This article inquires how proposed urban futures are stuck in the past. Dwelling on the ponderous nature of bureaucratic planning systems in the governance of urban water scarcity, it illuminates situations where the pace of climate change overtakes planning’s sustainability visions, rendering planned futures obsolete. Which temporal dynamics characterise this process? And what are the democratic stakes embedded in the making of these temporalities? Combining literatures on temporalities and planning, water as a temporal factor and the plural politics of emergencies, the article breaks new ground in urban future studies. It investigates the contradictory temporalities employed by different actors in the governance of water scarcity, and the role of hydrological time in the emergency politics associated with it. Building on the work of political theorist Jonathan White in particular, it attends to the democratic stakes in this process. Empirically, the article focuses on Germany’s planned Lusatia Lake District, which is set to become Europe’s largest artificial lake district through the flooding of abandoned coalfields. However, the region is now characterised by depleting water resources because regional plans failed to anticipate the combined effects of mining and climate change on water. Based on qualitative case study research in two towns, I argue that planning in Lusatia produces past futures, that is, visions no longer adequate for the contemporary moment. My line of argument unfolds through highlighting the contradictions inherent in the making of past futures by examining three sets of temporal dynamics: futures near and far, futures calculated and imagined and calls for speeding up and slowing down. They emerge from authorities holding on to outdated plans and growth-driven forecasts, entailing economically motivated projections of the future that skew decision making towards economic rationales at environmental costs.
AbramSWeszkalnysG (2011) Anthropologies of planning. Temporality, imagination, and ethnography. Focaal2011(61): 3–18.
2.
AdamB (1994) Time and Social Theory. Polity Press.
3.
AngeloH (2017) From the city lens toward urbanisation as a way of seeing: Country/city binaries on an urbanising planet. Urban Studies54(1): 158–178.
4.
AngeloHWachsmuthD (2015) Urbanizing urban political ecology: A critique of methodological cityism. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research39(1): 16–27.
5.
AnwarNHSawasAMustafaD (2020) ‘Without water, there is no life’: Negotiating everyday risks and gendered insecurities in Karachi’s informal settlements. Urban Studies57(6): 1320–1337.
6.
BakerZEkstromJBedsworthL (2018) Climate information? Embedding climate futures within temporalities of California water management. Environmental Sociology4(4): 419–433.
7.
BakkerK (2003) An Uncooperative Commodity: Privatizing Water in England and Wales. Oxford University Press.
8.
BarakO (2013) On Time: Technology and Temporality in Modern Egypt. University of California Press.
9.
BastianM (2014) Time and community: A scoping study. Time & Society23(2): 137–166.
10.
BearL (2014) Doubt, conflict, mediation: The anthropology of modern time. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute20(S1): 3–30.
11.
BerryKACohnTC (2023) Space, time, and hydrosocial imaginaries: Water quality governance of the Pyramid Lake Paiute tribe. Professional Geographer75(2): 296–304.
12.
BesedovskyNGrafeF-JHilbrandtH, et al. (2019) Time as infrastructure: For an analysis of contemporary urbanization. City23(4–5): 580–588.
BrennerN (1999) Globalisation as reterritorialisation: The re-scaling of urban governance in the European Union. Urban Studies36(3): 431–451.
15.
BrennerNKatsikisN (2020) Operational landscapes: Hinterlands of the Capitalocene. Architectural Design90: 22–31.
16.
BrennerNSchmidC (2014) The ‘urban age’ in question. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research38(3): 731–755.
17.
BrittonAOlmedoLTorresCA, et al. (2024) Hydrosocial imaginaries of green extractivism: Water-energy transitions and geothermal lithium development at the Salton Sea in Imperial Valley, California. Extractive Industries and Society20: 101567.
CalderonCMutterAWestinM, et al. (2024) Navigating swift and slow planning: Planners’ balancing act in the design of participatory processes. European Planning Studies32(2): 390–409.
21.
Cavazos CohnTBerryKPowys WhyteK, et al. (2019) Spatio-temporality and tribal water quality governance in the United States. Water11(1): 99.
22.
ChakkalakalSRenJ (2022) Un/doing future, unsettling temporalization. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research46(5): 845–850.
DattaA (2024) Distant time: The future of urbanisation from ‘there’ and ‘then’. Dialogues in Human Geography. Epub ahead of print 15May2024. DOI: 10.1177/20438206241253567.
25.
EdensorTHeadLKothariU (2020) Time, temporality and environmental change. Geoforum108: 255–258.
FabianJ (2014) Time and the Other: How Anthropology Makes Its Object. Columbia University Press.
28.
FordP (2008) Taboo: Time and belief in exotica. Representations103(1): 107–135.
29.
GhoshSMeerA (2021) Extended urbanisation and the agrarian question: Convergences, divergences and openings. Urban Studies58(6): 1097–1119.
30.
GiddensA (1981) Time and space in social theory. In: MatthesJ (ed.) Lebenswelt Und Soziale Probleme: Verhandlungen Des 20. Deutschen Soziologentages Zu Bremen 1980. Campus, pp.88–97.
31.
GrafeF-JHilbrandtH (2019) The temporalities of financialization: Infrastructures, dominations and openings in the Thames Tideway Tunnel. City23(4–5): 606–618.
32.
GuyerJI (2007) Prophecy and the near future: Thoughts on macroeconomic, evangelical, and punctuated time. American Ethnologist34(3): 409–421.
HajerMVersteegW (2019) Imagining the post-fossil city: Why is it so difficult to think of new possible worlds?Territory Politics Governance7(2): 122–134.
35.
HarrisonP (2006) On the edge of reason: Planning and urban futures in Africa. Urban Studies43(2): 319–335.
36.
HaugP (2004) Sinkende Einwohnerzahlen und steigende Kosten für kommunale Leistungen. Wirtschaft im Wandel10(11): 306–312.
37.
HeynenNKaikaMSwyngedouwE (2005) Urban political ecology: Politicizing the production of urban natures. In: HeynenNKaikaMSwyngedouwE (eds) In the Nature of Cities: Urban Political Ecology and the Politics of Urban Metabolism. Routledge, pp.1–20.
38.
HoustonDHillierJMacCallumD, et al. (2018) Make kin, not cities! Multispecies entanglements and ‘becoming-world’ in planning theory. Planning Theory17(2): 190–212.
39.
HuangJ-TWangC-H (2023) Water infrastructure and the imaginary of unfinished urban modernity in Taiwan. Professional Geographer75(2): 278–287.
40.
HudsonJ (2015) The multiple temporalities of informal spaces. Geography Compass9(8): 461–481.
41.
HüttlRF (1998) Ecology of post strip-mining landscapes in Lusatia, Germany. Environmental Science & Policy1(2): 129–135.
JonI (2020) Deciphering posthumanism: Why and how it matters to urban planning in the Anthropocene. Planning Theory19(4): 392–420.
44.
KabischNHaaseDHaaseA (2010) Evolving reurbanisation? Spatio-temporal dynamics as exemplified by the East German City of Leipzig. Urban Studies47(5): 967–990.
45.
KoziolM (2004) Folgen des demographischen Wandels für die kommunale Infrastruktur. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Kommunalwissenschafte1: 69–83.
LeitnerHSheppardE (2022) Speculating on land, property and peri/urban futures: A conjunctural approach to intra-metropolitan comparison. Urban Studies59(8): 1655–1675.
48.
LoftusA (2015) Water (in) security: Securing the right to water. The Geographical Journal181(4): 350–356.
49.
LoftusAMarchH (2019) Integrating what and for whom? Financialisation and the Thames Tideway Tunnel. Urban Studies56(11): 2280–2296.
50.
LuhmannN (1971) Die Knappheit der Zeit und die Vordringlichkeit des Befristeten. In: LuhmannN (ed.) Politische Planung. VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp.143–164.
MeehanKM (2014) Tool-power: Water infrastructure as wellsprings of state power. Geoforum57: 215–224.
55.
MillingtonNSchebaS (2021) Day zero and the infrastructures of climate change: Water governance, inequality, and infrastructural politics in Cape Town’s water crisis. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research45(1): 116–132.
MossT (2008) ‘Cold spots’ of urban infrastructure: ‘Shrinking’ processes in Eastern Germany and the modern infrastructural ideal. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research32(2): 436–451.
58.
NaumannMBerntM (2009) When the tap stays dry: Water networks in Eastern Germany. Local Environment14(5): 461–471.
59.
NettelbladtG (2025) Negotiating counterstrategies against the far right in Cottbus, Germany: Shifting relations of the state and civil society. Territory Politics Governance13(3): 324–343.
60.
NettelbladtG (forthcoming) Of contingent waters and fragile futures: Thinking Berlin’s looming water crisis through the temporalities of the hinterland. In: GrubbauerMPohlLThielJ (eds) Contingencies in Urban Future-Making. Transcript Verlag, pp.375–398.
61.
OeiPYBrauersHKemfertC (2017) Climate protection and a new operator: The eastern German lignite industry is changing. DIW Economic Bulletin6+7: 63–73.
62.
RacoMDurrantDLivingstoneN (2018) Slow cities, urban politics and the temporalities of planning: Lessons from London. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space36(7): 1176–1194.
63.
RadtkeJDavidM (2024) How Germany is phasing out lignite: Insights from the Coal Commission and local communities. Energy Sustainability and Society14(1): 7.
