In this study, we investigate the causal relationships between international tourism growth and regional economic expansion in China, and more importantly, disclose the factors determining the occurrence of these relationships. The empirical results reveal that 10 of 29 regions experienced tourism-led growth (TLG) during 1978 to 2013, whereas nine regions experienced economy-driven tourism growth (EDTG). Different from the past literature, this study uses Bayesian probit models to unveil the factors influencing these different growth patterns. Our results suggest that regions with less-developed economies, larger economic sizes, and covering larger geographic areas are more likely to experience TLG, and regions with less-developed economies are more likely to experience EDTG as well. Lastly, practical implications are provided.
AdamouA.CleridesS.2010. “Prospects and Limits of Tourism-Led Growth: The International Evidence.” Review of Economic Analysis3: 287–303.
2.
AkinboadeO. A.BraimohL. A.2010. “International Tourism and Economic Development in South Africa: A Granger Causality Test.” International Journal of Tourism Research12 (2): 149–63.
3.
Albaladejo PinaI. P.Martínez-GarcíaM. P.2013. “An Endogenous Growth Model of International Tourism.” Tourism Economics19 (3): 509–29.
4.
AlgieriB.2006. “International Tourism Specialisation of Small Countries.” International Journal of Tourism Research8 (1): 1–12.
5.
AmisanoG.GiorgettiM. L.2013. “Entry into Pharmaceutical Submarkets: A Bayesian Panel Probit Analysis.” Journal of Applied Econometrics28 (4): 667–701.
6.
AntonakakisN.DragouniM.FilisG.2015. “How Strong Is the Linkage between Tourism and Economic Growth in Europe?”Economic Modelling44: 142–55.
7.
AslanA.2013. “Tourism Development and Economic Growth in the Mediterranean Countries: Evidence from Panel Granger Causality Tests.” Current Issues in Tourism17 (4): 363–72.
8.
BalaguerJ.Cantavella-JordáM.2002. “Tourism as a Long-Run Economic Growth Factor: The Spanish Case.” Applied Economics34 (7): 877–84.
9.
BelayS.2007. “Revealed Comparative Advantage and Competitiveness in Services: A Study with Special Emphasis on Developing Countries.” Journal of Economic Studies34 (5): 376–88.
10.
BrauR.LanzaA.PigliaruF.2007. “How Fast Are Small Tourism Countries Growing? Evidence from the Data for 1980–2003.” Tourism Economics13 (4): 603–14.
11.
BridaJ. G.Cortes-JimenezI.PulinaM.2016. “Has the Tourism-Led Growth Hypothesis Been Validated? A Literature Review.” Current Issues in Tourism19 (5): 394–430.
12.
CaponeF.BoixR.2008. “Sources of Growth and Competitiveness of Local Tourist Production Systems: An Application to Italy (1991–2001).” Annals of Regional Science42 (1): 209–24.
13.
Cárdenas-GarcíaP. J.Pulido-FernándezJ. I.2014. “Does the Investment Climate Determine the Transformation of Tourism Growth into Economic Development?”Tourism Economics20 (4): 669–94.
14.
Cárdenas-GarcíaP. J.Sánchez-RiveroM.2015. “Tourism and Economic Development: Analysis of Geographic Features and Infrastructure Provision.” Current Issues in Tourism18 (7): 609–32.
CaponeF.BoixR.2008. “Sources of Growth and Competitiveness of Local Tourist Production Systems: An Application to Italy (1991-2001).” Annals of Regional Science42 (1): 209–24.
17.
Castro-NuñoM.Molina-ToucedoJ. A.Pablo-RomeroM. P.2013. “Tourism and GDP: A Meta-analysis of Panel Data Studies.” Journal of Travel Research52 (6): 745–58.
18.
ChangC.-L.KhamkaewT.McAleerM.2012. “IV Estimation of a Panel Threshold Model of Tourism Specialization and Economic Development.” Tourism Economics18 (1): 5–41.
19.
ChaoC.-C.HazariB. R.LaffargueJ.-P.SgroP. M.YuE. S. H.2006. “Tourism, Dutch Disease and Welfare in an Open Dynamic Economy.” Japanese Economic Review57 (4): 501–15.
20.
ChenL. L.DevereuxJ.1999. “Tourism and Welfare in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Theoretical Analysis.” Journal of African Economies8 (2): 209–27.
21.
ChiuY. B.YehLung-Tai. 2016. “The Threshold Effects of the Tourism-Led Growth Hypothesis: Evidence from a Cross-Sectional Model.” Journal of Travel Research56 (5): 625–37.
22.
Claver-CortésE.Molina-Azorı’nJ. F.Pereira-MolinerJ.2007. “Competitiveness in Mass Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (3): 727–45.
23.
CopelandB. R.1991. “Tourism, Welfare and De-industrialization in a Small Open Economy.” Economica58 (232): 515–29.
24.
CorrieK.StoecklN.ChaiechiT.2013. “Tourism and Economic Growth in Australia: An Empirical Investigation of Causal Links.” Tourism Economics19 (6): 1317–44.
25.
Cortés-JiménezI.NowakJ.-J.SahliM.2011. “Mass Beach Tourism and Economic Growth: Lessons from Tunisia.” Tourism Economics17 (3): 531–47.
26.
CroesR.2011. “Measuring and Explaining Competitiveness in the Context of Small Island Destinations.” Journal of Travel Research50 (4): 431–42.
27.
CroesR.VanegasM.2008. “Cointegration and Causality between Tourism and Poverty Reduction.” Journal of Travel Research47 (1): 94–103.
28.
de la MataT.Llano-VerdurasC.2012. “Spatial Pattern and Domestic Tourism: An Econometric Analysis Using Inter-regional Monetary Flows by Type of Journey.” Papers in Regional Science91 (2): 437–70.
29.
del P. Pablo-RomeroM.MolinaJ. A.2013. “Tourism and Economic Growth: A Review of Empirical Literature.” Tourism Management Perspectives8: 28–41.
30.
De VitaG.KyawK. S.2016. “Tourism Specialization, Absorptive Capacity, and Economic Growth.” Journal of Travel Research56 (4): 423–35.
31.
DurbarryR.2004. “Tourism and Economic Growth: The Case of Mauritius.” Tourism Economics10 (4): 389–401.
32.
EdwardsY. D.AllenbyG. M.2003. “Multivariate Analysis of Multiple Response Data.” Journal of Marketing Research40 (3): 321–34.
33.
ElliottG.RothenbergT. J.StockJ. H.1996. “Efficient Tests for an Autoregressive Unit Root.” Econometrica64 (4): 813–36.
34.
Eugenio-MartínJ. L.Martín MoralesN.ScarpaR.2004. “Tourism and Economic Growth in Latin American Countries: A Panel Data Approach.” FEEM Working Paper No. 26. 2004.
35.
Eugenio-MartinJ. L.Martín-MoralesN.SinclairM. T.2008. “The Role of Economic Development in Tourism Demand.” Tourism Economics14 (4): 673–90.
36.
FawazF.RahnamaM.StoutB.2014. “An Empirical Refinement of the Relationship between Tourism and Economic Growth.” Anatolia25 (3): 352–63.
37.
FiginiP.ViciL.2010. “Tourism and Growth in a Cross section of Countries.” Tourism Economics16 (4): 789–805.
38.
GrangerC. W. J.1988. “Causality, Cointegration, and Control.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control12 (2/3): 551–59.
39.
GunduzL.Hatemi-JA.2005. “Is the Tourism-Led Growth Hypothesis Valid for Turkey?” Applied Economics Letters12 (8): 499–504.
HuseM.GustavsenT.AlmedalS.1998. “Tourism Impact Comparisons among Norwegian Towns.” Annals of Tourism Research25 (3): 721–38.
42.
IvanovS. H.WebsterC.2013. “Tourism’s Contribution to Economic Growth: A Global Analysis for the First Decade of the Millennium.” Tourism Economics19 (3): 477–508.
43.
KatirciogluS. T.2009. “Tourism, Trade and Growth: The Case of Cyprus.” Applied Economics41 (21): 2741–50.
44.
KhadarooJ.SeetanahB.2007. “Transport Infrastructure and Tourism Development.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (4): 1021–32.
45.
KimH. J.ChenM.-H.JangS. S.2006. “Tourism Expansion and Economic Development: The Case of Taiwan.” Tourism Management27 (5): 925–33.
46.
Koenig-LewisN.BischoffE. E.2005. “Seasonality Research: The State of the Art.” International Journal of Tourism Research7 (4/5): 201–19.
LanzaA.PigliaruF.2000. “Why Are Tourism Countries Small and Fast-Growing?” In Tourism and Sustainable Economic Development, edited by FossatiA.PanellaG., 57–69. New York: Springer.
49.
LanzaA.TempleP.UrgaG.2003. “The Implications of Tourism Specialisation in the Long Run: An Econometric Analysis for 13 OECD Economies.” Tourism Management24 (3): 315–21.
50.
LeeC.-C.ChangC.-P.2008. “Tourism Development and Economic Growth: A Closer Look at Panels.” Tourism Management29 (1): 180–92.
51.
LeonesJ.ColbyB.CrandallK.1998. “Tracking Expenditures of the Elusive Nature Tourists of Southeastern Arizona.” Journal of Travel Research36 (3): 56–64.
52.
LesageJ. P.FischerM. M.2008. “Spatial Growth Regressions: Model Specification, Estimation and Interpretation.” Spatial Economic Analysis3 (3): 275–304.
53.
LuoH.YanY.YangY.2016. “Can Comparative Advantage Theory Explain Tourism Growth Models of Chinese Provinces? An Inter-Provincial Study on the Contribution of Production Factors to Tourism Growth and the Comparative Advantage of Tourism Resources in China”. Tourism Tribune31(3): 43–53.
54.
MaM.HassinkR.2013. “An Evolutionary Perspective on Tourism area Development”. Annals of Tourism Research41: 89–109.
55.
MaT.HongT.ZhangH.2015. “Tourism Spatial Spillover Effects and Urban Economic Growth.” Journal of Business Research68 (1): 71–80.
56.
McKercherB.ChanA.LamC.2008. “The Impact of Distance on International Tourist Movements.”Journal of Travel Research47(2): 208–24.
57.
NarayanP. K.NarayanS.2005. “Estimating Income and Price Elasticities of Imports for Fiji in a Cointegration Framework.” Economic Modelling22 (3): 423–38.
58.
NgS.PerronP.2001. “Lag Length Selection and the Construction of Unit Root Tests with Good Size and Power.” Econometrica69 (6): 1519–54.
59.
NowakJ.-J.SahliM.2007. “Coastal Tourism and ‘Dutch Disease’ in a Small Island Economy.” Tourism Economics13 (1): 49–65.
OhC.-O.2005. “The Contribution of Tourism Development to Economic Growth in the Korean Economy.” Tourism Management26 (1): 39–44.
62.
ParrillaJ. C.FontA. R.NadalJ. R.2007. “Tourism and Long-Term Growth a Spanish Perspective.” Annals of Tourism Research34 (3): 709–26.
63.
PayneJ. E.MervarA.2010. “The Tourism’s Growth Nexus in Croatia.” Tourism Economics16 (4): 1089–94.
64.
PesaranM. H.ShinY.1998. “An autoregressive Distributed-Lag Modelling Approach to Cointegration Analysis.” In Econometric Society Monographs, edited by StrømS., 371–413. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
65.
PesaranM. H.ShinY.SmithR. J.2001. “Bounds Testing Approaches to the Analysis of Level Relationships.” Journal of Applied Econometrics16 (3): 289–326.
66.
PrattS.2011. “Economic Linkages and Impacts across the TALC.” Annals of Tourism Research38 (2): 630–50.
67.
Pulido-FernándezJ. I.Cárdenas-GarcíaP. J.Villanueva-ÁlvaroJ. J.2013. “On the Role of Environmental Sustainability in the Transformation of Tourism Growth into Economic Development.” Environmental Engineering and Management Journal (EEMJ)12 (10): 2009-18.
68.
RidderstaatJ.CroesR.NijkampP.2014. “Tourism and Long-Run Economic Growth in Aruba.” International Journal of Tourism Research16 (5): 472–87.
69.
Robles TeigeiroL.DíazB.2014. “Estimation of Multipliers for the Activity of Hotels and Restaurants.” Tourism Management40:27–34.
70.
RossiP. E.AllenbyG. M.McCullochR.2012. Bayesian Statistics and Marketing. Chichester, UK: John Wiley and Sons.
71.
Sánchez-RiveroM.Cárdenas-GarcíaP. J.2014. “Population Characteristics and the Impact of Tourism on Economic Development.” Tourism Geographies16 (4): 615–35.
72.
SeetanahB.2011. “Assessing the Dynamic Economic Impact of Tourism for Island Economies.” Annals of Tourism Research38 (1): 291–308.
73.
SequeiraT. N.Maçãs NunesP.2008. “Does Tourism Influence Economic Growth? A Dynamic Panel Data Approach.” Applied Economics40 (18): 2431–41.
74.
ShanJ.WilsonK.2001. “Causality between Trade and Tourism: Empirical Evidence from China.” Applied Economics Letters8 (4): 279–83.
75.
TangC.2011. “Is the Tourism-Led Growth Hypothesis Valid for Malaysia? A View from Disaggregated Tourism Markets.” International Journal of Tourism Research13 (1): 97–101.
76.
TangC.-H.JangS.2009. “The Tourism–Economy Causality in the United States: A Sub-industry Level Examination.” Tourism Management30 (4): 553–58.
77.
TodaH. Y.YamamotoT.1995. “Statistical Inference in Vector Autoregressions with Possibly Integrated Processes.” Journal of Econometrics66 (1/2): 225–50.
78.
UNWTO (United Nations World Tourism Organization). 2017. Compendium of Tourism Statistics, Data 2011–2015, 2017 ed. Madrid, Spain: World Tourism Organization.
79.
UNWTO (United Nations World Tourism Organization). 2018. UNWTO World Tourism Barometer, January 2018, vol. 16. Madrid, Spain: World Tourism Organization.
80.
van LeeuwenE. S.NijkampP.RietveldP.2009. “A Meta-analytic Comparison of Regional Output Multipliers at Different Spatial Levels: Economic Impacts of Tourism.” In Advances in Tourism Economics: New Developments, edited by MatiasÁ.NijkampP.SarmentoM., 13–33. Heidelberg: Physica-Verlag.
81.
WeidenfeldA.2013. “Tourism and Cross Border Regional Innovation Systems.” Annals of Tourism Research42:191–213.
82.
WuD. C.SongH.ShenS.2017. “New Developments in Tourism and Hotel Demand Modeling and Forecasting.” International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management29 (1): 507–29.
83.
YangY.FikT.2014. “Spatial Effects in Regional Tourism Growth.” Annals of Tourism Research46:144–62.
84.
YangY.WongK. K. F.2012. “A Spatial Econometric Approach to Model Spillover Effects in Tourism Flows.” Journal of Travel Research51 (6): 768–78.
ZuoB.HuangS.2018. “Revisiting the Tourism-Led Economic Growth Hypothesis: The Case of China.” Journal of Travel Research57 (2): 151–63.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
