Occupational uncertainty has a considerable effect upon consumer decisions during a recession, especially with respect to discretionary products and services such as tourism. Using Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), the study examines the complex relations among job vulnerability, disposable income for tourism, marketing activities, and price and quality issues for Greek holiday makers returning from their vacations. The article also compares QCA with the two dominant linear methods of analysis (i.e. correlation and regression) and highlights the suitability of QCA when dealing with complexity in tourism. The results reveal four configurations explaining the attributes of Greek residents’ tourism decisions, characterized by value-for-money orientation, achievement of best available purchase, psychological strengthening, and price sensitivity. The study also employs predictive validity for the presented models. The findings are valid from both a methodological and managerial perspective suggesting new research insights.
AakerD.DayG.1990. Marketing Research. New York: John Wiley.
2.
AkisS.PeristianisN.WarnerJ.1996. “Residents’ Attitudes to Tourism Development: The Case of Cyprus.” Tourism Management17 (7): 481–94.
3.
AlegreJ.MateoS.PouL.2013. “Tourism Participation and Expenditure by Spanish Households: The Effects of the Economic Crisis and Unemployment.” Tourism Management39:37–49.
Alonso-AlmeidaM.BremserK.2013. “Strategic Responses of the Spanish Hospitality Sector to the Financial Crisis.” International Journal of Hospitality Management32:141–48.
6.
ArmstrongJ.2012. “Illusions in Regression Analysis.” International Journal of Forecasting28(3): 689-694.
7.
ArgyrouM. G.TsoukalasJ. D.2011. “The Greek Debt Crisis: Likely Causes, Mechanisms, and Outcomes.” The World Economy34 (2): 173–91.
8.
AshfordN. A.HallR. P.AshfordR. H.2012. “The Crisis in Employment and Consumer Demand: Reconciliation with Environmental Sustainability.” Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions2:1–22.
9.
BankerR. D.KhoslaI. K.SinhaK.1998. “Quality and Competition.” Management Science44 (9): 1179–92.
10.
BimonteS.FarallaV.2014. “Happiness and Nature-Based Vacations.” Annals of Tourism Research46:176–78.
11.
BlasS. S.Carvajal-TrujilloE.2014. “Cruise Passengers’ Experiences in a Mediterranean Port of Call. The Case Study of Valencia.” Ocean & Coastal Management102 (A): 307–16.
12.
BoukasN.ZiakasV.2014. “A Chaos Theory Perspective of Destination Crisis and Sustainable Tourism Development in Islands: The Case of Cyprus.” Tourism Planning and Development11 (2): 191–208.
13.
BroonerF.de HoogR.2014. “Vacationers and the Economic ‘Double Dip’ in Europe.” Tourism Management40:330–37.
14.
ByrneD.1998. Complexity Theory and the Social Sciences: An Introduction. London: Routledge.
15.
ChenC. C.PetrickJ. F.2016. “The Roles of Perceived Travel Benefits, Importance, and Constraints in Predicting Travel Behavior.” Journal of Travel Research55 (4): 509–22.
16.
ChikwecheT.FletcherR.2010. “Understanding Factors That Influence Purchases in Subsistence Markets.” Journal of Business Research63 (6): 643–50.
17.
ChoV.2001. “Tourism Forecasting and Its Relationship with Leading Economic Indicators.” Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research25 (4): 399–420.
18.
DosiG.FagioloG.NapoletanoM.RoventiniA.2013. “Income Distribution, Credit and Fiscal Policies in an Agent-Based Keynesian Model.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control37 (8): 1598–1625.
19.
EconomouM.MadianosM.PeppouL. E.PatelakisA.StefanisC. N.2013. “Major Depression in the Era of Economic Crisis: A Replication of a Cross-Sectional Study across Greece.” Journal of Affective Disorders145 (3): 308–14.
20.
Eugenio-MartinJ. L.Campos-SoriaJ. A.2014. “Economic Crisis and Tourism Expenditure Cutback Decision.” Annals of Tourism Research44:53–73.
21.
Eurofound. 2005. Quality of Life in Europe: Working and Living in an Enlarged Europe. European Foundation for the Improvement of Living, Luxembourg: Working Conditions Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
22.
European Commission. 2013. EU Employment and Social Situation: Quarterly Review June 2013. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
23.
FaulknerB.RussellR.2000. “Turbulence, Chaos and Complexity in Tourism Systems: A Research Direction for the New Millennium.” In Tourism in the 21st Century: Lessons from Experience, edited by FaulknerR.MoscardoG.LawsE., 328–49. London: Continuum.
24.
FergusonV. L.2014. “Implementing Price Increases in Turbulent Economies: Pricing Approaches for Reducing Perceptions of Price Unfairness.” Journal of Business Research67 (1): 2732–37.
25.
FissP. C.2011. “Building Better Causal Theories: A Fuzzy Set Approach to Typologies in Organization Research.” Academy of Management Journal54 (2): 393– 420.
26.
FitzgeraldL. A.EijnattenF. M.2002. “Chaos Speak: A Glossary of Chaordic Terms and Phrases.” Journal of Organizational Change Management15 (4): 412–23.
GhellabY.PapadakisK.2011. “The Politics of Economic Adjustment: State Unilateralism or Social Dialogue?” In The Global Crisis: Causes, Responses and Challenges, edited by SomaviaJ.81–91. Geneva: ILO.
29.
GigerenzerG.BrightonH.2009. “Homo Heuristics: Why Biased Minds Make Better Inferences.” Topics in Cognitive Science1:107–43.
30.
GoumagiasN. D.Hristu-VarsakelisD.SaraidarisA.2012. “A Decision Support Model for Tax Revenue Collection in Greece.” Decision Support Systems53 (1): 76–96.
31.
GrossM. J.BrownG.2008. “An Empirical Structural Model of Tourists and Places: Progressing Involvement and Place Attachment into Tourism.” Tourism Management29 (6): 1141–51.
HelliwellJ.LayardR.SachsJ.2015. World Happiness Report 2015. New York: Sustainable Development Solutions Network.
34.
IfantiA. A.ArgyriouA. A.KalofonouF. H.KalofonosH. P.2013. “Financial Crisis and Austerity Measures in Greece: Their Impact on Health Promotion Policies and Public Health Care.” Health Policy113 (1-2): 8–12.
35.
International Monetary Fund. 2011. World Economic Outlook. World Economic and Financial Surveys. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
KaytazM.GulM. C.2014. “Consumer Response to Economic Crisis and Lessons for Marketers: The Turkish Experience.” Journal of Business Research67 (1): 2701–6.
38.
KentR. A.ArgouslidisP. C.2005. “Shaping Business Decisions Using Fuzzy-Set Analysis.” Journal of Marketing Management21 (5-6): 641–58.
39.
KimH. W.XuY.GuptaS.2012. “Which Is More Important in Internet Shopping, Perceived Price or Trust?”Electronic Commerce Research & Applications11 (3): 241–52.
40.
KuhnP.2002. Losing Work, Moving On: International Perspectives on Worker Displacement. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
41.
KyleG.GraefeA.ManningR.BaconJ.2003. “An Examination of the Relationships between Leisure Activity Involvement and Place Attachment among Hikers along the Appalachian Trail.” Journal of Leisure Research35 (3): 249–73.
42.
LawsE.PrideauxB.2005. “Crisis Management: A Suggested Typology.” Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing19 (2/3): 1–8.
43.
LeahyA.HealyS.MurphyM.2014. The European Crisis and Its Human Cost: A Call for Fair Alternatives and Solutions. Dublin: Social Justice Ireland.
44.
LegewieN.2013. “An Introduction to Applied Data Analysis with Qualitative Comparative Analysis.” Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung/Forum: Qualitative Social Research14 (3): 1–45.
45.
LiG.SongH.WittS. F.2005. “Recent Developments in Econometric Modelling and Forecasting.” Journal of Travel Research44 (1): 82–99.
46.
LichtensteinD. R.BurtonS.1989. “The Relationship between Perceived and Objective Price-Quality.” Journal of Marketing Research26 (4): 429–43.
47.
LichtensteinD. R.RidgwayN. M.NetemeyerR. G.1993. “Price Perceptions and Consumer Shopping Behavior: A Field Study.” Journal of Marketing Research30 (2): 234–45.
48.
LongestK.VaiseyS.2008. “Fuzzy: A Program for Performing Qualitative Comparative Analyses (QCA) in STATA.” STATA Journal8 (1): 79–104.
49.
MarcussenC. H.2011. “Determinants of Tourist Spending in Cross-Sectional Studies and at Danish Destinations.” Tourism Economics17 (4): 833–55.
50.
MarkovitisY.BoerD.Van DickR.2014. “Economic Crisis and the Employee: The Effects of Economic Crisis on Employee Job Satisfaction, Commitment, and Self-Regulation.” European Management Journal32 (3): 413–22.
51.
MartinD.IsozakiM.2013. “Hotel Marketing Strategies in Turbulent Times: Path Analysis of Strategic Decisions.” Journal of Business Research66 (9): 1544–49.
52.
McDonaldJ. R.2009. “Complexity Science: An Alternative World View for Understanding Sustainable Tourism Development.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism17 (4): 455–71.
53.
McKenzieD.SchargrodskyE.2011. “Buying Less but Shopping More: The Use of Nonmarket Labor during a Crisis.” Journal of LACEA Economia11 (2): 1–35.
54.
MelloP. A.2014a. “A Comparative Analysis of Constitutional and Political Restrictions on the Use of Force.” Paper presented at: 4th Global International Studies Conference, 6–9 August, Frankfurt, Germany.
55.
MelloP. A.2014b. Democratic Participation in Armed Conflict: Military Involvement in Kosovo, Afghanistan, and Iraq. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
56.
MinnaretL.MaitlandR.MillerG.2009. “Tourism and Social Policy: The Value of Social Tourism.” Annals of Tourism Research56 (2): 316–34.
57.
MoorthyK. S.1988. “Product and Price Competition in a Duopoly.” Marketing Science7 (2): 141–68.
58.
MorganN.PritchardA.SedgleyD.2015. “Social Tourism and Well-Being in Later Life.” Annals of Tourism Research52:1–15.
59.
MurphyE.ScottM.2014. “Household Vulnerability in Rural Areas: Results of an Index Applied during a Housing Crash, Economic Crisis and under Austerity Conditions.” Geoforum51:75–86.
60.
NealJ. D.UysalM.SirgyM. J.2007. “The Effect of Tourism Services on Travelers’ Quality of Life.” Journal of Travel Research46 (2): 154–63.
61.
NicolauJ. L.2012. “Asymmetric Tourist Response to Price: Loss Aversion Segmentation.” Journal of Travel Research51 (5): 568–76.
62.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development). 2013. OECD Employment Outlook 2013. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, Publishing. 29July2013.
63.
OkumusF.KaramustafaK.2005. “Impact of an Economic Crisis: Evidence from Turkey.” Annals of Tourism Research32 (4): 942–61.
64.
OlmedoE.MateosR.2015. “Quantitative Characterization of Chaordic Tourist Destination.” Tourism Management47:115–26.
65.
OlthuisG.2015. Unified Protector: Protection of Civilians? Master’s thesis, University of Twente / University of Munster.
66.
OrdaniniA.ParasuramanA.RuberaG.2014. “When the Recipe Is More Important Than the Ingredients: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) of Service Innovation Configurations.” Journal of Service Research17 (2): 134–49.
67.
PapatheodorouA.2001 “Why People Travel to Different Places?”Annals of Tourism Research28 (1): 164–79.
68.
PapatheodorouA.ArvanitisP.2014. “Tourism and the Economic Crisis in Greece: Regional Perspectives.” Region et Développement39:183–203.
69.
PapatheodorouA.RossellóJ.XiaoH.2010. “Global Economic Crisis and Tourism: Consequences and Perspectives.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 39–45.
70.
PappasN.2014. “The Effect of Distance, Expenditure and Culture on the Expression of Social Status through Tourism.” Tourism Planning & Development11 (4): 387–404.
71.
PappasN.2015a. “Achieving Competitiveness in Greek Accommodation Establishments during Recession.” International Journal of Tourism Research17 (4): 375–87.
72.
PappasN.2015b. “Marketing Hospitality Industry in an Era of Crisis.” Tourism Planning and Development12 (3): 333–49.
73.
PappasN.2016. “Marketing Strategies, Perceived Risks, and Consumer Trust in Online Buying Behaviour.” Journal of Retailing & Consumer Services29:92–103.
74.
PettigrewS.AndersonL.BolandW.de La VilleV.FifitaI. M. E.Fosse-GomezM. H.KindtM.LuukkanenL.MartinI.OzanneL.K.. 2014. “The Experience of Risk in Families: Conceptualisations and Implications for Transformative Consumer Research.” Journal of Marketing Management30 (17-18): 1772–99.
75.
QuelchJ. A.JoczK. E.2009. “How to Market in a Downturn.” Harvard Business Review36–46.
76.
RaginC. C.2000. Fuzzy-Set Social Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
77.
RihouxB.RaginC. C.2009. Configurational Comparative Methods: Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) and Related Techniques. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
78.
RitchieJ. R. B.MolinarC. M. A.FrechtlingD. C.2010. “Impacts of World Recession and Economic Crisis on Tourism: North America.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 5–15.
79.
RobertsS.PashlerH.2000. “How Persuasive is a Good Fit? A Comment on Theory Testing.” Psychological Review107: 358-367.
80.
RussellR.FaulknerB.2004. “Entrepreneurship, Chaos and the Tourism Area Lifecycle.” Annals of Tourism Research31 (3): 556–79.
81.
SanchezJ.CallarisaL.RodrıguezR. M.MolinerM. A.2006. “Perceived Value of the Purchase of a Tourism Product.” Tourism Management27 (3): 394–409.
82.
SchneiderC. Q.RohlfingI.2013. “Combining QCA and Process Training in Set-Theoretic Multi-method Research.” Sociological Methods and Research42 (4): 559–97.
83.
SeabraC.AbrantesJ. L.KastenholzE.2014. “The Influence of Terrorism Risk Perception on Purchase Involvement and Safety Concern of International Travellers.” Journal of Marketing Management30 (9-10): 874–903.
84.
SekaranU.BougieR.2009. Research Methods for Business: A Skill-Building Approach. Chichester, UK: Wiley.
SheldonP.DwyerL.2010. “The Global Financial Crisis and Tourism: Perspectives of the Academy.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 3–4.
87.
SinkovicsR. R.LeelapanyalertK.YaminM.2010. “A Comparative Examination of Consumer Decision Styles in Austria.” Journal of Marketing Management26 (11/12): 1021–36.
88.
SkarmeasD.LeonidouC. N.SaridakisC.2014. “Examining the Role of CSR Skepticism Using Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis.” Journal of Business Research67:1796–1805.
89.
SmeralE.2009. “The Impact of the Financial and Economic Crisis on European Tourism.” Journal of Travel Research48 (1): 3–13.
90.
SmeralE.2010. “Impacts of the World Recession and Economic Crisis on Tourism: Forecasts and Potential Risks.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 31–38.
91.
SongH.LinS.2010. “Impact of the Financial Economic Crisis on Tourism in Asia.” Journal of Travel Research49 (1): 16–30.
92.
TarnanidisT.Owusu-FrimpongN.NwankwoS.OmarM.2015. “A Confirmatory Factor Analysis of Consumer Styles Inventory: Evidence from Greece.” Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services22:164–77.
93.
ThraneC.FarsadE.2011. “Domestic Tourism Expenditures: The Non-linear Effects of Length of Stay and Travel Party Size.” Tourism Management32:46–52.
94.
TixierD.2010. “Recession or Mutation? Post-recovery Appeal of Major Consumer Brands.” Australasian Marketing Journal18 (3): 183–85.
United Nations World Tourism Organization. 2011. UNWTO Tourism Highlights. Madrid: World Tourism Organization.
97.
Van der MeerR. B.QuigleyJ.StorbeckJ. E.2005. “Using Regression Analysis to Model the Performance of UK Coastguard Centres.” Journal of the Operational Research Society56 (6): 630–41.
98.
VenierisD.2013. Crisis Social Policy and Social Justice: The Case for Greece. GreeSE Paper 69. April, 2013. London: London School of Economics, Hellenic Observatory, European Institution.
99.
VlontzosG.DuquenneM. N.2013. “Identification of Decision Making for Food under Economic Crisis: The Case of Greece.” Procedia Technology8:306–14.
100.
WangY. S.2009. “The Impact of Crisis Events and Macroeconomic Activity on Taiwan’s International Inbound Tourism Demand.” Tourism Management30 (1): 75–82.
101.
WhitefieldR. I.DuffyA. H. B.2012. “Extended Revenue Forecasting within a Service Industry.” International Journal of Production Economics141 (2): 505–18.
102.
WoodsideA. G.2013. “Moving beyond Multiple Regression Analysis to Algorithms: Calling for Adoption of a Paradigm Shift from Symmetric to Asymmetric Thinking in Data Analysis and Crafting Theory.” Journal of Business Research66 (4): 463–72.
103.
WoodsideA. G.2014. “Embrace•perform•model: Complexity Theory, Contrarian Case Analysis, and Multiple Realities.” Journal of Business Research67 (12): 2495–2503.
104.
WoodsideA. G.ZhangM.2013. “Cultural Diversity and Marketing Transactions: Are Market Integration, Large Community Size, and World Religions Necessary for Fairness in Ephemeral Exchanges?” Psychology & Marketing30 (3): 263–76.
105.
WuP. L.YehS. S.HuanT. C.WoodsideA. G.2014. “Applying Complexity Theory to Deepen Service Dominant Logic: Configural Analysis of Customer Experience-and-Outcome Assessments of Professional Services for Personal Transformations.” Journal of Business Research67 (8): 1647–70.
106.
YapG.AllenD.2011. “Investigating Other Leading Indicators Influencing Australian Domestic Tourism Demand.” Mathematics & Computers in Simulation81 (7): 1365–74.
107.
YoungT. R.1991. “Chaos and Social Change: Metaphysics of the Postmodern.” Social Science Journal28 (3): 289–306.
108.
YuJ.MaS.2013. “Impact of Decision Sequence of Pricing and Quality Investment in Decentralized Assembly System.” Journal of Manufacturing Systems32 (4): 664–79.
109.
ZahraA.RyanC.2007. “From Chaos to Cohesion—Complexity in Tourism Structures: An Analysis of New Zealand’s Regional Tourism Organisations.” Tourism Management28 (3): 854–62.
110.
ZeithamlV. A.1988. “Consumer Perceptions of Price, Quality, and Value: A Means–End Model and Synthesis of Evidence.” Journal of Marketing52 (3): 2–22.
111.
ZhouK. Z.SuC.BaoY.2002. “A Paradox of Price-Quality and Market Efficiency: A Comparative Study of US and China Markets.” International Journal of Research in Marketing19 (4): 349–65.
