This research assesses the effects of choice alternatives on the travel destination decisions of travelers. The decoy effect involves the addition of a new inferior alternative into a choice set, thereby increasing the choice of an existing option. Meanwhile, the compromise effect involves the addition of a new alternative into a choice set that increases selection of an existing option with nonextreme attributes, and decreases selection of options with extreme attributes. In this study, a series of scenario-based experiments is performed to determine if the decoy and compromise effects influence travel destination decisions. Results show that the decoy effect is stronger in a choice (vs. rejection) task, whereas the compromise effect is stronger in a rejection (vs. choice) task when deciding travel destinations.
BornsteinB. H.EmlerA. C.2001. “Rationality in Medical Decision Making: A Review of the Literature on Doctors’ Decision-Making Biases.” Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice7 (2): 97–107.
4.
CarrollR.VallenB.2014. “Compromise and Attraction Effects in Food Choice.” International Journal of Consumer Studies38 (6): 636–41.
5.
ChernevA.2009. “Choosing versus Rejecting: The Impact of Goal-Task Compatibility on Decision Confidence.” Social Cognition27 (2): 249–60.
6.
ChungJ. Y.KyleG. T.PetrickJ. F.AbsherJ. D.2011. “Fairness of Prices, User Fee Policy and Willingness to Pay among Visitors to a National Forest.” Tourism Management32 (5): 1038–46.
7.
ChungJ. Y.PetrickJ. F.2013. “Price Fairness of Airline Ancillary Fees: An Attributional Approach.” Journal of Travel Research52 (2): 168–81.
8.
CromptonJ.1992. “Structure of Vacation Destination Choice Sets.” Annals of Tourism Research19 (3): 420–34.
9.
CromptonJ. L.AnkomahP. K.1993. “Choice Set Propositions in Destination Decisions.” Annals of Tourism Research20 (3): 461–76.
10.
DharR.SimonsonI.2003. “The Effect of Forced Choice on Choice.” Journal of Marketing Research40 (2): 146–60.
11.
GanzachY.1995. “Attribute Scatter and Decision Outcome: Judgment versus Choice.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes62 (1): 113–22.
12.
Gonzalez-PrietoD.SallanJ. M.SimoP.CarrionR.2013. “Effects of the Addition of Simple and Double Decoys on the Purchasing Process of Airline Tickets,” Journal of Air Transport Management29:39–45.
13.
FazioR.1990. “A Practical Guide to the Use of Response Latency in Social Psychological Research.” Research Methods in Personality and Social Psychology11:74–97.
14.
FergusonJ.EllenP. Scholder. 2013. “Transparency in Pricing and Its Effect on Perceived Price Fairness.” Journal of Product & Brand Management22 (5): 404–12.
15.
FleischerA.TchetchikA.ToledoT.2015. “Does It Pay to Reveal Safety Information? The Effect of Safety Information on Flight Choice.” Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies56:210–20.
16.
HerneK.1997. “Decoy Alternatives in Policy Choices: Asymmetric Domination and Compromise Effects.” European Journal of Political Economy13 (3): 575–89.
17.
HerneK.1999. “The Effects of Decoy Gambles on Individual Choice.” Experimental Economics2 (1): 31–40.
18.
HuY.RitchieJ. R. B.1993. “Measuring Destination Attractiveness: A Contingency Approach.” Journal of Travel Research32 (2): 25–34.
19.
HuberJ.PayneJ. W.PutoC.1982. “Adding Asymmetrically Dominated Alternatives: Violations of Regularity and the Similarity Hypothesis.” Journal of Consumer Research9 (1): 90–8.
20.
IyengarS. S.LepperM. R.2000. “When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology79 (6): 995–1006.
21.
JosiamB. M.HobsonJ. S.1995. “Consumer Choice in Context: The Decoy Effect in Travel and Tourism.” Journal of Travel Research34 (1): 45–50.
22.
KahnemanD.TverskyA.1979. “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk.” Econometrica47 (2): 263–92.
23.
KarlM.ReintingerC.SchmudeJ.2015. “Reject or Select: Mapping Destination Choice.” Annals of Tourism Research54:48–64.
24.
KellerC.MarkertF.BucherT.2015. “Nudging Product Choices: The Effect of Position Change on Snack Bar Choice.” Food Quality and Preference41:41–3.
25.
KhanU.ZhuM.KalraA.2011. “When Trade-offs Matter: The Effect of Choice Construal on Context Effects.” Journal of Marketing Research48 (1): 62–71.
26.
KimJ.2017. “The Influence of Graphical versus Numerical Information Representation Modes on the Compromise Effect.” Marketing Letters28 (3): 397–409.
27.
KimJ.KimP. B.KimJ. E.2018. “Different or Similar Choices: The Effect of Decision Framing on Variety Seeking in Travel Bundle Packages.” Journal of Travel Research57 (1): 99–105.
28.
KimJ.SpenceM. T.MarshallR.2018. “The Color of Choice: The Influence of Presenting Product Information in Color on the Compromise Effect.” Journal of Retailing94 (2): 167–85.
29.
KimJ. H.JangS. S.2014. “A Scenario-Based Experiment and a Field Study: A Comparative Examination for Service Failure and Recovery.” International Journal of Hospitality Management41:125–32.
30.
KimS. A.KimJ.2016. “The Influence of Hedonic versus Utilitarian Consumption Situations on the Compromise Effect.” Marketing Letters27 (2): 387–401.
31.
KimS.CromptonJ. L.2001. “The Effects of Different Types of Information Messages on Perceptions of Price and Stated Willingness-to-Pay.” Journal of Leisure Research33 (3): 299–318.
32.
KimS.CromptonJ. L.2002. “The Influence of Selected Behavioral and Economic Variables on Perceptions of Admission Price Levels.” Journal of Travel Research41 (2): 144–52.
33.
KozakM.KimS.ChonK.2017. “Competitiveness of Overseas Pleasure Destinations: A Comparison Study Based on Choice Sets.” International Journal of Tourism Research19 (5): 569–83.
34.
LaranJ.WilcoxK.2011. “Choice, Rejection, and Elaboration on Preference-Inconsistent Alternatives.” Journal of Consumer Research38 (2): 229–41.
35.
LarsonJ. S.BilleterD. M.2013. “Consumer Behavior in ‘Equilibrium’: How Experiencing Physical Balance Increases Compromise Choice.” Journal of Marketing Research50 (4): 535–47.
36.
LoewensteinG.1999. “Is More Choice Always Better?” Social Security Brief7:1–7.
37.
LuceM. F.BettmanR. R.PayneJ. W.1997. “Choice Processing in Emotionally Difficult Decisions.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition23 (2): 384–405.
38.
MeyerR.JohnsonE. J.1995. “Empirical Generalization in the Modeling of Consumer Choice.” Marketing Science14 (3): G180–9.
39.
MouraliM.BöckenholtU.LarocheM.2007. “Compromise and Attraction Effects under Prevention and Promotion Motivations.” Journal of Consumer Research34 (2): 234–47.
40.
MouraliM.NagpalA.2013. “The Powerful Select, the Powerless Reject: Power’s Influence in Decision Strategies.” Journal of Business Research66 (7): 874–80.
41.
MurphyH. C.ChenM.2016. “Online Information Sources Used in Hotel Bookings: Examining Relevance and Recall.” Journal of Travel Research55 (4): 523–36.
42.
NagpalA.LeiJ.KhareA.2015. “To Choose or to Reject: The Effect of Decision Frame on Food Customization Decisions.” Journal of Retailing91 (3): 422–35.
43.
OppenheimerD. M.MeyvisT.DavidenkoN.2009. “Instructional Manipulation Checks: Detecting Satisficing to Increase Statistical Power. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology45 (4): 867–72.
44.
OppewalH.HuybersT.CrouchG. I.2015. “Tourist Destination and Experience Choice: A Choice Experimental Analysis of Decision Sequence Effects.” Tourism Management48:467–76.
45.
ParkC. W.JunS. Y.MacInnisD. J.2000. “Choosing What I Want versus Rejecting What I Do Not Want: An Application of Decision Framing to Product Option Choice Decisions.” Journal of Marketing Research37 (2): 187–202.
46.
ParkJ.KimJ.2005. “The Effects of Decoys on Preference Shifts: The Role of Attractiveness and Providing Justification.” Journal of Consumer Psychology15 (2): 94–107.
47.
ParkJ. Y.JangS.2013. “Confused by Too Many Choices: Choice Overload in Tourism.” Tourism Management35:1–12.
48.
PayneJ. W.BettmanJ. R.JohnsonE. J.1993. The Adaptive Decision Maker. New York: Cambridge University Press.
49.
PerdueR. R.MengF.2006. “Understanding Choice and Rejection in Destination Consideration Sets.” Tourism Analysis11 (6): 337–48.
50.
PocheptsovaA.AmirO.DharR.BaumeisterR. F.2009. “Deciding without Resources: Resource Depletion and Choice in Context.” Journal of Marketing Research46 (3): 344–55.
51.
ScarpiD.2011. “The Impact of Phantom Decoys on Choices in Cats.” Animal Cognition14 (1): 127–36.
52.
ScheibehenneB.GreifenederR.ToddP. M.2009. “What Moderates the Too-Much-Choice Effect.” Psychology and Marketing26 (3): 229–53.
53.
SchoemakerP. J. H.1982. “The Expected Utility Model: Its Variants, Purposes, Evidence and Limitations.” Journal of Economic Literature20 (2): 529–63.
54.
SchwartzB.2000. “Self-Determination: The Tyranny of Freedom.” American Psychologist55:79–88.
55.
SchwartzJ. A.ChapmanG. B.1999. “Are More Options Always Better? The Attraction Effect in Physicians’ Decisions about Medications.” Medical Decision Making19 (3): 315–23.
56.
ShafirE.1993. “Choosing versus Rejecting: Why Some Options Are Both Better and Worse Than Others.” Memory and Cognition21 (4): 546–56.
SimonsonI.1989. “Choice Based on Reasons: The Case of Attraction and Compromise Effects.” Journal of Consumer Research16 (2): 158–74.
59.
SirakayaE.WoodsideA. G.2005. “Building and Testing Theories of Decision Making by Travellers.” Tourism Management26:815–32.
60.
SmithS. J.ParsaH. G.BujisicM.van der RestJ. P.2015. “Hotel Cancelation Policies, Distributive and Procedural Fairness, and Consumer Patronage: A Study of the Lodging Industry.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing32 (7): 886–906.
61.
SokolovaT.KrishnaA.2016. “Take It or Leave It: How Choosing versus Rejecting Alternatives Affects Information Processing.” Journal of Consumer Research43 (4): 614–35.
62.
SteckenreuterA.WolfI. D.2013. “How to Use Persuasive Communication to Encourage Visitors to Pay Park User Fees.” Tourism Management37:58–70.
63.
TanH.LvX.LiuX.GursoyD.2018. “Evaluation Nudge: Effect of Evaluation Mode of Online Customer Reviews on Consumers’ Preferences.” Tourism Management65:29–40.
64.
ThalerR.1985. “Mental Accounting and Consumer Choice.” Marketing Science4 (3): 199–214.
65.
ThalerR.SunsteinC.2008. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness. New Haven: Yale University Press.
66.
UmS.CromptonJ. L.1990. “Attitude Determinants in Tourism Destination Choice.” Annals of Tourism Research17 (3): 432–48.
67.
Van MiddelkoopM.BorgersA.TimmermansH.2003. “Inducing Heuristic Principles of Tourist Choice of Travel Mode: A Rule-Based Approach.” Journal of Travel Research42 (1): 75–83.
68.
WedellD. H.1997. “Another Look at Reasons for Choosing and Rejecting.” Memory & Cognition25 (6): 873–87.
69.
WedellD. H.PettiboneJ. C.1999. “Preference and the Contextual Basis of Ideals in Judgment and Choice.” Journal of Experimental Psychology128 (3): 346–61.
70.
WeinerB.2000. “Intrapersonal and Interpersonal Theories of Motivation from an Attributional Perspective.” Educational Psychology Review12 (1): 1–14.
71.
WoodsideA. G.KingR. I.2001. “An Updated Model of Travel and Tourism Purchase-Consumption Systems.” Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing10 (1): 3–27.
72.
WoodsideA. G.SherrelD.1977. “Traveler Evoked, Inept, and Inert Sets of Vacation Destinations.” Journal of Travel Research16 (1): 14–8.
73.
XiaL.MonroeK. B.CoxJ. L.2004. “The Price Is Unfair! A Conceptual Framework of Price Fairness Perceptions.” Journal of Marketing68 (4): 1–15.
