Girls.” Procedia–Social and Behavioural Sciences30:1067–70.
56.
NieuwenhuysO.2001. “By the Sweat of their Brow? Street Children, NGOs and Children’s Rights in Addis Ababa.” Africa71:539–57.
PinkS.2001. Doing Visual Ethnography: Images, Media and Representation in Research. London, UK: Sage.
60.
Proczkowska-BjorklundM.RunesonI.GustafssonP.SvedinC. G.. 2008. “Communication and Child Behaviour Associated with Unwillingness to Take Premedication.” Acta Paediatrica97:1238–42.
61.
RadleyA.HodgettsD.CullenA.. 2005. “Visualising Homelessness: A Study in Photography and Estrangement.” Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology15:273–95.
62.
RhodesT.FitzgeraldJ.. 2006. “Visual Data in Addictions Research: Seeing Comes Before Words.” Addiction Research Theory14:349–63.
63.
RolphS.JohnsonJ.SmithR.. 2009. “Using Photography to Understand Change and Community in the History of Residential Care for Older People.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology12:421–39.
64.
SeabrookT.GreenE.. 2004. “Streetwise or Safe? Girls Negotiating Time and Space.” in Young People, Risk and Leisure. edited by MitchellW.BuntonR.GreenE.. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
65.
ShirlowP.MurtaghB.. 2006. Belfast: Segregation and the City. London, UK: Pluto Press.
66.
SilkeA.TaylorM.. 2000. “War without End: Comparing IRA and Loyalist Vigilantism in Northern Ireland.” The Howard Journal39:249–66.
67.
SinclairR.2004. “Participation in Practice: Making It Meaningful, Effective and Sustainable.” Children & Society18:106–18.
68.
SixsmithJ.BonehamM.GoldringJ. E.. 2003. “Accessing the Community: Gaining Insider Perspectives from the Outside.” Qualitative Health Research13(4): 578–89.
69.
SmithA. B.2007. “Children as Social Actors: An Introduction.” International Journal of Children’s Rights15:1–4.
70.
SmithE. F.GidlowB.SteelG.. 2012. “Engaging Adolescent Participants in Academic Research: The Use of Photo-elicitation Interviews to Evaluate School-based Outdoor Education Programmes.” Qualitative Research12: 367–87.
71.
TannerT.GarciaM.LazcanoJ.MolinaF.MolinaG.RodriguezG.TribunaloB.SeballosF.. 2009. “Children’s Participation in Community-based Disaster Risk Reduction and Adaptation to Climate.” Participatory Learning and Action60:54–64.
72.
ThompsonN. C.HunterE. C.MurrayL.NinciL.RolfsE. M.PallikkathayilL.. 2008. “The Experience of Living with Chronic Mental Illness: A Photovoice Study.” Perspectives in Psychiatric Care44:14–24.
73.
ThwaiteP. R. N.BennettD. L.PynorH.ZigmondH.. 2003. “Art and “the Language of Well-Being” in Adolescent Health Care.” Ann Acad Med Singapore32:71–77.
WiersmaE. C.2011. “Using Photovoice with People with Early-stage Alzheimer’s Disease: A Discussion of Methodology.” Dementia10:203–16.
79.
WilkinsonS.1998. “Focus Groups in Health Research: Exploring the Meanings of Health and Illness.” Journal of Health Psychology3(3): 329–48.
80.
WilsonN.MinklerM.DashoS.WallersteinN.MartinA. C.. 2008. “Getting to Social Action: The Youth Empowerment Strategies (YES!) Project.” Health Promotion Practice9(4): 395–403.
81.
WrightC. Y.DarkoN.StandenP. J.PatelT. G.. 2010. “Visual Research Methods: Using Cameras to Empower Socially Excluded Black Youth.” Sociology44:541–58.
82.
YohaniS. C.LarsenD. J.. 2009. “Hope Lives in the Heart: Refugee and Immigrant Children’s Perceptions of Hope and Hope-engendering Sources during Early Years of Adjustment.” Canadian Journal of Counselling43(4): 246–64.
