Evaluating turnout composite layering strategies for reducing thermal burden in structural firefighter protective clothing systems

Abstract

A modular approach for arranging the component layers used in the construction of structural firefighter turnout garments is explored as a strategy for reducing the thermal burden contributed by these protective garments to firefighter heat stress. An instrumented sweating manikin was used to measure the insulation, evaporative resistance and total heat loss through turnout systems configured to represent different layering strategies. The outer shell, moisture barrier and thermal liner layers of the structural turnout base composite were tested individually to determine each layer's thermal insulation and evaporative resistance. Multiple two- and three-layer combinations were analyzed for their application in specific working conditions. This study demonstrates that the moisture barrier layer contributes the most resistance to evaporative heat loss through the turnout system, while dry heat loss is most restricted by the thermal liner component. Removal of a single inner liner layer was equally beneficial for heat loss, regardless of material properties. It shows the potential benefit of turnout design strategy that utilizes a modular or adaptive layering approach to reduce turnout-related heat strain in conditions consistent with fire protection.

Keywords

heat stress protective clothing firefighter turnout modularity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Rossi

. New developments for firefighters’ protective clothing. Tech Text 2005; 48: 1–4.

den Hartog

. Challenges in future personal protective equipment - an overview of developments in user needs. Res J Text Appar 2010; 14: 22–37.

FireRescueOne. How TECGEN PPE’s high-tech, lightweight gear is keeping the heat off firefighters. FireRescue.com, http://www.firerescue1.com/fire-products/Personal-protective-equipment-ppe/articles/2034826-How-TECGEN-PPEs-high-tech-lightweight-gear-is-keeping-the-heat-off-firefighters/ (2014, accessed 24 July 2015).

FEMA. Urban Search & Rescue, http://www.fema.gov/urban-search-rescue (2015, accessed 2 September 2015).

NFPA 1971:2013. Standard on protective ensembles for structural fire fighting and proximity fire fighting.

Havenith

. Heat balance when wearing protective clothing. Ann Occup Hyg 1999; 43: 289–296.

DenHartog EA, Walker MA and Barker RL. Total heat loss as a predictor of physiological response in wildland firefighter gear. Text Res J. 2016; 86: 710–726.

Holmér

. Protective clothing in hot environments. Ind Health 2006; 44: 404–413.

Nunneley

. Heat stress in protective clothing. Scand J Work Environ Health 1989; 15: 52–57.

10.

Bouskill

Havenith

Kuklane

. Relationship between clothing ventilation and thermal insulation. AIHA J 2002; 63: 262–268.

11.

Barker

. From fabric hand to thermal comfort: the evolving role of objective measurements in explaining human comfort response to textiles. Int J Cloth Sci Technol 2002; 14: 181–200.

12.

Havenith

Nilsson

. Correction of clothing insulation for movement and wind effects, a meta-analysis. Eur J Appl Physiol 2004; 92: 636–640.

13.

Havenith

Heus

Lotens

. Clothing ventilation, vapour resistance and permeability index: changes due to posture, movement and wind. Ergonomics 1990; 33: 989–1005.

14.

McQuerry

Den Hartog

Barker

. A review of garment ventilation strategies for structural firefighter protective clothing. Text Res J 2015; 86: 1–16.

15.

Ciampo

. Fabrics and fibers protecting the firefighter. Nonwovens Ind 1998, pp. 1–2.

16.

Young R. Understanding turnout gear. Fire Apparel Magazine, http://www.fireapparatusmagazine.com/articles/print/volume-15/issue-10/departments/fire-industry-today/understanding-turnout-gear.html (2010, accessed 11 July 2014).

17.

Stull

Connor

McCarthy

Protective clothing and equipment performance requirements for fire service urban search and rescue teams. In: Johnson

Mansdorf

(eds). Performance of protective clothing, West Conshohocken, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1996, pp. 558–574.

18.

Duggan

. Energy cost of stepping in protective clothing ensembles. Ergonomics 1988; 31: 3–11.

19.

McLellan

Selkirk

. The management of heat stress for the firefighter, Toronto: Defence R&D Canada, 2005.

20.

Kurlick

. Stop, drop, and roll: workplace hazards of local government firefighters, 2009. Mon Labor Rev 2012; 134: 18–25.

21.

Globe Manufacturing. Total heat loss (THL), http://globeturnoutgear.com/education/standards-and-testing/total-heat-loss-thl (2015, accessed 1 January 2015).

22.

Ross K, Barker R and Deaton AS. Translation between heat loss measured using guarded sweating hot plate, sweating manikin, and physiologically assessed heat stress of firefighter turnout ensembles. In: Shepherd AM (ed) Performance of protective clothing and equipment: emerging issues and technologies. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International, 2012, pp.27–47.

23.

Walker MA. From sweating plates to manikins: evaluating the role of clothing in reducing the risk of heat stress in wildland firefighting. Thesis, Raleigh: NC State University, 2013.

24.

ASTM:2010. Standard test method for measuring the thermal insulation of clothing under a heated manikin ASTM F 1291.

25.

ASTM:2010. Standard test method for measuring the evaporative resistance of clothing using a sweating manikin ASTM F 2370.

26.

Fire Product Search. Technical rescue suits, http://www.fireproductsearch.com/products/firefighter-clothing/technical-rescue-suits/ (2015, accessed 2 September 2015).