This paper challenges the view that race is a reliable scientific variable or kind for the purpose of inductive inference within the social sciences. I characterize stability in terms of Extended Conditional Independence (ECI) and show that the heterogeneity and instability of racial categories across different background circumstances undermines their ability to support robust inductive inference and explanatory power. I claim this, in turn, undermines racial categories' status as real scientific variables or kinds. Race, has local stability within restricted sets of target systems and thus, its reality is limited to those domains. I argue for a restricted form of racial realism, a view I call Restricted Racial Realism (RRR).
AbrahamowiczAleksandra A.EbingerJosephWheltonSeamus P.Commodore-MensahYvonneYangEugene. 2023. “Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Hypertension: Barriers and Opportunities to Improve Blood Pressure Control.” Current Cardiology Reports25 (1): 17-27.
2.
AlcoffLinda Martín. 2006. Visible Identities: Race, Gender, and the Self. Oxford University Press.
3.
BaptisteDiana-LynTurkson-OcranRuth-AlmaOgungbeOluwabunmi, et al.2022. “Heterogeneity in Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factor Prevalence Among White, African American, African Immigrant, and Afro-Caribbean Adults: Insights from the 2010-2018 National Health Interview Survey.” Journal of the American Heart Association11 (18): e025235.
4.
BühlmannPeter. 2020. “Invariance, Causality and Robustness.” Statistical Science35 (3): 404-426.
5.
CarnethonMercedes R.JiaPuGeorgeHoward, et al.2017. “Cardiovascular Health in African Americans: A Scientific Statement from the American Heart Association.” Circulation136 (21): e393-e423.
6.
CartwrightNancy. 2007. Hunting Causes and Using Them: Approaches in Philosophy and Economics. Cambridge University Press.
7.
DarityWilliam A.Jr.MullenA. Kirsten. 2020 (2022). From Here to Equality: Reparations for Black Americans in the Twenty-First Century. 2nd ed.University of North Carolina Press.
8.
DawidA. Philip. 2010. “Beware of the DAG!” In Proceedings of Workshop on Causality: Objectives and Assessment, edited by GuyonIsabelleJanzingDominikSchölkopfBernard, 59-86. ML Research Press.
9.
DawidA. Philip. 2015. “Statistical Causality from a Decision-Theoretic Perspective.” Annual Review of Statistics and Its Application2: 273-303.
10.
DawidPhilip. 2021. “Decision-Theoretic Foundations for Statistical Causality.” Journal of Causal Inference9 (1): 39-77.
11.
DawidPhilip. 2022. “Decision-Theoretic Foundations for Statistical Causality: Response to Pearl.” Journal of Causal Inference10 (1): 296-299.
12.
De La Cruz-ViescaMelanyChenZhenxiangOngPaul M.HamiltonDarrickDarityWilliam A.Jr.2016. The Color of Wealth in Los Angeles. A Joint Publication of Duke University, The New School, University of California, Los Angeles, and the Insight Center for Community Economic Development. https://www.aasc.ucla.edu/besol/Color_of_Wealth_Report.pdf
13.
FordeAllana T.SimsMarioPaulMuntner, et al.2020. “Discrimination and Hypertension Risk Among African Americans in the Jackson Heart Study.” Hypertension76 (3): 715-723.
14.
GlasgowJoshuaHaslangerSallyJeffersChikeSpencerQuayshawn. 2019. What Is Race? Four Philosophical Views. Oxford University Press.
15.
GoodmanNelson. 1955 (1983). Fact, Fiction, and Forecast. 4th ed.Harvard University Press.
16.
HardimonMichael O.2017. Rethinking Race: The Case for Deflationary Reaslism. Harvard University Press.
17.
HaslangerSally. 2008. “A Social Constructionist Analysis of Race.” In Revisiting Race in a Genomic Age, edited by KoenigBarbara A.Soo-Jin LeeSandraRichardsonSarah S., 56-69. Rutgers University Press.
18.
HaslangerSally. 2012. Resisting Reality: Social Construction and Social Critique. Oxford University Press.
19.
JeffersChike. 2013. “The Cultural Theory of Race: Yet Another Look at Du Bois’s ‘The Conservation of Races.’” Ethics123 (3): 403-426.
20.
KendigCatherine. 2011. “Race as a Physiosocial Phenomenon.” History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences33 (2): 191-221.
21.
KentDavid M.ShahNilay D.. 2012. “Risk Models and Patient-Centered Evidence: Should Physicians Expect One Right Answer?” JAMA307 (15): 1585-1586.
22.
LadymanJames. 2012. “Science, Metaphysics and Method.” Philosophical Studies160 (1): 31-51.
23.
MasseyDouglas S.MooneyMargaritaTorresKimberly C.CharlesCamille Z.. 2007. “Black Immigrants and Black Natives Attending Selective Colleges and Universities in the United States.” American Journal of Education113 (2): 243-271.
24.
MillsCharles W.1998. Blackness Visible: Essays on Philosophy and Race. Cornell University Press.
25.
OutlawLucius. 1996. “‘Conserve’ Races? In Defense of W. E. B. Du Bois.” In W. E. B. Du Bois on Race and Culture: Philosophy, Politics, and Poetics, edited by BellBernard W.GrosholzEmilyStewartJames B., 15-37. Routledge.
26.
PearlJudea. 2015 (2022). “Detecting Latent Heterogeneity.” In Probabilistic and Causal Inference: The Works of Judea Pearl, edited by GeffnerHectorDechterRinaHalpernJoseph Y., 483-506. Association for Computing Machinery.
27.
PearlJudeaBareinboimElias. 2011. “Transportability of Causal and Statistical Relations: A Formal Approach.” In Proceedings of the 25th AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 247-254. AAAI Press.
28.
PeckRobert N.SmartLuke R.BeierRitaLiwaAnthony C.GrosskurthHeinerFitzgeraldDaniel W.SchmidtBernhard M. W.. 2013. “Difference in Blood Pressure Response to Ace-Inhibitor Monotherapy between Black and White Adults with Arterial Hypertension: A Meta-Analysis of 13 Clinical Trials.” BMC Nephrology14: 201.
29.
PokhrelAkritiOlayemiAdeniranOgbondaStephanieNairKironWangJen Chin. 2023. “Racial and Ethnic Differences in Sickle Cell Disease within the United States: From Demographics to Outcomes.” European Journal of Haematology110 (5): 554-563.
30.
RootMichael. 2000. “How We Divide the World.” Philosophy of Science67: S628-S639.
31.
RussoFederica. 2008. Causality and Causal Modelling in the Social Sciences: Measuring Variations. Springer.
SpencerQuayshawn. 2014. “A Radical Solution to the Race Problem.” Philosophy of Science81 (5): 1025-1038.
34.
SpencerQuayshawn. 2016. “Genuine Kinds and Scientific Reality.” In Natural Kinds and Classification in Scientific Practice, edited by KendigCatherine, 157-172. Routledge.
35.
SundstromRonald R.2002. “Race as a Human Kind.” Philosophy and Social Criticism28 (1): 91-115.
TaylorPaul C.2004. Race: A Philosophical Introduction. Polity Press.
38.
TsouJonathan Y.2020. “Social Construction, HPC Kinds, and the Projectability of Human Categories.” Philosophy of the Social Sciences50 (2): 115-137.
39.
TsouJonathan Y.2022. “Biological Essentialism, Projectable Human Kinds, and Psychiatric Classification.” Philosophy of Science89 (5): 1155-1165.
40.
VillarJoséIsmailLeila CheikhVictoraCesar G., et al.2014. “International Standards for Newborn Weight, Length, and Head Circumference by Gestational Age and Sex: The Newborn Cross-Sectional Study of the INTERGROWTH-21st Project.” Lancet384 (9946): 857-868.
41.
WoodwardJames. 2010. “Causation in Biology: Stability, Specificity, and the Choice of Levels of Explanation.” Biology & Philosophy25 (3): 287-318.
42.
YearbyRuqaiijah. 2018. “Racial Disparities in Health Status and Access to Healthcare: The Continuation of Inequality in the United States Due to Structural Racism.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology77 (3-4): 1113-1152.
