Cultivating beneficiary citizenship in urban community gardens in Metro Manila

Abstract

Chinese

This paper introduces ‘beneficiary citizenship’ as a way to understand a form of urban citizenship that has emerged from shifts in state–citizen relations. Through the case of state-initiated urban community gardens in Metro Manila, it examines beneficiary citizenship as conditionally granting urban dwellers welfare, entitlements or recognition in the city in return for their transformation into good, responsible citizens. Beneficiary citizenship captures the dual forces of neoliberal technologies of government and alternative citizenship claims that are simultaneously present in various participatory and community-centred state projects. Case study gardens established in a resettlement housing project, in a poverty reduction programme and in a gated village in Metro Manila all seek to cultivate good citizen traits deemed worthy of being granted recognition in the city through a transformation of self and the community. Yet, beneficiaries in these projects also use their good gardener/citizen subjectivity to mobilise ends different from those intended by garden projects as technologies of government. Community gardens therefore become spaces where urban dwellers articulate citizenship by combining various strategies granted by their participation in the projects, exceeding attempts to order and contain urban life.

Keywords

community gardens Metro Manila neoliberal governmentality urban agriculture urban citizenship

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alvarez

(2019) Benevolent evictions and cooperative housing models in post-Ondoy Manila. Radical Housing Journal 1(1): 49–68.

Alvarez

Cardenas

(2019) Evicting slums, ‘building back better’: Resiliency revanchism and disaster risk management in Manila. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 43(2): 227–249.

Arcilla

CAC

(2018) Producing empty socialized housing: Privatizing gains, socializing costs, and dispossessing the Filipino poor. Social Transformations: Journal of the Global South 6(1): 77–105.

Barron

(2017) Community gardening: Cultivating subjectivities, space, and justice. Local Environment 22(9): 1142–1158.

Blokland

Hentschel

Holm

, et al. (2015) Urban citizenship and right to the city: The fragmentation of claims. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 39(4): 655–665.

Brono

(2018) DSWD implements communal gardening project for 4Ps beneficiaries. Available at: https://pia.gov.ph/news/articles/1006381 (accessed 15 July 2019).

Choi

(2016) Metro Manila through the gentrification lens: Disparities in urban planning and displacement risks. Urban Studies 53(3): 577–592.

Crossan

Cumbers

McMaster

, et al. (2016) Contesting neoliberal urbanism in Glasgow’s community gardens: The practice of DIY citizenship. Antipode 48(4): 937–955.

DAP (2018) Bagong Bahay, Bagong Buhay: Complete in-city housing package for disaster preparedness and resiliency. Available at: https://www.dap.edu.ph/coe-psp/innov_initiatives/disiplina-village-bagongbahay-bagongbuhay-complete-in-city-housing-package-for-disaster-preparedness-and-resiliency/ (accessed 15 July 2019).

10.

Dizon

(2019) Philippine housing takeover: How the urban poor claimed their right to shelter. Radical Housing Journal 1(1): 105–129.

11.

DSWD (2018) More Pantawid Pamilya families continue to benefit from communal gardening. Available at: https://www.dswd.gov.ph/more-pantawid-pamilya-families-continue-to-benefit-from-communal-gardening/ (accessed 15 July 2019).

12.

Ghose

Pettygrove

(2014) Urban community gardens as spaces of citizenship. Antipode 46(4): 1092–1112.

13.

Gordon

Stack

(2007) Citizenship beyond the state: Thinking with early modern citizenship in the contemporary world. Citizenship Studies 11(2): 117–133.

14.

Holston

(2009) Insurgent citizenship in an era of global urban peripheries. City & Society 21(2): 245–267.

15.

Hutchison

(2007) The ‘disallowed’ political participation of Manila’s urban poor. Democratization 14(5): 853–872.

16.

Kusaka

(2017) Moral Politics in the Philippines: Inequality, Democracy and the Urban Poor. Singapore: NUS Press.

17.

Lemanski

(2018) Infrastructural citizenship: Spaces of living in Cape Town, South Africa. In: Ward

Jonas

AEG

Miller

, et al. (eds) The Routledge Handbook on Spaces of Urban Politics. Abingdon and New York: Routledge, pp. 350–360.

18.

(2016) Governing rural Indonesia: Convergence on the project system. Critical Policy Studies 10(1): 79–94.

19.

McClintock

(2014) Radical, reformist, and garden-variety neoliberal: Coming to terms with urban agriculture’s contradictions. Local Environment 19(2): 147–171.

20.

Neo

Chua

(2017) Beyond inclusion and exclusion: Community gardens as spaces of responsibility. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 107(3): 666–681.

21.

Ortega

AAC

(2016) Manila’s metropolitan landscape of gentrification: Global urban development, accumulation by dispossession and neoliberal warfare against informality. Geoforum 70: 35–50.

22.

Pudup

(2008) It takes a garden: Cultivating citizen-subjects in organized garden projects. Geoforum 39(3): 1228–1240.

23.

Purcell

(2003) Citizenship and the right to the global city: Reimagining the capitalist world order. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 27(3): 564–590.

24.

Rose

(1996) The death of the social? Re-figuring the territory of government. International Journal of Human Resource Management 25(3): 327–356.

25.

Rosol

(2014) On resistance in the post-political city: Conduct and counter-conduct in Vancouver. Space and Polity 18(1): 70–84.

26.

Saguin

KKC

Chanco

Tan

AIS

, et al. (2017) Reclaiming social equity in land use planning for sustainable cities. Public Policy Journal 18: 99–126.

27.

Seki

(2015) Capitalizing on desire: Reconfiguring ‘the social’ and the government of poverty in the Philippines. Development and Change 46(6): 1253–1276.

28.

Shatkin

(2004) Planning to forget: Informal settlements as ‘forgotten places’ in globalising Metro Manila. Urban Studies 41(12): 2469–2484.

29.

Shillington

(2013) Right to food, right to the city: Household urban agriculture, and socionatural metabolism in Managua, Nicaragua. Geoforum 44: 103–111.

30.

Simone

(2010) City Life from Jakarta to Dakar: Movements at the Crossroads. New York and London: Routledge.

31.

Staeheli

Ehrkamp

Leitner

, et al. (2012) Dreaming the ordinary: Daily life and the complex geographies of citizenship. Progress in Human Geography 36(5): 628–644.

32.

Travaline

Hunold

(2010) Urban agriculture and ecological citizenship in Philadelphia. Local Environment 15(6): 581–590.

33.

Yiftachel

(2015) Epilogue – From ‘gray space’ to equal ‘metrozenship’? Reflections on urban citizenship. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 39(4): 726–737.